4 ms·
If there's one thing I've learned from years of managing remote, distributed, WFH teams, it's to never underestimate the efficiency of in-person collaboration.
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
If there's one thing I've learned from years of managing remote, distributed, WFH teams, it's to never underestimate the efficiency of in-person collaboration.
WFH is almost unanimously popular among the HN comment section demographic. These thought pieces declaring an early victory for WFH tend to get upvoted because they tell everyone what they want to hear: WFH good, offices bad.
WFH is challenging. People who are new to WFH tend to assume that their workload will go down, that their efficiency will go up, and that they'll be happier if they leave their homes less. For some people, this is true. However, for most people it takes a lot of time and deliberate effort to reach the same levels of in-office productivity while working from home.
Coronavirus quarantine isn't even a good representation of WFH for many people. People with young children at home are struggling to balance childcare with their dayjob. People are struggling to resist the urge to binge Twitter for Coronavirus news and opinions all day. We're all going stir-crazy from the isolation. Many people's workloads have decreased as business has slowed down.
The author is exactly right that Coronavirus will force companies to refine their WFH workflows and tools, but I think it's not accurate to declare this an early victory for WFH. Ideally, we emerge from this with more options for those who prefer to WFH, but I don't see Coronavirus quarantine convincing the majority of companies or people that WFH is inherently superior.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt's entirely possible that this will be bad for WFH in general, as many people will mentally conflate working from home with an unpleasant and scary time. Personally I think the push for WFH is much smaller and noisier than most people think. People who don't want WFH, like me, tend to be pretty quite on the subject because "the status quo is fine for me, thanks" isn't something you can get fired up about.
- daveFNbuck 7y ago> It's entirely possible that this will be bad for WFH in general, as many people will mentally conflate working from home with an unpleasant and scary time. People are also experiencing unusually slow internet connections due to everyone being online all the time, which makes working from home a less pleasant experience than it was before.
- baron_harkonnen 7y agoWhy do all of the discussions about WFH center around what employees want? I started my career with my own office (at two different jobs) and transitioned form cubicles to open office. Each step in this process has been notably worse than the previous and no one argues about that at all. The reason WFH hasn't taken off has nothing to do with want works best for employers. WFH hasn't taken off because having a physical presence has been a huge part of how companies not only control employees but show off their status. Startups had to be in SF because VCs wanted to see an office. Now that everyone is forced home more companies are seeing that having an office is a liability, and is not nearly as necessary since everyone has had to learn to do remote work so the cultural inertia has shifted immediately. I suspect we'll see a change to WFH, not because workers like it, but because it is cheaper and production doesn't change (not to mention it quickly reveals whose "production" is really just physically presenting in an office)
- npo9 7y ago> I suspect we'll see a change to WFH, not because workers like it, but because it is cheaper and production doesn't change (not to mention it quickly reveals whose "production" is really just physically presenting in an office) I’m unconvinced and very skeptical that on the average across all people that transitioned to WFH due to COVID-19 there is “no change” in measurable productivity.
- ashtonkem 7y agoThe relative merits of WFH productivity wise are debatable. Being forced to WFH unplanned and against your will, during a stressful pandemic? If you think productivity isn’t down per hour* I have a bridge to sell you. *A lot of workers are surely working more hours to compensate, or out of boredom. This presents a whole different set of risks.
- ashtonkem 7y agoIt’ll be seen as a liability for new companies, but most existing companies have decades long leases they’ll be loathe to risk ditching. A return to status quo is a very strong factor in large organizations, after all. I think this’ll be less of a watershed moment for most industries.
- notyourloops 7y agoIt would be nice if those of us who handle WFH under a pandemic very well have some leverage after it's resolved to continue a WFH schedule. I really don't care for the long commute to an open office. The combination reduces both my quality of life and my quality of work.
- gdubs 7y agoHacker News is more diverse than that. I see plenty of strong opinions on both sides of the argument. It’s similar to comments that claim everyone here is of one political persuasion or another — and usually dang has a list of comments that show otherwise.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoWhat timeline are you measuring diversity in? HN has a lot of active users around the globe but you can see the ideological pendulum of the comments swing when Europe signs off and the US west coast climbs toward its peak.
- Supermancho 7y ago> Hacker News is more diverse than that. I see plenty of strong opinions on both sides of the argument. I do not see that. I see the typical back and forth intellectual analysis and warning, but not strong arguments. The majority of stories are how good WFH is in some dimension(s). It's universally been bad for productivity, for any amount of time, in every single company I've worked for (25+ years). The billion dollar company I work for has self-recognized how productivity has crashed and have started to implement metric collection. Ultimately the low level managers and individual employees know and the upper management wants to blame something else than their own employees in aggregate (which won't help things).
- saiya-jin 7y agoAnother opinion from the other camp - WFH generally sucks. I have much more work to do, everything is less efficient because people have various remote issues, and whole remote connection is yet another thing on top of everything else that can fail and slow things down. I ain't cheaping out on current quality of life by having massive commute and adding stress, so shaving off those 20 mins each way doesn't mean much to me. Work-life balance is better with clearly-cut 'theatre' for work and life, having commute as a separator. Oh yes of course team work with remote is inefficient, was before and will be in the future till we wire our brains together. Having a whole team nearby makes everything so much faster, and I don't even go to the topic of different time zones. The only benefit for me - more time with my baby. But in these super-short bursts till another interruption from work comes, and they do. Another thing which I haven't seen mentioned much - people are much less active in general, this will without doubt have bad consequences on their long term health (although these will be hard to track precisely). I am trying to motivate myself into weight training at home 2x per week, running 2-3 times per week weather permitting and long walks on the weekend, but its much harder compared to having gym, and I know literally only my parents (whom I motivate myself to do so) that are so active. Everybody took the 'stay on the couch' too literally. But that's another topic and maybe this is very local to folks around me.
- lotsofpulp 7y ago>people are much less active in general Based on the US's obesity statistics, I don't think lack of access to a gym is Americans' problem. Spending an hour plus commuting every day is probably more of a problem. Between getting ready in the morning, getting kids ready, making dinner at night, putting kids to bed, that extra hour or two commuting is what replaces various other activities. And working too much in general.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y ago>Spending an hour plus commuting every day is probably more of a problem. Precisely. Tied to this is how we zone everything so dam far apart from another. It's ridiculous to have parking minimums within a 500' radius everywhere when there's no living minimimums. If most were able to bike or walk to work then we'd kill 3 birds with one stone: transportation cost, excercise, and environment all at once.
- watwut 7y ago> We're all going stir-crazy from the isolation It does not seem to me that way. I have the same amount of communication as before. I am communicating from home to people who are home too - effectively peers in same situation which is actually improvement over what it was like during majority of last decade for me.