6 ms·
Almost all laws and legal orders have some ambiguity to them. Sloppy compliance is the correct choice both here and generally, because a) demonstrates to the co
by wpietri 7y ago
Almost all laws and legal orders have some ambiguity to them. Sloppy compliance is the correct choice both here and generally, because a) demonstrates to the court that you broadly agree and will respect the court's authority, and b) allows you to go about your business as much as possible.
Given Amazon's recent behaviors around worker protection, I expect their action here is chosen for maximum drama, an attempt to pressure the French government, and to warn other governments that they will disrupt the delivery of essential supplies if they don't get their way. So I agree with harryh; it's a middle finger.
It's been deeply disappointing to me. I've been on the fence with Amazon for a while about labor issues. But their behavior recently has crossed a line. I canceled my Prime membership yesterday. If they don't rapidly reform, it'll be the end of my 23 years as a customer.
- alharith 7y ago> Almost all laws and legal orders have some ambiguity to them. That doesn't make this a desired trait that should be willfully accepted. Force them to make them not ambiguous, otherwise they will remain as such. Ambiguous laws and punishments are one of the largest sources of judicial inequality in every nation. Authority does not need to be respected if it does not respect those who authorized it.
- ardy42 7y ago> That doesn't make this a desired trait that should be willfully accepted. Force them to make them not ambiguous, otherwise they will remain as such. Ambiguous laws and punishments are one of the largest sources of judicial inequality in every nation. It's not that simple. Fuzziness can be necessary to prevent bad actors from subverting the law through loopholes and to make the law applicable to future situations where it would reasonably be expected to apply. Fuzziness is also helpful to keep the law from being over-prescriptive. For instance, if you have a copyright law you might write it to apply to any "creative work" but leave that relatively undefined and left up to interpretation by a reasonable person (i.e. a judge). You don't want movies left unprotected, because the law was unambiguously written to only apply to writings. Similarly, you might write a law to mandate the availability of reasonable protections against infection, but you don't want the law to unambiguously require specific practices like hand-washing (because effective alternatives like hand-sanitizer didn't exist when the law was written). Most people here are software engineers or have familiarity with software engineering, analogous situations occur around writing requirements.
- DeathArrow 7y ago>For instance, if you have a copyright law you might write it to apply to any "creative work" but leave that relatively undefined and left up to interpretation by a reasonable person (i.e. a judge). You don't want movies left unprotected, because the law was unambiguously written to only apply to writings. Maybe in the anglo-saxon law system, this is true. In countries with napoleonic or roman law system judge's role is generally considered to be to apply the law as it is written, with the assumption that the law in most cases is sufficiently clear in itself.
- ardy42 7y ago> In countries with napoleonic or roman law system judge's role is generally considered to be to apply the law as it is written, with the assumption that the law in most cases is sufficiently clear in itself. I was under the impression that those Napoleonic/Roman law judges still have to interpret the law's meaning and apply it in ambiguous situations, but the difference is that their interpretations aren't binding on other judges like in the Anglo-Saxon system.
- zwaps 7y agoThe difference is more when it comes to precedence, which allows judges in Anglo-Saxon countries essentially to create law. Judges in France still need to interpret laws according to what they intended to do. There's then a majority and minority opinion(s) on how that law is intepreted, and these things are set by discourse and precedence, with judges being free to decide. In practice the difference is not so large.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> Fuzziness can be necessary to prevent bad actors from subverting the law through loopholes and to make the law applicable to future situations where it would reasonably be expected to apply. This is just a flowery way of granting unchecked power to prosecutors under the theory that they'll use it in good faith. If the law is ambiguous and the prosecutor is allowed to choose an adverse interpretation in order to ensnare "bad actors" then they can really use it to ensnare anyone for anything, because everyone is technically in violation under the strict interpretation so all they have to do is decide who they don't like and charge them with the violation that everyone is technically committing. It's a complete abandonment of the rule of law. The answer to "loopholes" is to close them, or better yet take more time to evaluate what you're doing from the start so you don't create them in the first place. Notice in particular that nearly all "loopholes" come from some combination of internal inconsistencies, unnecessary complexity or an inherent unreasonableness of the rules to begin with. (If you find yourself spending all day carving out exceptions to a rule, chances are it's a bad rule.) > Fuzziness is also helpful to keep the law from being over-prescriptive. This is not actually helpful because vagueness prohibits more alternatives than specificity. Overly specific rules are to be avoided, but at least then you know how to comply with them. If the rule just says "don't be bad" then you have to sit motionless and do nothing because there is no way to know what "bad" means until judgement is being passed and it's already too late not to do it. > For instance, if you have a copyright law you might write it to apply to any "creative work" but leave that relatively undefined and left up to interpretation by a reasonable person (i.e. a judge). You don't want movies left unprotected, because the law was unambiguously written to only apply to writings. This isn't an argument for intentional ambiguity. "Writings" was ambiguous because more than writings didn't exist when it was drafted. So it wasn't ambiguous in practice for about a hundred years. Then movies and sound recordings came to exist, there was a court case about whether they could be covered, the answer was yes, and once again the answer was unambiguous for about a hundred years since. There was only a short period between when the world changed and when the law was clarified that the answer wasn't clear. This is how you want it -- it shouldn't start off as ambiguous when it's passed and if something changes that causes it to be unclear then an interpretation should be chosen promptly so that it goes back to being unambiguous. The ambiguity is a thing to be minimized to the fullest extent practicable. Notice also that the Copyright Act doesn't say "creative work" but rather "work fixed in a tangible medium of expression," which is much more suitable language than "creative work," because it doesn't exclude movies or VR works just because they didn't exist when the words were drafted, but at the same time it then doesn't cover abstract ideas or unrecorded expressions or inventions that should be covered by patent rather than copyright. > Similarly, you might write a law to mandate the availability of reasonable protections against infection, but you don't want the law to unambiguously require specific practices like hand-washing (because effective alternatives like hand-sanitizer didn't exist when the law was written). Except that then no one has any idea at all what "reasonable protections against infection" means. Does it mean washing your hands, or full hazmat gear? Does everyone have to wear the hazmat gear or only doctors? Do you have to wash your hands after every new patient or is it against the law to only do it three times a day? Does it matter if the patient evaluation indicates they're not infected? That rule tells you nothing. It gives cover to negligent providers with good lawyers and gives cover to malicious prosecutors who then have a pretext to prosecute anybody they don't like. > Most people here are software engineers or have familiarity with software engineering, analogous situations occur around writing requirements This should make them more familiar with why you're wrong, because in technical writing you have similar constraints and manage to deal with them even when there is no judge to provide an ex post facto interpretation. It is necessary to be clear about what you're saying from the start.
- ska 7y agoIt's not a desired state, it's a natural state. By this I mean we don't know how to make such a system practical without ambiguity. Not that people haven't tried.
- option_greek 7y agoIf you are running the company, Sloppy compliance is never the correct choice. It will add a unnecessary (from the company point of view) liability for the future. Given the risk to the health of workers in this case, its not even the correct moral choice. Suspension is bad for their revenues but is morally and legally correct way forward.
- matthewdgreen 7y agoI think it's amusing that Amazon knows exactly what it's doing with this threat. France knows exactly what it's doing with this threat. The only people who don't seem to understand what's happening are the commenters here on HN.
- zapita 7y ago> The only people who don't seem to understand what's happening are the commenters here on HN. Sadly this is true of almost every topic other than software engineering, electronics and rockets.
- lonelappde 7y agoAnd also software engineering, electronics, and rockets.
- option_greek 7y agoOr may be every single thing that happens in the world doesn't need to have sinister motives behind it ?
- carapace 7y agoOh come now, Machiavelli was satire. /s
- MR4D 7y agoBut isn't that why we all love HN? /s (kinda)
- Mirioron 7y ago
- DuskStar 7y agoSloppy compliance is the proper route to take if you expect good faith to be rewarded. If you don't - if you think French regulators would be happy to make up some revenue shortfalls via fines of a foreign company - then overly-conservative compliance is the correct course of action. And guess what? Halting all deliveries is the most conservative course of action possible here.
- anoncareer0212 7y agoAlso guess what, France has happily demonstrated that their exact gameplan with US companies is to prescribe vague plans and figure out how to fine you for not meeting them 3 years later. American ignorance of the EU's protectionism is breathtaking
- maeln 7y agoThats not really it. US company (Apple, Google, Amazon, ...) understood the EU more than anybody an exploited every flaw they could find to pay as less tax as possible. The "magic fine" were not random and unjustified. Those country were already borderline, if not fully crossing the border, with a lot of regulation here. Country like France and Germany were sick of seeing a lot of profit made within their border while tax revenue flee elsewhere. The fine they given were not from vague plan, they were within the strict boundary of the law that those company keep playing with. Those same company are pushing for stricter and clearer regulation but are being faced with the opposition of other EU member who kind of profit from the practice of these company.
- oh_sigh 7y agoIs your argument that, say, Google, expected fines reaching into billions of dollars, but understood that they would end up with cash in their pocket by heavily avoiding taxes and just paying the fine? That seems like a risky game to play, because you don't know if the fines are going to be $1B or something more important like $100B or something.
- 7y ago
- Fjolsvith 7y agoAmazon would have to really screw up bad for me to give up the crazy benefits of a Prime membership to become a social justice warrior. Its just too valuable for a rural customer.
- wpietri 7y agoWeird that "I personally feel obliged to stop harming people through my actions" suddenly makes me a dreaded SJW.
- Fjolsvith 7y agoAmazon employees aren't slaves. No one is forcing them to endure my actions.
- wpietri 7y agoYou have a very poor understanding of labor history if you think the two possible states are a) violently enforced chattel slavery and b) everything's perfectly fine. If you were looking to correct that ignorance, you might try Loomis's "A History of America in 10 Strikes".
- Fjolsvith 7y agoYour argument seems to imply that an Amazon employee is unable to quit their job to find better working conditions. Under current, modern American labor laws, this is not true. Edit: I own a business, so I do know about employees leaving for better jobs.
- refurb 7y agoSloppy compliance is the correct choice both here and generally Oh my gosh. No. There are countless examples of companies who have put a good faith effort into complying with laws and regulations only to have the gov't drop the hammer on them later. And why not? Companies make good whipping boys for politicians and it's a relatively risk-free way to score political points.
- AmericanChopper 7y ago> Sloppy compliance is the correct choice both here and generally I’d say a more correct approach would be to assess the risks associated with any decision, according to whatever framework your fiduciaries deem necessary, and then to simply disregard the casual criticism of armchair commentators as irrelevant.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoSmart idea. Cancelling my prime membership also. For a company that is known for the one-click-buy, they definitely make it hard to cancel. Had to go through app - website - German website ( that's a first) - "click here to cancel" ( doesn't do anything, but found something on the same page "I do not want to use my advantages" does seem to do the trick). I kinda hate what some companies/people are currently doing though. Also, some people are really stepping up like Bill Gates, but I don't know if it will be enough.
- 101404 7y agoWhat's hard about it? I cancel my prime membership every other month (always switching between Netflix and Amazon). Click cancel, five times okay, and done.
- NicoJuicy 7y agoSwitch from app to website, languages ( I don't speak German) and false action button ( click here to cancel, that doesn't do anything) Like I said before...
- plandis 7y agoWhy would Amazon go through with sloppy compliance if they think they will be fined more than they can make? Not providing an enumerated list of essential goods makes it extremely likely that no matter what Amazon stops shipping, something Amazon thought was essential is deemed non-essential and results in fines. Deciding you can’t win isn’t throwing a temper tantrum; it’s a business decision based on likely outcomes and the profit/revenue of those outcomes.