4 ms·
> Very nearly 100% of experts in this field agree it's happening None of these "experts" have a track record of correct predictions that justifies taking their
by pdonis 7y ago
> Very nearly 100% of experts in this field agree it's happening
None of these "experts" have a track record of correct predictions that justifies taking their current predictions seriously. Remember we are not talking about the fact that the climate changes: yes, it does, it always has, and it always will (unless at some point in the distant future we learn how to control it accurately). We are talking about the dire predictions of catastrophe that have been made to try to justify spending many trillions of dollars on CO2 mitigation. Those predictions have never come true.
> Epidemiologists told everyone for a decade and a half this would happen, but here we are.
To know whether these were useful predictions, we would need to know more details. Did they predict when it would happen? Did they predict how it would spread? A prediction that "this will happen, some time in the future" is not very useful. AFAIK no epidemiologists were making predictions much more precise than that.
Looking at the actual frequency of epidemics of various sizes in the past, we might very roughly estimate that we will have one serious enough to involve a significant portion of health care resources once every decade or so. But you don't have to be an epidemiologist to do that; you just have to do the simplest possible extrapolation of the data. We had H1N1 about 10 years ago, and SARS about 18 years ago. That's still not a very strong prediction, but it would seem to be as good a basis for public policy discussion (which is to say, a fairly weak one but not negligible) as anything more complicated that has come from epidemiologists.
- MattRix 7y ago>A prediction that "this will happen, some time in the future" is not very useful Yes it is, if taken seriously.
- pdonis 7y agoWhat does "taken seriously" mean? We don't even know that from a prediction that vague. If the prediction is "we can expect a serious epidemic once every 10 years", then we have something definite that we can plan for, or at least discuss the costs of planning for. There's no way to discuss the costs of planning for "this will happen, some time in the future" without more detail.
- majormajor 7y agoSeems like the only correct response to that level of prediction is increasing investment in studying the problem. Which has largely happened in a lot of areas... except for the people who think the correct response is to ignore any prediction that isn't perfectly specific?
- pdonis 7y ago> increasing investment in studying the problem. That would be nice, yes. > except for the people who think the correct response is to ignore any prediction that isn't perfectly specific? If a prediction isn't giving you any useful, actionable information, you can't act on it. That doesn't necessarily mean you do nothing. If our public policy decision is "well, we don't really know how often epidemics like this will occur, but just to ballpark, let's plan on one every 10 years and see what we would need to do to prepare", that's fine. Just don't say we need to do that because the experts made a prediction. It's just a best judgment call based on very incomplete information.
- torpfactory 7y agoJust a friendly reminder that the consensus estimates about climate change have been reasonably accurate. Not perfect but decent enough as decision making tools. See for example the IPCC report from 1990: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPCC_First_Assessment_Report https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/IPCC_First_Assessment_Report There have certainly been very dramatic (all overly well reported) warnings representing a minority of researchers which have not been accurate. These should not invalidate the whole lot of predictions.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoSure. And while opinion polls are lagging, almost everyone in decision-making positions is on board with the minimal predictions in this report. (Even a lot of people normally considered climate change deniers are on board - according to Wikipedia, the report doesn't rule out that climate change is largely driven by natural variability!)
- pdonis 7y ago> the minimal predictions in this report Those minimal predictions don't justify spending trillions of dollars on CO2 mitigation. They basically say "the climate is going to change, so be ready to deal with it".
- chimprich 7y agoThis is a false economy. Several studies have demonstrated that it is cheaper to avert climate change than to deal with the effects. Switching to low- and zero-carbon fuels, achieving greater efficiencies and so on, is expensive, but still a lot cheaper than e.g. moving coastal cities or engineering mega-projects to combat flooding, dealing with huge numbers of migrants, dealing with massive changes in agriculture, worse natural disasters, and so on. Plus even if you deal with the effects for decades, your problem has not gone away. The situation is worse, and the planet is still heating.
- pdonis 7y ago
- yongjik 7y agoThese days, I consider anyone saying "[the climate] always has [changed], and it always will" as immediately disqualified for having any worthwhile opinion on the climate. Climate is a serious issue. It's time we stopped entertaining these people.
- div 7y agoThe only sensible stance to take. All these trolls have to do is be obstructionist, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchants_of_Doubt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Merchants_of_Doubt