9 ms·
These are Americans exercising their constitutional rights to freedom of speech and assembly. Whether you agree with the protestors or not is irrelevant. Your r
by chrisco255 7y ago
These are Americans exercising their constitutional rights to freedom of speech and assembly. Whether you agree with the protestors or not is irrelevant. Your rights are impacted, too, by this arbitrary platform bias. This cannot stand for long. We have to move away from centralized monopolies on the web.
- edgefield0 7y agoThis is a bogus argument. The protestors are advocating for behavior that will literally kill people, including medical personnel. The protesters are no different than those who call for deadly riots or civil war. They deserve to be shut down for jeopardizing public health and safety.
- octocop 7y agoWhy not monitor the movements of the ones in the group and alert the local police of their whereabouts, maybe arrest a few of them and it would be an even bigger statement
- devmunchies 7y agoany decision can kill people, whether its motor traffic laws, junk food laws, or smoking laws, or quarantine laws. its all open for debate and should not be deplatformed for mere protest. There is a point where quarantine does more damage than good, especially when thinking big picture and government control.
- edgefield0 7y agoYes, because all of those examples are equivalent to intentionally spreading a pandemic with no known vaccine or treatment with a 1-2% rate of death, where medical professionals and poor people will be disproportionately impacted.
- AmericanChopper 7y agoHeart disease is responsible for a quarter of all deaths in the US. Facebook distributing adds for Coke is going to cause for more deaths than all the worlds quarantine protest groups combined. Deplatforming groups for petitioning the government is a tremendously alarming decision from Facebook. Regardless of what you think about FB being a corporate platform, the worlds civil liberties have been switched off along side the economy. Governments have a terrible track record of abdicating the powers they seize during crises, and are all talking about a “new normal”, as if we shouldn’t expect freedom of movement or privacy to return once this is over. These people have every right to petition their government (in the US at least), and FB deplatforming them is a serious cause for concern, especially under the guise of “misinformation”.
- inscionent 7y agoI can't catch heart disease and die in 2 weeks because of someone's poor hygiene. If the CocaCola Corporation were advertising "Coke Float" parties right now, would that be okay? FB does not owe an person access to FB, they only do it for the Coke ad dollars...
- AmericanChopper 7y agoThe legal questions of what FB’s rights are to control their platform are irrelevant to a discussion on the merits of how they choose to do it (and I’d suggest aren’t as clear cut as your implying). If you’re isolating, then you also can’t catch coronavirus from somebody attending a protest. If you’re out in public, then you could also be randomly struck by a car (unintentional injuries are the 3rd leading cause of death in the US). Do you have the same view on advertisements for Ford? These people are exercising their constitutional right to petition their government. Facebook is trying to prevent them from doing it because they don’t want them to. No matter how justified you think that is, it is anti-civil liberties, and anti-democracy. They are also doing so (at least according to the reports I’ve read), under the guise of preventing misinformation. Again, no matter how justified you think it is, it has nothing to do with misinformation, and is a clear signal of how they intend to apply “misinformation” moderation. The problem that underlines all of this is that no private organization should have the power to control citizens to this extent. Regardless of what you think of these protestors, Mark Zuckerberg should not be the final arbiter on whether or not they’re allowed to organise themselves. HN and many other communities like it are very vocal about what services people should have access to, things like housing, transport, healthcare... but for speech all of a sudden we need a central authority to determine who’s worthy of access.
- glitcher 7y agoLooks like the strawman has some offspring now.
- 0xy 7y agoThe deaths caused by the coronavirus will be nothing compared to the deaths caused by economic destruction. A 30% unemployment rate will kill substantially more people than the coronavirus. In fact, you could argue the protesters are advocating for behavior that would prevent people from dying (people who get laid off and are now in poverty). As you should know, poverty carries a much higher mortality rate.
- edgefield0 7y agoNot if a competent government provided leadership and managed the process, including the period of isolation and financial support for those in need. Instead we have the bumbling Trump administration and the GOP sycophants, which is providing no leadership and directing billions of dollars to those who least need it.
- lovegoblin 7y ago> As you should know, poverty carries a much higher mortality rate. But it needn't. They could be advocating for social safety nets, but instead they want the right to put others at risk.
- phakding 7y agoYou have no data to support this.
- 0xy 7y agoWould you mind refuting specific points rather than disregarding my entire argument?
- phakding 7y agoYour claim that the ensuing poverty will cause more deaths then corona virus. Do you have anything to support this? You made a claim so the onus is on you to provide supporting data. I don't need to refute anything at this juncture.
- 7y ago
- PretzelFisch 7y agoTheir behavior would almost seems equivalent to "yelling fire in a movie theater".
- dependenttypes 7y agoYou need to stretch the definition of "almost" quite a bit in order to achieve that.
- dntbnmpls 7y agoYour comment exemplified the basis of all tyranny. Mindless hyperbolic fear. > The protestors are advocating for behavior that will literally kill people, including medical personnel. No they are not. No more than those advocating for the repeal of prohibition advocated for drunk driving. > The protesters are no different than those who call for deadly riots or civil war. They are very different. You're mindset is akin to blaming those who protested for civil rights for "deadly riots or civil war". It's amazing how your arguments are so similar to those who wanted to shut down civil rights' protests. > They deserve to be shut down for jeopardizing public health and safety. This type of thinking is why constitutional rights are under so much threat. Just an extreme rehash of "Won't you think of the children" fearmongering to take away rights.
- monksy 7y agoEven with the shelter in place ordinances in place you still have the right to protest. They didn't remove that. You just need to protest while distancing your self or blocking access for the emergency services. Creating a group of people standing closely together and/or blocking the streets is a safety issue at the moment. If the only way you can protest is to do it in public, you lack imagination.
- anigbrowl 7y agoQuite so. There was a protest in Israel over the weekend against Netanyahu (the incumbent prime minister who has been indicted for corruption), but where the protesters just spread themselves over a larger are while maintaining physical distancing.
- paul7986 7y agoI agree and we'll see how this affects the lives of each protester and those around them. Will many fall ill ... im hopeful they won't and with hope in mind these idiots (what many label them as) show us that we can get back to semi-normal sooner then later.
- SamWhited 7y agoThis entire comment is a strawman. This is not the same as "arbitrary platform bias". This is not Facebook saying "we have a certain political view and we talked to the government and they agreed so no other views are acceptable". This is them stopping stupid people from killing a lot of other people. Also, your rights aren't affected. This is Facebook telling stupid people to shut up and stop spreading fud that could actually hurt people, not the government breaking up peaceful and legal assemblies.
- smitty1e 7y agoThis is the government suppressing speech by proxy. Even if it survives legal review, this harms the spirit of the Bill of Rights, which is incorporated against the States. Voters should reply in November with their ballots as appropriate.
- agildehaus 7y agoWhere's the government in this? The government isn't forcing Facebook's hand.
- Lammy 7y agoThe government can be forcing Facebook's hand by making Facebook fearful of being investigated, fined, broken up, etc if they are found to have allowed manipulation of the 2020 election in any way, and the coronavirus and related topics have become unfortunately intertwined in that.
- CamperBob2 7y agoHuh? If any forcing is going on -- which there isn't -- they would presumably be forced to toe the Trump party line, not to suppress or censor it. Wouldn't the present Federal government be happy if Facebook were to encourage protests and general disrespect for warnings from health authorities? If anything, Facebook's actions here are courageous. It takes a lot to get me to defend Facebook, but the arguments popping up in this thread are proving to be more than sufficient.
- phakding 7y agoYou should know that this is not a grass root movement rather someone astroturfing. https://krebsonsecurity.com/2020/04/whos-behind-the-reopen-domain-surge/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2020/04/whos-behind-the-reopen-d... https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/salvadorhernandez/coronavirus-quarantine-protests-facebook-groups https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/salvadorhernandez/coron... Also take a look at this Reddit comment https://www.reddit.com/r/maryland/comments/g3niq3/comment/fnstpyl https://www.reddit.com/r/maryland/comments/g3niq3/comment/fn... If you don't trust BuzzFeed you can go look at the domain registration information for open[enter state name].com domains.
- bpodgursky 7y agoNo, it's a guy in Florida who went through and parked a bunch of domains with the same pattern. Maybe because he believed in the cause, and maybe because he wanted to make a few quick bucks. "Astroturfing" would be when paid shills or robots spam FCC comment boards. It's not astroturfing when thousands of genuine supporters of a cause show up at a protest, whether or not there is coordination (surprise, all protests need coordination). Trying to turn this into a sinister conspiracy -- and not genuine discontent -- is a cheap mental shortcut which lets you discount that a lot of people feel differently than you.
- maedla 7y agoNo, these people are spreading misinformation that in all likelihood will result in higher body counts. Free speech isn't shouting fire in a crowded theater.
- otterley 7y agoFine, they can do it in the public square, just like they always have, subject to health department regulations. Facebook is not a public entity; they are a private company and the Constitution does not constrain it. You can argue that Facebook is depriving you of your Constitutional rights until you're blue in the face, but it'll probably get you nowhere in court.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- aclsid 7y agoThis is a tough question because on one side freedom of speech is something that ought to be protected and it is somebody's opinion of what means misinformation or not. But on the other hand, if you allow people that spread extreme ideologies like fascism/nazism, communism, hatred between religious or ethnic groups, that is where you should draw the line. In here, supporting freedom of speech and therefore the ability for deniers to have a platform sets a dangerous precedent for the whole population. Just like anti-vaccine groups, they are creating a massive hazzard for people that disagree with them, so just like the law says, your right ends where mine begins.
- mike_d 7y ago> constitutional rights to freedom of speech and assembly The constitution applies to the government, not Facebook.
- a_tractor 7y agoConstitutional rights are derived from natural law and therefore applies to anything that wishes to interact with human beings.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nikofeyn 7y agoyou know, i'm pretty tired of people hiding behind "constitutional rights" in support of domestic terrorism. i'm the least fan of corporations, but you know what also can't stand for long? a president executing authoritarian power and promoting domestic terrorism that then "true americans" lap up and execute.
- esoterica 7y agoFacebook's constitutional right to free speech and assembly means they have the right to decide what speech they want to host and what speech they want to censor. The first amendment just means that the government can't throw you in prison for your speech, it doesn't mean you can force private organizations to provide a platform for your speech. You are ironically and hypocritically violating their free speech rights by demanding that the government force them to host speech against their will. It's equivalent to the government forcing you to put up a yard sign for a candidate you don't support.