4 ms·
If it's any comfort, the death rate is so high with ventilators (80%+, which is bad even for ventilators) that some doctors are trying to avoid using them, if p
by DoreenMichele 7y ago
If it's any comfort, the death rate is so high with ventilators (80%+, which is bad even for ventilators) that some doctors are trying to avoid using them, if possible, because they are concerned the ventilators are actually killing people.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22819580 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22819580
I previously suggested that ventilators were problematic and I wasn't happy with the rush to create more of them instead of promoting less invasive treatments. I'm glad some doctors are looking for alternatives, but we really need to be a lot more aggressive about that angle.
- est31 7y agoInteresting points, thank you. I previously mostly had the death rate for "ordinary" ICU admissions in mind, which were 50%. Didn't know that once you are you are connected a ventilator, you have a 80% death rate. To compare the effect of ventilators vs none, one needs good studies with randomized groups where one gets ventilators and the other doesn't. But I guess those aren't available and doing them is probably not possible due to moral issues. I wonder if there are statistics that are the next best thing, death rate of people who doctors would have wanted to connect to ventilators but there were none available. You shouldn't compare it to the death rate of people with ventilators in places where there is ventilator shortage because then obviously there is some element of choice in who gets the ventilator and who doesn't, e.g. they choose the patients with the worst symptoms, or the patients with the largest chances of survival. Most places probably have/had shortages, so the data we have are all pretty bad to judge whether ventilators help, and if yes how much.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI have a really serious lung condition. I used to use mechanical intervention to treat my condition. I have found other methods and no longer do that, in part because such interventions are hard to keep adequately sterile and are known to increase risk of antibiotic resistant infections because of that element. It's really not good to think of this problem space in terms of finding some group without ventilators at all. I get your point about the data, but the problem is that lungs are a critical system. If you have lung issues, you are a priority admit at an ER because that whole not breathing thing can kill within minutes. Inability to breathe is one of the quicker ways to die. What I was previously suggesting was non invasive airway clearance methods and management techniques like being mindful of better positions to sleep in (which is apparently at least part of what some doctors are now doing according to the article I linked above). I got hounded and attacked as "practicing medicine without a license" for talking about my first-hand experience with managing my very deadly condition using such techniques. You really can't just not treat patients experiencing lung distress and hope they live. That's a good way to kill people. But I have looked at a little info on ARDS (the process that actually kills people with Coronavirus) and how ventilators work and I'm quite horrified that the world rushed to create more ventilators rather than rushing to say "We must do everything possible to intervene effectively without ventilators. Ventilators must be an absolute last ditch effort after every other possible intervention has been exhausted." They aren't doing that. They are too quick to put people on ventilators and the fact that doctors are now coming up with non invasive alternatives tells you they haven't been sufficiently aggressive in exhausting all other treatment modalities first. I have substantial first-hand experience with staying alive in the face of having routine lung distress that could kill me. I knew from the outset that they were putting people on ventilators too quickly, that ventilators are quite dangerous in their own right and that there are, in fact, other options available. I'm quite frustrated by the whole thing. This absolutely never needed to be this ugly. I'm certainly not the only person on the planet who knew ahead of time that ventilators are problematic and that there are myriad other options available that can be tried first, especially before it gets that severe in hopes of not letting it get to that point.
- Santosh83 7y agoOutcome of reductionist thinking that is plaguing the world, thanks to its great success by and large, but the downside is wholistic approaches have been contemptuously tossed in the trash.
- cycomanic 7y agoThe thing is generally for lung treatment doctors follow a path of escalation, start with less invasive methods like oxygen and progress to ventilators. With covid 19 there have been several reports from doctors that skipping this and putting the patient directly on ventilators directly significantly improves survival. Doesn't that contradict what you are suggesting.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoSource? I cited my source, above. What you're saying is news to me. Without a source, I can only reply based on general life experience that most doctors are lazy and quick to prescribe drugs and surgery (or similar intervention -- in this case, ventilators) in place of trying to insist on educating patients and taking more low tech, often labor-intensive approaches instead. I have seen all the handouts saying if you have allergies and respiratory problems, your first line of defense should be things like having wood floors at home instead of carpeting. Not once has a doctor ever sat me down and had a meaty discussion with me about my decor choices or similar. It's always been, at best, "Which drug is your favorite?"
- Kliment 7y agoThe Chinese recommendations document ( Handbook of COVID-19 Prevention and Treatment available from https://covid-19.alibabacloud.com/ https://covid-19.alibabacloud.com/ ) suggests oxygen early on, and not keeping patients on noninvasive ventilation for long before moving on to invasive, or skipping noninvasive altogether (intubating earlier rather than later) gives better outcomes. I suspect this is what the parent post is referencing. However, this applies to hospitalized patients in intensive care. High flow oxygen is the best way to prevent them from reaching that stage. What you're talking about is a much earlier stage of treatment, in order to prevent the need for hospitalization. Once a patient has reached the invasive ventilation stage their chances of recovery have already dropped massively, but at that stage the outcomes with invasive ventilation are significantly better than without. That said, all the emergency hospitals with capacities in the thousands being built are designed to get as many patients as possible on oxygen early on, as this definitely prevents many deaths. Their ventilator patient capacity is significantly lower - the bulk of them (as used in China, Spain, Italy) are just endless rows of beds and oxygen plumbing, to relieve the ICUs and isolation wards from people who just need oxygen and isolation and allow them to be used to only treat critical patients.
- microcolonel 7y agoI think stating it as "ventilators are killing people" is wrong. It's an intervention because these people don't have enough oxygen in their blood, the intervention helps them put oxygen in their blood. It's all well and good to look at alternatives as you put it in your last sentence, but the way you put it at the outset sounds like you think ventilation is worse than nothing on the whole, which is probably not true, even if for some patients it is premature and makes things worse.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoThat isn't what I said. You misquoted me and I posted my source. To reiterate: Some doctors are concerned the ventilators are actually killing people. They are concerned because the death rate is shockingly high for ventilator usage, much higher than is typical with ventilators. The evidence is mounting that use of ventilators should probably be an absolute last ditch treatment option for people with Coronavirus and that other treatment modalities should be used first. Some of these are as simple as recommending different sleep positions to ease lung distress, something I talked about previously. It's not news at all that some positions are harder on the lungs than others. It's been medical practice for decades to put people on inclined surfaces when they have pneumonia to reduce the amount of lung surface being submerged in fluid. It has a known track record for improving survival and it's non invasive and doesn't require fancy equipment or training, etc etc. Though it lacks the geegaw "ooh, shiny!" appeal of people cooking up open source ventilator projects, so no one is all excited to talk about such simple and readily available interventions that any idiot can do, even from home, even without a formal diagnosis or doctor's prescription. Edit: My source doesn't baldly state, as I did, that doctors are concerned that ventilators are killing people. It more delicately states that ventilators may be harming certain patients and then cites the crazy high death rate as evidence of this possibility. I stand by my more bald framing of the issue. I'm aware it's not PC, but there comes a point past which efforts to be PC do a disservice to the truth.
- Santosh83 7y agoIt's not PC. It's the typical frightened backlash from those who have invested their lot with reductionist logic and simply cannot face any other approach to problems. You find this quite commonly in the field for which this forum exists, hence the outraged responses to you.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoAs far as I know mechanical ventilation is the last resort. It's all about the oxygen saturation. If that is too low, patients usually get oxygen first, and of course all the other issues need to be treated, if necessary. If SpO% is still too low, they try the ventilator. My point is: There is a very good reason patients go on a ventilator. They don't get enough oxygen. When they are on the ventilator, they DO have enough oxygen. And you really need that oxygen to survive and recuperate... So not putting them on a ventilator is sort of contra-indicated.
- nradov 7y agoYes that's likely correct based on what physicians are seeing in the field. Check out the latest care protocol from Eastern Virginia Medical School. https://www.evms.edu/covid-19/medical_information_resources/#d.en.140202 https://www.evms.edu/covid-19/medical_information_resources/...