9 ms·
GitHub’s new offer closely matches that from GitLab
- romanovcode 7y agoGitHub was better even without these features than GitLab tho. GitLab UI is slow and un-intuitive.
- danShumway 7y agoI do not understand this kind of brand loyalty. Even if you're not interested in using Gitlab yourself, the competition and user migrations are clearly turning Github into a better service. You benefit from Microsoft's need to court those users, even if you never touch Gitlab. Just take the newly reduced prices and free features in your favorite service and be happy.
- romanovcode 7y agoI am not loyal to GitHub at all, I was very excited and one of first users of GitLab, the CI component was amazing. I am just saying things like it is.
- BoorishBears 7y agoNot sure how saying "This one product is better than the other" is brand loyalty... I mean, they could have added "in my opinion", but I don't think it's too hard to assume they're referring to their opinion and not unilaterally declaring their word as law?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> I do not understand this kind of brand loyalty. What are you on about? They didn't mention any loyalty to a brand. They said qualitatively what they preferred about one product to another.
- djaque 7y agoI'm not sure about that. I've self hosted gitlab for the past four years and have had no issues performance wise and the UI feels pretty much the same as for github in terms of bein intuitive.
- number6 7y agoDid this two because of a) its selfhosted b) better CI/CD (At this time) c) docker repository
- bearjaws 7y agoI fail to see how Gitlab's UI is not intuitive, for the most part 90% of the GitHub functionality is in 3 menus. It does get complicated when you start adding kubernetes clusters and more of the Gitlab gold features, but even then I think its well managed. As far as speed goes, it is slower than GitHub, but has gotten a lot better over the last year. Just browsing around right now it loads within 1 second for pretty much anything besides pull requests.
- apocalyptic0n3 7y ago> As far as speed goes, it is slower than GitHub, but has gotten a lot better over the last year. Just browsing around right now it loads within 1 second for pretty much anything besides pull requests. And that goes down even further when self-hosting. We're hosting ours (700+ projects, a dozen active users, 40GB worth of repos, and a half dozen active CI Runners) on a $80 Linode with a dozen other internal services that are constantly being used and we see 400-700ms loads on most pages. The performance is fantastic, frankly. And the CI/CD is the best I've used (comparing against Jenkins, Bamboo, Travis, and Circle)
- emilycook 7y agoHey! GitLab employee here. The speed of the site has been on our radar too, we have a handbook page [1] detailing our metrics and our goals. Ultimately we want to have a speed index of less than 2 seconds for .com, but we know we aren't quite there yet. As for the UI being unintuitive, I'm sorry to hear that. Everyone has different UI preferences so it's understandable. If you want, we're holding a competition right now [2] for anyone who writes a review of GitLab vs GitHub if there are any specific features within GitHub's UI that you like better! [1] https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/engineering/performance/ https://about.gitlab.com/handbook/engineering/performance/ [2] https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/04/14/github-free-for-teams/ https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/04/14/github-free-for-tea...
- odiroot 7y agoNo it wasn't. Gitlab CI is such a great thing and well integrated with the main product. Github is nowhere near. Another thing is better branch protection, more granular branch merging and review policies. That's just from the top of my head.
- brenden2 7y agoTurns out competition is good for end users.
- johannes1234321 7y agoAs long as VCs fuel GL to stay alive against Microsoft's pockets (Microsoft benefits from it in multiple ways even if GitHub isn't profitable, GitLab has no other revenue stream)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cdurth 7y agoMy small org will be moving back to GitHub. While GitLab is a fantastic product, we have been looking for a low cost global search ability, and well, you can't argue with _free_.
- marceloabsousa 7y agoInteresting that you'll risk moving your dev ops workflow because of a single feature that GitHub doesn't even do well.
- cdurth 7y agowe utilize other systems for this (not great, but works). for the type of work we do, global search is a huge win over other potential trade offs.
- atrilumen 7y agoIs anyone working on an alternative to NPM?
- thinkmassive 7y agoHere's one recent attempt: https://github.com/braydonf/gpk https://github.com/braydonf/gpk
- boleary-gl 7y agoGitLab Developer Evangelist here. You can host NPM registries in your GitLab projects. https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/packages/npm_registry/ https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/packages/npm_registry/ Moving to Core (free AND open source) soon along with 17 other features: https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/03/30/new-features-to-core/ https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/03/30/new-features-to-cor...
- BoorishBears 7y agoIt's weird how the article looks at the true reason right there and then just chooses ignores it. Microsoft bought Github in part to get developer mindshare, just like VSCode, and WSL, and a ton of other great efforts have. They literally quote Nadella saying this on an earnings call! If Occam's razor and the money line up, why does this have to be some secret attempt to beat Gitlab?
- manojlds 7y agoYeah, Apple, Google, Amazon - the usual culprits - are the competition, not small fish like GitLab.
- DeathArrow 7y agoOpen source .NET, SQL server running on Linux, VS Code, Github, NPM, WSL, tons of opensource on Azure. I think you are right, and Microsoft is after winning developers, not fighting with Gitlab. I think this is a winning strategy and we will see even more moves in this direction. Probably more acquisitions, more open sourcing products, more free stuff, more cross platform tools targeted at developers. A developer by himself doesn't have much decision power, but if more developers prefer something, companies will follow and use Microsoft's products.
- cryptonector 7y agoDeveloper mindshare. Mindshare at all. Compare to Oracle. When Sun had been trying to win mindshare with OpenSolaris, what did Oracle do? It killed it. It also effectively killed any chance of winning that mindshare. I'm still salty about that. Open source is a business tool. A tool for building trust and mindshare.
- emilycook 7y agoGitLab community advocate here! I wanted to let everyone know about a challenge we're holding right now. If you send us your review of GitLab vs GitHub (whether positive/negative/neutral), we'll send you some swag. We know competition is good for end-users, so now it's our turn to evaluate what we're doing right and what we can improve upon. https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/04/14/github-free-for-teams/ https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/04/14/github-free-for-tea...
- earthboundkid 7y agoCompetition is good for the end user, but ISTM that Microsoft bought the biggest player in the space so that they could drown the competition in the bathtub and monopolize the market. It's a smart play from Microsoft's point of view, but FTC should never have permitted the acquisition in the first place and should prosecute them for illegal dumping now.
- stevehawk 7y agoGithub and Gitlab are not so important to any market as to warrant federal intervention. Both of them are easily replaced by anyone standing up their own git server. Not to mention the countless other code repository sites / software packages.
- marceloabsousa 7y agoI disagree. Github and Gitlab are so much more than just code hosting platforms. Their ability to influence software development is increasing to the point that if both Github and Gitlab suddenly disappear the consequences would be quite dramatic.
- johannes1234321 7y agoMoving of isn't easy - thanks to GitHub pages and markdown rendering your tool's homepage is the Git{Hub|Lab|...} page. That page is linked from "everywhere" else and indexed in search engines - all history aside from code is in there (discussions in bug issues and pull requests etc.) getting them out is possible, but all the linkage between commit messages and those might be problematic to migrate - contributors are often only known by their handle on that page, migrating of requires new setup of permissions and mapping of usernames to trust on a social level - there are tons of hooks configured for many projects - as GitHub Actions and GitLab CI gain more and more traction workflows depend on those "Just move the repo" is a fallancy which doesn't work. I have no doubts medium term about Microsoft steering GitHub, but I fear a single entity being so central in the opensoruce world (also consider npm acquisition etc.)
- stevespang 7y agoSorta like how some of the large OPEC players decided to crush the US shale industry - - - give it way, for free or practically for free . . . except most can see through the smokescreen of a giant evil corporation like MS.
- nerdbaggy 7y agoI love the Gitlab CI. It’s so easy to create a new project, and the CI is ready to go. No fumbling around, and the integration is great with the Gitlab docker image store.
- xtracto 7y agoI want to second this. I use GitLab for personal projects and have used their CI extensively. My work uses Github and has all the repos hosted there. I tried to start using Github Actions (or whatever it is called?) about a month ago, and just couldn't make sense of it.. does it provision servers from Docker images/docker-compose files? or is it only a "carcass" where I have to add an additional server? can I do everything "as code" or do I have to mingle with the web console ? After spending about 2 hours tinkering I gave up.
- bastardoperator 7y agoReally? I was able to throw together an entire CI/CD workflow in Github that builds, tests, measures coverage and deploys to GCE in like 30 minutes. Bringing your own agents looks fairly simple too and follows a GitOps model: https://help.github.com/en/actions/hosting-your-own-runners https://help.github.com/en/actions/hosting-your-own-runners
- jazoom 7y agoIt is great, except there STILL is no reasonable way of finding a particular image in the registry. You can't order by date uploaded! Only by name. Which means the order is out of whack as soon as you go from version 9 to version 10. And to make it worse, paging is extremely slow, so it could take an hour of paging into the middle of the list to find the name of the image you're looking for. Even if the image was uploaded 1 minute ago it could be in the middle page. Thankfully I don't have to do this very often, but it's a horrible experience when needed. For similar reasons deleting unneeded images takes forever and is not feasible.
- nerdbaggy 7y agoHmm good point about that. I’ve never really had maybe more than 5 so it hasn’t been an issue. The auto pruning is a pain too.
- anticensor 7y agosytse (GitLab CEO) and natfriedman (GitHub CEO) are curiously missing from the thread.
- remram 7y agoThe thread is 1 hour old.
- kthejoker2 7y agoWell since GitLab and GitHub clearly have a long running PR war on HN (ie these posts are planned and scheduled), this doesn't seem like much of an answer ...
- Normal_gaussian 7y agoThis article is published by a third party, and posted by a different third party.
- sytse 7y agoI was doing iteration office hours https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5e-6R5NWl0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u5e-6R5NWl0 :)
- philliphaydon 7y agoAltho it's still in preview, is Jetbrains Spaces essentially the same thing as GitLab?
- skofgar 7y agoIt definitely looks like to be a competitor
- corecoder 7y agoThe only one important (imho of course) feature that GitHub has and self-hosted GitLab lacks is search across repositories [0]. Search inside a single repository is done via git. Of course you can self-host and configure your own Sourgraph installation, but that's a bit more work. [0] https://forum.gitlab.com/t/search-code-across-all-projects/2263/18 https://forum.gitlab.com/t/search-code-across-all-projects/2...
- sytse 7y agoFor self-hosted instances you can use Advanced Global Search https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/search/advanced_global_search.html https://docs.gitlab.com/ee/user/search/advanced_global_searc... to do this. Please note that this requires installation of Elastic Search. It used to be a paid feature but I think we recently open sourced it.
- db579 7y agoThe blog post mentions that you recently open sourced 18 features that were previously paid. I assume that refers to this announcement: https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/03/30/new-features-to-core https://about.gitlab.com/blog/2020/03/30/new-features-to-cor.... It seems those are proposals (or at best commitments) for things to be open sourced in future versions rather than things that actually are available as open source already? Could you clarify please?
- boleary-gl 7y agoGitLab Developer Evangelist here. They are commitments. Each feature has its own issue for the engineering effort behind moving it to Core with various milestones based on team capacity and complexity of the move. You can track each with the table in the post that relates the feature to “GitLab issue” that represents the move.
- db579 7y agoFair enough. Don't get me wrong I'm very excited about the announcement and think it'll be great to have some of these features in the open source core, I just thought it was a little misleadingly worded in this blog post. Seemed to imply the work had already been done.
- tr-gitlab 7y agoGitLab PM here for the Package stage. We announced that the Package Registry offering will be included in GitLab Core. This means that for npm, Maven, NuGet, Conan and any future formats, you will be able to: - Establish GitLab as a private repository - Authenticate using your GitLab credentials, personal access or job token - Publish packages to GitLab - Pull packages from GitLab - Search for packages hosted on GitLab - Access an easy-to-use UI that displays package details and metadata and allows you to download any relevant files It does take a bit of work to migrate the code. We are currently investigating what work is required and will have a better sense of timing once the investigation is complete. We are hoping to have this complete in the next few months. You can follow along in the issue here: https://gitlab.com/groups/gitlab-org/-/epics/2867 https://gitlab.com/groups/gitlab-org/-/epics/2867.
- tester89 7y agoPeople celebrate as monopoly abuses power to further dominate the market
- kyboren 7y agoI used GitLab for years. That changed a few months ago. I deleted my account and now use GitHub. I advocate everywhere I can to choose GitHub over GitLab, or to migrate away from GitLab if it's already in use. These changes just make me more convinced that GitLab is on a path to oblivion. I put up with GitLab's slow interface, relatively poor UX, and relative lack of community because I wanted a trustworthy product that respected the privacy and security of my critical tooling and to support a company with a benign business model. After the tracking debacle a few months ago, it became clear to me that GitLab isn't trustworthy. They're looking for an acquisition, maybe an IPO, and exploiting users (and even on-prem customers!) is clearly going to be part of that game plan. So why stick with the crappier alternative? If I'm getting sold out either way, I might as well use the superior product. Maybe I could be convinced to switch back, though. @sytse did you fire Paul Machle yet? If not, then obviously Paul was merely taking the heat for doing what you want, and there is just no way I can ever trust GitLab. EDIT: Nope, looks like that goober is still the CFO: https://gitlab.com/pmachle https://gitlab.com/pmachle . Oh well, bye bye GitLab! I hope you die and make some more room for SourceHut. :)
- pdubs1 7y ago>They're looking for an acquisition, maybe an IPO, and exploiting users (and even on-prem customers!) is clearly going to be part of that game plan. Could you elaborate? In what way are you aware that Gitlab is: - seeking acquisition (makes sense that they would, I am just seeking some evidence to confirm the suspicion). To be fair, a large part of why I use GitLab is because it is not owned by Microsoft. Hence I am interested in whether or not GitLab will stay independent or "sell out". Certainly I'd lean on the latter, but again, seeking evidence of any planning on their part to seek acquisition. - exploiting users (or how it would be part of the "game plan" -- I can see exploiting user data they've gathered while users use their free service... but that's capitalism. Is there any other way they currently or might in the future exploit users?)
- kyboren 7y agoI have no hard evidence that they are actually actively seeking a buyout/IPO, but they did complete a Series E last year[0] led by Goldman Sachs and IONIQ Capital. Presumably their numerous investors will be looking for a solid return, either through an acquisition or IPO. WRT how they might exploit users, it's not really so much that there are specific ways I worry they will exploit users--well, I guess I am specifically worried they will once again hold private repos for ransom until you agree to some abusive new terms. It's perhaps best summarized with an infamous quote about user tracking from GitLab CFO Paul Machle: > I don’t understand. This should not be an opt in or an opt out. It is a condition of using our product. There is an acceptance of terms and the use of this data should be included in that. In other words, "Fuck the users, it's our product. Hold their repos for ransom until they agree." Which they in fact did for a short time until the PR blowback became unbearable. This was supposed to apply to self-hosted GitLab EE, too, BTW. The fact that Paul survived that very public middle finger to users and the security of the product and remains CFO shows that Sytse agrees with his philosophy, even if he isn't as brazen about it. The kind of money Sytse presumably has made and especially stands to make in a successful exit tends to have a peculiar effect on people, so perhaps it's not surprising... If you continue to use GitLab, be prepared: Make sure you have a replica of all the content (including issues etc.) you might need in the future. You just don't know how or when they're going to screw you over next, but you can be sure it'll happen. [0]: https://www.crunchbase.com/funding_round/gitlab-com-series-e--da5548fa https://www.crunchbase.com/funding_round/gitlab-com-series-e...