7 ms·
Motorola Xoom a huge disappointment
- TomOfTTB 16y agoMore than the iPad 2 I think the price cut on the iPad 1 Hurts the xoom. Because while the specs might be better on the Xoom you can't deny that the cheapest iPad is now half the price of the cheapest xoom. I think we're now to the point where other hardware manufactures have to decide whether they want to cede this market to Apple. If they don't they're going to have to take some short-term losses to keep up. That means cutting the hardware price to the point where you're not making a profit but where your prices are at least competitive with Apple. If they aren't willing to do that their only strategy is to wait and hope Apple slips up.
- wriq 16y ago"That means cutting the hardware price to the point where you're not making a profit but where your prices are at least competitive with Apple." Microsoft has the funds to take a loss for a while (like the 360) and push Windows/Xbox Live Marketplace in place of the App Store. Since I doubt they'll release hardware on their own, I could see them subsidizing hardware partners when they try to enter the market.
- ugh 16y agoThe problem for Microsoft is that when they do that the third generation of iPads and the second generation of Android tablets will probably already be shipping or shipping soon. It at least doesn’t look like there will be a tablet with a Microsoft OS in the first half of 2011 and I’m highly doubtful that there will be one in the second half — early 2012 seems more realistic. Microsoft has demonstrated that it can deliver a very competitive touch OS with Windows Phone 7 but it’s at this point still doubtful whether Windows phones will capture any meaningful slice of the smartphone market. A tablet OS from Microsoft would be similarly late to the game.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoYou might have said the same thing about the Altair or, ironically, the Apple II a few decades ago. This is still early days in the market, nobody has a lock on it. How old was the mobile MP3 player industry when Apple introduced the iPod? the iPad is a good device, for now. But it's not the end-all-be-all of tablets, it's just generation 1.5. In 5 years the iPad2 will look as limited and outdated as a flip-phone does today. Apple will need to continue innovating in order to maintain the advantage they have right now. They may very well do so, but it's silly to imagine that this horse race is won, it's only just started.
- ekanes 16y agoYour second sentence disputes your first. > This is still early days in the market, nobody has a lock on it. How old was the mobile MP3 player industry when Apple introduced the iPod? And now that there is an iPod, how many credible challengers have we seen? None, really. So Apple is able to lock down a market. The question is whether or not the competition is catching up or falling farther behind. Android is a great platform in principle, but the high price of hardware may be a barrier to entry for mainstream buyers.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoYou make the mistake of thinking that the iPad is the iPod of tablet computers. While MP3 players require only a minimal featureset this is not the case for tablet computers, there is still a lot of room left and a lot of market left. Apple could lock down this market, but the market has not even fully developed yet so it's silly to imagine that they have done so yet. See also: the mobile smart phone market.
- farlington 16y agoThe portable media player industry was a still a relatively small market when Apple introduced the iPod, and the iPod itself was in its third iteration or so before it really became a runaway hit. It's not the early days of the tablet market at all. Tablets have been around for a very long time—Microsoft, Archos, et al—it's a much older market than the portable media player was when the iPod was introduced. There just hadn't been any hit tablet products until the iPad. We're still in the early days of the iPad-style tablet market, true. But the key advantage for Android in the mobile phone market is/was carrier lock-in, and that's not a factor with the iPad. They have to compete on product and price. And Apple is extremely competitive in both those areas. It's also worth mentioning that, in this market anyway, Apple has a major advantage in its excellent retail channel.
- 6ren 16y agoThe only attack is to disrupt it. i.e.: 1. A crappier product (in terms of what iPad customers value); which targets non-iPad consumers; and that is better in other ways (that iPad customers don't value). e.g. kindle; or can run any apps; or any language is allowed; or is open; or is completely customizable; etc etc etc. 2. Over time, it gets better (read: slightly less crappy). 3. If it becomes good enough for iPad customers and also retains those other features which the iPad lacks, they will switch. The big questions are: "Is there a limit to how good this crappy product can become?"; "Will it ever become good enough for the iPad customers?"; and "Is it somehow difficult/impossible for the iPad to suddenly acquire those other features?" NB: it doesn't need to become better than, or even as good as the future iPad - just good enough. Microprocessors, screens, memory etc usually become faster, cheaper, use less energy. So, competitors will get better in these respects. In terms of user experience, they will also get better (even Windows improved). It might take a while. People think of the iPad itself as a disruptor (which it is); but it can be disrupted in turn. Unfortunately, the competitors are presently confronting it head-on... and they will lose, because the iPad is an incredibly great product in every respect that matters to its customers.
- smackfu 16y agoIs the iPad 1 price cut ongoing, or just until March 11th?
- allwein 16y agoOngoing until inventory is depleted. They aren't continuing to produce the iPad 1 at the lower price point.
- vladok 16y agoI genuinely wonder why companies can't get this right. I know Apple is good at what they do, but if you can't play in this game, why bother? I understand, on one hand, if you're making a budget knock off at 2/3rd the price. Then the lack of polish is forgivable from a business standpoint - the price is your biggest mover. But if you're competing with the iPad for top of the line why even bother? Why bother overpromising on battery, when the first reviews will prove that false. How does a corporation even assume they will have any success in the market with this type of strategy?
- johnthedebs 16y agoI think they know that a lot of people will buy something based on specs alone. Many people will look at the numbers and believe they're getting something great, without realizing that the experience will be pretty lousy. I'm certain the Android tablets will get better quickly, as the phones seem to be, but it obviously just isn't there yet. At this point it seems like Motorola wanted to capitalize on all the uninformed consumers, and those who don't want to buy an Apple product.
- r00fus 16y ago> I think they know that a lot of people will buy something based on specs alone. Really? I don't know anyone besides geeks and neo-philiacs (ie, folks like me) that behave that way. Most folks (ie, the mass-market) treat tech like they'd treat appliances or cars or other stuff they don't fully understand. They ask folks who do know, visit review sites, and play with what's on the showroom floors. When there is a large contingent of these that infer that the iPad is the best, the mass market buys it (as sales numbers show).
- rimantas 16y agoWell, there is a funny and sad at the same time case: cameras. My impression is that for a large portion of population the only thing that matters is megapixels.
- deleted 16y ago
- nlogn 16y agoRather short and lacking in details for a "review" isn't this? Anandtech and Engadget have already reviewed the Xoom in more detail and I have to say, this reads very much like someone wanting to validate their own opinion instead of offering a fair critique. I have observed the iPhone 3gs/3g (I have little experience with the 4) lagging significantly when many apps are installed (not just running, but merely installed) so UI lag is not something unique to Android. The power button placement and heavy weight seem to be, admittedly, poor decisions. As far as battery life goes, this review is very inconsistent with Anandtech's review which states that the Xoom's battery life is comparable with the iPad[1]. Not sure what exactly he is complaining about wrt widgets; I have several widgets working well on my phone and I'm sure they're fully compatible with Honeycomb. It is a shame that neither Flash or the micro-sd card slot are functional at release. I can only hope Motorola is working to remedy both of those issues. [1] http://www.anandtech.com/show/4191/motorola-xoom-review-first-honeycomb-tablet-arrives/14 http://www.anandtech.com/show/4191/motorola-xoom-review-firs...
- kylec 16y agoI agree 100% on the power button placement. I stopped by the Verizon store today to try it out and it literally took me several minutes to figure out how to turn it on. Of course, once you know where it is isn't not an issue, but it's not the best first impression. I imagine most people will fumble around the sides for a few seconds before they just give up and move on to the iPad.
- mikesaraf 16y agoThe argument about 16 available apps is shoddy at best. The release SDK for Honeycomb has only been out for about a week; It's being compared to a platform that has been around for over a year now. The only iPad apps that were available when it launched were by the few lucky companies that got pre-release access to its SDK. In 3 months the number of available honeycomb apps will be a different story and in 6 months it will be a non-issue.
- shaggyfrog 16y agoThere were way more than 16 iPad apps available at launch, and the ones that were available were also top-notch quality (especially the Apple Pages/Numbers/Keynote suite). 3 months is an eternity in this industry. No one's going to pass on an iPad or iPad 2 in favour of a Xoom on the vague promise of more apps coming in 3 months. You sound like you are lamenting what ought to be, instead of what actually is, today.
- TillE 16y agoYou could've said the same about the G1. It was a piece of crap compared to the competition. Yes, if you're a consumer who really needs a tablet this month, you'd be a fool to buy anything but the iPad 2. But if you're a developer, Android is only just now a viable platform for tablet-sized apps. I don't think the market will explode quite like what's happened with Android phones, but the Motorola Xoom is the first legitimate Android tablet. There will be many more. I don't see any compelling reason to buy a Xoom unless you're an enthusiastic developer or tinkerer. Personally, I'm happy to continue using my first-gen iPad until the iPad 3 comes along. But if you're talking about the Android platform rather than this one device right now, of course the future matters.
- ryannielsen 16y agoShoddy at best? iPad 2 ships on the 11th, with an enormous portfolio of apps. Do you think that's worth nothing? I'm betting the average consumer cares about four things: - How the product feels in the store. (Is it solid and how responsive is it?) - What they can do with it. (What apps can I run?) - Who's recommending the product. (What does the NYT say? What do my friends say?) - Price. (Can I afford this?) On which of those things does Xoom beat iPad or iPad 2? Who will walk into a store and see the Xoom next to an iPad or iPad 2 and say: I'm gonna buy the Xoom, even though it costs more, doesn't run the apps my friends are talking about, and isn't recommended by anyone I know! Hell, I'll go out on a limb and just guess, since I've held neither a Xoom or iPad 2, that the iPad 2 feels better in my hands. Past performance being a future predictor, I bet Apple nailed that experience. So, given that, is the argument that there's only 16 apps shoddy? By your post, it's an argument that there's no unique content for Honeycomb for the next 6 months – that there's no unique content vs. iPad or iPad 2 for the next 6 months. And don't forget that those 6 months are not a vacuum of development for either Apple or 3rd party devs. Apple's likely to announce a new iOS release, and there will be tens of thousands of new, unique apps posted to the iOS App Store. I think that's a pretty solid argument against Xoom, especially since Xoom loses on every other factor (I think consumers care about) right off the bat.
- btipling 16y agoUltimately everyone who wants a tablet will have to make a private decision of what they want for themselves. I have both an iPad (well I got it for my three year old daughter) and a Galaxy Tab and I have to say I love them both and they both have been life changing. If you get a Xoom, I doubt you'll be disappointed, because going from not having a tablet to getting one is going to be an amazing experience. I don't imagine the Xoom is being marketed to people who already have an iPad so there you go. Get an iPad for the many (wonderful) apps and media or get an android tablet because despite the many flaws in Android, it is a kick ass operating system and because you can actually purchase kindle, nook and epub titles directly from the e-reader apps. Listen to all the pundits and reviews, and then make a thoughtful decision and be happy with the one you made. Steve Jobs and John Gruber might not see it this way, but despite that there is some truth in the 'copy cat' nature of Android, it is a good thing that iOS has competition. It's not just lackluster competition either, Android is awesome. Nuff' said.
- tuhin 16y agoI seriously think that Android is the best thing to happen to iOS. Despite the design flaws, fragmentation, issues and every other bug, Android is the nearest thing to a competitor that iOS has. Yes, I am aware there is something called Windows Mobile 7. The very fragmentation and ubiquity of Android is its strength. While for US, I do not know how the economics work, but for a country like India, not everyone can or would afford to buy a phone for Rs. 30,000 (~USD 666.7). What Android is great at is tapping THAT market who are looking for a better than average experience with mobile. I mean if every one was going for the premium buyer who would make good experiences for the not so affluent. I have an iPhone, an MBP and will now be spending on the iPad 2. But then I look around and feel so happy that my friends, my juniors from college can afford a decent enough phone without sacrificing on the joys of modern technology and design in mobile OS.
- maguay 16y agoWhat does the average unlocked Android device cost there? In Thailand, most Android phones are still USD $400+. Oddly enough, last-gen Blackberry devices are the most popular smartphones (semi-smartphone) here since they're often USD $150-$200 unlocked. The HTC tattoo is cheaper, as are a couple others, but for the most part, Android is nearly as premium as iOS here.
- joe_the_user 16y agoI lamely predicted the iPad's failure when it first came out. But now the same factors make me imagine the iPad might stay the top selling longer than the iPhone. Tablets are an awkward, difficult form. They have lots of ergonomic and UI problems. But if Apple has somewhat solved these problems, duplicating its solutions could turn out to be harder than throwing features and hardware at the problem. A too-heavy tablet is a much worse problem than a too-heavy laptop or even a too-heavy phone. And similarly for all the other trade-offs. UI problems
- jrockway 16y agoI'm surprised that a self-proclaimed "XML Aficionado" would complain about something being too heavy.
- SeanDav 16y agoTo argue about the price/features of the Xoom vs iPad is to miss the point (in my opinion). The point is: Do you want to drink the Apple Kool-Aid or have similar functionality but much more freedom with Andriod. Personally I just won't buy Apple, no matter how much I recognize how good Apple are. I just do not want to be locked into 1 company.
- flyosity 16y agoI imagine your feelings run deep enough re: vendor lock-in that you certainly don't own a PS3, Xbox 360 or Wii, right? If you really don't want to be tied to one vendor and you're not also thinking about the biggest "locked-in" platforms on the planet then you're being hypocritical.
- SeanDav 16y agoActually I am pleased to admit I do not own a PS3, Xbox 360 or Wii. I play all my games on my PC. Although possibly I am being a bit hypocritical in that I generally use Windows.
- dagw 16y agoThe difference, at least for me is that games and gaming isn't really that important, it's a fun indulgence and not much more. If I can't play a certain game or use a certain controller on my PS3, then, so what. If on the other hand my productivity is hampered by the fact that I can't open a specific document, do a particular task or connect a particular peripheral to something I hope to use as a general purpose computing then that is a real problem. So it's not so much vendor lock-in as such, as vendor lock in that adversely affects me and gets in my way.
- orangecat 16y agoConsoles aren't attempting to replace general purpose PCs, while Apple has made it clear that they expect and want the majority of users to be using an iOS-like platform in the future. Having personal computing devices switch from open by default to closed by default would be a substantial change for the worse.
- ekidd 16y agoScoble keeps making the "only 16 apps" claim, but it's absolutely false. To be fair, there are currently 16 featured tablet apps in the Market. But if you search for "HD", "THD" or "Tablet", you'll find a great many more, including a Hacker News reader that I'm currently working on. :-) What's my take on the Xoom, as an owner and developer? - The weight and size don't bother me at all, but I've got big hands. I can hold it for hours when reading. The power button, however, is definitely weird. - Honeycomb and the Google apps are just amazing. I love the application switcher, the notification system, the tabbed browser, the Google Calendar client, the large, interactive widgets, etc. - There is a shortage of good tablet apps. To be fair, this will be true of any two-week-old tablet platform that tries to compete with the iPad. If we want a two-player tablet market, somebody's got to go through the "no apps" stage. - The lack of Flash and Netflix is painful, because it means there's very little video content to consume on the Xoom. And the Xoom would be a killer device for watching video. Flash will be fixed Real Soon Now, and Netflix is making very vague noises. All in all, I love my Xoom, and I enjoy writing software for it. I think that once Flash arrives, and more apps become available, that the inevitable 87 Android tablets launched in 2011 will stand a decent chance at making up some ground against the iPad. And this would be a good thing; even for iPad owners—Apple needs credible competition. And the Xoom is definitely a more credible device than the Android 1.5 phones ever were.
- swilliams 16y agoHow are you supposed to know to search for "HD", etc? What makes the iOS store easy is that there are completely separate tabs for iPhone and iPad apps. And when you do search, it displays results for both in separate boxes on the results screen. These things make it incredibly easy to find iPad specific apps. If the android market does these things, that's awesome, I legitimately don't know.
- sp332 16y agoThe Motorola Droid has slightly more pixels than other Android phones. This led to a bunch of apps coming out in a "Droid" edition which put those extra pixels to good use. The new tablets have 1280 x 800, 1024 x 768, 1024 x 600 etc. resolutions, so should each one have its own tab?
- briancooley 16y agoI don't understand why anyone would call the XOOM heavy in comparison to the iPad. The comparisons I have seen list them both at 730g. I have them both, and I would say that the XOOM is more comfortable to hold. The two big factors are the texture of the back and the fact that I so often hold them in portrait mode. The widescreen form factor of the XOOM makes it easier to handle in portrait mode.