13 ms·
Carnival Executives Knew They Had a Virus Problem, but Kept the Party Going
- throwaway55554 7y agoI wonder if a lot of these issues would just go away if CEO compensation of a straight salary that was a reasonable amount.
- godzillabrennus 7y agoWho determines what is a reasonable amount?
- lkrubner 7y agoAs with all things, reasonable people determine what is reasonable. There is a strong element of peer review in this, with reasonable recognizing each other as peers and showing at least some deference to some kind of agreed upon norms, if not about facts, at least about methods of gathering and evaluating facts. A refusal to respect those methods will generally cause reasonable people to view you as unreasonable. This might sounds elitist, but any process involving any kind of peer review necessarily involves people respecting certain approaches to information, while disrespecting other approaches.
- jerf 7y agoWho are the "peers" to a CEO of a company the size of Carnival that will be making the "peer review"? Will anyone be willing to take the job at the price this peer review will be setting? There's a wide range of possible answers to those interrelated questions. I don't have one particular answer in mind. Just pointing out that as nice as your post may sound at a conceptual level, fleshing it out in detail is decidedly non-trivial.
- toolz 7y agoFurther, if you price cap a CEO companies will just make a new position. If you price cap all employees, companies will just make multiple companies and have the leader work multiple jobs. People love to complain about loopholes, but it's feel good legislation ideas like this that empower the people willing to manipulate the system in the first place. If your legislation allows the manipulators to make the most money, you're effectively saying that's what you value the most in society.
- Spooky23 7y agoA 4 star general in the US Army makes something like $300k a year in total compensation. From a value of labor perspective, it’s hard to fathom that the Carnival Cruise Lines CEO is worth $12M annually on the basis of ability. Clearly a premium is being paid for something. Since society worships at the altar of shareholder value, public companies should be required to release data justifying how compensation maximizes shareholder value. For a cruise line, it obvious how paying some filipino able seaman poverty wages advances shareholder interest. And obviously the CFO likes the idea of having line workers from third world countries with limited rights whenever possible. But it’s unclear what the value of the $12M CEO is. What is the expected performance of a $1M CEO?
- arethuza 7y agoThe Royal Navy used to have adverts that said that as a the Captain of a UK Trident sub you could make £100K a year (mind you this was a few years ago) - my genuine reaction was "I don't think that's enough". NB UK nuclear weapons don't have permissive-action locks - they don't need any code from HQ to be able to launch or for the warheads to work. They are completely under the control of their crews so being the captain of one of these subs is quite a responsibility.
- Retric 7y agoThe heads of giant charity’s or government agencies have in similar jobs with vastly less compensation. The idea you can only find people at 50m/year because nobody would do it at 10m/year is ridiculous.
- criddell 7y agoI'm somewhat fond of the idea of a maximum ratio between the highest and lowest earners in a company, maybe 10:1. So if new employees are started at $50k, the max remuneration for any individual would be $500k. This provides an incentive to raise salaries at the bottom. I would apply this to all forms of payment. So if the CEO gets stock, they would be eligible to receive 10x whatever they give to their lowest level employee.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoThat's how you end up with a lot of super cheap "contractors" and very few actual employees, all of whom will be highly paid upper management.
- coldtea 7y agoWell, then have courts enforce the intent of the law with great punishments that forbid such "creative" bypasses of the spirit of the law...
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoShould Microsoft include janitors and good service workers who have long been outsourced, if they were ever employees at all? Security guards? Delivery people? The barista at the Starbucks nearby? This sounds like a law that would the courts would have a hard time enforcing, because companies and their employees depend on a wide variety of resources these days.
- coldtea 7y ago>Should Microsoft include janitors and good service workers who have long been outsourced, if they were ever employees at all? Security guards? Absolutely. >Delivery people? The barista at the Starbucks nearby? No.
- seanmcdirmid 7y ago
- mdszy 7y agoAt a certain point, a mob with the guillotine will.
- LyndsySimon 7y agoWill it though? Even if we set aside the question of whether or not this is a desirable outcome, I can think of exactly one instance where it has happened. Based upon your reference to the guillotine, I assume you're thinking of the same one. I would also note that even the French Revolution didn't exactly turn out as the instigators had wished. Instead of egalitarianism, they got "la Terreur" and decades of violence.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoAnother direction could be a mid six figure baseline salary and the rest of their compensation in the form of stock that vests 2% each year. Now they'll really be interested in the long term health of the company, even needing to make sure it ends up in good hands after they leave. The biggest problem with these kinds of schemes is that there's always going to be some other company that will still use large quarterly bonuses for their compensation package, which most CEOs will take instead.
- pgt 7y agoFor those confused by the headline Carnival is a cruise ship operator, not a festival.
- ginko 7y agoI initially thought this was about the carnival celebration in Gangelt, Germany. https://www.news18.com/news/world/in-german-town-of-gangelt-blood-samples-of-residents-show-14-now-immune-to-covid-19-report-2572279.html https://www.news18.com/news/world/in-german-town-of-gangelt-...
- ginko 7y agoI'm usually not one to complain about this, but may I ask why me admitting that I thought of a carnival event rather than a cruise line I haven't heard of before makes people want to downvote my comment?
- maximuscoolimus 7y agoThe 'misreads' are usually dead ends to discussion unless qualified back to original topic. I would not consider downvotes here personal, they simply steer the conversation to remain on track.
- McKayDavis 7y agoCarnival isn't solely to blame for the situation. Check this story from CNN on Feb 13th titled "Why it's still OK to take a cruise amid the coronavirus outbreak" https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/cruise-safety-coronavirus/index.html https://www.cnn.com/travel/article/cruise-safety-coronavirus...
- darkerside 7y agoThanks for linking this propagandistic PR puff piece. Long on opinion, short on facts, and likely pushed by a cruise industry association. It's a helpful reminder of how media works today.
- Buldak 7y agoIt's unclear to me why you think this article is exculpatory.
- nvahalik 7y agoThe article is being published by a "reputable" online news source. Regardless of whether or not it is truthful, if you saw a CNN article saying it was still safe to cruise, wouldn't you think about it?
- pmiller2 7y agoI could absolutely see people being persuaded that taking a cruise was safe if they saw it on CNN. Personally, I wouldn't be caught dead on a cruise ship, even before the pandemic, but that's just me. I did, however, fall for the "masks aren't necessary for the general public" line that the CDC was pushing for a while. I was doubly stupid, because I had a small stock of N95's from the recent California wildfires that I didn't even use. I'm now wearing one every time I go out other than to walk my dog. Fortunately, I have not (yet) had symptoms of the virus, and I hope I can avoid it for as long as possible, because I have mild asthma and a heart murmur, and don't really need any more cardiorespiratory issues.
- 7y ago
- spodek 7y agoAs someone who used to love flying and relied on it for income, family, etc, but stopped as I learned how much it polluted, pleasantly surprised to find how much my life improved without it, I read articles on the cruise industry as applying to flying. Ticket costs don't cover the costs of cleaning their environmental damage. Few people could afford it if they had to pay for that damage. In the case of contributing to pandemics, flying spreads viruses incredibly effectively. Boats trap a few thousand people at a time. Flights bring the virus to population centers of tens of millions in hours. For the time being, people associate flying with seeing loved ones and making money, so they associate not flying with never seeing their moms or losing their jobs. Experience shows the opposite. The more people fly, the more dispersed their families, so the less they see loved ones. Flying forces companies to fly people everywhere. I predict the vitriol people are starting to show for cruises will eventually make it to flying, however hard to conceive today.
- ses1984 7y ago>The more people fly, the more dispersed their families, so the less they see loved ones. Are you suggesting there is a causative relationship between flying and having a dispersed family?
- leetcrew 7y agois this controversial? the existence of cheap cross-country flights makes it much easier for people to move to the best location for their profession and fly back home to see everyone for easter and christmas (or whatever your big two holidays are).
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoPeople moved across oceans and continents for careers back when those moves took months. Being able to go back and see family is a perk that's moved its way down the income latter with the advent of cheap air travel but I don't think it's making or breaking anyone's decision to relocate or at least not in numbers large enough to matter. People will move far away for their careers regardless but if the cheap long distance transportation exists then people will use it. The people who are working in one city and taking a flight back home every weekend are statistically nonexistent. The people who moved across the country and take a plane back a couple times a year to celebrate as major holiday or something are far more numerous but those people would have still moved without the cheap airfare.
- williesleg 7y agoSo did china.
- hetspookjee 7y agoOfcourse they did, Carnival Cruise Lines is littered with controversies. Just like the almost yearly fine they need to pay for all their dumping on the sea. This is a horrible company in a lot of ways. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnival_Cruise_Line#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carnival_Cruise_Line#Controver...
- JoBrad 7y agoMy wife and I took a cruise for our honeymoon back in 2006. Carnival was very attractive since we were recently out of college and their prices were so cheap compared to everyone else. But just a little digging showed me they don’t take care of their ships, staff, or guests the way they should. Glad we didn’t choose them, and never will.
- crusso 7y agoI took the family on the Carnival Triumph years ago for a first-time cruise. It was okay and we had fun - but we had nothing to compare it to. A few years later we went on a Disney Cruise... we won't be going on Carnival ever again. We also noted that the Triumph was the ship that a few years ago had that engine fire that disabled power and left them adrift for days with toilets overflowing into cabins and no hot food available. Carnival cruises are cheap, but the risk of suffering a trip disaster - possibly with health consequences - is just not worth it.
- mark_l_watson 7y agoMy wife and I have gone on 20+ cruises since selling our own small cruising sailboat 25 years ago. We have decided “never again.” The thing that has put us off the last few cruises is realizing how workers on the ships are treated. Twenty years ago, it seemed to us that we would see off duty room stewards and other crew going ashore with their friends, and getting some down time. I know this is subjective, but over time, it seems like giving workers much needed down time stopped happening. Then fast forward to the present time, my wife and I just don’t want to take a chance getting on a ship because the current new corona virus is so much worse than the Nora virus, which used to be what you worried about on ships. The very real bummer though is this: there are many hundreds of small ports around the world where people rely on extra income from ships disgorging passengers who spend money. A young engineer in Yalta Ukraine told me that he augmented his income as a scientist from tourist related activities, and it was important income for him. Yes, the cruise industry should go away, but there will be collateral damage.
- schnevets 7y agoTo me modern cruises are one of the most egregious cases of late-stage capitalism: The original idea is sound: visit multiple destinations on a mobile hotel! The drive for value is acceptable: make the mobile hotel as fun as the destination with decent restaurants and entertainment But the inevitable result is catastrophic: increasingly gigantic ships that cram customers and attractions in, cost-cutting measures that harm the environment, exploitation of port towns
- eru 7y agoWhy do you think cruise ships are catastrophic? Before the virus hit, they seemed quite popular with paying customers and people were signing up to work for them voluntarily. You might not like it, but that doesn't make the business catastrophic. (I'm not really in the market for a cruise either.) (The main way you could help cruise ship employees would be to give them better outside options. Eg by opening up migration to rich countries more. Or by otherwise improving the economy of the places they hail from.)
- lonelappde 7y ago
- lonelappde 7y agoCruise ships are like diamond jewelry. Terrible products from terrible industries where the purveyors and customers are equally selfish and culpable.
- aaron695 7y agoNo they are not. Cruise ships are giant floating cities that travel the world. They are engineering marvels. You constantly see them in science fiction except in other settings, because they are amazing. A diamond is an amazing rock, but just a rock at the end of the day, with an industry selling something it's not. You're X is probably made from the same "terrible industries" as either of those example. That is a global issue around poverty which leads to the environment, nothing particular to those industries.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoThere will have been a lot of specialized infrastructure and resources to find that diamond and then refine it into a ring, but really, just because something is an engineering marvel means it's not terrible. If I built the most advanced baby smacker, capable of targeting and smacking babies from orbit doesn't mean it's a good idea. All told cruise ships seems like an excellent example of modern wastefulness, polluting more than all the cars in Europe and serving no real purpose to justify their gross excess.
- rswail 7y agoThey are not engineering marvels, they are polluting, their fuel is inefficient and incredibly dirty. They are ecologically damaging dumping their waste in the oceans and at mooring points, their anchorages causing incredible seabed degradation. The companies that own and run them register in tax havens and avoid responsibility for the safety of staff, passengers or the communities they use.
- oiasdjfoiasd 7y agoLol, none of what you just said refutes the fact that they are engineering marvels. Anyone that has been on a cruise ship can appreciate the magnitude and scale of engineering, logistics, etc. that went into it.
- nerdponx 7y agoHow is this not reckless endangerment in most states, or even manslaughter in the cases where someone died? Criminal charges are a necessary stopgap against market failures.
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoCruise companies were facing extinction either way, so they were simply waiting for international guidance from WHO so they could pass the buck.
- nerdponx 7y agoValid or otherwise, that doesn't make their behavior any less criminal in my opinion.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 7y agoWe did Carnival few years ago. It was a first for me. My wife and her family went on multiple vacations like that. Do not get me wrong. Our time was pleasant. That said, I talked with some of the workers there and it is no wonder the cruises are as cheap as they are. Cheap labor will do that. I am genuinely curious if the more expensive variations rely less on tax avoidance/evasion ( whichever was the legal one ) and cheap labor.
- foob4r 7y agoNothing at these corporations changes until both executives and low level minions get charged with felonies, and taken to trial. They must be deposed, brought to stand. Simply settling by paying the equivalent of x days of profits is not justifiable anymore.
- rayuela 7y agoThis seems like the very exact case where you'd want to pierce the corporate veil. If this doesn't qualify then what does?
- runnr_az 7y agoLooking forward to the inevitable legislation limiting lawsuits / damages related to Covid. Irony factor: it'll come from the same congress members who are now pushing the "allow people to sue China" agenda.
- throwaway_USD 7y ago>Irony factor: it'll come from the same congress members who are now pushing the "allow people to sue China" agenda. I think it will work something like this, the cruise ships are insured, the insurers will settle these cases and then the insurers will recover against China/Chinese owned assets. >the "allow people to sue China" agenda. Maybe that is a very legitimate agenda.
- acqq 7y agoThe good side: the ships allowed us to have the data about COVID-19 that could not be otherwise easily obtained. One could hardly invent better "experiment setup" with the real people. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_on_Diamond_Princess https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_coronavirus_pandemic_on_D... But some "experts" however decided to ignore the existence of that data, and even as it was already available in Wikipedia, continued to spread the claims (which are even now repeated!) that "we know too little about this disease to do anything, so better not doing anything before we do some 'random testing'."
- 3fe9a03ccd14ca5 7y agoIn their defense, February was a very confusing time for the virus, and it’s easy to look back in hindsight judgement. For example, on Feb 24 Pelosi was in crowded Chinese New Year celebration in China town urging people to “come down”. They were still calling the China travel ban “racist” and “xenophobic” during this time. Trump was bragging about 14 cases and saying we have it under control. People just really weren’t grappling with the seriousness of the situation. Now we all know, and we’re eager to blame different people and institutions. Not only that, but politicians are trying to rewrite their own histories. Don’t let them do that.
- caseysoftware 7y ago> the following morning, John joined about 200 other passengers in the ship’s Broadway-style theater for a lecture on Clint Eastwood movies. “I’m surprised they’re even letting this event happen,” he whispered to a nearby friend. “This is a big crowd.” Says the guy attending the event! This is what gets me about so much of the coverage. Most of it revolves around "look at all the foolish people around me!" and is completely oblivious of the fact that they're also participating in the same thing.
- satokema_work 7y agoLines like "kept the party going" make me think of David Foster Wallace's "A Supposedly Fun Thing I'll Never Do Again" and sound right on brand for a cruise line. Having read that titular essay, I have no desire to ever go on a cruise.
- oska 7y agoOnline copy of the original version of that essay: https://harpers.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/HarpersMagazine-1996-01-0007859.pdf https://harpers.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/09/HarpersMagazi...
- chvid 7y agoBefore we blame the cruise lines, the fitness clubs, the airlines, the ski resorts, the buffet restaurants ... lets remind ourselves that it is not a job for random companies to access the seriousness of potential pandemic virus. They have to, they should, rely on what the authorities say and the rules they lay out. The health authorities are the only ones who have the full picture and a chance to assess this. That the CDC according the article blames Carnival cruises really is not a good look.