5 ms·
It's a somewhat noble sentiment, but an absolutely terrible idea in practice. Letting large businesses (airlines etc.) go bankrupt isn't just a disaster for th
by crazygringo 7y ago
It's a somewhat noble sentiment, but an absolutely terrible idea in practice.
Letting large businesses (airlines etc.) go bankrupt isn't just a disaster for the rich -- it's a disaster for retirees who hold a majority of savings in equities (index funds etc.), as they've been told is the responsible thing to do.
Don't throw the baby out with the bathwater -- or grandma out with the billionaires.
We want to reduce inequality? Great. But do it in a targeted way, through taxation that takes into account people's income and overall wealth. Not in a blunt-instrument way that harms middle-class savers along with hedge funds.
And not through letting a host of major corporations go bankrupt through zero fault of their management/board.
(Remember, it's not like an airline can buy insurance against a months-long pandemic, nor are public companies supposed to retain unnecessary cash in times of profit -- the IRS virtually requires them to distribute it to shareholders either through dividends or buybacks.)
EDIT (in response to comments): OK, I exaggerated a little -- retirees shouldn't be holding a majority of savings in stock. But since one common rule of thumb is to hold a percentage in equities that is 100 minus your age, a 70-year-old still has 30% in equities. And your 50-year-old saving up for retirement has half. The main point still stands: normal middle-class folks hold equities as a significant part of their savings. It's not just billionaires who own equities.
- throwaway6734 7y agoNo retiree should hold a majority of their savings in equities
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- asdfasgasdgasdg 7y agoAll depends on your spending flexibility, time horizon, etc. If you can comfortably drop to half of your steady state spending for a couple of years, or if you do something like a CD ladder, it can make sense to have >50% of your retirement assets in stock.
- lordnacho 7y agoAren't retirees told that the sensible thing to do is to have a lot of bonds and relatively few equities? Also why hold your savings concentrated in a single company, even if you worked for it years ago?
- paxys 7y ago> as they've been told is the responsible thing to do. This is absolutely NOT the responsible thing to do. Every retirement fund, target date fund etc. constantly rebalances your portfolio so that as you get closer to retirement your holdings shift to bonds and other low-risk securities. Retirees should be holding little to no stock.
- sorum 7y agoThis. Very much this. If you (as someone nearing retirement) have your funds on auto-pilot, they'd have the right allocation.
- jhayward 7y ago> it's a disaster for retirees who hold a majority of savings in equities This is somewhat of a red herring, often used to deflect from the fact that the top 1% of the wealthy own about 50% of all equities, and the top 10% own about 80%. The top 20% own more than 90%. We can do things to address people's retirement savings without giving trillions of dollars to the richest people in the world.
- crazygringo 7y agoIt doesn't matter what percentage is owned by the rich, if middle-class folks will still suffer. My point is: keep companies healthy, but reduce inequality directly by taxing the rich. Attack the problem where it is, not by proxies. Punishing companies or all their owners indisciminately is a terrible idea.
- jhayward 7y agoIt does matter. We can easily repair retirement programs without enriching the rentier class. If we don’t allow the funds and enterprises to go bankrupt we are damaging capitalism and just running socialism for the rich. We have to allow these enterprises to fail and have their equity be wiped out to have a functioning capitalist economy. Again, fixing the lower 80% of America’s retirement programs directly, without bailing out enterprises they hold capital in, would be far cheaper than giving trillions to millionaires.
- crazygringo 7y ago> We have to allow these enterprises to fail and have their equity be wiped out to have a functioning capitalist economy. That is utterly absurd. COVID-19 isn't the fault of an airline or hotel company. There is zero reason these enterprises need to fail, any more than your local restaurant ought to go out of business and be replaced by another in a few months. And people's savings for retirement aren't part of any "program". They're spread over all sorts of investments. Trying to let corporations go bankrupt yet somehow "make up the different" in a fair way to individuals would be convoluted and frankly impossible. So no. Punishing corporations is the wrong target. Corporations aren't rich people. Keep the corporations going together with the corner restaurant... and tax the rich. Seeing COVID-19 as some kind of solution to economic inequality is dangerous confusion, and frankly bizarre. You want to lessen inequality? Bankrupting companies is one of the absolute dumbest ways to do it. Just tax the rich directly. Institute a wealth tax. It's simple, targeted, effective, and doesn't have the horrible side effects that bankrupting major corporations has.
- Ericson2314 7y agoYes to all the points below about bonds at stuff, but let's get to the deeper point. When push comes to shove in a crazy post Covid-19 world, we can care for them without financial gimmicks. You might have saved up abstract papers and computer database entries your entire career, but what you consume is physical goods made recent to your consuming them. We can ration out those goods to retirees (or bump up social security).
- cryptica 7y agoGrandma should have thought twice before investing in an evil corporation which took loans to evade taxes and screwed over other people's grandchildren.
- mtnGoat 7y ago>> And not through letting a host of major corporations go bankrupt through zero fault of their management/board. I cant not wrap my head around this. How is it NOT their fault? If you are the one at the wheel, you are in charge, thus you are fault. They could have been planing for a rainy day instead of spending the capital, its entirely their fault! I keep 6 months wages in a savings account because its smart... Corporations can do the same, and many do. The ones that refused, should be left to dry and are entirely at fault.
- crazygringo 7y agoNo corporations do not and should not. If your profits are 5% then for a year-long "rainy day" you'd need to make profit for 20 years and keep it in the bank without ever returning it to investors. That's ludicrous. Look up the "Accumulated Earnings Tax". The IRS essentially requires companies to return their profits to their shareholders each year and not save it, or else face a tax penalty. In the case of something unforeseeable like a global pandemic, both corporations and individuals need to be helped out alike. Companies large or small shouldn't go bankrupt because of something so unforeseeable, and neither should individuals.
- mtnGoat 7y agoi mean you could just pay the tax penalty? and how do some companies get away with stockpiling billions? Apple, Berkshire, as examples.