9 ms·
> An important point the article didn’t address is that high prices direct resources to more important uses. Neither do high prices. Those direct them to peopl
by wpietri 7y ago
> An important point the article didn’t address is that high prices direct resources to more important uses.
Neither do high prices. Those direct them to people with more money to spend. Confusing "richer" with "more important" is always a bad idea, but especially so with goods like medical supplies. A billionaire who wants to stockpile a million masks just in case definitely not "more important" than a million poor people getting 1 mask each.
- droopyEyelids 7y agoIn the absence of a law structuring the sale, money is the best proxy we have for importance. The law, in a system of democratic governance, is a big asterisk to that sentence! It's important too. But aside from that, price signaling is our most 'objective' way to determine importance.
- dwohnitmok 7y ago> In the absence of a law structuring the sale, money is the best proxy we have for importance. I strongly disagree under these circumstances. Prices are one benchmark of importance/value and are often useful as such. But Goodhart's Law comes here in full force. In particular I would argue that when unusual things happen, the usual benchmarks and proxies we have deserve extra scrutiny, since often any discrepancy between a measure and what is being measured is magnified in abnormal times. And right now times are quite abnormal. Now is exactly when traditional benchmarks of value should be re-evaluated to see if they are still useful under present circumstances.
- adrianN 7y agoYou can have a democratic system of government and still ration goods during a crisis. Democracy and economic policy are orthogonal things.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> A billionaire who wants to stockpile a million masks just in case definitely not "more important" than a million poor people getting 1 mask each. Real people don't behave like this. A billionaire can't make personal use of a million masks and there is no point in stockpiling them during a crisis just in case there is some future crisis. They're not going to be worth more a year from now than they are today because by then either demand will be lower or production will be higher. So nobody would be buying a million masks to hoard in a bunker right now. The people buying them would be the people who intend to use them. Then you need to differentiate who needs them the most, but there is no way to do that efficiently from the top of a tower. And willingness to pay is a pretty good proxy when marginal utility falls off pretty quickly with quantity. A software engineer isn't going to pay a high price for a thousand masks they don't need any more than the billionaire is going to buy a million. But a doctor's office might very well pay a high price for a thousand masks they do need, which is exactly what you want to see because it causes them to get what they need.
- yawaramin 7y agoThe assumption here is that 'doctor's offices' have that kind of cash to throw around? I'm wracking my brain trying to understand who these mythical doctors are who need masks more than hospitals which are the actual front lines of treating COVID-19 and are alarmingly low on PPE.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoSome doctors treat COVID-19 patients. If they have no PPE, they're more likely to get infected themselves and pass the virus to their other patients. Or they can outbid some hypochondriacs.
- Nursie 7y agoSounds like a wonderful system!
- wpietri 7y agoMy hyperbole aside, real people do behave like this. Look at the guys buying up all the hand sanitizer. Look at all the hoarding and panic buying that went on. It's 18 months or so before we get a vaccine. There's plenty of incentive to hoard PPE. And even taking your clinic example, you see the same issues there. If rich clinics outbid poor clinics for a limited supply, we'll see rich places stocking up and poor places going without.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> My hyperbole aside, real people do behave like this. Look at the guys buying up all the hand sanitizer. Look at all the hoarding and panic buying that went on. But then they're not price-insensitive billionaires, so if the price goes up it deters them from hoarding (and gives them a financial motive to unload their existing hoard), which is exactly what you want. > It's 18 months or so before we get a vaccine. There's plenty of incentive to hoard PPE. It's 18 months or so before we get a vaccine, but not before anybody can start manufacturing more PPE, which is already starting to happen and will only increase if demand doesn't subside. And if demand does subside, same result. > If rich clinics outbid poor clinics for a limited supply, we'll see rich places stocking up and poor places going without. What allocation process are you proposing that would avoid things like that happening? The same one we use to allocate tax dollars to bailouts doesn't feel like a strong candidate.
- nostromo 7y agoIsn't your comment a critique of all free markets? Food is largely a free market in the US. A billionaire could buy a billion dollars worth of beef tomorrow. But they don't, because why would they? And in fact, markets have done a better job of feeding people than any centralized planning system has. I don't see why masks would be any different.
- redis_mlc 7y ago> markets have done a better job of feeding people than any centralized planning system has. I wish HN would take their ECON101 lesson and shove it. All functioning governments susbsidize local farmers. The US pays farmers to produce milk and corn, amongst other things. The extra milk is often stockpiled as 5 pound cheese bricks. I've seen them. There is no "free markets with only comparative advantage" for food. How's the free market in ventilators and PPE working out for you? Hope you don't queue behind the wrong person at the grocery store.
- badpun 7y agoA counterexample: After WWII in Poland, Moscow installed a communist government in Warsaw, which promptly started implementing communist policies. One of the biggest ones was collectivization of farming - taking pieces of land and joining them into massive, state-run farms. After around 10 years of this, the studies started showing that this collectivized farming is so much less efficient than private farming (which didn't receive any subsidies!) that, if the whole country converts to it, there's a risk of nation-wide hunger. Further collectivization was stopped shortly after, even though it was clearly against the official dogma of private property and capitalism being the root of all evil.
- WalterBright 7y agoEvery economy that has tried collective farming, from small to large, has never been able to achieve self-sufficiency in food. The US economy around 1800 was the first economy in history to produce a consistent food surplus. You can see the results of this in the astonishing increase in the average height of Americans throughout the 19th century. In the Great Depression, the government ordered the slaughter of millions of hogs in order to try and raise the price of pork. https://livinghistoryfarm.org/farminginthe30s/crops_17.html https://livinghistoryfarm.org/farminginthe30s/crops_17.html
- roenxi 7y agoMr. Mouse has a good take on this but there is a second perspective that is worth considering: If we set up a dog-eat-dog world where only money matters, why would a billionaire hoard unneeded masks? They know that they can just buy what they need when the need it. The only people with incentive to hoard are poor and vulnerable people because they know they won't be able to afford masks when they run out. Entrepreneurial types looking for arbitrage will probably cause weird things to happen in the short term, but after a month or two things will rebound sharply to whatever the new normal is going to look like. If this crisis has taught me anything, it was a mistake not to hoard. I assumed I would be able to buy what I needed at outrageous prices, instead I ran the risk of running out of toilet paper because prices stayed unreasonably low. If bankrupting hoarders with high prices is going to be unacceptable, I'm going to become a hoarder out of necessity next time I see a crisis inbound. I'll stock up on much more toilet paper than I need because I can't predict when governments/major supermarkets/public at large will let me buy the stuff at market price; which is clearly a bit higher than what the supermarkets are charging.
- notauser 7y agoGiven that poor people can't afford to hoard because of the cost of storage (especially in cities) and financing, isn't it better that rich people are encouraged to hoard when supply is plentiful? The problem arises when rich people start hoarding at times when supply is constrained, because they can do it so much more rapidly and create a much greater shock to the system. It was notable in London that severe shortages only really existed at stores you can drive to. Stores that you can only walk to have been much better stocked.
- roenxi 7y ago> isn't it better that rich people are encouraged to hoard when supply is plentiful? The market signal that would make rich people hoard masks in the good times would be ... an expectation that if an unexpected crisis arose then prices would rise to extreme values. Nothing else is going to make that happen. Not even most governments manage to resist economising and running down their medical supplies after the last health scare they faced. I'm not going to hoard in good times because I'm not crazy; I know I can't be ready for everything. I'm just going to try and preempt everyone else at the start of a crisis. It won't work every time but that is the strategy that makes sense if the crisis response is includes 'stopping price-gouging'. If we allowed price gouging, I might seriously keep a few extra boxes of masks ready for selling to others the next time this happened. I like money. I have some shelf space. The only question is will prices go high enough to justify using it.
- WalterBright 7y ago> Neither do high prices. Sure they do. Look at what happens when an oil refinery blows up (happens now and then). Price for gas goes up until demand matches supply. Billionaires don't hoard gas. Gas prices fluctuate daily. This is all from matching supply with demand. The same goes for airline seats and the price of oranges. I don't think I ever pay the same price twice for oranges at the supermarket.
- wpietri 7y agoGas and oranges are hard to hoard; airline seats are impossible. And your examples are all from normal times, not major disasters. None of what you say is relevant to disaster profiteering.
- downerending 7y agoDisagree. Gasoline is perhaps the quintessential example of disaster price "gouging". Ask anyone in a hurricane zone. Personally I have mixed feelings: If the prices don't go up, the incentive to ramp up production is pretty weak. It does, though, seem inhumane that increased prices can have an outsized bad effect for the very poor in disaster situations.
- WalterBright 7y agoWhat happens in a hurricane zone (or used to happen until laws were passed against it) is everyone outside the zone with a pickup truck and a gas can would fill the can with gas and drive it into the zone and sell it at a profit. This caused a huge hue and cry about how terrible it was. So the law clamped down on it. Now people in a hurricane zone get no gas while they wait around for the government to provide some. So, which is better: 1. gas at a higher price 2. no gas ?
- downerending 7y agoApparently it's easier to downvote than to suggest a workable alternative. Per Sowell, there is no cosmic justice, and pretending so just makes things worse.