4 ms·
Human rights violations on free movement and association. Home confinement must be voluntary, or it is a major fundamental infringement upon basic human rights
by sneak 7y ago
Human rights violations on free movement and association.
Home confinement must be voluntary, or it is a major fundamental infringement upon basic human rights.
I assume you wouldn’t tolerate the government shutting down or mass censoring the media/publishing during an emergency?
Everyone should be staying home. No one should be using force to ensure that.
- FireBeyond 7y ago> Home confinement must be voluntary No-one is "confined". Even in Washington state, which has some of the more strict rules in place, says "You are perfectly allowed to go outside, and do the things you need to do, but practice common sense and public health best practices when you do". > No one should be using force to ensure that. Where has force been applied to keep people in their homes?
- sneak 7y agohttp://abc3340.com/news/nation-world/police-alabama-woman-arrested-for-holding-party-during-covid-19-shelter-in-place-order http://abc3340.com/news/nation-world/police-alabama-woman-ar... https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/490445-louisiana-pastor-charged-with-misdemeanor-for-holding-services https://thehill.com/blogs/blog-briefing-room/news/490445-lou... These are not isolated incidents. To be clear, I don’t agree with their actions. I also don’t agree that what they were doing should be illegal.
- FireBeyond 7y agoBeing cited for coordinating and organizing specifically prohibited (sure, we can debate the merits of this) public gatherings in confined spaces is still several steps removed from "confined in home by force".
- anigbrowl 7y agoYour counter-example for people disputing your claim about confinement is a woman who organized a party. This doesn't help your argument at all.
- throwawaysea 7y agoIn Washington state, there are threats of fines for using facilities like parks. Most of our outside activities either take place in a private destination (like work or some other business) or a public one (city parks, state park trails, national forest alnds). When the private businesses are ordered closed, public lands are closed by the government, then the citizen has nothing left to go to. You can claim that isn't coercion because you don't have to stay in your home and could aimlessly walk outside, but to most people, it feels like coercion. After all, private businesses and individuals can make their own voluntary risk assessment about staying open, and public lands belong well, to the public who front the taxes to support them.
- dylz 7y ago> After all, private businesses and individuals can make their own voluntary risk assessment about staying open Absolutely hell no. They were given the chance and repeatedly made the wrong "risk assessment" resulting in deaths.
- throwawaysea 7y agoFreedom requires that people make individual risk assessments. The true mortality rate of COVID-19 is only around 0.37%, based on the results from the broad antibody test in Germany. The typical flu season is 0.1%. For healthy people under 50, the risk is very low and they should be permitted to go about their lives if they so choose. Those that are too scared to go outside can self isolate per their own risk assessment. But curtailing others’ freedom due to their own fears is not OK. Your statement, labeling others’ choices as the wrong risk assessment, feels very authoritarian to me. By that logic we should ban anything that carries a nonzero possibility of death, whether it is skiing or biking or alcohol.
- dylz 7y agoIn this case, I do not mean individuals. I mean businesses. > For healthy people under 50 This is not their choice: in the US you have completely unnecessary businesses forcing people with conditions, elderly people, etc. that could be transacted entirely online forcing people to "go to work or get fired and we will refuse any unemployment claim because you decided to no-show", "you are not allowed to wear masks because you will scare customers, even if you buy masks yourself", -type of bullshit. It does not help that unemployment is also rather broken or overloaded and people are not getting paid that need it the most. This is unacceptable. And yes, you can argue that the individuals for this can eventually win in court, but they are also generally from populations where knowing how to navigate the complexity of the legal system is rare. This comparison would be a lot better if certain portions of the US were not under situations where they are stuck between a rock and a hard place with regard to work availability, workers' rights, etc. > But curtailing others’ freedom due to their own fears is not OK. It's not only fears of individuals, but also a rate limited healthcare system. The people making the risk assessment as an individual to go out and gather should also consider "you no longer have access to medical care" as part of the risk assessment.
- ajross 7y ago> Human rights violations on free movement and association. Can you be specific? No one is preventing you from visiting a friend or going to a private residence... > Home confinement must be voluntary Is it not? > Everyone should be staying home. No one should be using force to ensure that. Who is using force to ensure people stay home? I'm really shocked at the difference in the way the lockdowns are perceived by some people. I mean, just read the text of your local order. Here's the one for California, for example: https://covid19.ca.gov/stay-home-except-for-essential-needs/ https://covid19.ca.gov/stay-home-except-for-essential-needs/ Now... read through that and tell me exactly which provisions constitute a "Human right violation" to you?
- alisonatwork 7y agoFrom the page you linked "public events and gatherings" are banned. That sounds like restricting freedom of assembly to me. Clearly forcing many businesses to shut down is restricting the right to work, and forcing schools to shut down or go online restricts the right to education. Outside of individual states, the travel bans being instituted around the world are definitely restrictions on freedom of movement. Disclaimer: I don't live in the US and the lockdowns in my country were (and to some degree still are) far more draconian than this. However, I can still see why people in the US are upset about what their government has required of them.
- nradov 7y agoThe "shelter in place" orders in many California counties don't allow for visiting a friend or going to a private residence. This is absolutely a violation of the right to free assembly. Temporarily restricting that right might be appropriate to slow down the pandemic, but it is technically a human rights violation.
- ajross 7y ago> The "shelter in place" orders in many California counties don't allow for visiting a friend or going to a private residence. Which counties? Are there any people who have been prevented from visiting friends, or prosecuted for doing so? I mean, I'm seeing a whole lot of screaming about Freedom here and very little evidence of any such abridgement.