7 ms·
Intuitionist mathematics claims that mathematics is purely the result of the constructive mental activity of humans rather than the discovery of fundamental pri
by DeathArrow 7y ago
Intuitionist mathematics claims that mathematics is purely the result of the constructive mental activity of humans rather than the discovery of fundamental principles existing in an objective reality. [0]
In intuitionist mathematics there is only potential infinity, no actual infinity. Constructive set theory differs from Zermelo set theory.
That has many consequences in practice. Applying intuitionist mathematics to physics we can come to the conclusion that time flows and it helps reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity.[1]
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intuitionism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intuitionism
[1] https://www.quantamagazine.org/does-time-really-flow-new-clues-come-from-a-century-old-approach-to-math-20200407/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/does-time-really-flow-new-clu...
- hyw 7y ago> Applying intuitionist mathematics to physics we can come to the conclusion that time flows Can you expound on this a little more? I'm completely new to the idea of intuitionistic mathematics and much more so to its applications in physics; the constructive approach to thinking about objects and properties is very refreshing and I'd like to hear how you've related those principles with the paradox of time in the context of classical physics.
- DeathArrow 7y ago>Can you expound on this a little more? Unfortunately no. I got the info from Quanta Magazine article. I am not knowledgeable enough to respond on this. Even though I did some high level math courses in University, I wasn't interested enough. I am sure other HN users understand this stuff better.
- tartoran 7y agoFrom the wikipedia source: In the philosophy of mathematics, intuitionism, or neointuitionism (opposed to preintuitionism), is an approach where mathematics is considered to be purely the result of the constructive mental activity of humans rather than the discovery of fundamental principles claimed to exist in an objective reality. That is, logic and mathematics are not considered analytic activities wherein deep properties of objective reality are revealed and applied but are instead considered the application of internally consistent methods used to realize more complex mental constructs, regardless of their possible independent existence in an objective reality. And Im wodering why Im not looking more into the philosophy of math, i find this interesting because I am mainly an intuition driven person. Any ideas for courses online?
- dnautics 7y agoThe mathematical definition of intuition is not the colloquial definition. For example, in intuitionistic mathematics, you can't proof by contradiction, which means that some things that are "intuitively true" in the colloquial sense, are inaccessible.
- mikorym 7y agoThe reason why intuitionist mathematics is useful in QM is because it can be viewed as resource based logic. But remember that (as far as I know) you can do intuitionist mathematics in classical mathematics, but not the other way around. So you can think of intuitionist mathematics as being embedded in classical mathematics.
- h-cobordism 7y agoI think in your first paragraph you're confusing intuitionistic logic and linear logic --- intuitionistic logic still lets you "clone" and "delete" propositions freely. The second paragraph is somewhat true --- at its base, the modern use of the term "intuitionistic logic" refers merely to not accepting the law of the excluded middle. However, there are varieties of intuitionism that are very, very inconsistent with classical logic, like those adopting the idea that "every function between real numbers is continuous".
- mikorym 7y agoWhen you separate internal and external logic, for example in topos theory, the external logic is still classical. For example, any topos has internal logic on subobjects of at least a Heyting algebra. In some cases you specialise to a Boolean algebra. However, when you write things down such as your arguments around functors and constructions, you argue according to classical mathematics externally. When you enter into the category (which is chosen not to be Boolean) and argue on the subobject structure, then you are entering intuitionistic logic. This is what I mean when I say that classical logic can be argued to have intuitionistic logic embedded in it. The cardinality of the reals being equal to the cardinality of the naturals is then something you have to construct inside the topos. So you need to construct along the spirit of a natural numbers object (perhaps a real numbers object) and then use the internal logic to argue about continuity.
- mikorym 7y agoI think you are right about the comment about linear logic. I must be confusing A U A with A U ^A. I checked the paper that I was thinking about and the condition that I saw there is distributivity being dropped rather than double negation being dropped.
- hliyan 7y agoI've always thought math as we know it is a result of both deep underlying relationships between natural constructs and how we perceive them. For example, a species who has no sense of vision will not develop geometry the same way we would. A species that has a sense of vision that also includes a direct distance perception (as opposed to our stereoscopic vision) will probably come up with a very different form of geometry. Though I'd like to think that most species would come up with some version of calculus, even though the notation will be obviously different. Afterall, two of our own species did so independently.
- Kaiyou 7y agoCombining the words "most" and "species" feels a little bit silly. Among all the millions of species on this planet only humans have displayed the intelligence necessary to contemplate any of this.
- ableal 7y ago> on this planet Location was not specified ...
- foldr 7y agoThat's only true if you limit this to conscious thought. Lots of organisms perform impressively complex calculations. The desert ant odometer is one classic example: https://jeb.biologists.org/content/210/2/198 https://jeb.biologists.org/content/210/2/198
- Phenomenit 7y agoI've always figured it's our visions ability to perceive wholes, one of something. A clear conceptual border between two entities.
- hliyan 7y agoYes, but it's possible to perceive distict objects without vision, except the separation is in time, rather than space. Or, depends on the number of sense organs available (e.g. a blind person can sense two different objects simultaneously by holding one in each hand).
- peterburkimsher 7y agoTell me more about the difference between "potential infinity" and "actual infinity". Recursive functions in computer programming, or fractals in maths, are infinite but can be described. Each small part looks like the whole, but the whole can never be fully known within a finite universe. Is that "potential" or "actual" infinity? I've been thinking a lot about infinity this past week, mostly because of Conway's lectures. I'm trying to figure out whether the following logic makes sense. - Assuming that the universe is finite -> Infinity cannot be approximated with finite numbers (MIP* = RE) [1] -> Numbers cannot have infinite strings of digits -> The future can never be perfectly preordained (Gisin) [2] -> Free will exists (Conway) [3] This is not a proof that free will exists! But I think this is a consistency proof that free will is finite. Now you're telling me that there's another kind of infinity, and I want to know what that means for this thought. [1] https://www.quantamagazine.org/landmark-computer-science-proof-cascades-through-physics-and-math-20200304/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/landmark-computer-science-pro... [2] https://www.quantamagazine.org/does-time-really-flow-new-clues-come-from-a-century-old-approach-to-math-20200407/ https://www.quantamagazine.org/does-time-really-flow-new-clu... [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tmx2tpcdKZY&feature=youtu.be&t=712 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tmx2tpcdKZY&feature=youtu.be...
- gowld 7y agoThe video timestamp you linked does not say "free will exists". Is says "humans has free will implies element particles have free will".
- peterburkimsher 7y agoHis definition of free will is quite limited. He only suggests that free will is limited to a "free" choice between options within one's power. Conway said that there either is determinism or free will. If the future can be perfectly preordained (Gisin) due to infinite possibilities, then there is no free will. But if there are finite options, I think that there is "free will" for particles and people to choose between those options. https://youtu.be/tmx2tpcdKZY?t=1074 https://youtu.be/tmx2tpcdKZY?t=1074 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_will_theorem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_will_theorem
- naasking 7y ago> Intuitionist mathematics claims that mathematics is purely the result of the constructive mental activity of humans rather than the discovery of fundamental principles existing in an objective reality. [0] The "mental activity" part isn't strictly necessary. A constructive mathematics will produce results that are largely the same. What matters most is that mathematical objects are proven by construction, and so proofs have a direct translation to computation.
- maxiepoo 7y agoI think you and OP are talking about different things because the term "intuitionist" has been used for both the philosophy that EJ Brouwer espoused (which matches what OP said) and the large field of constructive mathematics that has been greatly influenced by Brouwer's philosophy but has embraced approaches like formal logic which Brouwer himself disliked.
- naasking 7y agoI was merely pointing out that the "mental" dependency of intuitionism isn't strictly necessary. Take it out, and you're left with an equally valid constructive logic.