4 ms·
I think an important problem with cars, e- or not, is size and weight. Moving two tons of car to move 100kg of passengers and baggage is just excessive. Compare
by adrianN 7y ago
I think an important problem with cars, e- or not, is size and weight. Moving two tons of car to move 100kg of passengers and baggage is just excessive. Compare cars with bicycles where less than 100W sustained are enough to navigate city traffic about 80% as fast as in a car. There must be a better trade-off point of comfort, safety and efficiency than a modern car.
- skyfaller 7y agoYeah, I think that electric bicycles are clearly superior in urban environments. Here in Philadelphia I sold my pickup truck and replaced it with a Tern GSD electric cargo bike, and it can do just about anything a car can do, including carry an adult passenger. Protection from the elements and accessibility are two legitimate concerns that might be addressed by bike-cars like the PEBL in the future: https://www.better.bike/ https://www.better.bike/ Outside of urban environments, velomobiles with aerodynamic shells have some potential, and would allow travel at highway speeds while using much less energy. Low-Tech Magazine suggests "If all 300 million Americans replace their car with an electric velomobile, they need only 25 % of the electricity produced by existing American wind turbines": https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2012/10/electric-velomobiles.html https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2012/10/electric-velomobil... - Part 2 (link in footer is broken) https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2012/10/electric-velomobiles-part-two.html https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2012/10/electric-velomobil... https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2010/09/the-velomobile-high-tech-bike-or-low-tech-car.html https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2010/09/the-velomobile-hig... The main problem with high-speed velomobiles is they're too fast for bike trails, but are too small and low to the ground to safely share highways with cars. Most pictures/videos I see of them are on rural roads with almost no traffic. In order for them to become popular, we probably would have to completely reimagine our transportation infrastructure.
- api 7y agoIsn't safety an issue too? You'd be turned into pizza toppings in a highway speed accident in one of those. They do show that huge efficiency improvements are possible, but they are not there yet. I feel like there's probably a happy medium: a larger somewhat heavier car with safety features built around active immobilization and advanced materials. It wouldn't be quite as efficient as these, but it would be more efficient than a conventionally built car. I also must point out that weight and aerodynamics are more significant for efficiency than size in an absolute sense. Aerodynamics matters the most at highway speeds. You can lengthen the vehicle and add a trunk for cargo without losing too much.
- skyfaller 7y agoKind of depends on the accident, doesn't it? The aerodynamic shell does provide some protection, depending on the design, and no doubt if these were mass-produced safety features could be ironed out. But if you hit a tree, you're lucky to survive regardless of what vehicle you're in. At any rate, people ride motorcycles with no shell despite serious safety disadvantages, and society has no problem with people making that choice. I have to believe that velomobiles with a shell could be made significantly safer than motorcycles. Of course, the biggest threat to velomobiles, bicycles etc. is the automobile, and if collisions with cars/trucks aren't dealt with in some reasonable fashion, all other safety concerns seem rather secondary.
- Retric 7y agoCars are designed to reasonably safely handle head on collisions with a brick walls at 55 MPH. I doubt a lightweight shell is going to provide anywhere near that level of protection.
- close04 7y agoYou never get something for nothing. The advantages of the bike come at a cost. Mainly in the comfort and capacity topics. Since this isolation thing started I basically cycle ~40-60Km every day just for fun. But if it's too cold or hot, raining, or have to carry stuff larger that the average backpack I'll plant myself firmly in the driver seat of my 1.something ton car to do it. Of course I don't need a 3t truck but I couldn't find any vehicle that ticks all the boxes.
- soperj 7y ago>Protection from the elements Must easier to just get good rain gear, a lot lighter too (and probably cheaper).
- skyfaller 7y agoI went for this option. My top of the line Tern GSD cost ~$6,000. A rain shell / completely rainproof outfit, mostly from Showers Pass, cost ~$700. A top of the line PEBL would cost ~$13,000. Still roughly double the price, although mass production could probably reduce the price of the PEBL. That said, I've made an alarming/annoying discovery: rain gear doesn't stay rainproof forever! Gore-tex style rainproof gear eventually must be refreshed using e.g. Nixwax at ~$20 a pop plus your washing labor, and it doesn't always work, meaning you have to junk the clothes or accept that they are no longer rainproof. It seems prudent to have multiple redundant rain shells since you can't always tell when your rain gear is going to stop being rainproof until you go out in the rain and get wet. This means that you may have to do significantly more maintenance and replacement for rain gear than you would have to do for the enclosure of the PEBL. In other words, the cost/hassle may depend on how often you have to travel in the rain.
- jeffreygoesto 7y agoWait. Where have I seen some threewheeler like the PEBL before? Right https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQh56geU0X8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QQh56geU0X8 ;-). Well, in reality it is not as bad, according to https://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/entertainment/news/a27897/jeremy-clarkson-admits-reliant-robin-rollovers-were-totally-rigged/ https://www.roadandtrack.com/car-culture/entertainment/news/...
- skyfaller 7y agoIt's worth noting that the Reliant Robin has its single wheel in the front, rather than in the back as the PEBL does. I think having two wheels in front should be much more stable. Frankly I don't understand why any three-wheel vehicles ever put the single wheel in the front, is it so they can turn easier?
- Scene_Cast2 7y agoSo the car is a self-contained transportation box. Feels to me that a bunch of the weight comes from the self-contained "sovereign" or "autonomous" bit (in the sense that there's a driver that can do whatever they want - the car isn't really a part of an enforced larger system). Most cars do behave according to the rules, but the crashes (and all the safety) comes into play when someone doesn't... If you try to synchronize the system (e.g. have one central master server controlling all cars on high-speed roads), then I have a feeling that a lot of weight can be shed.
- jeffreyrogers 7y agoI've been thinking that it would make sense to make dedicated lanes for lightweight vehicles. That would mitigate some of the safety concerns w.r.t. smaller cars/motorcyles and incentivize a switch to smaller vehicles in urban environments.
- jsight 7y agoSo the car alternative is only 2.5x as much power as a bike, goes 100% the speed of a car, and is air conditioned? That seems like a worthwhile tradeoff.
- sudosysgen 7y ago2.5x?? There is absolutely no way a car uses 250w on average in city driving, even with regen. If that was the case, some Teslas would have an autonomy of 400 hours(!) in city driving. More like 25-100x more energy. And that's quite generous still. In a city, bikes are indeed multiple orders of magnitude more efficient than cars for personal transportation.
- soperj 7y agoThey said 2.5x as much power as a bike, not car.
- sudosysgen 7y agoElectric cars do not use 2.5 times the power of a car. Unless there is another electric vehicle that can go 100% the speed of a car, and is air-conditioned, that I don't know of.
- soperj 7y agothe velomobile. literally what the topic of what this person is replying to.
- Retric 7y agoE-Bikes are already at 1,000+ watts. So the estimate is 2,500 watts for something like an enclosed golf cart with AC which seems possible, though I assume they mean car speeds inside a city not highway speeds.
- sudosysgen 7y agoThey are at 1000+ watts peak, but unless your average speed is of 45mph in a city all the time, you're not pushing 1kw on average. More like 100-200 watts on average.