3 ms·
A patchwork of "targeted" programs is unsatisfactory for many reasons. It lets people fall through the cracks, and it results in unintended effects as the progr
by zozbot234 7y ago
A patchwork of "targeted" programs is unsatisfactory for many reasons. It lets people fall through the cracks, and it results in unintended effects as the programs are not designed or managed in a consistent way. The need for some sort of minimal income floor is universal, and it should be addressed in a universally-applicable way.
- zhoujianfu 7y agoExactly.. my personal genealogy for discovering UBI was: The government should provide for a base level of food, medicine, housing, and education. But let private industry compete for it, so just provide vouchers for each of those things. But, how to efficiently allocate the amounts for each individual? How much health care voucher vs. food voucher vs. housing voucher vs. education voucher? Ah, just have a universal “health or food or housing or education” voucher! Oh, but what about transportation! Okay, a universal “housing, food, medicine, transportation, and education” voucher. Oh wait, we have one of those already! The dollar.
- limomium 7y agoYes. And the "universal" part makes it UNCONDITIONAL on receive, which is the important part. It removes the necessity for a government institution to decide per individual how much they are eligible for. Much money is saved. Since the government already has an institution for checking taxes, the conditionality is merely moved to the end - they check not whether you get UBI, but just how much taxes you owe.
- ineedasername 7y agoBut then people need to go out and shop for those things using UBI, for example compete for housing in markets that may offer no affordable housing, but housing subsidies would help resolve that. If targeted programs can be poorly designed or mismanaged inconsistently, then so could UBI. The whole idea is to thoughtfully design a program. If that is possible, there's no reason we can't thoughtfully design targeted programs, and UBI would still be there in a lesser capacity precisely for those people that would fall through the cracks of those targeted programs. UBI just feels like a kind of sledgehammer, when a dozen scalpels might perform better. I'll grant that UBI would be superior to the very loose "safety net" of social programs in the US though. Even with a "strong" UBI program, I still think we'd need other programs as well-- UBI will be far too low for people that suddenly lose a job that pays 5x UBI and need to get by until they find new comparable employment, as an example.
- limomium 7y agoFar too low for what, exactly? Buying real estate, cars, expensive clothing, huge TVs and investments? If you suddenly lose a well-paying job, food and housing still cost the same for everyone, which you can afford on UBI, by design. You'll have to give up the expensive lifestyle afforded by the lost job, of course. Maybe move to cheaper housing. So what?
- 6510 7y agoA tailored program would not allow you to keep your 100 k in savings.