4 ms·
Illegal, no, but a massive overreaction. This is why the Swedish model (of telling people to take reasonable steps like not getting too close, and staying home
by arcticbull 7y ago
Illegal, no, but a massive overreaction. This is why the Swedish model (of telling people to take reasonable steps like not getting too close, and staying home when sick, and away from old people) is proving so successful. They've even started to see a flattening of the curve alongside the rest of the world without lockdowns. [1, 2]
[1] https://fee.org/articles/sweden-s-top-epidemiologist-covid-19-infections-flattening-under-policy-of-individual-responsibility/ https://fee.org/articles/sweden-s-top-epidemiologist-covid-1...
[2] https://aatishb.com/covidtrends/?location=Canada&location=Sweden&location=US&location=United+Kingdom https://aatishb.com/covidtrends/?location=Canada&location=Sw...
- edoo 7y agoQuarantining the sick is legal but otherwise the freedom of assembly clause in the 1st amendment does not say "except when there is a pandemic or other fear". If you don't believe that should be the law fine, but since it is law and is incorporated to the states via the 14th amendment it qualifies as illegal.
- bobthepanda 7y agoNot quite; you'd have to drag this through court to get any sort of legal determination on it.
- asdf21 7y agoAnd I think they would just say it was "reasonable" given the information known at the time.
- dwaltrip 7y agoCan you please provide links to judicial opinions or rulings that validate your interpretation of the law?
- edoo 7y agoIf you read the federalist papers you'll note that the intention was literal, not to be reinterpreted for the times. That also makes the thousands of gun laws illegal. If you start reinterpreting the constitution that is how you go full banana republic, and everyone knows you never go full banana republic. You are supposed to change the law not reinterpret.
- jcranmer 7y agoIt's pretty funny to watch people try to justify "literal" readings of the text, since they often focus on interpreting just one piece of text and ignore the effects of the analysis on the rest of the text. The First Amendment very clearly binds only Congress in its literal reading: it begins "Congress shall make no law..." And there is no literal text in any subsequent amendment that might cause incorporation to the states--the Fourteenth Amendment only literally incorporates the Fifth Amendment, and that by literal repetition of the text.
- pdonis 7y agoThe fact that legal realism--which says that the law is whatever judges say it is, even when what the judges say is patently ridiculous when compared to the actual words of the Constitution or statute--is the mainstream viewpoint in today's legal environment does not make it right.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 7y agoI would argue the second amendment doesn't explicitly say you can't own a nuclear warhead for personal amusement, but I would argue nobody's going to challenge the validity of such impositions.
- ta1771 7y agoProbably because they know it's futile, not because it shouldn't be covered under the Amendment.
- curryst 7y agoIt almost certainly shouldn't be covered. It states "being necessary to the security of a free State". What part of a nuclear warhead wielded by a militia contributes to the security of a free State? Nuclear weapons are rather unique in that they're essentially useless in a civil war. What are you going to do? Nuke the very land that you're fighting over? Biological and nuclear weapons should not fall in the scope of the 2nd amendment. They're useless for guaranteeing your liberties against a tyrannical government, and the consequences for storing them improperly are severe.
- pdonis 7y ago> What part of a nuclear warhead wielded by a militia contributes to the security of a free State? Depends on who's attacking and what might deter them. > They're useless for guaranteeing your liberties against a tyrannical government Which is only part of "the security of a free State", not all of it. The militia was also for repelling foreign invasions. Given our current modern world, I would agree that weapons of mass destruction (nuclear, biological, and chemical) shouldn't be available to anyone who wants them; but the correct legal way to make that happen in the U.S. would be to amend the Constitution to explicitly add that exception to the Second Amendment. As the Second Amendment is currently written, it does not admit of any exceptions. As I noted in another comment upthread, privately owned warships were significant at the time the Second Amendment was passed, and the framers of the Amendment did not exempt them from the category of "arms".
- 7y ago
- jcranmer 7y agoFreedom of assembly, like the other 1st amendment freedoms, can be regulated by government so long, per prior SCOTUS decisions. They key is that restrictions must be content-neutral and can only pertain to "time, place, and manner," additionally surviving strict scrutiny (which, in plain English, means "there's no other way to do it"). This is bread-and-butter First Amendment court case stuff; any US government class that's at least halfway competent ought to have covered this. The coronavirus bans on public gathering are fairly clearly permissible under SCOTUS precedent.
- bobthepanda 7y agoPart of the reason why lockdowns were resorted to in the first place is that Americans are, for various reasons, not likely to listen to official guidance about staying apart. See: all those panic articles about various people who knew they were at high risk and continued to go about their daily lives, or take flights or other forms of transporting masses of people, etc.
- ghaff 7y agoIn fact, the general take is that Americans have been pretty good at following distancing rules with or without hard rules but some were slow to do so (and most government was in retrospect slow to strongly recommend doing so) but, to a first approximation, few will do so over an extended period. So no.
- jhayward 7y agoThis isn't even close to true. The Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo. Spring Break. Florida beaches. Evangelical churches. Just because a majority of people do sensible things doesn't matter. The actions of the irresponsible and sociopathic minority still create the epidemic.
- zuminator 7y agoLet's not lose sight of the reason why lockdowns were advised in the first place. Absent the data from widespread testing, the spread of the disease was consistent with two epidemiological models -- low-contagion/high-mortality and high-contagion/low-mortality. In the latter model, there's not much to be done to stop the disease from infecting the population at large, and not that much that needs to be done, since the vast majority of people will emerge unscathed. But in the former model, it matters tremendously -- doing nothing will slowly but surely result in vast loss of life but quarantines can stop the disease dead in its tracks. Therefore the most cautious course of action, from a public health perspective, was to assume the former and proceed with a regime of extreme social distancing. Unfortunately doing so had dire economic consequences.
- edoo 7y agoThey knew within a week or two that the lockdowns had no effect. We converged right to the same level as Sweden. That they kept pushing it is insane.
- creato 7y agoWhat explains the difference between NY and CA if it isn't lockdowns? The difference in death per capita between the two is staggering (nearly 30x more people per capita have died in NY than CA).
- natrik 7y agoLots of things could explain it. Here are some: - The way deaths are counted in each state - Daily Temperature - Comorbidity percentage difference for residents - https://covid19tracker.health.ny.gov/views/NYS-COVID19-Tracker/NYSDOHCOVID-19Tracker-Fatalities?%3Aembed=yes&%3Atoolbar=no&%3Atabs=n https://covid19tracker.health.ny.gov/views/NYS-COVID19-Track...
- ImprovedSilence 7y agoAlso population density. In NYC, a higher % of the population is touching shared surfaces such as doors and elevator buttons just to get outside.
- perl4ever 7y agoSomething that you might consider looking at when comparing countries or areas is the ratio of active cases to recovered. A higher ratio suggests that the epidemic is in an earlier stage. Sweden has about 23 active cases for each one recovered. The US is about 10:1, Europe overall is about 2:1, so is Italy, and Spain is close to 1:1. Asia as a whole is about 1:1.
- arcticbull 7y agoThat likely has to do with availability of tests, who's getting tested, where and when. With Sweden not attempting to stop the spread, I doubt they've done wide-spread population testing. They're likely limiting it to hospitals, so the fact it's flat its really what matters until they kick off their wide-spread serological study in the works. [edit] I misread, disregard, but preserving for posterity.
- hyperpape 7y agoActive vs. recovered is a metric related to the people who are tested and confirmed. It cannot be changed by testing fewer people, only by rapidly ramping the number of tests up or down.
- arcticbull 7y agoAh pardon, I misread. You're totally right.
- rightbyte 7y agoThere is random sampling being done. 2,5% had an ongoing infection in Stockholm in late Mars.[1] Now, 11/100 blood givers in Stockholm who has not been sick in the last two weeks have antibodies according to researchers. That gives you a naive mortality rate of 0,4% per infection, assuming the spread among bloodgivers is the same as the population in general and just dividing the death count by 11% of the population. It is a high eastimate as I guess many wont get traceable antobodies and mostly asymptotic people give blood. [1] (Swedish) https://www.folkhalsomyndigheten.se/publicerat-material/publikationsarkiv/f/forekomsten-av-covid-19-i-region-stockholm-26-mars3-april-2020/ https://www.folkhalsomyndigheten.se/publicerat-material/publ...
- majormajor 7y agoThe answer to "what is the correct action to take in the face of uncertainty" is not "whatever people say we should've done after we gain full information." That's nonsense, it assumes that next time you should just know the future.