2 ms·
The actual text isn't an arbitrary byte string. There is logical data and then there is its representation. char, short, int, string can all logically refer to
by imtringued 7y ago
The actual text isn't an arbitrary byte string. There is logical data and then there is its representation. char, short, int, string can all logically refer to the number 0 but the representation is completely different. With char it is even possible to represent the same number in two ways. As a binary 0 or as the character code for 0. Allowing byte strings as the physical representation is not a bad idea to stay future proof but you will have to provide additional information by storing the character encoding that was used to create the arbitrary byte string. If you fail to do that then this information will have to provided through convention and that's how we get "stuck" with UTF-8 and I although I like UTF-8 this doesn't feel like the right solution. If everyone agrees to use UTF-8 then we should stop pretending that something is just an arbitrary byte string and formalize UTF-8.
The idea of an arbitrary byte string is fooling people into believing something that is not true. Developers falsely think their software can handle any character encoding. However, once you decide to support only a single character encoding you will notice that if something better comes along you need a way to differentiate the old and new codec. Then you decide to add a field that declares the character encoding type and suddenly it's obvious that your arbitrary byte string is a bad way of dealing with the problem. That byte string has meaning. Don't throw that meaning away.