4 ms·
Good grief that's a dramatic article. The economic decline may be stark but that's what happens when you effectively freeze economic activity. I'm not really su
by Barrin92 7y ago
Good grief that's a dramatic article. The economic decline may be stark but that's what happens when you effectively freeze economic activity. I'm not really sure why exactly things are never supposed to be the same given that people still have their training, factories are still around and those can be reopened once sufficient safety is guaranteed.
There's disruption in supply chains and business formation and whatnot, but I think it would be better to think about the economy in terms of actual resources and human capital rather than stock market figures, the former isn't vanishing into thin air.
There's this tendency to dramatically overrate the impact of contemporary events. People said the same thing after 9/11 when it came to other aspects of life, and apart from increased airport security and a few costly wars there indeed was nothing new under the sun.
The CDC estimated that the swine flu in 2009 may have killed up to half a million people globally. We'll see what the death toll of this is at the end but this isn't humanity's first pandemic and it isn't its worst, not by a significant margin.
- marcus_holmes 7y agoMy father was telling me stories of the Swine Flu outbreak in 1957. It sounds very similar - he was in boarding school, unable to be sent home, and there were a couple of dozen schoolboys and staff nursing everyone else for a few weeks. 3 years later it was the "swinging 60's" and the economy boomed. I think the difference between then and now is the "sophistication" of the financial markets, and how intertwined they are with government. "Too big to fail" didn't work last time, will some heads actually roll this time?
- ciconia 7y agoI agree it remains to be seen how the crisis will evolve, but I think the article makes a good case for why this crisis is different: the speed, the scale, and the fact that even before the crisis, since 2008, markets were being propped up by central banks.
- resu_nimda 7y agoI think it would be better to think about the economy in terms of actual resources and human capital rather than stock market figures, the former isn't vanishing into thin air. Agreed. This is why I don't get all the doom and gloom, and all the people saying the bailouts/stimulus/low interest rates are going to further wreck things. All of the actual value and technology that we've built up as a society is still there, ready and waiting to kick back into gear. I don't see how moving some numbers around in the meantime is going to create a long lasting deleterious effect. I feel pretty confident that, once the engine starts back up again, things are gonna boom. Would love to understand why I'm wrong, but this article just pointed out a bunch of statistics that are bad right now but didn't really seem to make an argument to back up its headline which I'm going to call BS clickbait.
- adventured 7y agoWe got our inevitable recession out of the way in this process, in a rapid sharp action. That of course is not meant to trivialize the terrible pain of going through this pandemic, nor the depths of the hit we're taking (the recession we would have endured would have been far less painful, including to employment). The economy will gently boom in the years following the distribution of a vaccine. Start to finish the Fed and US Government is going to pour enormous amounts of liquidity into the economy the likes of which has never been seen before in human history. There are no restraints at this point, no serious blockers saying don't do it. While everyone is acting fiscally wild, we should call up the Japanese and do a financing and technology deal with them, to build regional high-speed rail across the US and complete it this decade. It's a worthy infrastructure project that can produce a lot of jobs and economic floatation action (the airlines won't appreciate it). Make it a federal project, and aggressively swat away regulatory, environmental and NIMBYism delays. The Federal Reserve has crossed the rubicon (they've fully breached old lines in the sand that quasi kept them a layer or two removed from putting their hands on the real economy), we might as well do the things now that we should have done previously. They can snap their fingers and finance this project in the coming years. We should probably also go ahead and stop pretending the Federal Reserve isn't now a big corner of our Treasury and merge the two (won't happen officially, but it has happened de facto). There's no going back, not with the pile of debt we'll have coming out of this. It's perma QE all the way for the next 20-30 years.
- xbmcuser 7y agoA large percentage of the world's economy is about superfluous things and addictions. The 2-3 months break is going to wean off a lot of people and the number of people going back will be fewer. That's my opinion. What everyone else is looking at is money 1). large percentage of small businesses were running month to month after 2-3 months of no revenue many of them won't start back up again. 2). Over the lockdown period people have lost jobs, run through their savings or run up large credit card debt. Once it opens they will be frugal to either save up or pay of the debt. 3). Bankruptcies and repossessions are going to create a glut of supply at the same time demand will be less so industries won't be able to start back up much even after the lock down is removed. These are just some of things happening that I see going forward. Maybe I am wrong and that's not how economies work. All this is just the current situation we are not even sure how long these lockdowns will last. But as economy shrinks it will effect every industry.
- eirini1 7y agoI think its funny that you mention 9/11 as an example there because most people I know would agree that the whole world completely changed after 9/11 (and I'm not even American myself). Both on a cultural and social level, there is no event before the COVID-19 outbreak that changed the world more. You are correct - in a world where production was organized on a rational level, to serve certain needs or desires, the coronavirus outbreak would not have been as big of an issue. However we live in a world where profit and markets regulate production, and these are far from rational. Hence, unless massive changes come to how production is organized, the article has a very good point and you are the one who is looking at matters much too sober I think.
- luckylion 7y ago> Both on a cultural and social level, there is no event before the COVID-19 outbreak that changed the world more. Err, you mean this is worse than the world wars? I have my sincere doubts.
- Barrin92 7y ago>Both on a cultural and social level, there is no event before the COVID-19 outbreak that changed the world more. Let's be serious here for a second. We had the collapse of the Soviet Union, the creation of the internet, the emancipation of women, the civil rights era, The Great Leap Foward etc. Everyone can name two dozen things over the last few decades that changed the world more than this. Currently everyone is behaving like their college aged selves, sitting in their apartment playing Animal Crossing and ordering pizza for a few months. Humanity has endured greater change. I think some people need to turn the news off for a hot second and evaluate if they've gotten a little too soft over the years. Ask people in Africa if the world has changed, a continent with 25% of the world's disease burden and 1% of healthcare spending, this is just background noise over there
- twblalock 7y agoWe've seen economies bounce back from near total destruction of cities (e.g. Japan after WWII, Korea after the Korean War). That was worse than this. Our current situation is bad, but the underlying structure of the economy was fine before the virus hit. That gives us a much better starting point for rebuilding the economy than we had after previous disasters or recessions.
- generalpass 7y ago> Good grief that's a dramatic article. The economic decline may be stark but that's what happens when you effectively freeze economic activity. I'm not really sure why exactly things are never supposed to be the same given that people still have their training, factories are still around and those can be reopened once sufficient safety is guaranteed. > There's disruption in supply chains and business formation and whatnot, but I think it would be better to think about the economy in terms of actual resources and human capital rather than stock market figures, the former isn't vanishing into thin air. > There's this tendency to dramatically overrate the impact of contemporary events. People said the same thing after 9/11 when it came to other aspects of life, and apart from increased airport security and a few costly wars there indeed was nothing new under the sun. > The CDC estimated that the swine flu in 2009 may have killed up to half a million people globally. We'll see what the death toll of this is at the end but this isn't humanity's first pandemic and it isn't its worst, not by a significant margin. The issue is not the available resources, but the government activities. The government initiated the crash, they are sustaining and making the crash deeper, the length of the crash will be based on their actions, and the recovery will be based on what they decide. In previous recent events, people were free to operate their businesses largely the same as before the crash.