3 ms·
It was the contention to which you were responding, in a conversation which was similarly challenging the WHO (and everyone else's) estimate on the severity. A
by ajross 7y ago
It was the contention to which you were responding, in a conversation which was similarly challenging the WHO (and everyone else's) estimate on the severity. And I was pointing out that you can't do that, logically your argument was a tautology. The same effect you were arguing against would argue against your evidence.
- nradov 7y agoYou misunderstood my argument. I made no claim about severity. Merely than in about five days it will be clear which patients were presymptomatic versus asymptomatic.
- iso947 7y agoour assumption is something like “45% will show symptoms within 5 days, 5% after 5 days, 50% will not show symptoms in 100 years” If that’s wrong, and it’s 45% in 5 days 45% after 5 days and less than 90 days 10% don’t show symptoms within 100 years That would change things. I’m not aware of any evidence that that is the case.