8 ms·
always wish i could be a fly on the wall for these kinds of negotiations. if O'Connor demanded something ridiculous like 10 billion dollars... how do you talk
by swyx 7y ago
always wish i could be a fly on the wall for these kinds of negotiations.
if O'Connor demanded something ridiculous like 10 billion dollars... how do you talk him down when the situation is this onesided?
- GoodRxEngineer 7y agoTypically some sort of horrible "accident" would befall them
- gj667cc 7y agoCheck out the February article linked in the body of this article about when it went up for sale. It provides a little more context. Sounds like Mr. O'Connor was pretty reasonable about it. https://krebsonsecurity.com/2020/02/dangerous-domain-corp-com-goes-up-for-sale/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2020/02/dangerous-domain-corp-co...
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThis is the relevant part: "O’Connor said Microsoft actually offered to buy the domain several years back for $20,000. He turned them down, saying that at the time he thought it was too low and didn’t reflect the market value of the domain."
- lonelappde 7y agoWe need Georgian land value tax for domain names.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoI can't even imagine how an appraisal system would work. How do you even do price discovery? Ask people how much they'd spend on it without actually having to put their money where their mouth is? Land is nothing but objective and quantifiable qualities like its distance from the city, natural resources, size, fertility. Domain names are arbitrary. If people want to swap $millions for vanity, I say let them.
- jedberg 7y agoPrice discovery is easy. Every domain is available once a year. Anyone can bid. If you want to keep the domain, you pay 1% of the highest bid, otherwise the bidder gets it (they have to put in the money to secure the bid). The only downside is that well capitalized bidders could harass small owners with outsized bids, if they were willing to possibly end up with ownership.
- zeulhex 7y agoAgree, but economists do have a solution for this problem. Self-assess the value and pay taxes based on that value. If someone/the government makes an offer that is some percentage greater than that value, you must sell.
- ZainRiz 7y agoSounds like a solution only an econ could think up of, which doesn't take into consideration other external factors that would apply specifically to the person holding the property, such as: - human psychology (loss aversion, endowment effect, mental anxiety due to risk of being forced to sell your property) - switching costs (monetary, mental, time spent searching for alternatives, costs to moving to something else) - replacement costs (transaction costs, etc)
- robterrin 7y agoLogged in just to upvote your comment. An actual land value tax would be even better!
- LeonM 7y agoI believe it was not a negotiation, but an auction. So all MS had to do was outbid the highest bid, which would not have been 10 billion.
- caymanjim 7y ago> On Monday evening, he wrote to say that Microsoft had agreed to purchase it. O’Connor said he could not discuss the terms of the deal, nor could he offer further comment beyond acknowledging the sale of corp.com to Microsoft. Not an auction. There's no indication the owner did anything beyond mentioning the desire to auction it.
- jawns 7y agoIt's not one-sided. There is an incentive on both sides to come to a reasonable agreement. It's not like O'Connor can do anything (legally) with the sensitive data that's hitting his domain. If he could, I could understand why he might be reluctant to sell, even if given a strong offer. But the fact is, if Microsoft walks away from the negotiations, he gets nothing, and there are likely few other buyers he could ethically sell to, and those buyers are unlikely to offer as much as Microsoft can.
- narag 7y agoIt's not like O'Connor can do anything (legally) with the sensitive data that's hitting his domain. He could have sold the domain to someone not concerned with the "legally" part.
- shawnz 7y agoBut they would be under the same constraints as him. And it would be easy to see if they tried anything (are those ports accepting connections or not?) at which point it would have been quickly seized. Plus, wouldn't knowingly selling it to a bad actor be a violation of his due diligence?
- newswasboring 7y ago> And it would be easy to see if they tried anything (are those ports accepting connections or not?) at which point it would have been quickly seized. They can't seize a domain because you were running some service on it, can they?
- angus-prune 7y agoThey frequently seize domain names used for malware or controlling botnets. Just one example: https://www.cyberscoop.com/vpnfilter-botnet-fbi-seizure-apt-28-fancy-bear/ https://www.cyberscoop.com/vpnfilter-botnet-fbi-seizure-apt-...
- swarnie_ 7y agoI imagine homeland security can step in at some point if he was being totally unresonable.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]