4 ms·
> a CODE_OF_CONDUCT, because we assume preemptively that you are a racist homophobic asshole, and we have to cover our bases. This one is a new personal pet pe
by echelon 7y ago
> a CODE_OF_CONDUCT, because we assume preemptively that you are a racist homophobic asshole, and we have to cover our bases.
This one is a new personal pet peeve. I'm not a racist homophobe--I'm a good person. And though it doesn't give me any authority to speak on the matter, I'm bi and I've dated all sorts of people.
I don't like to be presumed to be an asshole (or presume that others may be), and I'm offended that we have to treat adults like this as part of a new social contract. Can't we just be good to one another? And when there are assholes, can't we handle everything on a case-by-case basis, as it arises?
By putting this into every single project, it feels like we're building an ivory tower that ignores the social progress we've made in the last century. It's disrespectful and patronizing to mature adults to presume how they might behave. I don't like to think of people as great ape descendants, but this kind of thing reminds me we're just animals, fighting and name calling. I don't like that. I don't like how it makes me feel. Software is an achievement of human intellect, and I don't like to be reminded of our flaws. Not in the root of every software project I want to grok or contribute to.
I'm not so close-minded to rule out changing my mind on this matter, but I'm perplexed and, as I admitted before, slightly annoyed. I really want to hear others' opinions on this.
I'm not trying to trivialize anyone's experiences. I missed whatever original conversations there were on this matter and I want to express both how I feel and that I want to know more.
edit: I'm going to be downvoted for even admitting this? That's why I debated even posting. I don't like operating like this.
- draw_down 7y agoAh jeez, have we really not beaten this topic to death already? Cmon
- oefrha 7y agoCome on, I hate this as much as you do, but we don’t need yet another flamewar over this with canned responses.
- echelon 7y ago> Come on, I hate this as much as you do, but we don’t need yet another flamewar over this with canned responses. I must live under a bush.
- onetimeonly____ 7y agoNah, it's just further proof that only the zealots at opposite sites of a pointless battle care about this fluff.
- pyuser583 7y agoI feel the opposite: these Codes are just boilerplate nobody cares about. I once attended a tech meetup held at the headquarters of a FAANG. As we were waiting for the presentation to start, they projected their a link to their code on conduct for the meeting. I tried to visit the link. It gave a 404. Apparently it hasn’t been working for some time. Nobody noticed. Ironically, the meetup was about site reliability engineering. Edit: in all fairness I’ve seen a good tech group destroyed over a dumb battle about their code of conduct.
- alqrx 7y agoA lot of these are added because "open" source authors these days depend on their corporate masters. Adding a CoC provides one with: 1) At least one month of meetings, drafts and otherwise easy "work". 2) Increasing one's personal brand and marketability inside the corporation and on Twitter. 3) Increasing one's non-meritocratic influence inside the project. So we are back to the title of this submission: Red tape is introduced in "open" source because corporate money destroys it.
- yoz-y 7y agoThe 1. assumes that engineers like going to meetings to have 'easy' work and I honestly never met one that would prefer spending a month in meetings and writing docs over almost anything else.
- boomlinde 7y agoI think it's there not because people are generally expected to behave this way, but to have a framework of rules for when someone occasionally does, so that you can say that moderation decisions aren't completely arbitrary when you kick them out, or so you can say that someone that was arbitrarily kicked out was kicked out for the wrong reasons. It seems like it could be useful for large and socially important projects with many contributors IMO but I'm not sure why <10 contributor projects pick up on the habit.
- will4274 7y agoJust think of it like a license. If you publish code, you should stick a license on it, so it's clear if/how other people can use it. If you publish a project, you should stick a code of conduct on it, so if any assholes show up, you can link them to something as you tell them to go away. For most developers, these can be glanced at and ignored "yeah, BSD again, great" / "contributors covenant again, blah blah". Having things like this is basically a requirement for getting N>5 when N is the number of developers working on the project, so just pick something sane. I do find conversations about codes of conduct particularly exhausting, akin to GPLv2 vs GLPv3 licensing debates. And usually an excessive interest in these things is a red flag.
- justin66 7y ago> And when there are assholes, can't we handle everything on a case-by-case basis, as it arises? Don't interpret this comment as support or lack of support for codes of conduct (I honestly don't have an opinion about the topic). This is just an observation: there are multiple species of attention-seeking internet troll who want very, very much for you to treat their absurd behavior "on a case by case basis." > I'm going to be downvoted for even admitting this? That's why I debated even posting. I don't like operating like this. The mob is handling our comments on a case by case basis!
- omginternets 7y ago>This is just an observation: there are multiple species of attention-seeking internet troll who want very, very much for you to treat their absurd behavior "on a case by case basis." In my experience the exact opposite is true. Most trolls want to argue the finer language of a CoC, and waste everyone's time in a pseudo-legal battle. "Case-by-case" doesn't mean you have to spend a lot of time. It just means you're asking yourself "is this person being disruptive" as opposed to being compelled to argue technicalities in order to justify your actions as a moderator.
- justin66 7y agoI'm talking beyond my expertise here - I've never been involved in a CoC argument, but I have witnessed a lot of trolling - but it seems to me like the same guy who would be happy to argue endlessly about the trouble he's caused and the punishment or censorship that's being meted out on a case by case basis would also be happy to argue endlessly about a code of conduct and its application. Just please pay attention to him! I sort of suspect the same applies to the third parties who like to whinge about how moderation is being done. > "Case-by-case" doesn't mean you have to spend a lot of time. It just means you're asking yourself "is this person being disruptive" as opposed to being compelled to argue technicalities in order to justify your actions as a moderator. Even I have seen the "you handled this one way last month, why are you treating this guy differently today?" arguments. I imagine if you're willing to discuss your decisions at all, you're going to be forced to argue technicalities, if you're infested by the kind of people who like to argue technicalities.
- dwb 7y agoCodes of conduct have come about because apparently we need them. The before-time, when adults were meant to just get on with each other like adults, resulted in some marginalised people feeling very pushed out. So, as usual, a handful of unkind people ruined it for everyone. I don't love having to spell out that racism or transphobia or whatever isn't acceptable, but experience has shown that we do have to say it. So it's a choice between feeling a bit bad about some humans being mean, or projects tending towards a monoculture of big-ego masculine types and hardly anyone else feeling like it's worth the hassle.
- omginternets 7y ago>I'm going to be downvoted for even admitting this? That's why I debated even posting. I don't like operating like this. I think this is a case where a minority of people care very deeply, both about the core issue and about proselytizing it. The rest of us are a silent majority who, like you, are rubbed the wrong way by the whole situation but don't care enough to make a fuss. To add to your point, here's what boggles my mind with this new CoC frenzy: you can enforce good behavior, even without a CoC. I don't have any popular open source projects under my stewardship, but if that ever happens, I don't think I'm going to add add a CoC. This is because, in my estimation: 1. They're political tools. The people who visibly push for their widespread use tend to have a revanchist attitude with respect to diversity, inclusion and social equality. They see CoCs as a symbolic action in a turf war, not unlike spray-painting a gang symbol in an alley. 2. As you yourself have noted, it puts people on the defensive. It makes them think before posting...but for all the wrong things. It's stifling. 3. I can still ban disruptive or toxic assholes. I don't need a fake constitution to grant me those powers. See point #1.
- tomhoward 7y ago> I'm going to be downvoted for even admitting this? Note that you're not downvoted anymore. Early downvotes are usually balanced out quite quickly if your comment is sincere and thoughtful.
- thrwaway69 7y agoI put COC because I use boilerplates that comes with it or because github nags me. It's not like I lose anything by pushing it to the repo. On the contrary, I can use the vagueness to shut down some cases. Hello, I received a complaint from an important member that you were not following the CoC and they have given me sufficient evidence of your inappropriate behaviour. For anonymity reasons, I can't provide information on who it was or what the evidence is but as of now, you have been ...xyz Sincerely, thrwaway69 (/s)