6 ms·
What's interesting is the extent to which the real pandemic seems to have been handled better than the simulation, despite what is objectively a less effective
by ajross 7y ago
What's interesting is the extent to which the real pandemic seems to have been handled better than the simulation, despite what is objectively a less effective federal response than the one envisioned (in practice, the actual federal response seems to have done more harm than good as far as disease control goes -- the one bright spot was the economic response).
It turns out that a few early mover states were more willing than expected to institute rigorous lockdowns, other states followed on more rapidly than expected, and the population as a whole (even in states with less effective responses) was... actually fairly well informed and took appropriate action.
Basically, we stayed home and beat this. Now we need to finish the job, of course, but absent some kind of crazy change in public behavior we're not going to see the doomsday numbers that everyone was worried about.
- chapium 7y agoIf we had patient zero the outlook could have been even worse.
- remote_phone 7y agoI’m actually surprised at how compliant citizens were in general. I would have expected more rioting or pushback but I guess that’s what we are seeing right now. It’s been 6 weeks and I’m surviving but my wife and kids are not doing as well. I can only imagine how bad some people have it, especially those in apartments. At some point people are going to do the math and figure that 80% mild symptoms rate that leads to immunity and a decent job is worth the risk rather than starving to death alone. I think that breaking point will be reached before end of June and I hope there are measures to deal with that. Personally I would give everyone $2000/month and drop prices of marijuana to keep the masses from rioting.
- mrfusion 7y agoWell the hospitals have plenty of excess capacity now. We’ve very successfully flattened the curve. It might be time to ease up. I thought this doctor explained the idea better than I could: https://medium.com/@jbgeach/eight-reasons-to-end-the-lockdowns-as-soon-as-possible-b7bb0bc94f00 https://medium.com/@jbgeach/eight-reasons-to-end-the-lockdow... But I’m just winging this like everyone. I could certainly be wrong.
- ajross 7y agoOnly in some areas. New York is still teetering right at capacity. Active cases have not dropped much at all, in fact. It's the rate of new infections that has leveled off. This is good evidence that the exponential growth has been halted. No, it's not time to ease up. Unlike in February, we have effectively zero buffer in many areas. A sudden increase in cases (which is what "easing up" means!) would push us right over the edge. We ease up when the outbreak can be sustained. It can't now, and won't for several weeks, maybe two months more. Stay home.
- mrfusion 7y agoWow that’s a much worse outlook than I’ve been hearing. Do you have a source on the zero buffer areas? I’ll have to read up more. I know in Florida we had to furlough a lot of medical staff because they didn’t get as many cases as expected and elective procedures are banned.
- ryankemper 7y agoIt really is highly ironic that by instituting a national lockdown and telling citizens to avoid the hospital across-the-board (instead of specifying high-impacted areas like New York), we destroyed tons of jobs in the medical industry. I dislike citing news articles, I'd prefer to cite real research, but here's a crappy source: https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2020/04/02/coronavirus-pandemic-jobs-us-health-care-workers-furloughed-laid-off/5102320002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/health/2020/04/02/corona... -- When I first started hearing about the Coronavirus and figuring out the situation, my initial reaction was that we need to foster herd immunity, and avoiding exposure is near-impossible over the long run therefore we should just "get it over with" - not going out of our way to get infected but also not hiding. Then as we heard about Italy, France, etc, my view shifted, and I viewed the lockdown as a necessary evil. I've now swung back the other way. Time will tell, but I really think that subsequent research we'll show that we took a huge problem - a covid pandemic - and turned it into two huge problems - a pandemic along with significant swaths of our economy getting destroyed. The argument to flatten the curve, beyond preventing exceeding hospital capacity, which is absolutely a critical goal, was also that those of us who are not at serious risk could spread to those who _are_ at risk, and therefore everyone needs to act in lockstep. Well, if you take a systems-level view, absolutely the best thing a non-at-risk person can do is get exposed to covid, fully quarantine themselves, and then return to daily life. Having a huge swath of the population with immunity is the best way to protect our at risk population. (In a perfect world, we could culture sars-cov-2 and voluntarily expose ourselves - basically a vaccine except you're exposing yourself to the real deal and not a virus rendered inert) Also, back on the "exceeding hospital capacity" point, it is precisely those at-risk who are filling up hospitals and needing intubation or ventilation. So we can have a huge portion of the population who is not at risk still living their lives (with some adjustments), and the effect on hospitalizations would really not be that bad as a result. I'll be closely following Sweden's data over the next months. I'm very curious how their strategy pans out.
- Der_Einzige 7y agoPot prices in the original legal states are already very low (with the possible exception of California which is double that of Oregon or Washington). There is a massive oversupply of the stuff on the west coast. I wouldn't complain about 80$ oz's turning into 50$ oz's, but it doesn't seem all that necessary. Also, folks shouldn't be smoking or even vaping right now (what's the point of making your possible lung complications from COVID worse???) Just make edibles.
- viklove 7y agoIt's so messed up to me that we would rather see food rotting on the shelves of supermarkets (ag output has barely slowed down at all), instead of just providing American citizens with the UBI they need to feed themselves through this pandemic. Why are we all so willing to risk our lives to prop up Q3 earnings reports for useless corporations that aren't necessary during this crisis?
- clairity 7y agomost of us don't care a lick about corporate earnings. we risk our lives every day just by waking up and doing anything, to the tune of 8000 american deaths a day (for example). should we just remain socially isolated for the rest of our lives instead? life is risk, and so risk is not a reason to forgo life.
- viklove 7y agoAre you trying to imply that all risk is equivalent? I'm not saying we should "forgo life," I'm just wondering why so many people are rushing to get back to driving Ubers, flipping burgers, etc. in the midst of this pandemic. It's not worth the risk of COVID, which is much, much higher than the baseline risk of everyday life.
- nradov 7y agoJust because people aren't rioting doesn't mean they are actually complying. And compliance will only decline further as time passes. I'm not endorsing this behavior but it's inevitable.
- mrfusion 7y agoI still want to see how Sweden ends up before we pat ourselves on the back. And I know it’s quite the contrarian viewpoint but it remains to be seen if the cure is worse than the disease. How many small businesses and livelihoods have we lost? How many suicides? How much unemployment?
- ryanobjc 7y agoThis analysis won’t work well because people will compare the what happened to the what happened. “It wasn’t worth 100,000 deaths to kill the economy” will be the stupid refrain. Never mind that what kind of economy would we have had with 2M deaths and bodies buried in Central Park?
- mrfusion 7y agoI’m not following your logic. If Sweden ups up not being too bad it would seem to imply we wouldn’t have had two million deaths (especially in NYC alone. I don’t think anyone thinks a 25% IFR)
- ajross 7y agoSweden is already above the US deaths per capita rate, still growing where we have peaked, and much higher than their neighbor nations in both cases and deaths. Also note that Sweden isn't exactly "not locked down" anyway. They didn't institute the hard rules in the same way that, say, Missouri did. Yet the population did it anyway, because they watch the news and see other areas shutting down. So restaurants are open, but empty. Theaters are closed. People are working from home. (Schools are open, which is one difference from most US states). Sweden is absolutely not unaffected economically. Also recognize that Sweden, like other nations in scandanavia, had a much smaller and somewhat later outbreak vs. the ones we saw elsewhere in Europe. They had warning that the Italians didn't. So it's a spectrum thing. They chose to accept some lessser economic impact (how much less isn't really measured yet) at the cost of some number of deaths vs. similar data in Norway and Finland. The policy you are arguing for via "open up the economy" almost certainly doesn't look like Sweden.
- 7y ago
- colordrops 7y ago> some kind of crazy change in public behavior It's already happening with protests in several states.
- eru 7y agoThe private sector response was pretty decent. For example, the major American sports leagues shut down on their own before the US government had any clue about what to do.