9 ms·
One of the things I find amazing about France is that out of all the energy they produce about 17% if from recycled nuclear[0]. Not 17% of the total nuclear pow
by godelski 7y ago
One of the things I find amazing about France is that out of all the energy they produce about 17% if from recycled nuclear[0]. Not 17% of the total nuclear power is from recycled, 17% of TOTAL power is from recycled nuclear. That's pretty neat!
And with regards to greenhouse gasses, hard to argue with this [1].
That being said, I don't mind the the reduction to 50% by 2035. Renewables are a good thing. I think there's this argument happening that is renewables vs nuclear which isn't healthy. Nuclear's competitor is coal and natural gas which serve as base loads (nuclear does also have the ability to do variable loads like these. For some reason people think it can't...). If slack can be picked up by renewables and that lessens the requirement for nuclear, that's a good thing. As long as this reduction doesn't involve building coal or natural gas plants in place of nuclear, I'm all in support of it (i.e. nuclear is being replaced purely by renewables). Though I would be happier if the plan was to explicitly discontinue their coal and gas plants first.
[0] https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-profiles/countries-a-f/france.aspx https://www.world-nuclear.org/information-library/country-pr...
[1] https://www.electricitymap.org/?countryCode=FR&page=country https://www.electricitymap.org/?countryCode=FR&page=country
- kaibee 7y ago> (nuclear does also have the ability to do variable loads like these. For some reason people think it can't...) Nuclear power is too expensive to leave idle capacity on standby.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoNot sure why you were downvoted, but this is correct. Outages are super expensive for a nuclear power plant, and plants take days to start and stop. Not only that, but capital costs are so large, you need to run it as much as possible to have any hope of just keeping up with interest payments. People think waste is the biggest problem with nuclear, but I think it is huge capital costs and lack of flexibility are even larger problems (not to mention insurance for accidents, but only the government can provide that). Coupling nuclear with some kind of large scale battery would work to even out load requirements, but the only thing that might work is pumped storage, which would require a huge reservoir at a decent elevation, not to mention being pretty inefficient.
- pfdietz 7y agoAnd if you have renewable sources that are much cheaper per kWh of output than nuclear, why charge those batteries with nuclear?
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoTrue except nuclear is basically a renewable itself given that we have enough fuel in reserve for 70k years or so. If we could get the capital and operating (including waste storage) costs down, it would basically be free energy. Barring achieving that, it is a problem that we should keep working on, it would be a pity to see nuclear plant development completely stopped (well, unless someone figures out profitable fusion).
- rbg246 7y agoI read there was 200years of nuclear (https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-global-uranium-deposits-last/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-glo...) but I can't find a source for your figures? Could you point me in the right direction?
- adrianN 7y agoFor a long-term nuclear strategy you need breeder reactors which extract nearly 100 times more energy from the same fuel (and at the same time help a lot with the nuclear waste problem), or a way of getting Uranium out of sea water.
- rbg246 7y agoThank you I learnt something
- p_l 7y agoThe 200 years number is for the most inefficient (and producing most radioactive waste) types of reactors, but those reactors are also the only ones USA wants you to have, so...
- Accujack 7y agoOld design nuclear plants are too expensive. Newer ones much less so.
- nickik 7y ago> (nuclear does also have the ability to do variable loads like these. For some reason people think it can't...). While nuclear certainty can adopt to grid demand quite well, if you have a good reactor. However it leads to bad utilization of your plant. For that reason, many of the next generation nuclear companies are designing their system to produce hot solar salt, like a Concentrated Solar Power Plant would. Moltex Energy for example, hopes to deploy a 1GW reactor that heats up solar salt (ie heat battery), and then us that to drive 3 CCGT (Combined Cycle Gas Turbines) that are mass produced for coal and gas plants to produce 3GW of electricity when prices are high. This is a major improvement over traditional PWR have much less heat and have to use insanely expensive bespoke steam turbines (that are also insanely huge). This is a good idea not just because it you can sell when prices are high and sell a lot, but also the nuclear island would only make a much smaller part of your total project cost, thus reducing the overall cost risk.
- 7952 7y agoMoltex looks really interesting. Although does it have a significant financial advantage over using renewable electricity to heat the salt? Because naively a grid connected molten salt battery would be more useful than one that is coupled to a nuclear reactor.
- a9h74j 7y agoI am glad to see a reference to Moltex Energy. They[1] IMHO have far too little name recognition and mindshare in threads like these. Burn uranium, thorium, or existing waste. Walk-away safe. Uses existing materials. Projected cost competitive with coal. [1] moltexenergy.com
- nickik 7y agoIts by far my favorite design of all advanced reactors designs out there. Their solution for dealing with the 'pumping' problem is brilliant and their idea to make the liquid salt reducing is an incredibly neat way to avoid corrosion issues.
- rakoo 7y ago> I think there's this argument happening that is renewables vs nuclear which isn't healthy. Nuclear's competitor is coal and natural gas which serve as base loads Well in France the goal of reducing the nuclear share is to increase the intermittent share (Solar and Wind), so it's definitely a Nuclear vs Intermittent Intermittent sources need a stable source to produce electricity when they can't and they also need changes in a network that is not built for withstanding a production this variable. The end result is that intermittent ends up being more expensive and, because it needs gas, to supplement it, emits more CO2 per kWh. France is the last country where intermittent sources should be propped up (if propped up at all) > Though I would be happier if the plan was to explicitly discontinue their coal and gas plants first. Coal is pretty much nonexistent in France, however gas can never go away because even though nuclear plants have amazing flexibility, it's still not as flexible as gas, which is used for very high very sudden demands. Unfortunately there aren't many ways to do this particular job (hydro still isn't as flexible) There's no good ecological, economical or safety-related reason to reduce nuclear to 50%, especially if it is intended to be replaced by Solar and Wind
- pfdietz 7y agoNo, intermittent sources need an affordably dispatchable source to produce when they can't. A steady, fixed cost source like nuclear, that must be producing most of the time to minimize the cost of its output, is unsuitable for acting as a backup to intermittent sources.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoThat's assuming you're using the steady source to cover for the intermittent source when it isn't generating. If you're using the steady source to replace the intermittent source entirely (as France had been doing) then it is producing most of the time and you don't have that problem. This is probably the largest impediment to a 100% renewable grid. You might be able to get over the solar day-night thing with batteries if you had to because you can justify a lot of batteries if they're getting used every night, but the thing where sometimes it's cloudy for a straight month is a serious issue.
- cycomanic 7y agoWhat is good about recycling nuclear? I believe the whole "recycling" in nuclear was a similar ploy like for recycling plastic, in other words mainly greenwashing. The other reason for it being military. Nuclear recycling is a uneconomical, multiplies (by a significant factor) the amount of waste. Admittedly, less radioactive, but still as toxic and importantly much longer lifetimes, so still needs to be stored for insane length of time.
- p_l 7y agoRecycling of nuclear fuel, outside of helping remove the waste problem, greatly increases your energy reserves. However, it got essentially scuttled in the name of war as control over access to nuclear technology, even for purely peaceful uses became the dominant doctrine.
- pfdietz 7y agoNo, it was scuttled because it made no economic sense. In the US, Carter's executive order was lifted a few years later by Reagan, but no civilian reprocessing occurred. Separated plutonium has negative value -- it adds more cost to fuel element manufacture than it saves in enriched uranium cost.
- catalogia 7y ago> What is good about recycling nuclear? Less mining.