3 ms·
I don't mean this to be a gotcha, but society has a lot of hidden complexity. Rigid prescriptive proposals like this are unlikely to be good ideas, which is why
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I don't mean this to be a gotcha, but society has a lot of hidden complexity. Rigid prescriptive proposals like this are unlikely to be good ideas, which is why governments haven't been presenting them.
In this particular case, the plan is great for personal life but is clearly infeasible economically. You can't just toggle a factory on and off every 2 weeks; it depends on supply chains extending weeks into the past and feeds into chains extending weeks into the future. Any complex business which is turned off in the 2 week breaks isn't going to be sustainable in the other 2 weeks.
- kurthr 7y agoCurrently, those businesses can't plan on anything a month away. There could be demand or not, supplies or not, workers or not... nobody knows. Demand is crushed and never returns... Now consider the alternative. You know that you will be open in 2 weeks, you know when you need get parts there, and you know when demand will show up. You can still use some amount of "essential" work at the corners. The point of the two phases is to make sure that things don't blow back up again and to make it obvious to everyone that it's fair. Then, demand is shifted rather than destroyed and the economy can function at slightly reduced capacity while still keeping the viral contagion controlled (not some crazy let's hope there's herd immunity and let everyone get it, or we'll keep the ICUs full for 18 months and hope the immunity lasts that long).