5 ms·
I'm somewhat fond of the idea of a maximum ratio between the highest and lowest earners in a company, maybe 10:1. So if new employees are started at $50k, the m
by criddell 7y ago
I'm somewhat fond of the idea of a maximum ratio between the highest and lowest earners in a company, maybe 10:1. So if new employees are started at $50k, the max remuneration for any individual would be $500k. This provides an incentive to raise salaries at the bottom.
I would apply this to all forms of payment. So if the CEO gets stock, they would be eligible to receive 10x whatever they give to their lowest level employee.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoThat's how you end up with a lot of super cheap "contractors" and very few actual employees, all of whom will be highly paid upper management.
- coldtea 7y agoWell, then have courts enforce the intent of the law with great punishments that forbid such "creative" bypasses of the spirit of the law...
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoShould Microsoft include janitors and good service workers who have long been outsourced, if they were ever employees at all? Security guards? Delivery people? The barista at the Starbucks nearby? This sounds like a law that would the courts would have a hard time enforcing, because companies and their employees depend on a wide variety of resources these days.
- coldtea 7y ago>Should Microsoft include janitors and good service workers who have long been outsourced, if they were ever employees at all? Security guards? Absolutely. >Delivery people? The barista at the Starbucks nearby? No.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThe starbucks is in a Microsoft building though, so why not? The delivery person only goes between microsoft buildings, so why not? Can we game this by getting rid of food services on campus (everyone has to go "out" for lunch), and by ensuring that all deliveries transit through non Microsoft property?
- coldtea 7y ago>Can we game this by getting rid of food services on campus (everyone has to go "out" for lunch), and by ensuring that all deliveries transit through non Microsoft property? Sure, but I'd still fine you if I was a judge. Like in copyright law that gets abused by copyright trolls, we need more laws that punish attempts to break the spirit of the law, even if they nominally follow the letter...
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoPut it this way: if I'm a tech company building a new campus and I know that I'll have to average food service workers salaries into our stats, why put food service on my campus at all? And if I decide not to put in food service, it having not existed before anyways, how is that breaking the spirit of the law? Do we have some kind of thought police going around figuring out if people make decisions for the "right" reasons or not? Sounds like 1984 to me.
- sct202 7y agoTons of companies already outsource entire departments to 3rd parties like HR, customer support, IT, warehousing, transportation, accounting, janitorial, building maintenance, cafeteria staff, etc. It would basically be the same thing but on steroids.
- airstrike 7y agoThe costs of enforcing those laws aren't zero. Not to mention bribing, corruption, and everything else that comes with micromanaging the economy
- pmiller2 7y agoNot so much "contractors," in terms of actual, physical people, but a split corporate structure where the management company contracts out staffing to the company that actually does the non-executive running of the business. See my sibling comment.
- pmiller2 7y agoThis idea comes up a lot, and, while I like the principle, there's a silly loophole that would need to be closed up somehow. The way I've heard it presented is like this: say you have a company, Burger Corp, where the lowest level cashier is a minimum wage earner making ~$15k per year. That would mean that Burger Corp's CEO could theoretically only be making ~$150k per year, right? The way to get around it is to have all the low level employees be employed by Burger Corp Crew Members Inc, and all the executives be employed by Burger Corp Executive Services Inc. If the lowest level employee of Burger Corp Executive Services makes $500k, then that means the CEO could make $5M. BCES then contracts with BCCM to actually staff the stores. I'm not sure how much of a problem this would actually be, but it does cut against the spirit of the idea of limiting CEO pay. I'm also not sure what the best way to close this loophole would be that also preserves the spirit of the rule, but the lesson here is that people will get around any arbitrary rule like this quite easily. That's actually how we ended up with CEOs having fairly low actual salaries (IIRC, Jeff Bezos takes a salary of around $80k, and a number of CEOs take $1 salaries), and the rest of their comp in stock -- an IRS rule change at some point (I believe in the 80's) is what brought on this trend, which still continues today.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoContracting out things like janitorial and facility maintenance services (basically the same workflow as what you're describing) is how BigCos get to make grandiose claims about how all their employees make at least X. The people making less don't work for them, they work for the facilities maintenance, catering or administrative staffing firms that bigCo hires to provide those services.
- wccrawford 7y agoI think having both the companies owned by the same people would come under quick scrutiny, and the companies would quickly move to finding someone to pay for a "service" for all their low-paid worker needs. So you'd end up with Burger Corp being executives like you said, and then hiring Service Company X to do all their cashiering and burger-flipping and janitorial services. They'd be owned by completely different people, and Service Company X might even service multiple companies much like many temp staffing agencies today. Attempting to stop this would also kill most existing janitorial services among other things, and it'd be really hard to regulate. In the end, things move around, but they don't really change.
- sithlord 7y agoThen companies would just contract out the lowest jobs, and only pay the higher ones.
- charlesu 7y agoMake a law that all contract work must be above $X amount and put some process around it. Hiring individual contractors for low skilled work should be onerous, expensive or both. Do something. We shouldn't simply accept that anything we do will be circumvented and not try at all.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThat is definitely a great way to kick start automation initiatives. Making janitors really expensive to hire means that you either have highly paid (less likely) or janitor robots (more likely). There are lots of opportunities for this in food service as well. This would have a huge side effect of accelerating the robotics industry.
- charlesu 7y agoThat's a great point. Many people will find that the market doesn't value their labor much at all, so we should tax automation as well. We can use the funds to provide income to displaced workers.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoWe will get there eventually, it is unavoidable...labor is rapidly losing in its value proposition vs. capital. The minimum wage puts a bottom on the level of human labor the economy can support. This isn't a bad thing, it pressures people up the labor value chain ($5/hour jobs don't exist, you better be able to do a $10/hour one), and it forces companies to constantly improve productivity to match (e.g. through automation). However, if you move the line too fast, productivity improvements will eliminate lower level labor too quickly, causing problems for society. Artificial restrictions on labor will only cause those things to accelerate unless we tax robots as people (as you propose).
- charlesu 7y agoWe would have to put some laws in place to keep executives from hiring the majority of employees as contractors, but this seems doable. CEO compensation is out of control in the US. We pay way more for executives who don't seem to be anymore talented than their European counterparts. They just have access to a similarly sized but much easier/homogenous (in terms of regulation, language, culture) market.
- scarface74 7y agoI’m sure a lot of people making minimum wage think that the average software developer’s salary is out of control too. Should we regulate that?
- JoeAltmaier 7y agoDeliberately dense? 20K vs 100K is 5X difference. 100K vs 100M is … quite a bit more than 5X. The executive suite has absconded with almost the entirety of the company's wealth, in almost every industry. Engineers are simply 'necessary evils' who haven't been outsourced yet. And curiously, seem content with 0.1% of what the executives say they need to simply to sign our paychecks.
- scarface74 7y agoThe minimum wage contractor working in the cafeteria is not making $20K nor is the average salary of a software engineer in any major city in the US only $100K. The average salary of a software engineer at a FAANGM is far more than $150K
- charlesu 7y agoFAANGM salaries aren't representative of the average software engineer's salary. Software engineering compensation is bimodal much like in the law field. There are a few making $300k+ (mostly in Silicon Valley, New York, and Seattle) and a ton making $60-130k.
- throwaway55554 7y agoYes, this seems very reasonable.
- ken 7y agoCruise ship employee salaries definitely do not start at $50,000/year. More like $5,000: https://www.businessinsider.com/cruise-ship-workers-reveal-how-much-money-they-make-2019-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/cruise-ship-workers-reveal-h... I’m sure they wouldn’t be able to remain profitable if they had to raise labor costs by more than 10x.
- bluGill 7y agoFor the third world counties they hire from those are great wages. By the standard of anyone reading this it isn't of course, but when you don't have options it is good.
- leetcrew 7y agothere are a couple problems with this. if the CEO is also a major shareholder (maybe they're also the founder), they don't actually need salary or bonuses to make huge amounts of money from the business. this can also create a perverse incentive for the salary structure. the CEO's pay is maximized by maximizing the lowest salary in the company. the easiest way of doing this is to pay everyone 1/10th of the CEO's pay. depending on the size of the company and the existing pay disparity, this could make most of the employees worse off than they were before. it might be better to target median or mean compensation instead, although you could probably find pathological counterexamples for these approaches too.
- scarface74 7y agoWould you also be okay if software developers or whatever industry you were in capped salaries where the highest paid employees were only allowed to make 10x what the lowest paid employees made? What if “employees” also included outside contractors that worked for the company (cooks, janitorial services, etc)? What if “employees” included all of the invisible foreign workers that exclusively manufactured for your employer?
- esotericn 7y agoI would be fine with it _iff_ pre-existing wealth were redistributed. As it stands, the idea that my own salary should be restricted is asinine in a world in which someone else starts out with >10M. All you achieve is cementing inequality forever.
- twblalock 7y agoLarger companies would just give their employees raises in order to be able to increase executive salaries, and smaller companies couldn't afford to compete with that. Your suggestion would further increase the dominance of large companies.