6 ms·
One of my favorite parts of Feynman's brilliant talk about the limits of minaturizing mechanical devices, "There's plenty of room at the bottom": """If, for in
by dekhn 7y ago
One of my favorite parts of Feynman's brilliant talk about the limits of minaturizing mechanical devices, "There's plenty of room at the bottom":
"""If, for instance, having made a small lathe with a pantograph, we find its lead screw irregular – more irregular than the large-scale one – we could lap the lead screw against breakable nuts that you can reverse in the usual way back and forth until this lead screw is, at its scale, as accurate as our original lead screws, at our scale.
We can make flats by rubbing unflat surfaces in triplicates together – in three pairs – and the flats then become flatter than the thing you started with. Thus, it is not impossible to improve precision on a small scale by the correct operations. So, when we build this stuff, it is necessary at each step to improve the accuracy of the equipment by working for awhile down there, making accurate lead screws, Johansen blocks, and all the other materials which we use in accurate machine work at the higher level. We have to stop at each level and manufacture all the stuff to go to the next level – a very long and very difficult program. Perhaps you can figure a better way than that to get down to small scale more rapidly."""
Many ideas contributed to the modern process of 5nm lithography, but having flat surface plates whose precision is determined by the correct application of operations rather than an external standard has turned out to be one of the most profound.
Now, of course, you can buy a granite surface place with accuracy exceeding almost anything available 100 years ago, for $30. And there are youtube videos of flat surface aficinados who scrape their own.
- Animats 7y agoMaking a precision lead screw is an important step. Maudslay invented the modern metal lathe. His original, from around 1800, is in the Science Museum, London, and it has most of the features of a metal lathe of 1900. Or today. A screw cutting lathe requires a good lead screw as its reference. Maudslay invented a "screw origination machine"[1], a clever special-purpose device for making a more accurate screw than the one you have. It only cuts soft metal, so the screw it makes is used in a second lathe to make one in hard steel. This is another of the key steps in bootstrapping to precision. Early precision work was limited to flat things and round things. Take a look at a steam locomotive from around 1900. Every surface that has to be held to a tight tolerance is flat or round. That's because the precision tools of the era were the planer, lathe, and drill. The general purpose milling machine came later. Incidentally, this is the real reason manholes were round. In the great era of city sewer-building, you could make round metal manhole covers easily, by casting and a quick lathe pass. The ring into which they fit could also be easily finished on a lathe. Making an iron rectangular frame and a lid to fit it would have been a much harder and more expensive job. [1] https://gracesguide.co.uk/Henry_Maudslay:_Machine_Tools https://gracesguide.co.uk/Henry_Maudslay:_Machine_Tools
- kazen44 7y agoIf you are interested in the history of precision engineering. I can highly recommend the book titled "The Perfectionists: How Precision Engineers Created the Modern World".[1] It does into detail on how precision manufacturing was created from the beginnings of the industrial revolution until today. The book has some funny anocdotes from history, and despite being quite long i found it easy to read. [1] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/35068671-the-perfectionists https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/35068671-the-perfectioni...
- defterGoose 7y agoIf you're going to go down such a rabbit hole, you'll be well served by checking out the ostensible bible on the subject as well, "Foundations of Mechanical Accuracy" by Moore.
- audiometry 7y agoThis book astounds me. The depths they went to achieve millionth of inch accuracy was crazy. That book is quite expensive and rare it seems. I have a copy but it was 100$+ dollars. There are a couple guys on YouTube doing very nice demonstrations of high-accuracy operations. One is Ox Tool Company. Interesting grinding operations etc. Really smart stuff. These machinists of the 1930 1940 1950s were just as clever as John Carmack or whoever your modern nerd heroes are.
- timdierks 7y agohttps://epdf.pub/foundations-of-mechanical-accuracy.html https://epdf.pub/foundations-of-mechanical-accuracy.html
- meatsock 7y agowithout the wait https://archive.org/details/FoundationsOfMechanicalAccuracy/mode/2up https://archive.org/details/FoundationsOfMechanicalAccuracy/...
- 7y ago