12 ms·
I think there's an interesting conversation to be had about the psychological nature of this pandemic. The author of the article is 39 years old, I'm quite surp
by Barrin92 7y ago
I think there's an interesting conversation to be had about the psychological nature of this pandemic. The author of the article is 39 years old, I'm quite surprised by the severity of the experience that he reports.
There was a similar article in the NYT recently by a woman whose husband contracted COVID, had a relatively 'normal' pneumonia, but the article read like a war report out of an Ebola zone, allusions to Chernobyl the TV series, and COVID as a silent killer, and so on.
Now I don't want to diminish the personal experience of anyone, but I'm still surprised how many people in their 40s, 50s, 60s who ought to have had personal experience with tragedy and illness seem to have serious psychological trouble coping with the simple fact that we're for a while living in a pandemic and that life has become somewhat more dangerous.
It's not that I'm personally not worried at all, but there has to be some perspective. Life is more dangerous, but it's always somewhat dangerous. I wonder if it's, in particular, a phenomenon of affluent societies that haven't had to deal with serious stressors in a long time.
If you've ever been to Israel and lived there for a while and you go to a wedding and five minutes later there's a bomb alarm and there's pretty much rockets flying your way all the time, and you observe how resilient people are in coping with danger in their life, observing a lot of cultural response here worries me a lot.
- sfj 7y agoI think older people are more worried about those they are taking care of than themselves. At least it's true in my case.
- wccrawford 7y agoI'm in my 40s and haven't had to deal with any really crazy situations like this. It isn't just that there's a possibility that 1 person I love could die from this, there's a possibly that any of them could. And the older they are, the more likely that they could die from it. On top of that, I can't spend time with them in the way that I would if I knew they were at risk. I have to stay away from them instead. It's the opposite of what I'd do if I knew a loved one was dying. I think I'm dealing with it better than most because I'm an introvert. But I watch other people around me being affected by this, and I can understand it. It's a lot of new, different stress all at once.
- Kaiyou 7y agoI'm thinking of this as a temporary hysteria. Nothing much you can do to reason with hysterical people. The only thing that sometimes works for hysteria is a good slap in the face.
- steveeq1 7y agoIt is temporary hysteria. Remember 'swine flu'? The infection fatality rate ended up being like 10x better than what the media initially reported.
- kerkeslager 7y agoDo you remember swine flu? The media storm died down as experts gathered more information and made recommendations. Note how with Covid19, the information has changed over time, but not enough to change expert recommendations, which have remained fairly consistent.
- steveeq1 7y agoNo it's not, the infection fatality rate keeps going down. This is just media hype and the risks are being overblown due to the many biases in human judgment (availabiltiy bias, survivorship bias, social bias, etc).
- kerkeslager 7y ago> No it's not, the infection fatality rate keeps going down. Which is why I didn't say the infection fatality rate is staying the same.
- ubercow13 7y agoDoes that even matter? If the best estimate of fataility rate is what it is now, surely that is what any response should be based on. The media is reporting various figures from scientists, not making them up. If you don't calibrate your response based on such figures, what do you calibrate it based on? A gut feeling that everything will probably be fine?
- wastedhours 7y ago> I wonder if it's, in particular, a phenomenon of affluent societies that haven't had to deal with serious stressors in a long time. Most likely it is, and I'd much rather live with occasionally being scared shitless by a global pandemic that might not be as bad as we feel it is than to deal with continual serious stressors day-in day-out. > cultural response here worries me a lot Why? I get that resilience is an important trait in a number of walks of life, but being concerned about a quite-deadly airborne respiratory virus that could be transferred by any Tom, Dick or Harry within close proximity seems like quite a valid thing to let get on top of you. There's also the sense of unknown about this all. Dying by cancer is, unless it's especially niche, quite well documented. And though you wont be around to rationalise it, being killed by a bomb is also a well understood process too. Being killed by something that someone might just exhale into your general direction, that has no documented cure, isn't that well understood by most of the population any more (and damn well shouldn't have to be). "It is what it is" is a great way to build mental resilience in trying times, but when you can't really identify what "it" actually "is", it becomes a lot harder.
- steveeq1 7y agoI know, it's amazing to me the number of people that are blowing the risk way out of proportion. I think there is a degree of "survivorship bias" in the news. People who get covid-19 and have a mild case dont get reported because it's bland and everyday.
- nradov 7y agoIt helps to take a historical perspective. Throughout most of human history, occasional wars, epidemics, and famines were just a normal part of life. In the US many people assumed those crises could no longer impact us, but of course our luck couldn't last forever. Reversion to the mean.
- gdubs 7y agoNovelty plays a role in fear. People in the Midwest get used to tornadoes. People in Florida get used to hurricanes. We all drive in cars, despite passing by severe accidents at a somewhat regular cadence. Going from healthy to struggling to breath can be incredibly disconcerting — something a relatively young person may never experienced. When there’s no certainty of outcome, rational people may lose their normal comfort in statistics. People are human, after all. Sure, we could all work on our resilience — but some compassion for people is warranted too.
- kerkeslager 7y agoI don't think that day-to-day danger is without personal cost, even for people who are "resilient". My experiences with living in various levels of dangerous situations[1] is that people become "politely selfish" in direct proportion to the level of risk. If you're doing okay it's not a problem, but the people at the bottom of society are the first to lose support when this happens. In the case of the US, I think a lot of the insane response we've gotten is because of a combination of two things. First, we've not had real personal danger within our borders in most of our lifetimes. Second, media has learned that it's profitable to sell fear. The result is a bunch of manufactured fears, that aren't rationally actionable because they don't exist to begin with, and we become accustomed to reacting irrationally to fear and not looking too closely at our responses because ultimately there's no consequence to doing something ineffective in response to a danger that doesn't exist. But when a real danger like Covid 19 comes along, people don't have a rational set of coping mechanisms honed against previous real dangers, so they react to a real danger the same way they've reacted to a bunch of nonexistent, media-manufactured dangers in the past. If people post about how WiFi causes cancer[2] on Facebook and then do nothing to avoid WiFi, that's not great, but it isn't critical. But if people post about Covid19 danger on Facebook and then do nothing to avoid Covid19, at a societal level that causes the disease to spread and kill more people. [1] I did live in Israel, although that's not what I'm talking about. I was 5-6 so I'm not sure how relevant that experience is. [2] I'm not saying WiFi causes cancer.