3 ms·
Maybe it's time. The whole USPS as a quasi-governmental entity thing has been an anachronism for about a hundred years and a farce ever since email replaced its
by AnthonyMouse 7y ago
Maybe it's time. The whole USPS as a quasi-governmental entity thing has been an anachronism for about a hundred years and a farce ever since email replaced its raison d'etre.
Just delete every law on the books that distinguishes it in any way from UPS or FedEx and let it live or die on its own merits.
- kitotik 7y agoSo price most rural citizens out of mail?
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoWhat mail? Spam? People don't mail things anymore. It's why they're going out of business. And it's not like mail would be unavailable. If it cost $2 for rural customers to mail a letter instead of $.50, would it really matter for the two letters that still get mailed a year?
- kitotik 7y agoYou seem to be disconnected from rural life completely. Many people rely on physical mail for things like social security checks, taxes, bills, communication with family and friends. Remember, broadband never actually got rolled out everywhere like phones did(hint: one was considered a vital utility)
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Many people rely on physical mail for things like social security checks, taxes, bills, communication with family and friends. All of those things can be done on the internet and don't require broadband. Also, how many times a year do you have to file your taxes, if you really want to do it that way?
- jackyinger 7y agoMy brother bought a rural place that doesn’t have any internet whatsoever, and it’s not that far out in the sticks. If internet access is needed to interact with the government/banks/etc, we have to do better to provide it to rural folks.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoYou can get a phone line basically anywhere for the same reason you can get mail there, and if you can get a phone line then you can get dial-up, which doesn't get you YouTube but it does get you email and online banking and all of those sorts of things.
- kitotik 7y agoSo, “let them eat cake”.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoHow is that not a completely viable solution? Have you actually used dial up? It's terrible slow compared to broadband but a whole lot faster than mailing a letter.
- RedShift1 7y agoYes, dial up is technically still internet... But do you really get internet that way? Websites these days are made for broadband, some of them coming in at a few MB just to get to the login screen. Plus you gotta turn off all non-essential internet communication in Windows (telemetry, updates, ...) or that 4 kB/s you get are lost to that. If you're paying by the minute it's going to get expensive real fast.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoIts purpose isn't to be real internet, its purpose is just to do what the postal service does. It doesn't matter if cnn.com has 500MB of javascript because you're not going there, you're just doing email and banking. And nobody pays by the minute anymore.
- jdxcode 7y agoIf starlink gets off the ground as promised broadband will be a solved problem. I feel like the most likely scenario right now is it will take on a limited form of its current self, maybe delivery once per week? Much higher postage?
- kitotik 7y agoLots of things could happen, but likely not by Q3 when they are projected to run out of money.
- jariel 7y ago"Many people rely on physical mail for things like social security checks, taxes, bills, communication with family and friends." A somewhat higher postage rate would not affect this that much, and no, there are not that many people always sending letters, and broadband isn't required to pay bills. The vast, vast majority of mail (even bills sent etc.) is completely wasted, it would be incredibly more efficient to dump it in lieu of sending 'only the mail that is needed'.
- sio8ohPi 7y ago> social security checks, taxes, bills Sounds like we could go to weekly or even bimontly delivery for all of these. > communication with family and friends My grandmother had a telephone growing up deep in rural Kentucky 80 years ago. It's 2020. Get with the times.
- mlyle 7y agoI'm more concerned that it may be drastically expensive-- or completely unavailable-- for rural people to receive packages. Right now UPS/FedEx/etc don't go everywhere and rely upon USPS for last mile in many areas.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoEither that wouldn't happen or it would be solved by the UPS equivalent of a PO box, which eliminates the last mile problem by moving the mailbox.
- orwin 7y agoYou assume these people all have cars. You know what? The best solution is lifting taxes (most of them don't pay much anyway) and usual phone bills (that are freaking expensive for the service it provides). it will probably cost less than to pay for the last mile.
- alkibiades 7y agoif that’s the worry we can just subsidize UPS etc to service them. it’s a lot cheaper and more efficient than this
- kitotik 7y agoYou’ve hit the crux of the situation here: you either support some things being nationalized for the greater benefit of society, or you take the neoliberal approach and say “there is no society, may the best corporation win”. I have no doubt that privatizing all mail can generate better margins and return some nice profits to a handful of individuals at the expense of less citizens having access to the service.
- notacoward 7y agoIt's only efficient as a way to funnel taxpayer money into stockholders' pockets. "Privatizing" a service but continuing to pick winners and subsidize them isn't really privatizing and isn't compatible with a real free market. It's literally a kind of command economy, albeit one designed to benefit only a few.
- bhupy 7y ago> continuing to pick winners and subsidize them Another approach could be to just give rural Americans more cash, and let them pick the winners, as consumers.
- HideousKojima 7y agoOne big potential issue is that it's the only legal way to serve lawsuits and court orders other than in person, IIRC.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoAnybody who can't afford to have a courier hand-deliver the thing and is still doing it has no idea how much a lawsuit actually costs. This would also provide an opportunity to fix it the other way -- instead of requiring the USPS to do it, allow any certified letter carrier to do it even if it's UPS or FedEx.
- 0x5f3759df-i 7y agoOr maybe we accept that the postal service was important enough to include in the constitution, [1] stop demanding an important government service pay for itself, and just give USPS tax funding to make up any shortfall. Lets also not forget that UPS and FexEx often use USPS for the last mile of their shipments. [2] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_Clause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Postal_Clause [2] https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-mail-does-the-trick-for-fedex-ups-1407182247 https://www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-mail-does-the-trick-for-fed...
- sio8ohPi 7y agoThe post office was important in 1787 to "provide the means of intercourse between the citizens of remote parts of the confederation, on such a regular footing, as must contribute greatly to the convenience of commerce, and to the free, and frequent communication of facts, and sentiments between individuals." It is totally obsolete for this purpose, having been almost totally supplanted by phone calls, email, text messages, IM, and video calls.