12 ms·
Landlord service Naborly makes blacklist of tenants who missed 4/1 rent (YC '18)
- reaperducer 7y ago"The more data we have on what happens over the next few days is going to really accelerate our ability to retrain our AI systems and then help all of you accurately understand tenant risk moving forward into this new world" AI seems to be like Javascript. It can be used for good, or it can be used for evil. And for some reason the evil uses are always out in front. We need to fix people so they don't think this sort of thing is OK.
- r00fus 7y ago> It can be used for good, or it can be used for evil. It is used to make money. Evil seems to pay better these days. You don't fix people, you fix incentives. This requires regulation to prohibit bad behavior and reward for good behaviors.
- falcolas 7y agoEvil will always pay better, until everyone is equally evil. There's an essay titled "Meditations on Moloch" which covers this topic quite well (including how you can't sufficiently fix incentives).
- jwbwater 7y agoInteresting read, but I didn't see anything constituting a proof that it is impossible to fix incentives.
- crististm 7y agoPeople have ethics. Technology does not.
- pmiller2 7y agoWhat ethics allow someone to think creating a "blacklist" of people who were unable to pay rent during the largest public health crisis in a century is a good idea? Five seconds of thought tells you this is just a way to target the most vulnerable among us.
- throwaway2048 7y agoWhich is exactly the goal, every landlord would rather have ridiculously rich tenants, and most wouldn't give a single shit about what happened to the people who weren't.
- pmiller2 7y agoOf course, but rich people are on to that scam already. I would wager that most of those who can afford to own a home do, simply because they don't want a landlord as a liability.
- mandelbrotwurst 7y agoYou'd lose that wager. There are many reasons why someone who could pay for a home would choose not to - e.g. maybe they do not plan to their in their current geographical area for a long enough period of time for it to be worthwhile, the cost of renting vs. owning in their area is low, they do not want to be responsible for maintenance, etc. Edit: I now realize you said "most". You would not lose the wager.
- pmiller2 7y agoWhere is the data set on this?
- threatofrain 7y agoWhat is creditworthiness if not a proxy for the same thing anyway?
- 7y ago
- save_ferris 7y agoThat's just not realistic, kinda like saying that we need to fix people to not commit murder. We'll never be able to stop bad behavior, but we can dis-incentivize it by illegalizing it.
- avs733 7y agoIf nothing else this seems like the type of data that you just don't want to collect. The PR and potential risks of what happens next massively outweigh any sort of value I could see this having given the situation around COVID. Just because you can doesn't mean you should
- reaperducer 7y agoIt also seems like exactly the sort of information that the credit agencies would collect and offer for sale. As we have seen with their data breaches, they have no shame, and operating in a black box under the shield of "trade secrets" lets them do any slimy thing they want. PR might bring down a small company like Naborly, but Experian and the others are bulletproof.
- downshun 7y agoPosibly off-topic but I read these often here > (these companies) have no shame Companies have no morals. People have morals. Thus reframing 'BigCorp is bad' trope.
- reaperducer 7y agoI think you're just splitting hairs. It's much easier, common, and not incorrect to say, "Company A does bad things" rather than "An important subset of the people at the head of Company A have enacted policies that caused bad things to happen."
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- avs733 7y agoThey are shameless...but the big players also seem smart enough to do these things passively and quietly. If I put on my 'if I where an investor' hat...any CEO who would post a YouTube video basically asking for this data seems right now seems like so tone deaf action that I wouldn't want them making strategic decisions because they are so short term focused.
- jakelazaroff 7y agoIs this even legal? Can someone who knows about Canada's tenant protection laws chime in?
- zormino 7y agoI don't know very much and can't speak to it's legality, but I do know Canada (at least Ontario) has very strong tenant protections, and the law tends to land on the side of the tenants instead of the landlords. I wouldn't be surprised if this was either illegal or if tenants could take the landlord to court if they though they were passed over because of this.
- robert_foss 7y agoMy experience of Ontario tenant laws were very much the opposite. If you want to have a terrible housing situation, moving to Toronto is a good bet.
- monkeywork 7y agoThe LTB [1] in Ontario is heavily leaned towards the tenant and currently is blocking all evictions in the city regardless of payment of rent. >COVID-19 Notice: Until further notice, the LTB is suspending the issuance of eviction orders and all hearings related to eviction applications — unless the matter relates to an urgent issue such as an illegal act or serious impairment of safety. 1. http://www.sjto.gov.on.ca/ltb/ http://www.sjto.gov.on.ca/ltb/
- jlokier 7y agoWhat stops them issuing a no-fault eviction notice as soon as the COVID-19 notice is relaxed, because on their preference for a more creditworthy tenant?
- monkeywork 7y agoall evictions require approval by the LTB ... Landlords are fine to file an eviction but it has to be approved and while no official policy has come out yet it's incredibly reasonable to expect that there will be provisions put in place to keep people from just being insta-evicted once the state of emergency is over. that said those that can pay their rent SHOULD BE, because I imagine one of the critera for having the LTB rule in your favour is showing you were in a hardship at the time.
- jimbob45 7y ago> Housing lawyer Benjamin Ries, with the University of Toronto's Downtown Legal Services, said his organization has sent a letter to Naborly seeking clarification of the company's intentions, because it seems like it's building an illegal "blacklist. Is such a blacklist actually illegal or did they mistype “immoral”?
- Mikeb85 7y agoIt violates privacy laws so it's illegal. And like the article also says, credit rating agencies need to be registered through the government and consumers need to give their consent for a credit check.
- bob1029 7y agoI am not so sure. Do you have to give consent for a bank to submit a charge-off report to the various credit bureaus in case of negative balance or other delinquency? This sounds like the initial data collection which is a massive grey area IMO. The use of that data to make an approve/decline decision is where the regulations start to take effect.
- Mikeb85 7y ago> I am not so sure. Do you have to give consent for a bank to submit a charge-off report to the various credit bureaus in case of negative balance or other delinquency? No, but you need to give permission for anyone to run a credit check on you. Literally no one can legally see that info without you giving them permission to do so. Whereas anyone can sign up for this service and see info about you. Edit - also, banks won't give you a bad score as long as you keep paying the minimum on all your credit products. And in my experience, their willingness to give you a mortgage or extend credit has more to do with your income and assets than a credit score.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 7y ago
- mmhsieh 7y agothis is like a creepier version of Don't Date Him Girl.
- duxup 7y ago>"Please note that we keep reporting fully confidential and DO NOT notify your tenant that you have reported to our system." Brutal. They know how it looks, they just don't care to be seen being that guy.
- aaomidi 7y agoAnd people wonder why Mao has recently gained in popularity. There's a maximum you can push people until it springs back into your face.
- pmiller2 7y agoSince you mentioned Mao, I'm going to glom on here with this: what service does a landlord offer beyond four walls, a floor, and a ceiling, that's worth hundreds or thousands of dollars a month? They deal with maintenance issues, sure; occasionally, they can help mediate disputes between neighbors. But, beyond that, what justifies them getting paid simply for owning more of a thing (housing) than they can personally use? It seems like the perfect set of incentives to create hoarding and abuse, which is exactly what we see in the real world.
- kyboren 7y agoThey offer the service of providing limited-term accommodation with no assumption of liability for regular, small payments. Contrast this to owning a house/condo, where the owner has an indefinite right to the property, but assumes liability (e.g. mortgage debt, property taxes) and/or plunks down a very large amount of cash all at once. > what justifies them getting paid simply for owning more of a thing (housing) than they can personally use? ... Because they own it, and let others use it for a fee. Let me just ask straight up: Do you believe that private property should not exist?
- pmiller2 7y ago>Let me just ask straight up: Do you believe that private property should not exist? Absolutely, that would be an ideal. However, don't make the mistake of conflating private property and personal property. A primary residence would be personal property, as would a car, etc. As for the other "services" you mention, if the housing market weren't distorted by people thinking housing needs to be an inflating asset, most of those problems could solve themselves in a market scenario.
- 7y ago
- Hippocrates 7y agoI've been thinking about this a lot lately, starting with the public outcry from Airbnb hosts who have had their bookings cancelled. And then, Cheesecake Factory announced it would not pay April 1 rent on any of its locations. The economic fallout of this situation is something we will all bear the brunt of. Landlords are not shielded from it. I'm not saying everyone should stop paying rent, but the fact of the matter is, if people and businesses are not making money for months on end, many of them will have no choice but to stop paying. It is unconscionable that someone thought to turn this into a blacklist which many of the unlucky millions who have recently lost their jobs will end up on.
- monkeywork 7y agoblacklist is bad yes I agree because it doesn't take situation in mind and current situation may not indicate anything about the renter in the future. Landlords are in a slightly different boat than say the restaurant down the street. The restaurant isn't forced to provide services to anyone if they aren't getting paid, most places right now have basically blocked evictions (which is a good thing) and forcing landlords to keep people in place regardless if they get paid or not. Many are turning this into a protest against rent and even if they have the means to pay are organizing rent strikes ... this is going to bite people in the butt this summer / fall when we are out of this mess. My not so informed opinion is that once states of emergency are lifted if you didn't pay your rent your landlord can take you to the arbitration board in your area ... if you can prove you were out of work then you get X months to pay back your back rent (where X maybe equals 2x the number of months you missed rent) and if you can't prove you were out of work you have 30 days to pay your back rent or your out.
- qqssccfftt 7y agoMaybe the landlords should get a job?
- monkeywork 7y agomost have jobs.. not sure what your comment is implying. Do you believe landlords should offer their property and services for free?
- tengbretson 7y agoThis doesn't sound all that different from a regular credit rating. As it relates to the financial troubles people are going through right now, while failing to pay April 1 rent is a data point, I think the uniqueness of the situation we're in will prove it not to be a particularly useful data point for landlords going forward. Any landlord that overweights that in their decision-making around who to rent to is probably doing so to their own longterm detriment.
- anonymousab 7y agoWhen there's a glut of people looking to rent, a seemingly endless supply, landlords can afford a lot of false negative rejections. This means that trying to single out the people who were able to pay during this epidemic - by simply filtering out anyone who didn't - can be a 'winning' strategy. Or at worst, a non losing one.
- Mikeb85 7y agoAnd thanks to the economic situation and Airbnb apocalypse there's a glut of apartments to rent in Toronto now.
- lmilcin 7y agoThe difference is financial companies are well regulated and keep the information securely. Oh crap... Equifax... nevermind.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 7y agoIn California, all mortgage companies have said they will not notify credit report agencies during this time. That makes this another example of protection for landowners with renters on their own, causing additional friction in the upward movement of poor and lower-middle class of America.
- mcguire 7y agoWhat?
- TrackerFF 7y agoI mean, they can create these lists all they want - but in the end, it's gonna be all noise. We're living in extraordinary times, and records like these do not work for their intended purpose: Singling out renters with history / patterns of delinquency. In fact - If anything, landlords should buckle up and brace for the worst. Trying to get someone evicted right now isn't going to do sh!t. You'll spend MONTHS on the process, with probably no good replacement. No, the best thing to do right now is to contact your tenants and bank(if they own your unit), and work out a plan that works for all parties. You're both deep in it, and there are no good ways out for the next 3-4 months, only the least terrible. And I absolutely understand the frustration of fresh landlords that are mortgaged to their necks with their (maybe) only rental, but that's unfortunately how life is. Good times and bad times.
- zentiggr 7y agoNot going to be noise for prospective tenants who are denied based on a missed payment, reported without context or mitigation. As usual, this is good news for the business end of the database+AI, screw you end of the stick for consumers who have no access to examine, dispute, or have deleted anything the company has collected. Transparency again. And again. Companies need to be forced to disclose the column names in their DBs and justify publicly why they are keeping each piece of data.
- beckingz 7y agoI agree with the sentiment, but the obfuscation of database column names that this would cause would be catastrophic for those of us who work with databases.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoIt's not good news for landlords if they can't find tenants because they've all been blacklisted even though many would have been good tenants absent the current crisis. Landlords who have monthly carrying costs but no tenants will quickly get hit in the wallet. In the end, unless there is an overabundance of renters, the landlords are going to have to look past this event and look at data from before the pandemic.
- anonymousab 7y agoThis seems like it would naturally be one data point and risk calculation service in an eventual/inevitable social credit system. Publicly trying to create that specific aspect in isolation seems to be a big misstep, though they'd probably have a better chance with it legally in the US than Canada.
- throwawaymanbot 7y agoFilth. Just when you cant think some of them sink any lower.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whymauri 7y agoSad to see this from a YCombinator company.
- ahelwer 7y agoWould be useful to edit the title to note it is a YC company, as is convention.
- Apocryphon 7y agoDone. Had to tweak title for character limit.
- mabbo 7y ago> "The more data we have on what happens over the next few days is going to really accelerate our ability to retrain our AI systems and then help all of you accurately understand tenant risk moving forward into this new world," This is actually dumb in terms of ML, and really dumb in terms of discrimination. Given someone missed rent April 1st 2020, what does that tell you going forward about their future? Does it imply they're likely to miss rent again someday? Far less than the same data point any other time before. So it's not useful that way. So why get these data points about people? Perhaps what it does imply is that they may have poor health? Or a disability? Or that they don't have a university degree? Or (data still coming as to this relationship) that they are more likely to be a specific race? I feel that what these folks are really doing is trying to have their model learn to predict "won't pay rent" based on a data point that implies all the things they're not allowed to train their model to predict with due to obvious discrimination laws. Edit 5 minutes later: It could be innocent stupidity too. Hanlon's razor is important.
- T-hawk 7y agoThere's value in the converse of that data point, though, right? If someone made rent on April 1st (and maybe even more importantly May 1st), that might be an even stronger signal that they'll continue to do so without interruption.
- thaumasiotes 7y agoDepends on how common each is. It's a signal that puts people in the top or bottom X% of renters. If knowing someone is in the bottom 90% of renters isn't that useful, then knowing someone else is in the top 10% is, yes. If the threshold is closer to the median, then both sides are closer in usefulness to each other. I'd be pretty surprised if making rent in April was really at the 90th percentile, though.
- phkahler 7y agoThe big differentiator is going to white collar jobs. There will be others, but it doesnt take an AI to figure out who is at risk.
- ekoontz 7y agoDid any of these legal (not to mention ethical) questions come up when they applied for YC?
- quotemstr 7y agoHrm. Wasn't everyone saying a few years ago that "freedom to do X isn't freedom from consequences for doing X"? How is this situation any different? If you don't pay your rent, that's fine. Plenty of jurisdictions have suspended rent payments. But that you didn't pay your rent is a true fact. You either did or you didn't. It's part of history. It's a feature of objective reality. You can't stop people from remembering true facts and talking about them. You don't make a better world by suppressing information.
- bdowling 7y ago> Plenty of jurisdictions have suspended rent payments. Many jurisdictions where I am have suspended evictions for non-payment of rent, but not the rent payments themselves. Tenants are still liable for the rent and may be liable for additional interest. In the U.S., it would probably be unconstitutional for a government to just take away all the rents from landlords.
- jedberg 7y agoThe big problem here is that it will be hidden. If I get a tenant applying this fall, and I see on their credit report a "missed April rent" mark, I'm going to ignore it for obvious reasons. But if I get their report, it will just say "high risk" but won't tell me why, and I'll have no way of knowing it was because of missing rent in April.
- Ididntdothis 7y agoI think it would be a good rule that whenever somebody requests a report about a person that information needs to be available to the person too. Whenever somebody gets a credit report about, you get a copy. Same for background reports, credit reports and stuff like this.
- Loughla 7y agoAnd this is what people talk about when they mention the dangers of blindly trusting technology. It bakes in inequality, and no one is to blame, because it's such a complicated piece of software/hardware/code/whatever you want to blame.
- FriendlyNormie 7y agoHow is a screening service like this that fabricates a summary instead of impartially presenting all the raw data they have not in violation of libel laws?
- swiley 7y agoI’m reasonably sure this is illegal in the US (in Virginia at least.) You’re required to process rental applications in the order you receive them and can only reject them for certain reasons (failing a credit check for example.) Unless a credit company starts using this it means very little here.
- daun 7y agoIf you know anyone in California who might be affected by this company please let them know to file a complaint against Naborly. They apparently have no idea what the laws here are, and they are also most likely in violation of numerous other United States credit reporting laws. Edit: Their Privacy Policy says nothing about California, and it looks like they're most likely already in violation of California's CCPA. Edit 2: Can't find them registered anywhere in the US as a credit reporting agency. I guess YC is now funding companies flagrantly violating US law.
- kylek 7y agoCan you recommend a pitchfork store?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bobongo 7y agoSame with DC
- Gibbon1 7y agoIf I remember landlords tried this in California 30 years ago and the state just up and made it illegal.
- lidHanteyk 7y agoNaborly are in Ontario; they are, it sounds, flagrantly violating Canadian law. A former privacy commissioner is quoted as saying that they would investigate Naborly over these allegations. For examples of flagrantly violating US law amongst YC's prides and joy [0], consider examining DoorDash [1] or Airbnb [2]. [0] https://www.ycombinator.com/topcompanies/ https://www.ycombinator.com/topcompanies/ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DoorDash#Criticism_and_lawsuits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DoorDash#Criticism_and_lawsuit... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbnb#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbnb#Controversies
- rexpop 7y agoAnd when no government agency will honor these complaints? What, then?
- Farfromthehood 7y agoI'm a Naborly user (landlord) in the USA. Naborly emailed repeatedly asking for this information (I refused). Interestingly, they asked about my tenants' payment on April 1st, not even taking into account grace periods or such. Also, I never signed up to receive their emails, and I've expressly asked them to stop emailing me.
- SrslyJosh 7y agoThank you for not participating. Have you considered dropping them entirely?
- devindotcom 7y agoI'm interested in checking this out myself, if you're comfortable sharing those communications would you contact me, devin at techcrunch dot com? I'd just like to see how the company approached this.
- JdeBP 7y agoThere's (apparently) one posted in this very discussion at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22807064 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22807064 , notice.
- FpUser 7y agoI am curious at what point all those private corporations with their never ending data gathering, scoring, etc will accomplish that exact thing done by China. China profiles their citizens, assigns them social score and the ones that do not get enough points get their rights diminished. We seem to have a lot of black lists that affect our lives. And those lists multiply and grow bigger by the day. But of course as long as we being screwed by corporations rather than the government it is all kosher.
- pfortuny 7y agoSo... is data good or is it not? I mean, I am sure each and every bank, renter, landlord, whatever has a list including those people who did not pay on April 1. Otherwise it would be against everybody’s interests. What is the problem here? Intent? Ah, then the burden of the proof is greater.
- OniBait 7y agoThere's actually a TON of regulatory compliance involved with tenant screening like this in the US. Pretty sure that they run afoul of a few provisions in the FCRA. That they claim to "keep reporting fully confidential and DO NOT notify your tenant that you have reported to our system." seems really fishy to me. If a landlord makes an adverse decision based on information in their system, the person being screened has a legal right to view that information and dispute it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Analemma_ 7y agoIt's becoming increasingly obvious that we're assembling our own copy of China's social credit system, except it's privately-owned (and apparently YC-funded). I don't see that as an improvement in any way.
- unloco 7y agoUnless you can request and dispute your data, it's absolutely illegal. I'm sure they are reaming out a loophole, but the bottom line is; A company cannot secretly gather data used for financial decisions and just not tell you about it.
- andyjsong 7y agoResults of the survey if anyone is interested: https://naborly.com/blog/covid-19 https://naborly.com/blog/covid-19 And the email that was sent after the initial request for data: >I would appreciate a moment of your time to clarify my team’s efforts to make a positive impact amidst the COVID-19 crisis. Yesterday, I wrote an email asking landlords to provide information on April rent payments. This information was intended to allow Naborly to better support landlords and tenants and promote a mutual understanding of the severe impact the economic shutdown is having on the rental industry. Upon reflection, I recognize that the email was poorly worded and did not provide sufficient context. I am deeply sorry if it suggested that Naborly or myself were trying to do anything other than help. Our goal at Naborly is to provide a tenant screening tool that is free from bias, and we are firm believers that housing is a human right. For tenants, we aim to remove traditional barriers to housing such as level of income, student or immigration status, or prior evictions. For landlords, we provide a screening tool that captures a tenant’s entire ability to pay rent, beyond factors such as credit history. As part of that goal, we have always had a reporting tool that allows landlords to provide feedback, both positive and negative, on their tenants. In light of the COVID-19 crisis, this information is more important than ever. We serve over 800,000 rental units and their owners and are in a unique position to compile information on the hardships facing tenants and landlords alike. Having accurate information allows us to adapt our screening tools to ensure tenants are not unfairly viewed as intentionally delinquent on their rent obligations. Last week, we were grateful to have received survey responses from more than 5000 tenants and 700 landlords on the difficulties the COVID-19 pandemic has created for them, and were able to use that information to promote a constructive dialogue between tenants and landlords. You can read the results of our survey here. Naborly is and will always be committed to unbiased accuracy, fairness, and equality in our risk assessment. The notion that we are trying to hurt tenants in this time of crisis is against everything we believe in as a team. I am deeply sorry that the way I expressed myself did not reflect who we are as a company and what we are trying to accomplish. It was not my intention. Our support lines are open to all landlords and tenants to assist in navigating the government programs available to them and to answer any other questions they may have. Sincerely, Dylan Lenz Founder & CEO Naborly Inc.
- bmm6o 7y ago
- roflchoppa 7y ago@samatlman check your boys out.
- peter_d_sherman 7y agoApparently Naborly is like Yelp, but about tenants, for landlords... But that must mean there's something else like Yelp, but about landlords, for tenants...
- ahelwer 7y agoYelp itself is roughly like this actually, a few large apartment buildings are on there. One of the places I used to live offered us a Starbucks gift card if we wrote a positive review.
- ThrowAway1Day 7y agoThis seems to be a common thread amongst YC startups. Uber, AirBNB, Instacart, DoorDash, etc. Why do many YC companies act in such sociopathic manners? Cash Rules Everything Around Me. I'm throwing a party when these guys go to jail.