4 ms·
You can get a phone line basically anywhere for the same reason you can get mail there, and if you can get a phone line then you can get dial-up, which doesn't
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
You can get a phone line basically anywhere for the same reason you can get mail there, and if you can get a phone line then you can get dial-up, which doesn't get you YouTube but it does get you email and online banking and all of those sorts of things.
- kitotik 7y agoSo, “let them eat cake”.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoHow is that not a completely viable solution? Have you actually used dial up? It's terrible slow compared to broadband but a whole lot faster than mailing a letter.
- RedShift1 7y agoYes, dial up is technically still internet... But do you really get internet that way? Websites these days are made for broadband, some of them coming in at a few MB just to get to the login screen. Plus you gotta turn off all non-essential internet communication in Windows (telemetry, updates, ...) or that 4 kB/s you get are lost to that. If you're paying by the minute it's going to get expensive real fast.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIts purpose isn't to be real internet, its purpose is just to do what the postal service does. It doesn't matter if cnn.com has 500MB of javascript because you're not going there, you're just doing email and banking. And nobody pays by the minute anymore.
- RedShift1 7y agoBut even those banking and webmail sites are in the order of megabytes.
- orwin 7y agoYou assume that all these people have AC current. I know for a fact that at least half a dozen american in West Virginia (lincoln county) get there only electricity with solar panels. Yes, they can access their emails thanks to the public library, but how much longer this public service will stay open?
- kitotik 7y agoWhat are they using to connect to these services? An up to date windows 10 laptop? A MacBook? You are making a lot of assumptions about a lot of people. Even on a completely updated, modern machine try throttling your bandwidth to 56k and paying your bills via your banks website.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago"Up to date"? The latest version of Windows 10 can technically run on hardware older than anybody would have any interest in using. Like late 1990s or so. Anybody can get a much newer PC than that, like an early Core i5, for around $50-$100, which someone might actually want to use. Dial up is slow. But if that's the problem you want to solve then how do you do it by subsidizing the postal service?
- sio8ohPi 7y agoI just paid my credit card bill at 50k down/20k up. It's fine. Took about half an hour, but I'm browsing HN (also throttled) in this tab so it's not too inconvenient. You could also read a book or cook or something.