5 ms·
Decision-making over social distancing is taking a toll on our mental health
- bitlax 7y agoThe irony of a Rolling Stone writer's concern with how one's actions can affect others.
- nullc 7y agoThe irony of a hacker news post concerning a rolling stone writers concern with how one's actions can affect others. :) [HN is very interesting, but it's also a fairly reliable source of some extremely inhumane and self-centered comments.]
- dntbnmpls 7y agoIn HN's defense, a HN comment didn't make up a fake rape article to ruin the lives of many innocent young people to push a certain narrative like a rolling stone's writer did. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus
- Ensorceled 7y agoA six year old, retracted article written by somebody described as "a former journalist". What else ya got?
- dexterdog 7y agoAre all of the editors who approved the article listed as "former editors?" Answer: No. Sean Woods, who was the editor directly responsible for the articles, is still a writer for RS.
- Ensorceled 7y agoSeriously, are there other instances/events or just this one? All news sources have their failures, some are consistently bad, is Rolling Stone in the consistently bad category?
- dntbnmpls 7y ago> What else ya got? That's not enough? People like you are why we have a "news" industry.
- Ensorceled 7y agoIt was six years ago. It was retracted. The person responsible was fired and blacklisted from the industry. What did people like you want to happen? Because EVERY news source has at least one skeleton like this in their closet.
- dntbnmpls 7y ago> It was six years ago. It was retracted. The person responsible was fired and blacklisted from the industry. Shouldn't the company itself be "fired and blacklisted"? > What did people like you want to happen? See above. > Because EVERY news source has at least one skeleton like this in their closet. It's not their "closet". They did it INTENTIONALLY to push an agenda. Meaning it's a problem with the institution itself. They intentionally set out to create "news" where it didn't exist to further their agenda. They retracted once they got caught. I wonder if you would be so dismissive of the "sins" of other "news" institutions that don't align with your bias or agenda.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThe thing that really gets me about HN comments is the lack of plausible deniability for stupid comments. People say dumb stuff on 2^N-chan and you can just assume they're trolls trying to rile up the extremeists. People say dumb stuff on Reddit and you can chalk it up to them being teenagers without life experience to have a more reality based opinion. People say dumb stuff on HN and you can't really make up any excuse for them because they have "Senior Engineer at X" and a link to a personal website that shows they're not an idiot or a deadbeat and you're left wondering how people so smart can be so stupid. Of course it's well known that most people don't know much about things outside their area(s) of expertise but it's still frustrating nonetheless because you'd expect smart people to know this and either not run their mouth or qualify their statements.
- pjc50 7y agoHave you checked the Presidential twitter feed? Stupidity is fashionable. Stupidity is popular. Stupidity is loyalty. (Other factions are also perfectly capable of this, e.g. the leaked Labour internal documents, but the right are really making a performance out of it these days)
- op03 7y agoRationality is Bounded - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bounded_rationality https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bounded_rationality The internet does a bad job of signalling that.
- paulcole 7y agoIf somebody says something that makes you think they’re an idiot or a deadbeat, believe them.
- wickerman 7y agoSorry, where's the irony? I'm not familiar with what reputation Rolling Stone has.
- umanwizard 7y agoProbably a reference to this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Rape_on_Campus
- Ensorceled 7y agoAs a Canadian who doesn't really consume Rolling Stone as a news source, I'm left to wonder: 1. Is this a "fake news" person, who refers to all journalism that isn't Breitbart/Fox as "the MSM" or some such? 2. Is this person still holding a personal grudge from when Rolling Stone left Rush off their best bands of all time list? 3. Are they snarkily referencing some incident(s) where Rolling Stone abused their position/punched down but can't be bothered to link to it?
- tyingq 7y agoI think the mental toll is more complex than that. This situation changes a lot of things. One example is many couples that used to have regular time apart are now together almost 24x7. One of many things that are different now.
- have_faith 7y agoMe and my partner are doing OK. But I have noticed that my single overtly extraverted friends are doing less so while living alone. Some have managed to fill their time with constant zoom parties and the like in order to fulfil their extraverted needs but it's obvious they still crave a lot more than that and it's just enough to tide them over. It's going to be very interesting how that progresses in the coming weeks (and months...?). Regardless of the validity of systems such as the Myers Briggs personality types I am very interested in how the various corners are handling the situation. Particularly INTP/INTJ's (assumedly a lot of HN...).
- djsumdog 7y agoAnd those of us who went into this disaster single and without kids have been separated from nearly everyone, and have absolutely no hope of that ending anytime soon.
- hobs 7y agoNot a huge fan of them, but my dating apps have been pretty buzzy because all of the people staying inside. There's plenty of bored single people in the same boat as far as I can tell.
- segmondy 7y agoAnd those with partners who are in health care are now fearful of being together because they don't wish to get sick at the same time if they get infected.
- sheeshkebab 7y agoThis bull shit of social distancing... what are people thinking that they won’t get the virus by staying away for a while? There are close to 20m newly unemployed people that could give a shit about it. There will be risks of riots soon if this goes on. And in the end we’ll get worst of both ends.
- Gollapalli 7y agoI'm not sure it's fair to say that it's just social distancing, but you're absolutely right that economic effects have a potential to destroy this country. (writing from the US) 52% of people under the age of 45 have been laid off, put on leave, or had hours reduced. Putting the people with young families, or who would have been looking to start families in dire straits is a great recipe for high crime and social unrest.
- peterlk 7y ago> 52% of people under the age of 45 have been laid off, put on leave, or had hours reduced Do you have a source for this? I'm not finding it with a quick google search
- Gollapalli 7y ago> In a new report, Data for Progress found that a staggering 52 percent of people under the age of 45 have lost a job, been put on leave, or had their hours reduced due to the pandemic, compared with 26 percent of people over the age of 45. Nearly half said that the cash payments the federal government is sending to lower- and middle-income individuals would cover just a week or two of expenses, compared with a third of older adults. This means skipped meals, scuppered start-ups, and lost homes. From: https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/04/millennials-are-new-lost-generation/609832/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2020/04/millennial... Report cited in quote: http://filesforprogress.org/memos/the-staggering-economic-impact-coronavirus.pdf http://filesforprogress.org/memos/the-staggering-economic-im... (I haven't read this.)
- djsumdog 7y ago
- djsumdog 7y agoCOVID-19 is two diseases. One is the obvious one that is killing thousands of people, where their own body is breaking down and fighting against them. The second is the disease where society, in an attempt to fight the disease, could end up deeply hurting itself: https://battlepenguin.com/philosophy/covid-19-is-two-diseases/ https://battlepenguin.com/philosophy/covid-19-is-two-disease...
- dusted 7y agoI'm enjoying it, I like working from home and I prefer to interact with people in text or voice calls over face to face. I wish society would adapt to this and get better infrastructure for things like shopping in my area so I literally never had to leave the house to interact with another human. I like watching TV shows with my best friend on a discord session, we just press play at the same time. It's like, finally the rest of society has to abide to how I want things to be, I'm glad that I don't have to say "sorry, got a cold so not shaking hands" anymore, because now we just don't do that, it was gross to begin with, why would I want to touch some strangers hands? The economy breaking down from this, well, that's not only a bad thing, the economy was broken to begin with, in the best case, this forces us to rethink the systems.
- djsumdog 7y agoAnd the hundreds of thousands dead around the world?
- dusted 7y agoI'm fairly certain that number would be _A_LOT_ higher if nobody isolated. I'm also speculating that the general amount of people dying from infectious disease will fall, the flu takes a toll every year, we could prevent a lot of those. Why suffer through the common cold if you can simply avoid getting it to begin with? As I read your question again, I think you may have misunderstood what I meant in my previous post. I do not think the actual virus is a good thing, I wish for that to be over as soon as possible, but the isolation part, more of that please.
- djsumdog 7y agoAre you suggesting this should be a regular thing? I get that maybe some aspects of your personal experience are better. I don't like shaking hands either and wish we bowed like some East Asians. But your words feel like they don't truly understand the ramifications of the life and death struggles going on in hospitals, or that the vast majority of human beings that are not you, evolved to need a good amount of social interaction. This is not normal and should never ever considered being any type of normal. We can deal with the fatalities, and it is tragic, but the long term effects on society and the erosion of our rights and civil liberties will take decades to recover from. This is not a time of honor.
- lnsru 7y agoI will be not popular here, but I have no problems with this so called social distancing (as it is in Germany). The local newsletters write at lest 3 articles daily how bad it is. But it isn’t bad at all! One may open the door and can have a walk. One can drive to the woods and still have a walk. Phones and internet are working fine. It’s not that families of 4 would be locked down in 25 square meters flats for months. Perhaps it’s my subjective perspective: I was homeless and broken decade ago, but now have supportive wife, side project with bright perspective, still employed and with full fridge.
- kayodelycaon 7y agoSome of us need social interaction to be healthy and live alone. Walking in the woods only does so much.
- lnsru 7y agoThat’s right, but in Germany you could go to the woods with somebody and it still would be totally fine. Edit: fellow salesmen still thrive during pandemic on the phone. Looks like their luxury cars and weekly meetings at the client’s location are not needed at the end. These were extreme extroverts talking without a break.
- lpah4all 7y agoWhat one values in life is the basis of mental health, unless one has a physical pathology (e.g. depression). Congratulations on your success. There is a significant part of the world population that refuse to learn how to look at the world as appreciatively as we do. The struggles my wife and I have faced throughout our lives give us the foundation for the joy and inner peace we feel in our lives. I know there will be a lot of people that are suffering during this through no fault of their own, and I hope they persevere and that they reach out to their communities for caring help, and that they receive it. But a significant percent of us in the wealthier countries of the world are simply having to adjust to not being able to trod all over the world giving fuck-all about anyone else. I say it's well and truly time for them to appreciate their grocery clerks and hospital orderlies and realize that all people are valuable and that the more they struggle in life, the more we should help. Personally, I'm very happy with the improvement in air quality from the reduction in society's busyness. Endless growth of GDP was always setting us up for disaster; this seems like a kindof gentle way (if brutally abrupt) to slow down our economies, but we'll see how/if/when we come out of the other side.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- motohagiography 7y agoMoral fatigue in the article is very much a thing, but moreso for people living together. As someone who fits into what I call the "untroubled loner" category, I'm the source of zoom respite for a lot of people stuck together, which takes energy for me, but nothing compared to what it means to a relationship where suddenly you need to be emotionally present and "on," all the time when previously you didn't. I'm regularly in touch with about 30 people in different places via zoom, slack, etc, and the impact could be described on a Pareto distribution. Too much mental health concern and sympathy bothers me a bit because it can be a social license to behave terribly, and the self-care narrative can seem like an enabler instead of a mitigation for a crisis. I'm advising friends to remember how abnormal this is. Their normal might not come back, but being just a bit more charitable with each other as they adapt can turn a relationship breaker into a deeper level of trust. Marriages and family are wealth, and right now they aren't earning interest or returns from the outside. Some people are starting to spend and draw down their emotional capital by being needy or subconsciously giving in to conflict for the excitement. If you lacked personal boundaries going into this, it's going to be hard when they necessarily build up just to stay sane in confinement, so being charitable about that mental space is key. All I can say is the best way through this will be to exercise, read the stoics, and work on mastering something. This too shall pass.
- aaron695 7y ago> Decision-making over social distancing is taking a toll on our mental health This is a really good article. I'm more a fan on the real title "The Reason You’re Exhausted Is ‘Moral Fatigue’" Handling ‘Moral Fatigue’ effects R0. If it becomes to much people will give up, which ends lockdowns early and it reduces productivity and short term happiness. With the Moral Fatigue comes adventure though, it's like a foreign holiday, stressful, but we understand the reward. The real "toll on our mental health" will be the joblessness and health budget cuts for the coming years, not Moral Fatigue.
- TopHand 7y agoI think the mental toll for what is going on right now is going to appear laughable in the months to come. No matter which way we jump there are going to be ugly consequences. A huge part of not examining the problems and trying to come up with the best solutions is that it is being made into a political debate on whose policies were and should be followed. We at where we're at. What we should be looking at is what is the best way out. We need to triage the situation by deciding what we want the future to look like. Do we want our children to grow up with the education and employment opportunities that they had six months ago, or do we want to completely minimize the loss of life? The people most at risk are people with compromised cardiovascular systems and compromised respiratory systems. I also understand that obese people are at high risk. You can conclude that the way these people became compromised is through lifestyle choices. They chose to smoke, drink, and over indulge in food for many years. I'm sorry the bill has become due. But I don't think my children should have to pay the price for their choices. I know a lot of readers are going to be saying that the greatest at risk group are people over 65. I'm in this group. It is my personal opinion that I would rather my grandchildren grow up with high potential than to prolong my life another few years. In reality I'm not truly concerned because I'm relatively healthy for my age group because of the choices I have made.
- kian 7y agoDo you really think that all people with cardiovascular and respiratory issues are 'paying the price for their choices'? I guess asthma sufferers (such as the nurse who ran marathons but had exercise-induced asthma who died recently), people with congenital heart issues, and immunocompromised patients and those with auto-immune disorders all just should have chosen not to be born with their respective illnesses? And tsk tsk for all of those foolish people currently on cancer treatment - don't they know that cancer is easy to avoid because we know every cause? Even if you believe that the majority of people with these conditions are at fault - just be clear that the people who 'caused this to themselves' will not be the only ones who suffer. -- edited to remove an uncharitable reading and response --
- TopHand 7y agoYes there are those who suffer through no consequence of their own. But they are in the minority. I'm guessing that the majority of people with these compromises have been smoking, drinking and made poor lifestyle choices. I didn't feel I needed to write a complete essay covering every possible case. Yes there are innocent victims. But again, the majority are probably from lifestyle choices. I was not arguing to be allowed to wonder the streets. I was arguing that there are consequences to every direction we turn and that we need to consider what kind of future we want in the following decades. This will eventually end. What do we want life to look like when it ends? Just for your info, I live a fairly isolated life on a working ranch. My wife and I can go as long as a month without seeing another human being. My lifestyle has not changed all that much other than the fact that at the base level of the food supply, I can see that shortages are coming. Most living Americans have not lived through food shortages. The big political question of the coming years may not be how do we distribute the wealth, but how do we ease the hunger!