6 ms·
This sounds like a great system on face value, but it also adds a perverse incentive for insurers to drive up repair costs (and hence their premiums) in order t
by taneq 7y ago
This sounds like a great system on face value, but it also adds a perverse incentive for insurers to drive up repair costs (and hence their premiums) in order to increase their own revenue. I've heard this effect put forward as one reason that the U.S. medical system's prices are so overinflated.
- triceratops 7y agoFortunately (afaik) there are no in/out of network auto mechanics, and the mechanics don't negotiate rates with the companies (again afaik). The barriers to setting up an auto repair shop are also far lower than setting up a hospital.
- sturgill 7y agoAlso there is less concern with an auto “death panel” where cost of repair exceeds replacement value. I can’t imagine Aetna offering you $50k to just die already...
- clarry 7y agoSomeone bumped my rear last year and their insurance company had me take the car to a body shop.. to be re-painted. I don't know what final cost was but I heard an estimate that put it at roughly the value of a new bumper. Of course buying a new bumper and installing it would be a much quicker & simpler job than sanding and painting an old bumper (this is Honda btw, replacement bumpers come pre-painted), but it wouldn't allow the body shop to make as much profit.
- triceratops 7y agoIf the final price of repairing the bumper was the same (or nearly same) as buying and installing a new bumper, why do you say the former has a higher profit margin? Surely it's more profitable to spend fewer hours and earn the same revenue - as they would do by installing a new bumper?
- kd5bjo 7y agoIt’s a matter of parts vs labor cost. For the shop, the labor cost is already sunk: they’re paying their mechanics to be present whether or not they’re actively working on a job. The replacement bumper is an expensive part that requires little labor, and so doesn’t offset the shop’s previous investment in labor contracts as much as the repair work would. Also, mechanics in the US usually charge book time instead of actual work time to customers: you pay for the hours that the manual says the job should take regardless of how fast or slow the mechanic actually is. So, more efficient mechanics prefer labor-heavy jobs because working faster than average effectively brings in a bonus.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>: they’re paying their mechanics to be present whether or not they’re actively working on a job. Usually this is not the case. Google "flat rate pay", it is the norm for automotive shops. As you get into more specialty stuff (commercial truck and heavy equipment repair, pure body and paint work) hourly pay is more common but still not the norm. >Also, mechanics in the US usually charge book time instead of actual work time to customers: you pay for the hours that the manual says the job should take regardless of how fast or slow the mechanic actually is. So, more efficient mechanics prefer labor-heavy jobs because working faster than average effectively brings in a bonus. This is correct but what you're missing is that because of how flat rate pay works the shop rate is XX and the tech gets YY of that so the incentive for both the shop and the tech is to work as fast as possible without doing so bad a job that the customer comes back telling you to fix it. It's also worth pointing out that labor and parts pricing schemes is one of the back end things shops tweak in order to differentiate themselves and/or obtain competitive advantage so that adds a whole 'nother layer of incentives on top of the incentives provided by flat rate pay. Parts markups schemes (if any) vary wildly from shop to shop. Some shops have a couple suppliers and order everything for them. Some shops stack up two weeks of work and have the service writer spend their afternoon ordering stuff through the same eCommerce channels consumers use. Some shops try not to stack up future work, have accounts with all the local parts stores and get stuff delivered same day. Some shops vary the parts markup by part class (e.g. one markup for body parts and a different markup for brake parts). Some shops charge the customer cost and make their money on labor to incentivize customers to splurge for "while you're in there" type repairs (e.g. rotors to go with pads). Some shops proudly discount the labor (lower shop rate) and try to make it up on parts. Labor cost to the shop also varies by tech. The guy who can re spray a bumper is gonna make a higher fraction of the shop labor rate than the guy who can only install a bumper cover. The service writer can also have their pay tied to incentives to sell parts, or maybe a class of parts, or maybe labor, etc. etc. Depending on the specifics of the particular shop slapping on pre-painted bumper covers may very well make the same amount of money as a proper re-spray. There's so much variation it's hard to generalize.
- otuutti 7y agoEven though the new bumper is factory painted it doesn't necessarily mean that the new bumper and old colour will match 1:1 -> they might have to paint the new bumper regardless which is why it might be preferable to just fix the existing one.
- clarry 7y agoIn my experience honda parts do match 1:1 and I don't think they'd waste the effort on maintaining a stock of pre-painted parts if the receiving body shop was going to have to paint it anyway.
- bluGill 7y agoSo Honda has got around uv from the sun fading paint?
- RHSeeger 7y agoNah, they pre-fade them for you. > I'd like a 1995 Civic bumper, dark blue, with UV Fading to match 10 in-garage years and 10 out, but indirect sunlight. Please.
- pixl97 7y agoDepends how old your car is and how much UV damage the current paint has. New cars match in pretty well, older cars generally need some touch up.
- gambiting 7y agoIn fact all the manufacturers I've ever worked with send you an unpainted bumper when you order a new one(or any body panel really) and it has to be painted before being fitted, specifically for the reason you mentioned. A good body shop will match the paint that's actually on your vehicle.
- wsh 7y agoThere are many “in-network” auto body shops, which get referrals from insurance companies in exchange for negotiated rates. The industry’s term for this is Direct Repair Program (DRP).
- triceratops 7y agoTIL. But there's a vibrant and competitive market for auto repairs in general. In-network shops can't be more expensive than out-of-network shops. There's no "certificate of need" system that can block the starting of new auto shops.[1] Auto repair costs are capped at the value of the vehicle. There isn't a stream of indigent customers coming in for emergency repair that have to be subsidized by everyone else. There's far more visibility into risks - insurers have access to your driving history and can refuse to offer coverage based on it. You can volunteer even more information to lower your rates - from credit history, marital status, educational level, all the way up to installing a device on your car's OBD port to monitor your driving habits. In short, auto insurance and repair really isn't anything like healthcare. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_of_need https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Certificate_of_need
- jlebar 7y ago> In-network shops can't be more expensive than out-of-network shops. "My insurance told me to go to X shop, which was 3x as expensive as this other shop and was going to take two weeks to repair my window." -my roommate
- stonogo 7y agoIt is illegal in the United States for the insurance agency to dictate which shop does the repairs.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y agoYep, the only item they can dictate is where the estimate is done.
- 7y ago
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- taneq 7y agoInsurance companies don't dictate 'preferred repairers' where you live?
- triceratops 7y agoI have liability-only insurance, so I really don't know.
- triceratops 7y agoThat's an odd comment to be downvoted over.
- lawnchair_larry 7y agoTheir preferred shops are to be completely disregarded. You should not only disregard them, but also make a point of not using them. If you use their “preferred” shop, you are not the customer, the insurance company is. There’s no benefit to you whatsoever, and they still have to pay regardless.
- reaperducer 7y agoPreferred does not mean mandatory. It is illegal for an insurance company to require you to use their repair shop.
- rickstones 7y agoNo but some (UK insurers at least) write into the policy that you pay a lesser excess if you use one of their preferred garages
- taneq 7y agoYep, same in Australia (at least last time I made an insurance claim, which was something like 15 years ago).
- hunter2_ 7y agoThis isn't the only thing driving that effect. In any situation, a price tag can be higher when those receiving the service don't feel it in the wallet immediately, whether for reasons of insurance or even loans (homes, tuition, etc.) and those facilitating (insurers, lenders) would surely be incentivised to do whatever they can to make using their services the best way to get a fair price. Look at rental car rates where a retail walk-up customer pays double or triple what insurance pays -- for the same exact car.
- taneq 7y agoThis is also true. "Your health insurance benefits for optical have reset, would you like to come in for new glasses?" "Well sure, my current ones are fine if the new pair is gonna be free..."
- ip26 7y agoUnrelated but similar: https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/why-taxpayers-pay-mckinsey-3m-a-year https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/why-taxpayers-pay-mckinse...
- chrischen 7y agoBut the insurance companies still don't get to pocket that money if the costs are increased, how does it incentivize them?
- lasdfas 7y agoIt's normally not a fixed amount. It's generally a percentage above costs. If all costs increase, they increase their revenue. They get the same percentage of a bigger pie.
- freepor 7y agoBasically, if an industry is limited to “cost plus” profits (eg 5% of payouts) their incentive is to drive payouts as high as possible.
- thaumasiotes 7y ago> it also adds a perverse incentive for insurers to drive up repair costs (and hence their premiums) in order to increase their own revenue. Yes, this is the problem with cost-plus pricing in every context.
- taneq 7y agoTotally. I see it in my own industry (minesite automation) - the client wants some parts, we order the parts, add our markup, and bill the client. The more expensive the parts, the more money in my pocket. (I still do the right thing and try to get them the best price, but I can see the temptation.)
- thaumasiotes 7y agoOut of curiosity, if the client knows which parts they want, why aren't they ordering the parts themselves?
- eru 7y agoIt's also an unnecessary system, as healthy competition would drive down premiums anyway.
- Waterluvian 7y agoIt's only unnecessary once there is healthy competition. Which there almost never is.
- eru 7y agoWhat makes you think so? Especially since auto insurance is something you can get online (or via the phone, if you are old fashioned) anywhere in the country from anyone else in the country. Alas lots of regulations that are supposedly in favour of the customer don't really do very much despite good intentions, when there's a lack of competition. For example, British grocery shopping was priding itself on being very competitive (it wasn't), got constantly dinged by their regulator for stupid stuff; but only really woke up once Aldi and Lidl showed up on the scene and gave them a run for their money. Similar with British retail banking. It used to be really awful. For example, they charged you extra fees if you were poor enough that occasionally you didn't have enough money for your standing orders to succeed. (Instead of just failing the standing order, they failed them and charged you.) Their regulator told them off and fined them repeatedly. But without changing anything much. The recent arrival of new challenger banks like Monzo seems to be making a difference, though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 7y agoUnlike healthcare, there is a functional, competitive market for insurance and repair. Most states have dozens of insurers and hundreds or thousands of repair shops. Healthcare is different as it is a series of cartels on multiple layers, and the risk-based aspect of insurance is blunted by the amount of chronic stuff covered. Your auto insurer doesn't cover broken brakes, but your health insurance covers blood pressure pills.
- voicedYoda 7y agoSpot on. I've worked in P&C and life/ health insurance, and really wish states would regulate life/health like they do for P&C.
- pauljurczak 7y agoThere is a semblance of price discovery in auto repair market, which is completely missing in healthcare market. In many (most?) states, it is completely legal for healthcare provider to answer pricing questions with "we don't know".
- ceejayoz 7y agoNot only is it legal, it's probably true! There are like 10 layers of mayhem and negotiation and esoteric rules.
- labcomputer 7y agoThis is partially a result of the way that health insurers in the US (both public and private) pay for procedures. A 15 minute consult with a GP is paid differently depending on whether the outcome of that consult is that you're diagnosed with e.g., strep throat vs. cancer.
- eru 7y agoYes. In Singapore, to give one example, it's the norm to get either a fixed price up-front for your healthcare needs or a good estimate. Prices for common procedures are publicly posted at your doctor's practice.
- 7y ago
- linsomniac 7y agoUnlike healthcare, if I go to a body shop or mechanic, they tell me how much it's going to cost me and even write it down on the work order, before they start working. Because of that, I've never gone to pick up a car from, say, a brake job and been presented with a 4-5 digit unexpected bill because "Our shop assistant wasn't available so we had to pull in the Bugatti specialist next door to help bleed the brakes".
- coredog64 7y agoMany years ago, my wife crashed our truck. The insurance guy took a look, estimated that it wasn’t a total loss, and directed the shop to fix it. Unfortunately, he missed several significant signs of expensive damage. The engine had to be replaced, the frame required more work, etc. etc. At the end of the process, GEICO bought us a very expensive new old truck.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- eru 7y ago> Unlike healthcare, if I go to a body shop or mechanic, they tell me how much it's going to cost me and even write it down on the work order, before they start working. It might be hard to believe, but that's largely how healthcare pricing works in Singapore. Especially for routine treatments and surgeries.