15 ms·
How Tech Can Build
- naringas 7y agonice constructive counterpoint to https://a16z.com/2020/04/18/its-time-to-build/ https://a16z.com/2020/04/18/its-time-to-build/ a key point (IMO) innovation happened online becuase being a new space enabled by novel technology, it wasn't regulated yet. But now it's mainstream, so inovation will decrease. also, this quote from an intervier questioning Marc Andreessen > a “primary technology” would need to involve, you know, some fundamental new insight in code, some proprietary set of algorithms. tells me that so many people just don't get it. software due to being immaterial just doesn't play by the same rules as other mechanical machines. I know I cannot explain it properly; but why is open source such a superior way to develop infrastructure software? finally > Human progress in this view is solely online. IMO, we don't need a new cleverer algorithm. I believe that Amazon's success is not some really sophisitcated piece of code, but the way in which they integrated computer technology into the very core of the organization.
- josephmosby 7y agoInfrastructure software, by its nature, is designed to power hundreds or thousands or millions of different needs. That suits an open source model. We tend to inflate problems that touch us directly and deflate problems that we don't see very often. Consider if I am the government official responsible for making sure roads are paved. The roads that I use every day (to commute, to go to the grocery, etc.) are likely to be pristine. I will make sure of it. The roads I rarely see will be dealt with on their regular schedule, and maybe not at all if time runs out. However, if paving decisions were made by a large group of citizens, each of whom had the ability to just go out and pave the road themselves if they felt like it, the city would be much more paved. The same allegory works for closed versus open source. Consider if LinkedIn had left Kafka as closed source. If we looked at the code base, we would likely still find a pretty good message bus, but it would be optimized for the nuances of LinkedIn's system architecture and proclivities in passing messages. Once it became open source, developers from Facebook and Google and Startup #1 and Manufacturing Firm #2 and so on all jumped in to solve problems. They achieved consensus on how those problems should be solved and pushed forward. Two points on this allegory that are relevant to Andreessen's argument: everyone in the infrastructure committee had skin in the game (they wanted problems solved) and they had the capacity to go deal with the problems themselves. Andreessen argues we have a lot of the first already but we don't have nearly as much of the second as we need.
- meheleventyone 7y ago> I know I cannot explain it properly; but why is open source such a superior way to develop infrastructure software? Isn't it just cost? As you say software is immaterial and so the only real cost is in the labor to create it which open source neatly does away with.
- NortySpock 7y agoWell, there's still the operational cost of setting up and running the hardware (again, skilled labor), but at least the software is free.
- meheleventyone 7y agoAbsolutely but the OP was talking about development of the software.
- naringas 7y agoyes, but at least until everything went back into the (mainframe) cloud, the opreational cost of running the software was coverd by the user. My pc's hardware is mine, and the electricity bill is also mine. So 'licensing' software is very much a form of rent. Quite frankly this is an open problem. e.g. the debate about AWS suddenly providing, redis, elastcisearch, etc as a service and making the original developers redundant.
- naringas 7y agolet's not forget about the (often overlooked) cost of maintenance but yes, software does have marginal cost, this is a brutal game changer we (as a civilization) are just not dealing with appropriately
- PaulDavisThe1st 7y agoAlthough I mostly agree with you about amzn, they do in fact have some really sophisticated pieces of code. The core aspects of why the company succeeded are not related directly to that code, but without it, it seems quite unlikely to me that they would have succeeded in the way that they have.
- naringas 7y agoBut in the end, isn't all that sophistication subject to diminishing returns??
- generalpass 7y agoI tend to think the technology industry could benefit from a heavy dose of humility. This isn't just a problem for people at the top - it is pervasive at all levels and professions within the technology industry. That would go a long ways towards the ends being discussed.
- coffeefirst 7y agoI'm surprised this is being downvoted. Again and again we've seen really smart people who made a great photo app try to bring their approach to something that's genuinely hard for reasons that go beyond how to write code or build a SaaS business, and leave a trail of wreckage in their wake. Healthcare, education, civic life, etc. are all extremely valuable problems, but only if you actually get it right. Humility doesn't mean don't tackle them, it means recognizing that your expertise in one thing doesn't translate to another automatically. There are counterexamples, and they'll all tell you that the code was the easy part.
- carapace 7y agoEveryone could benefit from a heavy dose of humility.
- cvaidya1986 7y agoCan VCs co invest in trillion dollar government infrastructure projects? Roads bridges hospitals online education healthcare etc. ?
- sails 7y agoReturns on those projects are bond-like (actually are bonds typically) in their predictability, so they _could_, but I can't imagine they would.
- sanderjd 7y agoRight, which seems like the point: it is time to build, but not in the way that VCs build things.
- flyingcroissant 7y agoThis is sometimes done as a “public-private partnership”.
- noworriesnate 7y agoA VC could build a company to fulfill a government contract? I doubt it would be able to compete with established firms though because the startup wouldn't have a history and the established firm would.
- hpoe 7y agoThey already have in several of the things you listed. Online Education? Coursera, Lynda, Pluralsight, Kahn Academy, Youtube for crying out loud. Healthcare? - Healthtech is becoming a big thing, I had the opportunity to interview at a company that is currently working on a private health cloud where they aggregate all of the info about you, your smart watch, your phone, etc. (Note: That you choose and opt into) to make it available to determine the best outcomes for you personally and help the Dr. working with you practice individualized medicine. You list other things, but hospitals are being changed by technology at an amazing pace, the fact that now during a pandemic I don't have to leave my home to see my PCP, you think that was the burdened bloated Hospital beracuracy that came up with that? You then list roads and bridges, but the point is that yes, VCs and entrepenuers could figure out how to solve those too given time and a enough freedom, even we can't see it right now, it may be because our vision is just too limited to see what could be, that's what makes entrepreneurs, real entrepreneurs, different they are visionary.
- ealexhudson 7y agoI want to like a lot of this. The UK is full of "crap towns" with poor housing, poor design and environs that are generally anti-human (as well as anti- a lot of other things). I don't particularly agree the problem is "regulatory capture" unless that's simply a shorthand way of saying, "we, as society, have agreed that inertia is our preferred approach". In some cases it may well be regulatory capture; in most I don't believe it is (obvious case in point for housing is green belt: we know it's a nonsense, but it's an absolute political impediment, not a regulatory one. The people do not want to build there). There shouldn't be problems with people having access to healthcare, or living in housing which is not just healthy but is also pleasant. People should have access to nature as well as all their other conveniences, working should not require long commutes and we shouldn't be generating the absolute tsunamis of waste we currently do just to survive. There are constructivist answers to all these problems. Andreesen appears to be suggesting it's just a matter of willpower. I don't believe the solution is that simple.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- burlesona 7y agoThis is an interesting commentary on Andreesen’s piece, but it doesn’t really change or contradict anything. At the end of the day, the US is a litigious society covered in Byzantine regulation that most people aren’t even aware of. This covers the most basic things: would you like to build a townhouse for your family with just one parking space? Illegal in the vast majority of the United States, where 2+ parking spaces per home are required by law. Want to build an apartment building in San Francisco to capitalize on the incredible demand for housing? You’ll spend at least 6 years getting a building permit, and what you’re actually allowed to build will be mostly the result of ugly haggling with special interest groups along the way. These are just a few examples I happen to be familiar with. We’ve chosen for things to be like this by the way we allow our government at every level to be captured by lobbyists, special interests, and partisanship. Realistically, to change things, we need reform that fixes the way the government itself operates, and while there are many ideas that sound good, everything has unexpected side effects. That is a very, very hard problem, to solve.
- josinalvo 7y ago> Illegal in the vast majority of the United States, where 2+ parking spaces per home are required by law What does that mean? Do people need to build homes with at least 2 parking spaces per home, inside the area of their property? Does it generalize to apartments?
- fierarul 7y agoDealing with people you discover that all the weird rules are there because somebody or a situation made them necessary. For every well meaning well behaving individual there is another that will park his car in your freaking back yard if you don't fence your property. Would you raise a building while taking into account the surrounding people and context? Well, perhaps. But many others will absolutely destroy the location in all concerns and just maximise square footage. This problem has no solution! Whatever set of rules you agree upon, somebody will find a creative way to mess with them and a new rule or clarification will need to be added. Then people will complain why so many rules.
- 7y ago
- michaelt 7y ago> has tech [...] been the primary source of American innovation because it represented the future? Or has it been the future because it was the only space where innovation was possible, because of things like inertia and regulatory capture in the real world? Here's a third option: Due to Baumol's cost disease, if the wages for Java programmers rise, the wages for CNC milling machine programmers are going to go in the same direction - and if manufacturers can't pay, there will be a "skills shortage" Why would a graduate who can program and design electronics do the latter, if the former pays 3x as much straight out of college?
- MattGaiser 7y agoCan confirm. I graduated from computer engineering, which had a heavy electrical component. Knew a lot of electrical engineers as well. If my graduating class stayed in tech at all, it was in software.
- alextheparrot 7y agoAre you familiar enough with Baumol’s to comment on why we don’t see this effect in, for example, medicine vs basic biochemistry? Presumably there is a lot of overlap in these cohorts, but most research jobs pay significantly less than research jobs. Both industries seem to be “more productive” these days as well, with massive gains in biological research techniques over the last 20 years. I guess it is easy to see something and give it a name, but the wikipedia description didn’t leave me with a very solid understanding.
- jeffreyrogers 7y agoDoctors are limited by the American Medical Association which sets the limit on residency slots. Basic biochemistry is done by low-paid grad students, a large percentage (possibly a majority at some schools) of whom are from lower cost of living countries, particularly China and India.
- wbl 7y agoThe AMA has been lobbying to raise the limit. The issue is residents are unproductive and thus need government subsidy for hospitals to train.
- gkanai 7y agoBen's analysis is fine. It's not really relevant to the big picture imo. Andreesen needed to do more than just call for action in his blog post. He should have committed his own funds towards the goals he is calling for. Gates is doing a lot via his foundation. Dorsey is committing a significant portion of his net worth towards goals Dorsey wants. Without something more than a blog post, it's just a blog post. This virus won't be defeated by 'software' in the Silicon Valley sense. It will be defeated by vaccines. So help the labs create and distribute a vaccine. Or if that's too short-term, look at any of the problems that this pandemic has laid bare- there's lots to fix that is not VC-funded startups.
- MattGaiser 7y ago> Andreesen needed to do more than just call for action in his blog post. He should have committed his own funds towards the goals he is calling for. That was the part I found frustrating about his original post. He talks of the need to build and the need to push people to build, but when he is one of the 1000 most capable people of building in North America (between his past experience building, his vast network, and his billionaire level of wealth), he prefers to sit back, sit on plenty of corporate boards, and wait for solutions to walk in the door.
- jasode 7y ago>Third — and related to both of the above — figure out an investing model that is suited to outcomes that have a higher liklihood of success along with a lower upside. This is truly the most important piece — and where Andreessen, given his position, can make the most impact. Andreessen Horowitz has thought more about how to change venture capital than anyone else, but the fundamental constraint has remained the assumption of high costs, high risk, and grand slam outcomes. We should keep that model, but surely there is room for another? I'm puzzled that the above paragraph was written by Ben Thompson with his background including an MBA and the writing of insightful articles about startups. The reason VCs don't invest in other non-VC things like "boring" and "low-return" city infrastructure projects, or small/medium businesses to help communities -- is because that's not what the people who put money into their fund expected them to do. Some folks seem to forget that VCs are ultimately managing other people's money. Pension funds, university endowments, charities, some wealthy families, etc. The investment officer working as custodian of a teachers' pension fund didn't give money to a VC like a16z to build a new sewer system. The pension fund is looking for 15-20% returns and looked to a16z's expertise on evaluating startup founders. That's what they specialize in. Previous comment about the complexity of different investments leads to specialization: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21365966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21365966 I think Ben's idea is that Marc A (and a16z) is influential and so they can put out a prospectus for a new type of fund with a different investment thesis that avoids YC software startups and focuses on low-risk low-return low-margin "hard" projects. Well here's the problem, the pension fund officers will not think it's a good use of their money and will invest their money elsewhere. Therefore, the VC fund using Ben's ideas does not raise any money. The customers (Limited Partners) with the millions to invest is the constraint that any person raising a new fund with "feel good" ideas faces. E.g. let's say you want to create an investment fund that "feeds poor 5-year old children nutritious meals and reads books to them because children are the investment into our future." Ok, it sounds noble but when the investment officer of the Firemen Retirement Fund asks how it makes money, you need to have a credible answer. Otherwise, your fund gets no money and the feel-good investment thesis goes nowhere. My previous comment on why alternative investment ideas don't need essays about it. They just need financial mavericks to pursue it and everybody will copy them. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21588264 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21588264) However, Andreessen Horowitz is probably not the financial maverick that can prove the alternative investment idea will work. Their firm and their staff are built to understand software startups. Somebody else has to lead with Ben's ideas.
- seibelj 7y agoI'm amused by these morality screeds from rich tech thought leaders. "Why don't the talented sacrifice easy money in software by getting into [insert super regulated, low-margin business]?" says profit-maximizing tech capitalists who ignored said businesses for a decade. I will make the best decisions for me, and you will make the best decisions for you. If you want to charity-fund a business that helps society more than your profit margin, then pay me the same amount of money and eat the loss on your end. I'll keep working at what pays me the most, as will 99% of everyone.
- TuringNYC 7y agoMy other favorite is when VCs pretend their risk taking in MANY businesses is equivalent to founders' risk taking in a SINGLE business. No. Founders dont have portfolios to even out risk. They have a single lottery ticket. Worse, are VCs who say this, because you know they actually know better.
- troughway 7y ago100% agreed. These same muppets hailed globalization and tried to sell us on this with their trite blog posting bullshit. Why are they backpedaling now? Turns out the grass isn't always greener on the other side, huh?
- bhl 7y agoFor that reason, I prefer Chamath Palihapitiya's 2019 annual letter [1] over pmarca's essay. It's not merely descriptive of societal problems at large, but calls out actor and makes prescriptions. Two lines from the letter > Governments can do a lot to make it more expensive for Big Tech to hoard human capital and allow this talent to flow more naturally to small businesses and startups so that they can more effectively compete and create vibrant ecosystems. > The intellectual lobotomization of smart, young STEM talent has been an explicit strategy by Big Tech fueled by unseemly profitability and hi flying stock prices. I think the reason why pmarca's essay is so tame in comparison, is that pmarca believes you can have the best of both worlds: high venture returns and non-tech societal progress that doesn't necessitate government. [1] https://www.socialcapital.com/annual-letters/2019 https://www.socialcapital.com/annual-letters/2019
- antisocial 7y agoFWIW, NIMBYism, self-interest are ruining all that is great about America - https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2015/01/the-upper-middle-class-is-ruining-all-that-is-great-about-america.html https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2015/01/the-upper-middle...
- TuringNYC 7y agoThanks for posting this excellent article. This really resonated both as a Brooklyner and as a full-time founder of a health-tech startup (for 3yrs.) Lesson Learned: whatever doctors or hospitals say in their "Thought Leadership" pieces...if you end up making medicine more efficient and threaten their fee-per-use system, you will get tons of of pushback from the first-do-no-harm crowd. Talk is cheap, you should focus on what the AMA and individual medical Boards do, not what they say. Epilogue: I'm back at a larger startup.
- renewiltord 7y agoThis is just the nature of the world. There are enough defensible reasons to screw your own team so people will do that anyway. The real reason is that once you've hit some degree of prosperity, loss aversion overtakes gain seeking. Today's America is therefore focused on maintenance of its wealth. You can try anything you like, but it won't work. America cannot build in the real world because it constrains itself out of fear of losing what it has, because it has so much. All these articles and open letters and appeals are just the same as internal company memos at massive corporations exhorting innovation. But IBM can't innovate, no matter how many innovation labs it funds. It just can't. The fire is dead and that's a property of what it's hit: the upper limit of prosperity. The next innovation won't come from IBM and it will rocket past IBM and then hit its own upper limit. Perhaps the only recent big companies that have innovated are Apple and Amazon. Maybe there's something to be learned from their relative approaches. But America as it stands won't build, because it can't build. The excuses will be numerous: "law written in blood", "do we want to end up like X who built but built wrong", "America is big", "America is sparse". But the problem is none of that. The problem is that America won, that America is prosperous and glorious, and so it can no longer countenance any risk of loss.
- nmfisher 7y ago"It's tough to get out of bed to do roadwork at 5am when you've been sleeping in silk pajamas” - Marvin Hagler I think there's definitely something to be said for Elon Musk sinking his entire Paypal fortune into Tesla. Hitting the reset button and starting again from ground zero is one hell of an incentive to succeed.
- carapace 7y agoWe have known what to do since the 70's, e.g.: Permaculture (Bill Mollison) Pattern Language (Christopher Alexander) Design Science Revolution (Bucky Fuller) Plus things like the hypercar and passive solar architecture, etc. All of this was worked out decades ago. But then... in the 80's everyone got high on cocaine; in the 90's it was raves; in the 00's it was the internet (and war); and in the 10's our phones. I am glossing over hella stuff, of course, but my point is that we have all the answers already (just as Bucky calculated half a century ago.) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercar_(concept_car) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypercar_(concept_car)
- pascalxus 7y agoI can identify with this essay. And, I've always wondered why people don't want to build, why people are so hell bent on preventing others from building. I mean, what on earth is the problem with letting others build? build more housing, build more transportation? Even when a start up wants to do something as simple as put more buses on the road, it quickly gets shut down by regulation (at least in the bay area)
- romanovtexas 7y ago>"First, tech should embrace and accelerate distributed work. It makes tech more accessible to more people. It seeds more parts of the country with potential entrepreneurs. It dramatically decreases the cost of living for employees. It creates the conditions for more stable companies that can take on less risky yet still necessary opportunities that may throw off a nice dividend instead of an IPO. And, critically, it gives tech companies a weapon to wield against overbearing regulation, because companies can always pick-up-and-leave." The next big "tech" revolution is working from home -- and distributed working. It has been around, like the way smartphones were around before the iPhone -- in concept, but never realized in practicality. It is an imperative that tech should accelerate and develop a cohesive set of products that will enable iPhone like working from home.
- TuringNYC 7y agoThis is so true. Half the VCs you talk to want you to re-locate to the Bay Area. What does that mean to someone mid-career (you know, the type with enough experience to really do something big and build) - it means: - They often have kids. - They may have student loans from advanced degrees - They have to worry about healthcare for their whole family - They may be willing to live on ramen-noodle salaries, but dont want to subject their kids to it. Unless seed funds and VCs start allowing more reasonable founders salaries, or allow non-bay-area founding locations with reasonable cost of living, the numbers often just dont work out At this point in the discussion, I will often have a load of people jumping on me to "get roomates" or "eat pasta" or the "all schools are good" argument. Let me pre-answer those: 1. OK, so you have a family with children. Do you really want roommates? 2. Yes theoretically I can eat pasta everyday and save money. But is that really the life I want to give to my family (FYI, I can easily work on wall street and make a half-million salary, so really...) 3. No, not all schools are good. My high school for example had metal detectors on entrance. A staff member died from a heart attach after a confrontation from a student. No, not all schools are good. Perhaps you want to subject your kids to that, I dont. So what do you end up with? Rich kids funding other rich kids building juice squeezers, after which they will just join the VC firm and perpetuate the cycle. And as for the eggheads, present them with a shitty enough "deal" and it makes total sense to either go to a big firm or go work on Wall St. "Thought Leadership" is cheap.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- analog31 7y agoWe're great at building private wealth. We suck at building public wealth. We built a database worth a trillion dollars. We've built oligopolies in vital industries. The newspaper reports on "the economy" by a private wealth measure -- the stock index. Another measure -- jobs -- is reported in numbers and not dollars, because the numbers are a leading indicator of public support for private wealth. We haven't begun to fight for our survival until we agree to tap into private wealth.
- tschellenbach 7y agoThird — and related to both of the above — figure out an investing model that is suited to outcomes that have a higher liklihood of success along with a lower upside. The tricky part is that the type of build projects Andreesen argues for are more costly, have a higher risk and a lower upside compared to most software startups. We need substantially more capital allocated to the VC segment before the focus will shift to these projects.
- julianeon 7y agoI wrote a writeup about this article, and the "Time to Build" article that inspired it, here. Kind of a tl;dr and hopefully a useful summary. Of Stratechery's points, I think I agree the most with the one about distributed work. https://www.reactever.com/time-to-build-reflections https://www.reactever.com/time-to-build-reflections