5 ms·
The US stands alone in consumer arbitration. In most countries consumer arbitration is either heavily regulated, or non binding. In EU pre-dispute binding co
by nabla9 7y ago
The US stands alone in consumer arbitration.
In most countries consumer arbitration is either heavily regulated, or non binding. In EU pre-dispute binding consumer arbitration clauses are considered unfair terms.
American Exceptionalism in Consumer Arbitration
https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2265556 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2265556
- marcus_holmes 7y agoThanks for this. I'm curious: I live in Germany. Is YC/HN's arbitration clause enforceable against me? Can I take them to court in Germany?
- tjpnz 7y agoNot a lawyer but I suspect it would depend on the country. As an example there are clauses written into ToS which don't allow refunds on digital purchases. These work fine in the US but are illegal in countries with stronger consumer protections like Australia. US companies do still have to obey local laws - at least when it comes to the sale of faulty goods.
- KarlKemp 7y agoIt’s complicated... I would suspect (not a lawyer) that the main issue will be jurisdiction. As a consumer in the EU, jurisdiction in matters with commercial entities is the consumer’s place of residence. But HN/YC isn’t in the EU, and I don’t think there are any legal agreements b/w the EU and USA that are relevant here. Free trade agreements tend to include such issues, but TTIP’s well-known fate means this is left to the parties to specify in any contract. Then, there’s a difference b/w HN and YC. HN’s relationship to users is that of a commercial entity to consumers. But YC investing in your startup isn’t. Consumer protections would not apply even if YC were in the EU. To summarize: yes, the arbitration clause, at least of YC, would apply to the same extend as if you were a US citizen.
- wsy 7y agoAlso not a lawyer. To be covered by Germany's consumer protection law, you need show that you are end consumer of a commercial product or service. I don't see how that would apply to YC/HN. If you could pull that part off, I think you could take YC to court in Germany, and even achieve a favorable judgement. However, I don't see any way how you could enforce the outcome, except if YC has assets in Germany.
- pmiller2 7y agoI am not a lawyer, but I highly doubt it, if all you've done is create an account. There is no mention of the arbitration clause in the account signup, so you literally can't agree to it during the signup.
- alexfromapex 7y agoThe US government should’ve stepped in a long time ago and made arbitration optional for essential services. If I’m opposed to entering an arbitration agreement, what recourse do I have?
- pauljurczak 7y agoThe US government had stepped in a long time ago and sided with big business as it almost always does. Abandon any hope that they will make a significant move against so called "free market".
- jpambrun 7y agoIn Canada we had the Douez v. Facebook supreme court case that, from my understanding, made forum selection clauses in consumer contracts unenforceable.
- matheusmoreira 7y agoThe fact arbitration is a standard clause in every contract or terms of service proves it benefits nobody but the business. It's all about making consumers renounce their right to proper legal recourse. Why can corporations make people renounce their rights to begin with? Why even give people rights when every company will put a clause in their contracts that says "oh those are nice but please leave them at the door before doing business with us" ? It makes no sense.
- mindslight 7y agoIt's because the USian view has come to see rights as axiomatic primitives to be layered on top of rather than context-free qualitative assertions. This is regressive due to complexity-induced contradiction, but here we are. It's similar to how with Turing completeness you can implement a low level interpreter on top of a high level language, eschewing the high level language's fancy constructs.
- pyuser583 7y agoWhat the fuck did you just say?
- cryptonector 7y agoWell, anyone can ask you to renounce certain rights, and you can even agree, and courts can (and for certain rights have) rule that you cannot waive those rights. Even if there's a right that is well known you cannot renounced, you can be asked to renounce it, and you can agree to do so, and still not lose the right. Arbitration can't completely remove access to the courts -- it can (and does) make it harder to get there. Case law for this sort of thing is always evolving, and so is statutory law. It's entirely possible for the courts to modify arbitration sufficiently to make the playing field more even.
- pyuser583 7y agoPart of the popularity is herd mentality. I know arbitration lawyers who find it bizarre - many company’s that would be better served by not using arbitration want it anyway.