5 ms·
> In other words, data enthusiasts (such as myself) should leave the modelling up to the professionals. This is really important to understand, and unfortunate
by littlestymaar 7y ago
> In other words, data enthusiasts (such as myself) should leave the modelling up to the professionals.
This is really important to understand, and unfortunately often overlooked, especially by economists, who often work with good data and solid mathematical background but no prior domain knowledge and no reference to literature of the given field.
- glofish 7y agono, I really don't think so. no epidemiologist actually has seen anything like what we are seeing today, they are not all that well prepared. this disease defies the models, youth is unaffected etc. If they were prepared well then they would not insist on imposing the exact same rules for NYC as for rural NY State. The two places could not be any more different.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoDefine "like". People haven't seen the exact scenario, but people - epidemiologists and others - have studied the Spanish Flu, and MERS, SARS, H1N1, seasonal flus, etc., which all have useful similarities.
- glofish 7y agonone of these diseases are anything like this, no person under 18 has died of the disease in Italy, 3% or less of cases in population under 20 etc. many people don't show symptoms but are quite infectious etc which disease is like that? none actually.
- MrPatan 7y agoGiven how bad the data about the current pandemic is, why do you think data about previous pandemics was any better?
- frank2 7y agoBecause there has been more time to collect and analyze the data about the previous ones.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoAnd because there's far less political pressure to obfuscate figures of past epidemics.
- littlestymaar 7y agoDo your know why the Spanish Flu was called this way ? Because Spain was one of the few countries not involved in WWI, and then didn't had the strong level of censorship that was ubiquitous at this time. Pressure to obfuscate the impact of the epidemic where way higher then.
- jeremyjh 7y agoYes but we know quite a lot about its spread and impact now. This is like the fog of war, its hard to see what is happening while a battle is underway but afterward many different accounts can be pieced together to gain an accurate understanding of what happened.
- littlestymaar 7y agoAgree, as I agreed with frank2's comment upthread too.
- etangent 7y agoI have not seen a single useful model from professional epidemiologists so far -- at least nothing that would guide me better than "look at China and Italy and consider that it might also happen here."
- xzel 7y agoI would argue that they're all useful but its very tough to be accurate when confounding actions are occurring to the problem. For example, in the US, the increase in social distancing measures and mask usage couldn't be easily baked into the original models. Forecasting accurately is very tough. Look at what's been said about Renaissance and its Medallion fund, they're right a little over 50% (they just leverage very heavily). Think about that, the most consistent and dominate hedgefund might only be right about 51% of the time. The issue with just using historical data is the data might be different. But I'm sure all of their models were using data or at least some domain knowledge from the spread in Italy and China.
- icelancer 7y ago>> For example, in the US, the increase in social distancing measures and mask usage couldn't be easily baked into the original models. The IHME model - one of the most cited models - explicitly factored this into their model.
- mattkrause 7y ago"Factored in" covers a lot of ground. Here, for reference is the IHME model preprint: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.27.20043752v1.full.pdf https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.03.27.20043752v... The parameterization of social distancing is on pages 3-4. They considered four coarse categories of interventions, with the total effect given by a ad hoc score of 1, 0.67, 0.334, or 0. It should be blindingly obvious that can be improved upon with more data and work. Moreover, the effects of social distancing aren't even constant--compliance certainly varies from place to place and over time (enforcement changes, people get restless).
- 7y ago
- KCUOJJQJ 7y agoI panicked a bit in March, partly because I watched a video of a mathematics YouTuber, who I think is pretentious. Usually I don't watch his videos, because I think he's pretentious. But I watched his video about exponential growth and epidemics. At the end there is the text "The only thing to fear is the lack of fear itself." (the opposite of what Franklin D. Roosevelt said). I would have panicked less if I had read the text of this hacker news story, instead.