6 ms·
Spain is moving to permanently establish universal basic income
- s9w 7y agoNadia Calviño.. I read that name recently. Oh wait > "Europe must respond united to the crisis," Nadia Calvino said in an interview with radio station Onda Cero. "I don't give up. We still think that, eventually, there must be a system of debt sharing, be they eurobonds, coronabonds or reconstruction bonds." https://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2020/04/01/world/europe/01reuters-health-coronavirus-spain-debt.html https://www.nytimes.com/reuters/2020/04/01/world/europe/01re...
- ohmaigad 7y agoHaving a shared debt but not shared fiscal policies across the board. What could go wrong.
- iso1631 7y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22795358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22795358 (57 comments, 20 hours ago) I think the general view is "some ministers in Spain would like to implement UBI" How that works, especially with freedom of movement from the rest of the EU, is anyones guess
- fastball 7y agoPresumably it would be citizens rather than residents.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI'm not sure that would be legal, would it? I think there was a test case in 2015 that said you could have tests that a resident was not there just to claim benefit, but I think the point was that it was illegal to just completely restrict a benefit to your own citizens.
- skywal_l 7y agoIt would probably be modeled the same way as social benefits are modeled. A mixed of citizenship and residency...
- slightwinder 7y ago> How that works, especially with freedom of movement from the rest of the EU, is anyones guess This was already answered. Germany has a welfare-system which is basically a restrictec UBI, and there were non-german eu-citizen demanding access to it and went as high as the European Court of Justice. Result: they have no right to claim social welfare outside their own country. Freedom of movement in EU has limits and you must behave like a proper local citizen (like working there for some time) to get access to other countries systems. And even then benefits are time limited.
- rufusroflpunch 7y agoIsn’t one of the central selling point of UBI that it would replace the existing welfare state with one single payment? What’s the likelihood that countries that implement this just tack it on the existing welfare state as yet another payment? I’m putting that is almost a certainty.
- ginko 7y ago> I’m putting that is almost a certainty. Why? States aren't made of infinite money.
- kaffeemitsahne 7y agoActually...
- lordnacho 7y agoWe're about to test whether they are. If we somehow manage to print all this money and nothing bad happens, then why not? I have some doubts about whether it can work, but if it does, we should think about the new economic reality. At the moment though, I get the image of Wily E Coyote running over the cliff edge, but he hasn't looked down yet.
- HideousKojima 7y ago>We're about to test whether they are. If we somehow manage to print all this money and nothing bad happens, then why not? Fortunately, other states already have tried this, and shown that it causes immense economic harm. Specifically, we have the examples of Venezuela (53,798,500% inflation since 2016), Zimbabwe (peaked at 79,600,000,000% per month), and Weimar Germany (merely 29,500% per month at its peak). So you should be asking, what if we manage to print all this money and something truly terrible, horrible, and damaging to the lives of everyone in the country happens? And what if it's something easily predicted by almost any economist and with massive historical precedents? And what if it sets the stage for genocidal dictators and the most violent war in history, as it did in the case of Weimar Germany?
- fsflover 7y agoComment from the other discussion: bwb 1 day ago I am in Spain and Bloomberg is just translating the comments of a far left party that has no ability to do that. Bad reporting. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22792359 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22792359
- pfortuny 7y agoThanks for clarifying this. I also live in Spain and daydreaming is too good to begin describing this “move”.
- p2detar 7y agoWith EU’s declining population growth, UBI may very well be the way out of impossible retirement plans in the future. Something that IMO millennials in the EU will face sooner or later. I don’t claim to know all the economic implications of UBI, but I’m really convinced that as an EU citizen and millennial my retirement is questionable to say the least.
- leto_ii 7y ago> I’m really convinced that as an EU citizen and millennial my retirement is questionable to say the least. Hear, hear! :D I share your condition and concerns.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoUS citizen here. Can y'all go into detail? If you have universal healthcare, and you've paid off a residence, what shortfall and outsized expenses do you project in retirement?
- mercer 7y agoI'm also interested to hear more, but FWIW as an EU-resident and millennial with a bunch of millennial and lots of 'zoomer' friends: 1) out of everyone I know, working- to middle-class, only three people 'own' a house. One of them inherited it from their father, and the other recently bought one with a mortgage and has an unusually stable job. Of the rest of us/them, I'd say a good 70% live in a flatshare (regardless of whether they're in their twenties of thirties), 20% live in a small apartment with their partner, and the remaining 10% or so have some kind of studio apartment because they make decent money or because their student organization provided them with cheap housing. 2) with the exception of those who have jobs where a pension is built up automatically, none have bothered. Which is probably about 80% of them (100+ people). And in conversation the general assumption is that any kind of pension will probably not exist by the time we need them, so why bother (not saying I agree, btw). That said, I'd say my social network skews toward working class and educated-but-not-STEM. And urban, which favors the precariat.
- 7y ago
- HideousKojima 7y agoEvery single UBI proposal I've seen has failed to work even with back of the envelope math, even when using generous assumptions and estimates. They end up either 1) Gutting existing entitlements by a huge amount (and current receipients of those entitlements get far less under UBI than they did before) 2) Raise taxes by an obscene amount that destroys most if not all of the benefit of a UBI for the middle class and most of the lower class (and that's before you get into potential economic effects) 3) Provides such a paltry amount that it fails to support the basic needs of the average person/family 4) Depend on massive amounts of money printing and/or debt well in excess of most nations' current debts, or 5) Some combination of the above. People vastly overestimate how much money the wealthy have even if we taxed them at 100% and somehow prevented them and their wealth from fleeing to some tax haven somewhere.
- dangus 7y agoWhich proposals don’t work? What math are you speaking of? Do you have any data to back up your claim? I only mean to push back on this because your comment seems to be dismissive of the entire concept while seeming to closely align with the interests of the kinds of people who don’t want it (the wealthy). I find the idea of just not bothering to tax wealth because they’ll just find a tax haven elsewhere to be defeatist nonsense. It’s not hard to craft legislation that forces the wealthy to pay. If we are overestimating how much wealth the wealthy possess, how is it that three people own more wealth than over half of the entire United States? https://www.cnbc.com/2017/11/09/gates-bezos-buffett-have-more-wealth-than-half-the-us-combined.html https://www.cnbc.com/2017/11/09/gates-bezos-buffett-have-mor... Excess wealth needs to be taxed because being excessively wealthy is bad for society as a whole, just like we tax alcohol and cigarettes.
- HideousKojima 7y agoShow me a proposal for the US (since I'm most familiar with tax rates, existing benefits, etc. there) and I'll show you how the math doesn't add up. Edit: As far as the three wealthiest in the US owning that much, it still amounts to very little per capita if redistributed to the entire population. You could give every individual in the US a one-time payment of about $3,000, after which there'd be no more money to take from them. The top 1% only have about $25 trillion in combined wealth, which would be enough to fund a UBI of ~$3,000 a month for two years, after which you'd run out of money. And that's pretending that a massive looting of the holdings of the nation's wealthiest wouldn't have any significant economic side effects (and that they wouldn't all just flee to tax havens). And that's ignoring that a good chunk of that wealth is not held in liquid assets.
- nogabebop23 7y agoSo a universal basic income that: "mostly aimed at families, but differentiating between their circumstances." Sounds really universal. How is this not typical income redistribution where someone picks the winners and losers?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- symgryph 7y agoThat is About $330 billion. Spains GDP is about 1.2 trillion. That’s most of their GDP just going out to basic income. I wonder who’s gonna pay for it
- tgafpc2 7y agoUntil they run out of money and realize the EU is too broke to bail them out.