4 ms·
"We took the measures that mitigated a disaster, therefore the disaster was never going to happen" is an idiotic opinion. A virus that spreads from close proxi
by XorNot 7y ago
"We took the measures that mitigated a disaster, therefore the disaster was never going to happen" is an idiotic opinion.
A virus that spreads from close proximity with infected people, and you're arguing that shoving people back in close proximity is not going to contribute to spreading it? Why? On what basis will this not happen, despite this being exactly what happened?
Spain took about 1 month to go from "hm this coronavirus thing is spreading" to "if you're over 75 we're not going to bother with ventilators because we can't spare the capacity".
Things have to reopen eventually, but if you haven't actually increased your test and tracing capacity, then the effect is going to be exactly what happened in 1918 https://www.popsci.com/story/health/coronavirus-1918-flu-pandemic/ https://www.popsci.com/story/health/coronavirus-1918-flu-pan... (wherein an experiment with a control was accidentally run at a substantial cost in lives between two US cities).
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoSorry, what's the accidental experiment here? The article doesn't suggest any cities in 1918 were doing testing or contact tracing - they couldn't have been, because they didn't even know that the flu was a virus at the time. And I'm not seeing anything about a general closure of non-essential businesses either. I certainly wouldn't dispute that closing schools and banning public gatherings were good moves.
- XorNot 7y agoQuarantine measures were widely implemented in major cities during the 1918 pandemic, but at different times in response to different catastrophes and with a very different result in deaths per capita. See the bottom graph. Deaths/week vs when closures were implemented. Another more wordy source: https://www.businessinsider.com.au/history-of-how-st-louis-vs-philadelphia-treated-1918-flu-pandemic-2020-4?r=US&IR=T https://www.businessinsider.com.au/history-of-how-st-louis-v... > Around the same time, the city of St. Louis was closing schools, libraries, courthouses, churches, playgrounds as well as limiting the number of people on streetcars and staggering work shifts to minimise contact. St Louis did relatively well - but they released quarantine measures early and got an unnecessary double peak (see the first source, which shows exactly pretty clearly exactly when they did it, and then quickly reimplemented it). The lessons of history here really could not be clearer.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoYour more wordy source does not describe general business closures and doesn't say the word "quarantine". The lessons of history are clear that we needed to do something, certainly.
- ceejayoz 7y ago"It doesn't say the word quarantine, it only describes it" is a weird hill to die on.
- ceejayoz 7y ago> The article doesn't suggest any cities in 1918 were doing testing or contact tracing - they couldn't have been, because they didn't even know that the flu was a virus at the time. That's silly. They didn't know it was a virus. They certainly knew it was communicable. Contact tracing is entirely possible; we were doing that in the 1800s. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1854_Broad_Street_cholera_outbreak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1854_Broad_Street_cholera_outb...
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoTesting in the modern sense was impossible as a matter of science. Modern contact tracing could in principle have been done, but it's my understanding that it wasn't. The kind of tracing in the Broad Street outbreak is very different - cholera mostly doesn't spread from person to person, so John Snow had to figure out only where each of the victims spent their time and not an exponential sized web of people they went out drinking with.