4 ms·
Ah that explains it. Otherwise doesn't a refund go against the whole idea of insurance? The idea is you pay a premium not knowing if you'll need it or not, and
by chrisseaton 7y ago
Ah that explains it.
Otherwise doesn't a refund go against the whole idea of insurance? The idea is you pay a premium not knowing if you'll need it or not, and they take on all the risk if you do need it.
If you ask for your premium back because you didn't need it you're missing the point of insurance.
- ceejayoz 7y agoBrand loyalty is a thing, too, though. "Allstate did me a solid when they didn't have to" is a pretty good PR move, especially if they're suddenly awash in cash due to reduced claims.
- harikb 7y agoIf it was just PR, companies will spend $10 on ads talking about it for every $1 they give away. Give credit to the regulation when it works - next time someone says regulation is bad.. remember this.
- AnthonyMouse 7y agoFor a mutual insurance company, what difference does the regulation make? Whether the customers get the money as a refund check or the mutual insurance dividend or lower premiums next period, they still get it. Even for a for-profit insurer, insurance is a fairly competitive market. They might have to give the customers the money anyway to keep them from defecting to the mutual insurance companies. Even if they didn't, that would make being in the insurance market more profitable, which would attract new competitors, which would drive down premiums/margins until the risk-adjusted return of becoming an insurance carrier was back where it was. In other words, in a competitive market the customer gets the money one way or another. This is a common occurrence with regulation. The regulation requires some good thing that would have happened regardless, the good thing happens and the proponents credit the regulation even though it was inevitable. Meanwhile you have a compliance cost, because it takes resources to keep track of the regulation and make sure you're complying with it even if it was the exact thing you were going to do anyway. That makes everyone poorer -- the compliance cost is the opposite of the windfall, so it makes it less attractive to compete in the insurance market and allows companies to pass on the compliance costs as higher premiums.
- harikb 7y agoYou are making two claims 1. If there is extra profit one year, these companies will willingly reduce premiums instead of giving bonuses, stock buy backs, or dividends to investors. I don’t know if you have observed the stock market recently 2. “Compliance cost” - these things are not done via paper and fax machines. Regulation simply asks one to keep track of, say in the case of medical companies, administration cost vs servicing cost etc - things you would have had to do anyways in your public-good-seeking scenario above
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> 1. If there is extra profit one year, these companies will willingly reduce premiums instead of giving bonuses, stock buy backs, or dividends to investors. I don’t know if you have observed the stock market recently It's the thing competitive markets require of them. If costs go down, one company is going to notice how much more profit they can make by lowering prices and using the lower prices to triple their market share. The others then have to do the same thing or they continue to lose market share. The buybacks are something else entirely -- they're a result of low long-term interest rates. Companies have at least two ways of raising capital. They can sell stock and they can borrow money. When interest rates are low it makes more sense to raise money through borrowing than selling shares. Buybacks are the reverse of selling shares, so when interest rates are reduced there is a rebalancing which involves companies borrowing more money and buying back shares because it's cheaper to use borrowed capital than invested capital when interest rates are low. > 2. “Compliance cost” - these things are not done via paper and fax machines. Regulation simply asks one to keep track of, say in the case of medical companies, administration cost vs servicing cost etc - things you would have had to do anyways in your public-good-seeking scenario above Have you seen the regulations in some of these industries? There is nothing simple about it. It requires you to have lawyers in addition to accountants. And the lawyers are pathologically risk-averse but have plenary control over compliance policy because no one wants to end up in court, so the rules in practice are characteristically much more rigid than what the legislature intended. Many of the costs are also fixed rather than proportional to customer volume, which disproportionately impacts smaller companies and results in a disproportionately large negative impact on competition.
- coredog64 7y agoThe next time someone said water boarding is bad, remember when you were thirsty and had a cold glass of ice water.
- analog31 7y agoCar insurance is more than just insurance, though. For one thing, it's mandatory. A person with zero assets buying insurance is also missing the point of liability insurance, but they have to buy it anyway.
- perl4ever 7y agoDo you think that the price an insurance company sets for risk in advance is by definition correct? I mean, something that comes to mind in terms of current events, people selling puts (stock options) just before the stuff hit the fan with COVID-19, were selling insurance. It seems really difficult in my mind to argue that that insurance was priced correctly just before the panic started.
- gwright 7y ago> Do you think that the price an insurance company sets for risk in advance is by definition correct? The question doesn't make sense. The price is neither correct nor incorrect, it is just the price. It may or may not lead to financial success based on a whole host of factors but that isn't the same thing as "correct" or "incorrect".
- imtringued 7y agoThe insurance company can also just reduce the billed amount.
- dllthomas 7y agoThere's a difference between "you didn't need it" and "an unusually small portion of the (large) risk pool needed it".
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> The idea is you pay a premium not knowing if you'll need it or not, and they take on all the risk if you do need it. It's not getting your premium back because you didn't need it. You'd still get back this portion of the premium even if you get into a car accident on your way to the grocery store, because it's not about you, it's about everybody else. The average risk went down, so the average premium went down. This certainly happens in the other direction too, they'll raise your premium for the next period if the average risk goes up. But their marketing departments aren't stupid. Sending everybody a check right now makes their "largess" more conspicuous to customers than sending everybody a smaller bill next quarter. It also keeps you from canceling your policy with them and switching to someone else currently offering a lower rate because of the currently lower risk.
- unbalancedevh 7y agoI just got a refund check from Progressive, the same time I got my next bill. I wish they had just reduced the bill.
- Spivak 7y agoI can’t even imagine how annoying a system like that would be to implement. So you credit everyone’s account but then you have mark this money as special to ensure that it eventually gets paid out to every account in either credit or cash. Then you have to monitor the accounts for policy cancellations and issue checks.
- djannzjkzxn 7y agoThe credit card companies don’t seem to have any trouble applying my cash back rewards to my account balance without sending me a check. But if I do cancel my account and end up with a positive balance, they do send a check. Seems like basic accounting to me, not some sort of wizardry like you suggest. Mailing checks is probably more expensive if anything.
- triceratops 7y agoThe premium is calculated based on a certain set of risk factors. Miles driven is one of them. If that changes, it's reasonable to ask for a refund.