35 ms·
Who’s behind the “reopen” domain surge?
- Loughla 7y ago>[. . .] the Dorr brothers simply seek “to stir the pot and make as much animosity as they can, and then raise money off that animosity. I am fascinated by people like this. They have to understand they are doing awful things to the world around them. How do people like that sleep at night, or look themselves in the mirror? Even if you believe in gun rights to the extreme, being purposefully combative, negative, divisive, and awful just to make money is not a great look. How? Why? Why do people do these things?
- ModernMech 7y agoSome people have a nonexistent or weak conscience. We call them psychopaths and sociopaths. They are not all bloodthirsty ax murderers as portrayed by Hollywood.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThat’s a very good trait to have success in business.
- ModernMech 7y agoI linked to this in another thread today. Relevant even more here: https://www.psychology.org.au/news/media_releases/13September2016/Brooks/ https://www.psychology.org.au/news/media_releases/13Septembe... "One study of 261 corporate professionals in the supply chain management industry showed extremely high prevalence rates of psychopathy, with 21% of participants found to have clinically significant levels of psychopathic traits - a figure comparable to prison populations."
- christkv 7y agoSo there is a 21% chance according to that study that Tim Cook is a psychopath :)
- bryanrasmussen 7y agoAre you sure that having significant psychopathic traits is the same as being a psychopath?
- tekdude 7y agoThat is how the DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders) works. Psychologists identify people exhibiting similar disordered behavior, then they extrapolate underlying traits that are likely related to that disorder. The disorder and the traits get published in the DSM, with the guidelines of, "Subjects who exhibit N of these traits can be designated a psychopath."
- dchyrdvh 7y agoThe goal of business is to undermine competitors. It's hard to imagine a good person with such mindset.
- battery_cowboy 7y agoThe goal used to be too provide a good or service that people need and exchange them for a fair price so you can survive. Now, business has been turned into a way to fuck other people over so you can get more resources than you'll need for 1000 lifetimes.
- dchyrdvh 7y agoThe goal has ever been making as much as possible while giving as little as possible. That's how it's been since humans developed ego. You're describing business between post-ego humans also known as saints. We don't have many of those yet.
- Animats 7y agoYes, unfortunately. See "Assholes, a Theory", by Aaron James, a serious book on this topic.
- seppin 7y agoA good businessperson only makes a sale if the person on the other end will come back for more.
- sigkill 7y agoUnless of course, you can drown it out by sheer volume of sales.
- seppin 7y agoThe traveling huckster model breaks down eventually too, there's only so many people you can scam. Also, that life isn't a good one.
- yellow_postit 7y agoAt internet scale though you can get pretty far and if a new huckster is born every minute then it’s a revolving door of trolling. State sponsored money can’t hurt either.
- NortySpock 7y agoBut only if repeat business is relatively frequent. This isn't particularly true for durable goods sellers or people who sell one-off things. Is the car salesman ever going to see you again? Is the realtor ever going to see you again? Is the mattress store salesman ever going to see you again? Is the artist who sells you band merch or paintings going to see you again? Probably not.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- abawany 7y ago
- KarlKemp 7y agoIt's not. Good businesses thrive with their customers/employees/other stakeholders. You're thinking of slavers, or the mafia.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoRead biographies of famous business people. You will find them full of stories where they act in a very cruel manner if it benefits them.
- procgen 7y agoSociopathy.
- Animats 7y agoThere have been jerks like that for a long time, back at least to the Roman Empire. The difference today is that the Internet's combination of scale and anonymity makes it possible for minor players to pretend to be a large movement. It used to require ownership of a newspaper or a radio station to pull this off.
- rconti 7y agoAnd because social media platforms incentivize controversial opinions that get lots of engagement, even if most of it is disagreement. Twitter's particularly bad for this because of it's default-public-broadcast nature, but you'll see this in public Facebook posts as well. (eg, I have a friend who is a state-level politician, and I made the mistake of reading the comments in one of his posts, and they're all sub-human trolls. You know; you look at the profile and there's no content. Just 'evocative images' like stylized pictures of the constitution and the US flag, but no original content, no grandkids pictures, etc).
- dvtrn 7y agoAnd because social media platforms incentivize controversial opinions that get lots of engagement, even if most of it is disagreement. IMO this puts the carriage before the horse: the platforms incentivize engagement, sans enough social pressure to actually tackle it, the platform seems not to care much what that engagement looks like, and this is what we get.
- rconti 7y agoI agree, and I used to make this same technology-neutral point, but I figure we might as well call a spade a spade at this point, since it's obvious what we get.
- chatmasta 7y agoRe: Roman Empire, here’s a nice list of graffiti from Roman bathrooms: https://kashgar.com.au/blogs/history/the-bawdy-graffiti-of-pompeii-and-herculaneu https://kashgar.com.au/blogs/history/the-bawdy-graffiti-of-p...
- jedberg 7y agoSome people measure their worth and the worth of others based on their bank accounts. They want to increase their self worth relative to others, which means making their bank account bigger.
- wyldfire 7y ago> Even if you believe in gun rights to the extreme, being purposefully combative, negative, divisive, and awful just to make money is not a great look. From what I've read on this page and others, they raise money not necessarily for personal wealth's sake but instead to further their cause. "Give us money because this latest news report says they are coming over to your house tomorrow morning to take your guns." It seems in line with other cable entertainment ("news") sources who hold sessions to discuss the latest "sky is falling" policy proposals from lawmakers whose ideology they oppose.
- oldsklgdfth 7y agoBoth create information glut. So much content so rapidly that you cannot properly process. If it passes the sniff test (which is usually underpinned by personal experiences, preferences and biases) and falls in line with your intuition it's one more thing that you "know" withou understanding. Similar to strange danger, the true disinformation is the subtle inaccurate "facts" we allow ourselves to believe.
- SlowRobotAhead 7y ago> Give us money because this latest news report says they are coming over to your house tomorrow morning to take your guns." Here is the thing about that. You can’t use that as “crazy” anymore. This presidential cycle a candidate stood up and said “hell yes we’re coming to take your [most popular rifles in America]”, it was met with studio applause and not one single candidate interjected with a “hey now wait”. Biden was the “most critical” saying he wasn’t sure that would be constitutional but then also said the guy that made the statement would be his chosen “gun tzar”. The New Jersey NICS (background check system) was off for weeks because of Covid19. Meaning it was ENTIRELY illegal to buy / sell / trade a firearm in the entire state. This is the system they want for the whole county. The Gov and legislature in VA just publicly floated using the National Guard to carry out their gun ban proposal. So... I don’t have a stated position on the topic, but that example of “look how crazy these people are! They think people are trying to do exactly what they say!” Isn’t a good one.
- frockington1 7y ago
- lilyball 7y agoBecause society rewards them for it.
- seppin 7y agoThey share the same mentality that every criminal has always held to justify their crimes, "it's a bad world and i'm just part of it". Trump says the same thing often, too.
- oldsklgdfth 7y agoTroll level one million! I have a couple of friends that are trolls(they call themselves that). They frequent Facebook and they make silly comments are try to rile people up, because....well i guess they're bored. They take pride in being banned from Facebook so shock humor. They are pretty funny. Why is this relevant? What I have learned from them is that high-speed internet is conducive to trolling at all levels. Facebook users want comments and reactions, so their post do just that. Large sites want clicks and attention, so their content does just that. A deep multifaceted conversation is boring and difficult to do. And above all else does not give you the same satisfaction as emotional content. The internet is an emotional medium, not a rational one. I treat it that way. To learn more on this check out neil portman, specifically his book "amusing ourselves to death". I try to remind myself that things on the internet could very well have been produced by an angry techsavvy teenager, rather than to attribute any authority to it.
- dboreham 7y agoSomething I've noticed, and fallen victim to in recent weeks, is that FB will often display in my feed a post by a news site (for me, they're usually NPR, CNBC or the local TV station), and underneath they'll display exactly _one_ comment. That one comment is almost always something insane (no more serious than the flu, they're counting all dead people not just dead from the virus, you get the picture). But when I open the story to view all comments, there are hundreds of not-insane ones. In fact it is often impossible to find the "featured" comment if I wanted to reply since there are so many others. I get the distinct impression that FB has an algorithm that promotes disinformation comments in order to....well I assume in order to make more money somehow. I've had to train myself to read the news stories (which are useful to me) but brain-skip over the featured comment.
- oldsklgdfth 7y agoThat's probably my buddy, don't bite ;) I would argue the case that facebook is not malicious and promote disinformation. If their algorithm promotes comments that get lots of emojis and responses you would see the same behavior. I see it in many forums, the top comments are usually controversial. Now add to that fact that all sites rely on web traffic to make money and you get a systems of incentives that breeds discontent and divisiveness. On top of all that high speed visual medium, such as the internet, produce an emotional response with little time to rationally process information.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- grecy 7y agoPeople have been making billions for decades by wilfully destroying the planet, or exploiting third world populations. This is nothing new, it's just hitting closer to home than you're used to.
- inscionent 7y agoRules of Acquisition 34: War is good for business. 35: Peace is good for business.
- losteric 7y agoFor some people, I think it's away of dealing with feeling isolated and alone... hurting others makes them feel better, less alone, in their unhappiness. Also probably scratches an itch for ignorant/powerless sociopaths.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dmos62 7y agoThere can be a wider sense to being destructive. Example mindset: if we as a society have too much inertia to steer away from tragedy, it's better to hasten its arrival, rather than slow it, because the later it comes, the more destructive it will be. Constructive destruction. In that vein, populism is good, identity politics is good, culture of greed is good, growing inequality is good, etc. I don't share that viewpoint, but, I do think that many of these destructive trends are an unconscious civilization-level self-regulation, which has the purpose of dropping inertia by gradually destroying self.
- castratikron 7y agoSo basically their answer to the trolley problem is to flip the switch and have it run over one person instead of five. It only makes sense to act that way if you absolutely know a tragedy will occur. Of course, in the real world, the future is not so certain. You can't know for sure if the damage you do in the short term is any less than the damage that would have happened.
- dmos62 7y agoI think there's a fair amount of people who think that status quo is untenable. That, and a sense of overwhelming inertia is all it takes.
- phs318u 7y agoSounds like self-serving, "ends justify the means" bullshit to me.
- dmos62 7y agoLike a villain in a movie, right? Where you're setup to despise him, but also sympathize with him just a bit. I think that people who are genuinely destructive might have rationalizations about why they're doing what they're doing, but the rationalization is just a distraction. Ultimately they don't really know, because it's bigger than them.
- crocodiletears 7y ago
- viklove 7y agoIt's just common sense in a system of capitalism. When you have people like Adam Neumann, Martin Shkreli, etc. getting filthy rich off of their non-existent consciences, then it's only natural that you'll have smaller fish like this trying to do the same. Most of them don't even end up in prison.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoWell - this is basically the Twitter and Facebook business model. It's just that they're wilfully curating and disseminating the bullshit for profit instead of creating it. And even that is just a reinvention of the old tabloid business model, but with better analytics and slightly more ass covering - especially on FB, which can't quite decide if it should remove this traffic for moral reasons, or optimise its algos for the user engagement it generates. The troll business has always been toxic and poisonous, but now it's far more concentrated. Without social media and the more insane elements in the MSM, trolls would be limited to mad little mail order operations and micro-niche lecture tours of mostly empty church halls.
- u801e 7y ago> Being purposefully combative, negative, divisive, and awful just to make money is not a great look. How? Why? Why do people do these things? I actually came across a BBC article[1] several weeks ago that examined the motivations behind one of the sources of fake news. [1] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-sh/the_godfather_of_fake_news https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/resources/idt-sh/the_godfather_of...
- hliyan 7y agoMy theory: a certain percentage of people have a lower than average empathetic response, usually by birth, but sometimes also by repeated exposure to mistreatment/neglect at a young age. These indivduals probably played an evolutionary role in human tribes (perhaps something similar to those "soldier" ants in some ant colonies). But the scale and connectedness of modern society allows such individuals to expand their influence in ways that were not possible in prehisotric societies. And so they go ahead and do it. I don't believe they have any problems sleeping at night or looking at themselves in the mirror. Those circuits in their brains either don't function or are heavily attenuated.
- 55555 7y agoThey want money and aren't as socialized as you.
- DaniloDias 7y agoAmericans are busy. The only reliable way to get attention is to be pithy and controversial. This is how politics on both sides has been working for the last 30 years. They do it because the other side is fighting the same dirty way, and if they don’t respond in kind, they will lose something they value.
- dwd 7y agoFollow the money? Alex Jones for example sets himself up to profit from the conspiracy theories he pushes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucelee/2018/08/16/alex-jones-top-10-health-claims-and-why-they-are-wrong/#237de4613e7f https://www.forbes.com/sites/brucelee/2018/08/16/alex-jones-...
- chadlavi 7y agoSociopathy?
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoThey're basically the kind of people who would be picked up in secret by the FBI/CIA and co in the Cold War for inciting unrest and instability, because who would benefit from a sweeping pandemic in the US and consequent instability? Superficially, it'd be the gun sellers, because more individuality and chaos means more people will want to "protect" themselves. But beyond that, internationally there's foreign nations that can benefit from the US being disorganized. It means they can buy in / loan out financial dependency (e.g. China building ports and infrastructure in Africa which they will gain full ownership of if they can't pay off the loans), which leads to control and an advantage in e.g. trade deals. Plus if the US is finally forced to deal with its own problems, it won't stir as much shit abroad. Russia seems to have an interest in (re)claiming territory; who is going to stop them from claiming Afghanistan (again) if the US is too busy dealing with an epidemic and/or a revolution? Disclaimers: Not an American, not a historian or politician, I'm just spewing random bullshit, citation needed etc.
- milkytron 7y agoWill this post be flagged just like the others?
- jimhefferon 7y agoDoesn't being tied to gun rights mean being Russian puppets? Isn't that the current political reality?
- austincheney 7y agoThis article does not appear to be about politics, such as gun rights policy. Instead it is about a few individuals who, once identified, align with more extreme positions, guns rights are the most pronounced of a few identified subjective criteria, seeking to astro-turf an influence campaign.
- jimhefferon 7y ago> astro-turf an influence campaign So, forgive me, honest question. I understand that to mean Russian puppets. Is that not the reality of the NRA at this moment?
- chance_state 7y agoNot really sure what point you're making or what you're asking. What is a "Russian puppet"?
- jimhefferon 7y agoLike the NRA, an organization or person who is controlled by Russian money, or some other pressure that they have over the people in charge. https://www.npr.org/2019/09/27/764879242/nra-was-foreign-asset-to-russia-ahead-of-2016-new-senate-report-reveals https://www.npr.org/2019/09/27/764879242/nra-was-foreign-ass...
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoThat link shows that the NRA may have had some contact with Russia pre-2016. Even that much is disputed. But even if true, it is a "long* way from controlled by Russia, either via money or pressure.
- paulgb 7y ago> Both the Minnesota and Pennsylvania gun advocacy sites include the same Google Analytics tracker in their source code I enjoy the irony of an analytics tool designed to track users instead being used to reveal something the site owner was trying to hide. There's just something poetic about it.
- henriquez 7y agoIt’s not poetic, it’s just fucked. Like laughing at a train wreck because someone you didn’t like was on the train.
- dijit 7y agoI don't see the similarity. if we're making parables then it's more like rebels stealing the weapons of the standing army to use against them. Or, more accurately: the FBI using a specific model of camera that only they can buy to spy on people, and that model being known to the survielled.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoAre you suggesting the pro-isolation crowd is actually a centralized entity pretending to be a grass-roots movement?
- dijit 7y agoApologies, I don’t understand how you took that meaning from what I said. Even in the least charitable interpretation of my statements there is nothing that suggests what you imply. Rebels is a catch-all term for any person or persons rallying against the status quo. It does not imply organisation.
- paulryanrogers 7y agoThanks for clarifying. My lack of sleep may be affecting my critical thinking.
- ggm 7y agoI'm not hunting to a false moral equivalence and there is no need for a bilateral symmetry here. I just observe as the comments in the Krebs article do: where are the Dems/BlueFlag equivalents? Their absence is interesting. I actually do take heart from a lack of obscured PAC type industry funded backrooms behind the absent 'stay locked down' protest movement. Is throws the lack of goodwill into sharper focus perhaps.
- mattnewton 7y agoWhy would anyone want a “stay locked down” PAC? It’s not a political position that really benefits anyone, it’s a humanitarian one.
- marvin 7y agoAnd also, arguably, an economic one. A population where everyone over 50 (middle class or not) is afraid to do anything in public because a deadly pandemic is rampant, will not be conductive to an economic recovery. I've seen multiple economists make that argument in the last few weeks. The view that it's the economy vs. health & safety is very much contested.
- twomoretime 7y ago>where are the Dems/BlueFlag equivalents? Their absence is interesting. They exist, but the few sources that will report on them are "not credible." As in right leaning. The story in the OP is totally credible, but If you talk about a billionaire like Soros doing something like this with leftist agitators, you're shunned as a crazy conspiracy theorist. I recognize there's less in the way of actual proof beyond circumstantial and primarily associative evidence, but my point is that none of the legitimate news networks are going to perform such investigations into groups like Antifa and movements like BLM, which makes the evidence hard to come by. In fact it's no secret that shot callers in Antifa are at least guest journalists in city and online papers in the PNW. Our media is just as partisan as our politicians right now.
- amanaplanacanal 7y ago
- saagarjha 7y agoI find it interesting that many of the protestors, including one holding a sign saying "COVID-19 is a lie", are wearing face masks.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoWell, if you're breaking the law and being photographed, maybe a face mask is a good idea. And maybe, given what they're protesting, the face mask has a certain ironic humor to it. Or maybe they're hypocrites, or just not thinking very well.
- Cyph0n 7y agoGiven what they’re trying to protest, probably the very last one.
- nsxwolf 7y agoI would like to think it's possible to protest lockdowns and their economic destruction while also taking the virus seriously and observing social distancing and wearing masks.
- saagarjha 7y agoI don't think it's possible to take the virus seriously while also carrying a sign that says "COVID is a lie".
- nsxwolf 7y agoIs that the view of every protester?
- saagarjha 7y agoThat I cannot say.
- leadingthenet 7y ago
- anonu 7y agoLet's jump to the conclusion here that Russia is still meddling in American politics, society and culture. What I cannot believe is how the USA still allows this after all the country has been through with the current administration, investigations, impeachments. USA's most important characteristics: openness, freedom, independence are just tools and weapons used against us. And we never learn...
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoI don't know how you got from the article to your first paragraph. Maybe we shouldn't just to that conclusion. (It may in fact be true, but maybe, you know, evidence, rather than just assuming?)
- toomanyrichies 7y agoI mean, to quote the article itself: "A Twitter account tied to Murphy’s email address promoted nothing but spammy paid surveys for years. And a Skype lookup on his phone number curiously returns a Russian profile under the name валентина сынах (translated as “Valentine Sons”)." Not saying it's a smoking gun, but it's hardly as baseless as you're claiming.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoAh. I read (I thought) the article, but I apparently got fooled by an ad break, and thought I had reached the end. Still, even if true, that's Murphy. That's not the Dorr brothers, or the Koch site, or the Orange County Republicans. So, even if Murphy is a Russian cutout, much of the rest of this isn't. That leaves anonu's point as somewhat valid - they're still meddling, at least to some degree (and in fact, I kind of presume that they would continue to try to do so) - but his comment still seems like a bit of a reach for a response to the article. One of those registering has a maybe-to-plausible Russian link, so let's veer off and talk about Russian meddling? Yes, we do in fact need to talk about it (and more, find ways to stop it), but this article doesn't seem like the place.
- wtallis 7y ago
- hysan 7y agoThis is a fascinating example of real world propaganda that, given the impact of the pandemic, has a high probability of being in history textbooks. Given that, I’m curious, how do does the HN population think we should respond? Imagine looking back on this in hindsight. What type of picture would we want to paint for future generations to learn from?
- rootusrootus 7y agoEither we successfully manage to educate the majority of Americans on how to apply critical thinking skills to what they see on the Internet, or we balkanize the 'net and try to keep the bad actors out (or at least force them to attack from a location we have legal jurisdiction over). I feel like this is just one more nail in the coffin of the free worldwide Internet. I really don't see any good solutions. It is super difficult to defend against entities acting in bad faith when their cost of their actions is essentially zero.
- jacobush 7y agoPeople will not be educated because they see right past “truth” and look for their “group” or “tribe”. Like a deeper truth. (Autocorrect suggested deeper trump.)
- knolax 7y agoWhat makes you think the bad actors aren't already within "our" legal jurisdiction. The "Foreign" part of misinformation campaigns is a red herring. Case in point TFA is more likely the doing of domestic neoliberals than foreign actors.
- ngold 7y agoThis is just weaponized public relations. The public will become educated. It reminds me of the Flintstones brought to you by cigarette brand x.
- empath75 7y agoPublic relations was always weaponized.
- OliverJones 7y agoI live five miles from the New Hampshire border. We've long chuckled that their state slogan should be "Live Free Then Die." It's possible this will come true for some victims of this disinformation campaign. And victims they will be. In the meantime, Brian Krebs is just the guy to feed the trolls. His site is rigged for handling DDOS. I wonder? Is it time for Twitter to reevaluate their account-closing policies, to make it easier for them to suspend accounts belonging to persons who spread disinformation about the epidemic?
- pattrn 7y agoI live a mile north of New Hampshire's southern border. We have no income tax, no sales tax, the median property tax is within $800 per year of the neighboring states, and the median income is only $3,000 per year less than Massachusetts (pretty sure after accounting for taxes, New Hampshire is higher). As far as death rates go, the life expectancy is 79.5 years, which is pretty close to the 80.5 in Massachusetts and 79.7 in Vermont. Contrary to popular belief, we've been practicing social distancing for many years, simply due to the our low population density (/kidding). It's a pretty great place to live. Life's good here, especially if you're a software developer. Come join the dark side! We have cookies.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoAs someone who was more or less forced to move to southern New England for his career I love northern New England but I have less than high opinion for people who talk it up as though it's the greatest thing ever. People moving to Northern New England for the taxes (after counting government fees and other taxes it's not really that low when it's all said and done) or the low prices or other shallow benefits and don't understand that these are different places with different cultures (though if their only experience is the I95 or I93 corridor I can see how someone might miss that) will be the death of it. I have lived in ME, NH and VT, they all have distinct cultures that are different than the culture you get in MA and CT (haven't lived in RI). I'm not gonna say they're wholesale superior (obviously it comes down to personal values and preference) but I find the things their culture does right very important personally and the things it does wrong very unimportant so naturally I like them all a lot better than MA and CT. If you're gonna move to NH, ME or VT do it for the culture fit, not for the shallow crap like being able to buy beer at Walmart. Also, to anyone from NH, ME or VT reading this, sorry for lumping you all together but I think we can all agree you have more in common with each other than you do with any state to the south. So yeah, it's a great place to live but please stop broadcasting that or it will stop being that way.
- jka 7y agoIt's fairly remarkable to see how weaponized misinformation is becoming. Here's a snippet from Wikipedia[1] detailing the background behind the already-very-dubiously-named Local Government Information Services -- which is in no way a federally (or even regionally) accredited institution: "Locality Labs published Hinsdale School News, a newspaper that masqueraded as the student publication of a high school in Hinsdale, Illinois by using the logo of Hinsdale Township High School District 86. In March 2019, the publication released a number of articles opposing a Hinsdale referendum that would increase the school district's budget by $140 million.[1] Officials from District 86 sent a cease and desist letter to Franklin Archer, LGIS, and other related companies, claiming that their publication of the Hinsdale School News was deceptive and violated trademark law.[5]" This is a wake-up call for authenticity. Regardless of whether foreign influence is involved -- and it can be very challenging to determine whether it is -- U.S. nationals are taking actions that imitate authority without possessing it. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_Government_Information_Services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local_Government_Information_S...
- koheripbal 7y agoI think far more concerning are the cases where the perpetrators are foreign entities.
- jka 7y agoThe effect could be the same regardless of source, and the attribution could become fractally difficult depending on how many channels of influence are available to the perpetrator. Personally, I'd recommend that people focus on the results of the actions that are taking place, and devise measures to lead or redirect those towards positive outcomes. The time spent attempting to attribute nefarious outside actors -- even if you end up being correct -- could end up essentially wasted relative to the real-world impact that has occurred. Edit: I'm not suggesting that attribution or recording provenance are not worthwhile. They are valuable, especially in future. But focus should remain on what is going to happen in the near-term as a result of real-world actions.
- 7y ago
- russellbeattie 7y agoIf Americans or American companies want to register a bunch of domains to promote their policy agenda and political opinion, that's totally fine with me. Even if it may be somewhat disingenuously designed to look grass roots. It's freedom of speech and I'm in total support of it. (Regardless of how ignorant and stupid it might be). If Russia is doing it to sow discord, that's an act of war in my opinion, and should be dealt with in the harshest, most severe way possible. It won't be, of course, because the President is a Putin lackey (or close enough to one to make no difference), but hopefully come January 20th of next year, we will have a different president who will protect the U.S. like he should.
- thundergolfer 7y agoSo what exactly would the “harshest, most severe possible” actions be? Because when I hear someone say that in the context of war, my mind goes to some pretty severe actions. Would you sanction them? Maybe, but that’s hardly the “most severe”. This is war, after all. Would you missile strike Russia?
- Zenbit_UX 7y agoDirect action action on one military superpower from another doesn't happen anymore, not since the proliferation of nuclear weapons. Any such action would have unthinkable consequences for humanity. America's weapon of choice is economic devastation via sanctions, it can leverage its position in the world to convince its allies to follow suit for added effect. Russia, on the outside of NATO, is forced to play a more subtle game, sowing discord and long term instability.
- russellbeattie 7y agoStarting a conventional or nuclear war with Russia is in the "not possible" category. Sorry if it wasn't clear that I'm not totally insane. I am angry, however, and permanently dissuading Russian leaders from screwing with U.S. politics should be possible by both our intelligence services as well as overt policy. People will literally be dying in the U.S. because of this latest Russian misinformation campaign. If we had a capable leader in the White House, this would be acknowledged and dealt with appropriately.
- rayhendricks 7y agoLink to the reddit thread explaining things here. Alright there is most likely more than one astroturfing actor right now. https://www.reddit.com/r/maryland/comments/g3niq3/i_simply_cannot_believe_that_people_are/fnstpyl/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf https://www.reddit.com/r/maryland/comments/g3niq3/i_simply_c...
- jorblumesea 7y agoWhere is US counter-intel in this? Isn't this what the FBI is supposed to be handling and partially designed for? It seems crazy that possible foreign entities are causing chaos at home and we seem unable (unwilling?) to stop it.
- chameleon_world 7y agoI would bet this is not foreign entities. But who knows. Maybe the FBI are looking into this. They aren't going to tweet about it, so who knows what they are doing.
- karatestomp 7y agoThe protests are being cheered on by the President in his tweets and press conferences, and championed by more mainstream right-wing news (Fox) with constant coverage. I doubt Trump’s FBI is being given much room to investigate this sort of thing, assuming they want to.
- meowface 7y agoWho's to say counter-intelligence isn't already all over it? There's only so much they can do besides monitor, analyze, and attribute it, though. They publicly announce things when there's a lot of aggregated evidence collected over time, and high potential impact, like some of the past official announcements about the election interference. Releasing a statement for every instance of confirmed or suspected disinformation/propaganda just isn't practical and also may just play right into the hands of the intelligence agency they're trying to counter. It's possible the actors may, on some level, actually want their plausibly deniable actions to be recognized in some cases. It creates yet another wedge in American politics, just like all of the other stuff Russian intelligence has done in recent years. They or others may be trying to construct a double bind: one sort of victory if they remain undetected or at least unexposed; another sort of victory if they do get exposed. Not to mention the primary practical purpose of keeping it secret so they can continue to monitor further activity. If they blow the lid on it, they'll change tactics and be harder to trace in the future. That's why spy rings are often tracked over years before being busted, like the case involving Anna Chapman. You can't effectively counter intelligence if you immediately announce that the intelligence has been countered. In infosec terms, it's like burning a zero-day. Also, there isn't any solid evidence this is Russian state-sponsored activity. Certainly a real possibility, but also could just be a random dude trying to make a buck and/or have fun. Either way, there's surely a ton of stuff going on behind the scenes which we're not aware of and may never be aware of. Surely some intelligence or law enforcement people have seen this very thread, or at least the Krebs article. Finally, there could already be some covert countering occurring, like when Cyber Command targeted Russia's IRA troll farm in 2018 and temporarily disabled their internet access.
- renewiltord 7y agoThis is truly wonderful news. Elements like these are powerful self-corrective measures of a free society. A free society can be exploited through propaganda, and this one certainly has, for generations. Now we will be immunized, through the presence of rampant pathogens. And we will be immunized through the deaths of those who are gullible and those around them. Is your city very gullible? You'll have lots of deaths. There is no appreciable Reopen movement in San Francisco. This is vigilance. This is strength. The weak will cull themselves.
- Press2forEN 7y agoOne data point. I attended the local rally in my home town and I've never heard of any of the domains or organizations mentioned in this article. Blanket condemnation of "astroturfing" and "misinformation" just reinforces the bubble.
- Zenbit_UX 7y agoYou attended in support or to watch? Why would you want to me in a crowd of others right now?
- throwawaysea 7y agoI don't understand why it matters if the reopen domains or Facebook groups are being created/organized by some individuals or a group. There are dubious claims from Reddit labeling this as 'astroturfing', but astroturfing would require that these actors create fake accounts or pay for posts or hire actors for protesters. But everything seems to point at the protesters being real individuals who are simply aligned on the sentiment of reopening. Even if someone is gaining in some way from the effort of registering domains, creating Facebook groups, and writing descriptions, I don't think it removes the legitimacy of the underlying sentiment or protesters. I don't think it makes it "less grassroots". After all, literally every other act of protest or campaigning or other activism involves organizing. Unless we're about to claim that anyone performing organizing is astroturfing, it is nonsensical to apply the label here.
- hartator 7y agoWhy can't it be our regular domain squatters? No need to see a super consisparency. People are upset for real. And the withdrawal of rights everywhere is indeed concerning.
- belltaco 7y agoThe article shows exactly why they're not regular domain squatters.
- hartator 7y agoWhere? > Many of the domains are still dormant, leading to parked pages and registration records obscured behind privacy protection services. All of the mentioned domains I check as either parked or a redirection. It can be one guy deciding to surf the wave and waiting for the domains to be bought.
- balozi 7y agoMy thoughts exactly. This seems to me like a the same old domain mining tricks circa 1996. Resume Treadstone soundtrack.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- im3w1l 7y agoSo I read all of this and to me it sounds like much ado about nothing. Can anyone explain, without loaded language, what is wrong here? "People I don't like (gun rights, republicans) are organizing in favor of a cause I don't support (reopening)". Is there any more to it than that?
- papeda 7y agoThe content of the article explores (and to a large extent answers) the question in its headline. It doesn't seem to make any value judgements. It is interesting to see who is behind this cause and organizing to support it. The track record of the Dorr brothers suggests their involvement is not motivated by genuine interest in the cause.
- im3w1l 7y agoI read the article but it's coming from a very different viewpoint than mine. And because of the format of the article it wasn't clear whether all the domains traced to Dorr Brothers or if only some of them did. It keeps going after that connection after all. One thing I'm curious about, if Dorr brothers are ripping off Republicans - why are Republicans not upset? Why are Democrats upset on their behalf?
- casefields 7y agoAnd it was completely wrong: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/reopen-liberate-urls/ https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/reopen-liberate... The political tunnel vision was strong with this one.
- im3w1l 7y agoI don't think your article invalidates the discussion papeda and I had. He may have had "tunnel vision" and only focused on a small part of the story, but as far as I can tell the Dorr Brother involvement has not been discredited.
- happytoexplain 7y ago
- WaitWaitWha 7y agoAt this point, I see two problems with Kreb's article. First, to me only the VA tweet was specific to 2nd Amendment. The others were not. I presume VA was specifically noted because of the recent gun law past there. Second, this smells more like domain kiting or tasting where it worked. Most seem to jump on the "political" bandwagon on the intention of the domain owner. I disagree. Kreb points to "were created just hours after", "Web site design company", and "promoted nothing but spammy paid surveys for years". That reads to me more like an web marketing opportunist trying to get eyeballs for ad revenue.
- CharlesMerriam2 7y agoThe "reopen" campaigns are simple strategy for recruiting members. The states will reopen, eventually and inevitably, and your raw recruits will claim credit for forcing a change on 'the establishment'. Making an assumptive sale that they are cohesive group by registering many domains seems like a valid tactic. What am I missing?
- yellow_postit 7y agoI’d bet a lot of the members also end up on some PAC donation mailing lists supporting predominantly one political party.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- sevencolors 7y agoSeems it wasn't some fringe group. Just an old hippie trying to preempt such groups: https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/reopen-liberate-urls/ https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/reopen-liberate...
- wideasleep1 7y agoWell, that certainly wasn't the dramatic irony I was expecting! “I bought these names to try to stop the insanity, basically. And it just turned to insanity,” he said. He felt forced to unplug his phone, and his inbox exploded with messages attacking him—and potentially trying to hack him. Almost all of the hate was coming from liberals, many of them egged on by presuming posts from amateur Twitter sleuths who mistakenly pegged Murphy as a conservative organizing protests in defiance of nationwide stay at home orders. None of the hate was from conservatives angry at him for keeping them from using the domains themselves." edit: Tomorrow, I wonder if we'll be reading Brian's mea culpa. He did go overboard with the whole Azrael Abyss tone, and was clearly trolled. Poor Guy. On the interwebs, the stories just write themselves.
- elil17 7y agoThere is a fundraiser going on to outbid these gun groups for domains which are being sold by domain resellers: https://www.gofundme.com/f/stop-anticoronavirus-websites-buy-domain-names?utm_source=customer&utm_medium=copy_link&utm_campaign=p_cf+share-flow-1 https://www.gofundme.com/f/stop-anticoronavirus-websites-buy...
- otfc23 7y agoAll you people that believe in "social distancing" and shaming your neighbors on nextdoor are fucking fascists. Rot in Hell!
- lsiebert 7y agoApparently Michael Murphy registered a bunch of domains to try to block people doing this BS, not to support it, and isn't related to the other registrations. https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/reopen-liberate-urls/ https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2020/04/reopen-liberate...
- robocat 7y agoTitle: “How an “Old Hippie” Got Accused of Astroturfing the Right-Wing Campaign to Reopen the Economy” “Murphy snapped up domains for every still available iteration of reopenAL.com, reopenAK.com, reopenAR.com, and so forth, that hadn’t already been purchased, along with every domain he could for variations like liberateWV.com, liberateWY.com, and liberateWI.com.” “I realized all these fringe guys are gonna get a hold of these websites, So I went out and bought ‘em up that night,” he told me. The financial burden of thwarting fringe-right groups? “It cost me about four grand,” Murphy said. “I don’t have the money quite frankly. I was just trying to do something good. I’m in massive credit debt to do this.” “Murphy said that he recognized that his plan isn’t foolproof. While similar domains have already been obtained and still remain up for purchase, he thinks keeping fringe-right wingers from the one’s he purchased has made a difference.”
- drapred7 7y agoGreat find Isiebert. >Almost all of the hate was coming from liberals, many of them egged on by presuming posts from amateur Twitter sleuths [...] None of the hate was from conservatives angry at him for keeping them from using the domains themselves. This is consistent with the GOP astroturfing the registrations. The Left's response is obviously organic, if vitriolic.
- ashtuchkin 7y agoI'm pretty sure the Russian trail in this article is a red herring. I looked up "Валентина Сынах" Skype user and, as expected, their full phone number is +7904xxxxxxx (see full number in the article), with Russian prefix +7. Note, WHOIS records have US number +1904xxxxxxx. Not sure why the author only searched for the last 10 digits. +7 904 code is a very busy area code in Russia shared by several major carriers, covering the majority of Russian regions, so the probability of someone having any particular 7 digits in that area is pretty high. For example there's someone else registered in Skype with number +7904xxxxxx4, just one digit apart. I haven't been able to find an English source, but you can look at the list of carriers and regions in Russian in [1]. Also, US area code +1 904 matches the address in WHOIS records (both Jacksonville, FL), so at least it doesn't look like someone just changed the first digit and used their own Russian number. [1] https://www.kody.su/mobile/904 https://www.kody.su/mobile/904
- gorgoiler 7y agoVery interesting. Friendly heads up: seeing full phone numbers posted here feels quite uncomfortable. If you’re sure there’s no potential for getting it wrong that’s cool but it’s risky if you’re not 100% sure it’s harm-free. Maybe redact them?
- ashtuchkin 7y agoUpdated, thanks!
- Thorentis 7y agoBecause including a potential link to Russia gets more views and outrage.
- f055 7y agoCan't believe nobody here mentioned that his translation is a funny blunder. When you type "валентина сынах" into Google Translate you in fact get "Valentine Sons" but it's a mistake. There's actually a helpful tip showing the correct translation from Ukrainian of the person's name "Valentina Synakh" (Synah, to be accurate). Making a Russian connection out of this is a bit far fetched... But I guess that was the point.
- quotemstr 7y agoI am much more worried about censorship under the guise of "fighting misinformation" than about any level of misinformation. A functioning democracy is robust against people saying random things in public. If you feel the need to use some central authority to stop people saying things --- even if you think those things are "astroturf" or whatever --- something is fundamentally broken. So what if someone wants to launch a bunch of "reopen" websites in some coordinated way? These websites just say something. It's not some kind of attack. It's a bunch of words.
- brianolson 7y agoMinnesota Public Radio reaches similar conclusions https://www.mprnews.org/story/2020/04/20/behind-calls-to-reopen-economy-a-mn-activist-and-his-family https://www.mprnews.org/story/2020/04/20/behind-calls-to-reo...
- teilo 7y agoThese are not "gun rights" groups. These are "gun rights" clickbait scams, targeting the grass-roots conservative types to get them to join various "rights" organizations. There are a bunch of these groups, and they do absolutely no lobbying. I suspect most of them are shell companies for a fewer number of individuals. They claim to be non-profits, but are not tax exempt. They have been around for many years, and they always use the latest hot-button issue to exploit their target audience. I'm amazed no one's gone after them yet.
- explorigin 7y agoKrebs updated the article. Basically all those domains were registered by someone snatching them up before someone else could for the purpose of preventing profiteering.