11 ms·
This got me to think about the ACLU and what they are doing. I see some issues about accommodating justice and other issues affected by the pandemic and the in
by mc32 7y ago
This got me to think about the ACLU and what they are doing.
I see some issues about accommodating justice and other issues affected by the pandemic and the intersection with liberties... it's more about looking at the compounding effect than protecting against fundamental change and fundamental threats to civil rights.
But I don’t see any take on any measures governments have taken to kerb civil rights in the time of the pandemic as well as talk about tracking and contact tracing. Also kerbs on the right to assembly and to go out and about, etc.
Yes this would abut against the fight against the disease, but that’s not their job. They usually don’t contextualize liberties. But here they seem silent and it’s a bit puzzling.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThe ACLU has largely transitioned away from civil rights absolutism towards progressive advocacy. They haven't entirely tossed it out the door, and still sometimes defend the civil rights of non-progressive groups, but the modern ACLU definitely feels it's important to contextualize liberties.
- rootusrootus 7y agoAgreed, they have significantly changed over even just the last few years. It makes me a little sad, because we have plenty of progressive advocacy groups, and I appreciated the ACLU trying to be more focused.
- yingw787 7y agoYeah, that is interesting. I donate to the ACLU monthly and I haven't gotten anything related to the pandemic, just regular board of directors voting. ...are they working on the EARN IT act by any chance?
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoTheir current efforts are focused on getting lots of people released from jails and prisons, since they might catch COVID-19 if they're in jail.
- mc32 7y agoSee I don’t get it. If one of these people who get early release so much as go fishing somewhere they can end up back in jail. That seems perverse to me.
- zozbot234 7y agoThat helps with social distancing. It's not a bad thing given the circumstances.
- yingw787 7y agoCool. I'll keep my donations flowing.
- duckMuppet 7y agoWell it's far more important to have the ACLU working on advocacy and rights for LGBTQ+ where there are demonstrable acts of violence and systemic oppression rather than waste time hand holding individuals who think they should be able purchase an Arsenal of firearms and spread Covid by not obeying and respecting their fellow citizens through their non compliance. I'd say they are definitely where they need to be.. It's prudent and wise they not be involved with rabble rousers who through their non compliance, indifference, and questioning of authority silently slaughter members of minority communities that this disease adversely affects more than wealthy elites who miss their bed bath and beyond or their tee time.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoRight, this is the kind of position I was referring to. The modern ACLU tends to direct their attention towards specific identity groups they feel are most deserving. I don't think they're quite as far along that path as you are - I can't imagine an ACLU representative implying you have a civic duty to unquestioningly accept the government's pandemic control measures - but maybe I'm wrong.
- soulofmischief 7y agoIn Robert D. Putnam's Bowling Alone, he talks about how several independent studies have elucidated that in modern times, civil engagement is at an all-time high when one considers the average number of civil group memberships per American (It's greater than one!), however the average number of Americans holding leadership positions within a civil group has plummeted. We also attend far fewer in-person events. The reality is clear. Civil leadership has been consolidated into the ranks of middle management and ad executives. Modern civil activism is pay-by-mail, one-newsletter-at-a-time, simply install and forget. If you find yourself frustrated with the leadership of the civil groups you maintain, consider splintering you and those in your groups who trust you into a new civil group which focuses on a local level: Local canvasing could be far more effective than distributing online propaganda.
- andrepd 7y ago>Local canvasing could be far more effective than distributing online propaganda. I tend to believe that, but are you aware of any studies that try to show that?
- soulofmischief 7y agoNothing comes to mind, but I'll ping you if I come across any.
- projektfu 7y agoI haven't seen a test case, but I wonder if they'd still come out and support unpopular speakers? https://www.aclu.org/other/aclu-history-taking-stand-free-speech-skokie https://www.aclu.org/other/aclu-history-taking-stand-free-sp... That was a classically apt appearance because no doubt a hypothetical Nazi state would ban the ACLU. I've been personally torn about this myself. I got chewed out once by a professor for advocating that people turn out to oppose David Horowitz. My opinion was that his speech was foul and needed obvious opposition, but I didn't want him shouted down. I thought that his schtick of going to universities promoting "academic freedom" which basically meant being able to tell liberal professors to shut up was dreck. However, he was shouted down and couldn't be heard. I felt bad about that, and agreed with the professor in the end. But, in a way, the dude was getting a taste of his own medicine: he certainly advocated for deplatforming people himself.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoThey defended Milo Yiannopoulos in 2017, so I'm willing to let them ride on that for a few more years.
- mc32 7y agoIt seems you’re right and it’s a shame that in this time when a few governments are taking advantage of the situation they don’t have their ears perked and tuned to ensure governments (local, state, fed) aren’t going overboard, impinging rights, or looking to erode them. I mean this affects the whole US constituency.
- projektfu 7y agoI think the protestors are being stupid, but if they get arrested I would like to see the ACLU help defend them. Even though I think established law would put them in the "shouting fire in a crowded theater" camp, unless the courts are willing to reverse that precedent.
- kragen 7y agoThat precedent was comprehensively reversed by the 1950s.
- projektfu 7y agoCool, hopefully that's the case. I'm not familiar enough with the case law to know. It's just a salient point of my high school education.
- loeg 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Wendell_Holmes_Jr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oliver_Wendell_Holmes_Jr. The quote you know dates to 1919 and was a metaphor used to justify suppression of political speech during WWI. https://www.oyez.org/cases/1900-1940/249us47 https://www.oyez.org/cases/1900-1940/249us47 It's pretty fucking shameful. https://www.popehat.com/2018/06/28/make-no-law-episode-seven-fire-in-a-crowded-theater/ https://www.popehat.com/2018/06/28/make-no-law-episode-seven... for a great podcast about it.
- kragen 7y agoMy deepest condolences on your high school "education".
- geofft 7y agoYou mentioned Milo downthread, but I'll give another counterexample: the ACLU sued the city of Charlottesville when they said they'd only permit Unite the Right to happen at the larger McIntire Park on safety grounds. As a result of the lawsuit, the rally happened at the much smaller and busier Lee Park. (Personally, that's why I no longer support the ACLU - this wasn't analogous to the Illinois Nazis case, and as everyone expected, violence happened and someone died. I felt like the ACLU had let their focus on civil rights absolutism drive them to defending someone whose civil rights weren't actually under threat instead of spending their resources on actual ongoing threats to civil rights.)
- dmix 7y agoACLU changed their policy of supporting everyone against any freedom of speech and freedom of assembly repression by the government AFTER Charlottesville. That only supports the OP's point. That was the point they gave into to pressure from outside groups and gave up their values. Compromising once is enough to compromise it always and their recent posturing on social media has done nothing to dissuade that this is the case. They've only doubled down and joined the outrage mob driven political system. I personally don't want to live in a world where every political ideology needs their own legal defence non-profits which only do things for political ends... not for a higher purpose. Largely because they lose tons of credibility in the face of dismissal when they compromise their values for politics. Credibility is very important in this sort of thing. Plenty of other major human rights groups including Human Rights Watch and the ACLU long defended far-right groups and the world didn't burn down in the 1960s, 70s, 80s, 90s, etc. They did it because they same thing that shuts those 'bad guys' down will be used to bring down the 'good guys'. I highly recommend the founder of Human Rights Watch's book on this topic when they defended Neo-nazis in the 1970s: Defending My Enemy: American Nazis in Skokie, Illinois, and the Risks of Freedom: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aryeh_Neier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aryeh_Neier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_America_v._Village_of_Skokie https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Socialist_Party_of_Am... https://www.amazon.com/Defending-My-Enemy-Neier/dp/0525089721 https://www.amazon.com/Defending-My-Enemy-Neier/dp/052508972...
- 7y ago
- goodrubyist 7y agoWoah, took me some time to digest this -- "contextualize liberties" must be the most Orwellian phrase in existence, only thing that might come close is another phrase you used, "civil rights absolutism."
- 411111111111111 7y agoSo in your opinion I should have the right to enslave you? Some liberties have to be put into context to see that they're plain amoral. It's easy for slavery, but harder for other topics. The same applies to the other expression you have an issue with. Some freedoms are detrimental to society and accepting them causes actual harm to people. Things are never easy with topics like this.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- modwest 7y agoThe famous “yelling fire in a crowded theory” test for free speech is an example of contextualizing liberties. There is nothing truly Orwellian about it. “Your right to swing your arms ends just where the other man’s nose begins” is another example. Society is a context where we exercise our liberties.
- nisuni 7y agoThe yelling fire example is an extreme edge case, and it’s usually used by people who would like to limit freedom of speech much more than that. I’ve never heard it being used genuinely not even once. I find it irritating: you don’t want freedom of speech? State than openly and tell me why.
- ksml 7y agoYeah, I don't want unlimited freedom of speech. Some types of speech are harmful with little benefit, from my perspective. I don't see the justification for making it permissible to yell "fire" in a movie theater.
- lph 7y ago...which could also be explained by progressive groups being the target of more repression lately than conservative groups.
- m0zg 7y ago> the target of more repression lately Such as?
- DeathArrow 7y agoThere's still EFF left to fight for civil rights, although EFF has a much more limited scope.
- bsder 7y ago> But I don’t see any take on any measures governments have taken to kerb civil rights in the time of the pandemic Part of it is that I expect that the ACLU doesn't really want to take on cases that are simply going to be moot once the state of emergency ends. I expect that their ears will perk up a little more about things that don't go back to "normal" once everything is done with. And part of it is probably not wanting court cases to actually go through the courts unless they are sure they can win. If you send a case through to the Supreme Court right now, you may lose and set a really bad precedent. The ACLU is likely better off fighting by lobbying and getting laws passed rather than using the courts right now.
- mc32 7y agoI'm not saying everything ends up being like the Patriot Act, but sometimes they do and once they get enacted they like hanging on way past their due date --sometimes they don't even sunset at all.
- hannasanarion 7y agoAnd what makes you think that the current scenario is an example? You think the government likes having a near-complete cessation of tax revenue?
- 3ygun 7y agoI follow on Twitter and have seen a lot about prisoner/immigrant advocacy (probably because of my Twitter bubble/liking habbits). But re-looking seems like a good mix of voting rights and medical access mixed in https://twitter.com/ACLU/ https://twitter.com/ACLU/
- jdp23 7y agoStay-Home Orders: Your Rights During the COVID-19 Pandemic (ACLU-Texas): https://www.aclutx.org/en/know-your-rights/stay-home-orders-your-rights-during-covid-19-pandemic https://www.aclutx.org/en/know-your-rights/stay-home-orders-... How to Think About the Right to Privacy and Using Location Data to Fight COVID-19 (by Jay Stanley of the ACLU) : https://www.justsecurity.org/69444/how-to-think-about-the-right-to-privacy-and-using-location-data-to-fight-covid-19/ https://www.justsecurity.org/69444/how-to-think-about-the-ri... Apple and Google Announced a Coronavirus Tracking System. How Worried Should We Be?: https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/apple-and-google-announced-a-coronavirus-tracking-system-how-worried-should-we-be/ https://www.aclu.org/news/privacy-technology/apple-and-googl... ACLU sues federal agencies seeking records of facial-recognition use at airports and U.S. border: https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/03/12/aclu-sues-federal-agencies-seeking-records-facial-recognition-use-airports-us-border/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/03/12/aclu-su...
- specialist 7y agoWhat should they be working on? Contact your local affiliate and tell them. "The ACLU" isn't one homogeneous entity. I've spoken with my locals about privacy and voting rights. Naive me thought I'd have ready allies. Nope. Lefties are all over the place. Agreement on one issue is no predictor for any other issues. First persuade others to acknowledge a problem. Then get commitments of effort, support. Then forge a consensus around an action plan. Be very wary of kindly seeming people who are actively working against you.getting everyone to agree to the same set of reforms is even more work. Worse of all, getting momentum is very hard. Because your coalition will dissolve the moment any change is enacted (if not earlier). Because no one will agree on the next steps. Rinse, lather, repeat. Policy and coalition building is a lot of work. Maybe avoid my mistake of burning out too soon. Pace yourself for a marathon. Good luck.
- specialist 7y agoHysterical.
- tastroder 7y ago> as well as talk about tracking and contact tracing. Uh, they published a full white paper on this outlining their views: https://www.aclu.org/report/aclu-white-paper-principles-technology-assisted-contact-tracing https://www.aclu.org/report/aclu-white-paper-principles-tech...