6 ms·
Police Are Still Citing the Homeless, Despite CDC and Council Guidance
- tuxxy 7y agoDoes this really even need to be said? Police don't care about the health or the safety of the homeless.
- sfj 7y agoAll police are bad people.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI posted it because someone outright asked me for information a few days ago concerning how the pandemic is impacting the homeless population: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22819760 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22819760
- scollet 7y agoIf there's a systemic problem, I believe it should be reiterated until an acceptable resolution is found. It is systemic, so we should recognize that an individual's reinforcement of the problem is a small part. There is a greater sum that equals a militancy towards disenfranchised groups. A discussion is to be had at both a micro and macro levels. Please don't leave it at the micro. Some people are unaware and information is key to arguing this plight.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoI don’t think it’s appropriate for society to expect police to also behave as mental health care professionals. We don’t want to spend the money on mental healthcare facilities and don’t want to create a legal framework for involuntary committing of people, but we do want to blame police for not being able to handle society’s mentally ill.
- ehnto 7y agoIt's pretty appropriate for them to act like people who want to help the community though, and homeless are still part of the community.
- lotsofpulp 7y agoTheir bosses (the voters) raise hell at the politicians to push the homeless out of sight. If police don’t do that, the local politicians will have to replace the police, or else the voters will replace the politician.
- ehnto 7y agoI can see what you are saying, you are probably right about the cause and effect. But I think you've unfairly shifted the blame to voters. Voters don't know how to handle a societal problem as big and as endemic as a growing homeless population, that's why we put our trust in politicians, councils and governors. Voters are just signalling a desire for a clean and safe neighborhood, and suppose even that they don't care how it's done, it's still the city and police force's responsibility to figure out a way to do it humanely and in a way that helps solve the issue, not sweep it into another neighborhood. I want to point out that I am not anti-police, I'm just lamenting what seems to be a lack of empathy and perhaps even a lack of bravery for someone in the chain to change the approach. It's by no means an easy problem to solve, I don't envy those in charge.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago> Voters are just signalling a desire for a clean and safe neighborhood, and suppose even that they don't care how it's done, it's still the city and police force's responsibility to figure out a way to do it humanely and in a way that helps solve the issue, not sweep it into another neighborhood. I’m not willing to give voters the benefit of the doubt. We have a pretty well educated population that consistently goes to the polls and votes for the person that promises the lowest taxes. We can all say we want to support our fellow citizens all we want, but I have yet to see any action on that front.
- qqssccfftt 7y agoPolice do not care about the health or safety of people.
- Jonnax 7y agoSure. But it's not helpful to say that. If someone says the police are especially bad towards the homeless, saying that they're bad to everyone just belittles and says that the concerns of the homeless aren't important.
- jeltz 7y agoMaybe, but it is a bit relevant in a pandemic. Even if you do not care about homeless people they will still infect others and use ICU resources. Compassionate treatment of homeless also happens to be what is best for everyone here, even the people who are not homeless.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoIt's 3am where I am and I'm quite surprised to see this on the front page. I've already deleted one comment because I'm not in good shape to judge if it was informative or pointlessly fighty. But I will note that I mostly wasn't hassled by the police while homeless for nearly six years. In fact, they tended to look out for my welfare to whatever degree they could without creating a conflict of interest for themselves. One night, the police came up to our tent (I was homeless with my two adult sons) and shined a flashlight on it and ordered us to come out with our hands up. When I opened the tent and came out, they went "Oh, it's you." and promptly dropped into social worker mode, asking if I knew about various local services, etc. They were looking for a guy named Michael who was camped in the area. He had beat up his girlfriend and she had filed a police report. So they were pretty keyed up, expecting to deal with a violent criminal. They were quite relieved to see it was me and my sons instead. I knew the area well and I walked them over to where Michael stayed when he camped there and also talked about paths into and out of the little valley where I was camped and what I generally knew about Michael and his habits. I don't drink. I don't do drugs. I do remote work online which I began doing while homeless. I am not a criminal. Etc. I'm just desperately poor because I have too many personal challenges and too few resources. And the cops mostly didn't bother me, though I certainly had a few negative experiences with them as well. Cops are human. They aren't a monolith. Different cops behave differently from each other and the same cop can behave differently in different circumstances and with different people. Just like any other random human on planet earth.
- Ar-Curunir 7y ago*don't care about anything but protecting capital
- jeltz 7y agoYes, because if people stop saying it I feel that we have accepted it as unfixable. And I would like to think it is fixable.
- AndyMcConachie 7y agoPolice mostly just follow orders. Most terrible things we like to pin on police should probably instead be pinned on police, local political leadership, and ultimately local polities. If police are assholes in your area there's probably a good chance it's because the local political elites want them to be assholes.
- chithanh 7y ago> because the local political elites enable them to be assholes FTFY
- imtringued 7y agoIt is true. When a policeman breaks the law himself he might get covered by his higher ups and merely lose his rank or the job but still not face any criminal consequences.
- RickJWagner 7y agoMight. Or when she breaks the law, she might get thrown in jail like everyone else. It depends on how corrupt the local establishment is. The cops play a tactical role. For reference, see the original handling of the Jussie Smollett case. Clearly laws were broken, but corrupt higher-ups provided cover.
- bilbo0s 7y agoIn all honesty, I'm not really sure how the whole, "well everyone is corrupt" thing all you guys commenting here seem to be doing helps. I mean, yeah, everyone is corrupt, but you are still responsible for your actions. I mean, if the DA or mayor or whatever in a town is bent, does that mean a cop who coerces sexual favors from a prostitute he's caught in that jurisdiction is not a dirtbag? Of course not. It only means that your DA is a dirtbag, and your cop is a dirtbag. (It's also likely that the dirtbaggery extends to others in city leadership. The judges, the mayor, some council people. Etc. Just like the dirtbaggery in the police force likely extends to other cops in that department.)
- macspoofing 7y agoDo you? Do you think protecting the 'right' of the homeless (who are probably suffering from mental illness and/or addiction) to live in squalor, without basic sanitation?
- BigChiefSmokem 7y agoPolice is a broad term and I don’t think you can apply that attribute to a group. Police being powerless to do anything about the problem (they are law enforcement, not public health services) is probably the more reasonable question to ask. This of course goes back to local leaders, status quo thinking and self interest getting in the way of any meaningful action. Remember the homeless are being cited for things the community itself voted on.
- AlgorithmicTime 7y agoTo be clear, I don't care about the health or safety of the homeless, either.
- m4r35n357 7y agoSo are the police themselves not breaking the law here?
- m4r35n357 7y agoWhy answer when you can just downvote . . . ?
- wccrawford 7y agoNo, because it's not "the law", it's "guidance".
- papeda 7y agoI don't think so. The featured article only mentions 1) federal encouragement to relax these citations and 2) a city council resolution encouraging the mayor to evaluate the situation. Neither of these are law.
- known 7y agoCorona Crisis is not a law and order issue; Police should be trained accordingly;
- dmos62 7y agoIsn't the confinement, obligatory social distancing, etc. a law and order issue?
- scollet 7y agoMeans of compliance should be taken into account. Persecution for not having that priviledge should be heavily scrutinized.
- dmos62 7y agoYou get no argument from me.
- arsome 7y agoThat's a great thing to say but how do you do the enforcement like that? Do you expect the police to just know who's homeless? Take their word for it? Do you have them hand out citations and take it up in court? I can't see any of these as good options.
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoI'm going to guess that if you see someone pitching a tent on the sidewalk or sleeping in the doorway of a business, there is a fairly good chance they are homeless. Sleeping in a car doesn't necessarily mean anything, but if it is full of otherwise household items, the chances of the person being homeless goes up. You can also, you know, ask. Sure, a few folks might lie, but it is better to let them get away with the lie than to punish a bunch of folks with no choice.
- forgotmypw23 7y agoI've heard from many San Diegans that the police are brutal to the outdoor dwellers. It's been that way for years, and will continue, probably. Many get beat up, aka assaulted. These stories is one of the reasons I chose not to move there even back when I was getting software salary and stock options. I don't think it creates a good feeling all around, something I couldn't quite put my finger on at the time. Great weather though, if you like sun and nothing else.
- derision 7y agoIn my experience many of those "outside dwellers" aren't exactly pacifists themselves..
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- FpUser 7y agoBooking people to jail for sleeping in the cars. That definitely sounds like the land of free.
- RickJWagner 7y agoAh, sounds like a NIMBY clean-up effort.
- scollet 7y agoIs "NIMPYism" a product of investment, in that homeowners are incentived to protect their property value? I would argue that burgeoning or prospective homeowners are passive proponents of derisive action, in respect to your argument, but I hesitate to boil it down to local, popular opinion. My understanding is that there is a predisposition in play that is influenced by a variety of factors, one including an absolute number of the law from superior influence, but another (leaning towards your point on a grander scale) is a cultural osmosis. Would you immediately assume that a random, home-owning voter is contributing to this detriment, that there is an overplay of asymmetrical beauracracy, or that there is some factor of elements including the aforementioned interests? I would appreciate your argument (or any others'), in good faith, if I've not represented the full spectrum.
- GaryNumanVevo 7y agoNIMBYism is highly studied among economists, socio-economics and the like. I suggest reading some studies
- scollet 7y agoGood suggestion. I felt after writing the comment that I was out of my depth.
- creaghpatr 7y agoThis story is about San Diego, specifically.
- clsec 7y agoSan Diego is a very red city/county. It has always had an extremely strong military presence. It also has a very high retiree population. And add the fact that it sits right on the border with Mexico and you might start to see why it is the way it is. I lived there for a short while after living in SF my entire life and had to cut my stay short because of the overall atmosphere of the county. To me it feels like the reddest place in CA.
- lonelappde 7y agoNothing in there says "hate the homeless more than other places".
- _bxg1 7y agoYes, it does.
- 34679 7y agoRedding would certainly give them a run. I've lived in the Bay Area and San Diego, and my experience is that San Diego is the cleanest, most well organized city in California and I absolutely love it. As far as the "atmosphere", I found the people of San Diego to generally be much nicer and open to individuals with different opinions than anywhere around SF. The level of elitism in the SF Bay area is despicable.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- threatofrain 7y agoHere we see that part of SD's cleanliness is from police fining or enforcing on the unclean, whereas SF just throws money at the homeless. SD's cleanliness is very similar to Irvine's concept of cleanliness.
- socalnate1 7y agoThat was true 15 years ago, but is not true any more. (It's still "redder" than LA or SF, but not even close to the reddest place in CA). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_San_Diego_County https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Politics_of_San_Diego_County
- panzagl 7y agoThe article states that the guidance is not to break up camps- then gives examples that aren't camps, they're people congregating against storefronts and other high traffic areas. These people would be moving soon anyway, to suggest the police are somehow increasing the risk of Corona spread by asking them to move before other people get there is spurious and opportunistic.
- vondur 7y agoIs leaving homeless encampments where they all group together a good solution? Here in Los Angeles they had a bubonic plague outbreak in their encampments and they still allowed them to live on the street.
- ls612 7y agoAt least we can control the bubonic plague with antibiotics.