7 ms·
I totally agree. Google has become useless for about half my searches. It gives me only the biggest, most commercial or most popular results. Anything obscure i
by mcv 7y ago
I totally agree. Google has become useless for about half my searches. It gives me only the biggest, most commercial or most popular results. Anything obscure is impossible to find.
I'd like to have a search engine where you get only the most obscure, hard-to-find content. One where you can tweak the kind of content you're looking for, or even switch between different modes: am I just looking for the definition of a common but complex term, am I looking for a specific article that I vaguely remember a phrase from, do I want something I've seen before, or am I in the mood to discover new, unexpected things?
Also, I just don't want to see results from some sites. Let me tweak the importance of some sites, rather than relying on Google's gameable algorithms.
- midef 7y agoI like playing around with "Million Short" - https://millionshort.com https://millionshort.com. It's a search engine that lets you logarithmically filter-out the top websites. It isn't perfect, of course, but its a fun way to discover things.
- mcv 7y agoThat is a fantastic idea. Of course some of those top sites, especially the blogging and self-hosting platforms, can still contain obscure stuff that might be just what I'm looking for.
- kilroy123 7y agoI love the idea and have tried to use their service a number of times over the years. I've never been terribly happy with the results.
- netsharc 7y agoI have another "Google is shit now" anecdote: a few months ago I wanted to look up some trivia for the movie "Lord of War". I entered this term in Google, and since there was a game that was just released, it responded with "Showing you results for 'God of War'". No results on the front page had anything related to the Nic Cage movie.
- mda 7y agoCan you find the exact search term from your search history?
- netsharc 7y agoIt was "lord of war director's commentary". I thought it was because many more people were googling for the game, but I just tried and Google is still doing this!
- fingerlocks 7y agoIf you click the “search instead for...” then the non-video result was exactly what I believe you wanted.
- mattmanser 7y agoThe point is, why is it doing this? It's not even suggesting both God of War and Lord of War, for me all the results on the first page are about God of War.
- hvis 7y agoIt's probably correcting people's typos, as well as saving a crap-ton of money this way (search results are undoubtedly cached).
- eitland 7y agoAt the cost of destroying their once in-its-own-league quality. Today I use DDG mostly, thanks to Googles choices. DDG is equally bad WRT this but - it is easier to move from DDG to Google (just add !g) than the other way around - and DDG isn't as invasive
- krapp 7y agoI just searched "Lord of War" and the front page is entirely about the movie. Don't know what to tell you.
- bryanrasmussen 7y agohttps://millionshort.com/about https://millionshort.com/about is an implementation of the idea of finding obscure content, but it seems not successful to me.
- mda 7y agoHalf your searches? Isn't it a bit dramatic? You can always check your search history, but I seriously doubt 50% of your searches Google can not find anything - assuming data is somewhere accessible-. Tell us a few of the obscure things that you know exist openly and google could not find for you. I see these claims all the time, but usually with zero examples.
- mcv 7y agoIt's a very rough estimate. I'm not going to check every search in my history. But it feels like the chances I'll find what I need are comparable to the chances I won't. One example: this weekend I was looking for lyrics from the British folk band Why?. I know they exist; my brother has a bunch of their albums. I have quoted lyrics at Google, I've searched for it on Youtube, I've searched for the band name combined with song titles or names of band members, and I found tons other bands and other random crap, but not the band I was looking for. Eventually I searched for a very specific phrase that was also the title of one of their live albums: "Jig at a Why? Gig", and that finally turned up results. It's an obscure band, and their name being a common word certainly doesn't help, but certainly combined with song titles, lyrics and band members, it should be pretty clear what I'm looking for? But with Google giving strong preference to the most popular results, Google becomes primarily good at finding things you don't need a search engine for to find them. I want a search engine that's good at finding things that are lost, rather than in plain sight.
- BostonFern 7y agoLyrics are notoriously hard to find on Google. I assume it's in part due to copyright issues, but it's also not how Google works. Searches are based on key words, not exact matches of several words in order.
- fiblye 7y agoThere was once I time where I could type maybe 5 random words from a song and get it as the top hit. Now there are times where I can’t remember the song title, but I can type a few lines of lyrics verbatim plus include the musician’s name and get only random, unrelated links.
- trendscout 7y agoDDG doesn't work for me either when it comes to more general, not tech-ish stuff. One thing for news I found was https://yetigogo.com https://yetigogo.com
- blaser-waffle 7y agoYeah DDG is hit or miss. Most (70% or more) DDG searches work but a lot of times Google or Bing does a better job.
- eitland 7y agoTo me it seems the problem with Google goes far deeper than struggling with bad SEO. - For years it has been next to impossible to get a result that is faithful to the search you actually typed in. This is not dependent on SEO spammers at all, only on Googles unwillingness to accept that not every user is equal and some of us mean exactly what we write, especially when we take the time to enclose our queries in double quotes and set the "verbatim" option. - Ad targeting has been so bad it has been ridiculous. Yes, on average it works but around the edges it is somewhere between tragic and hilarious. For ten years after I met my wife the most relevant ads Google could think of was dating sites. Not toys, not family holidays, not tech conferences, not magazine subscriptions, not offers from local shops, but scammy dating sites that was so ridiculous that I cannot imagine how most people would fall for them. (For a while I wondered if this was all a fluke but now I have confirmed it happens to others in my situation as well.) - Also in other areas it is becoming ridiculous. For example: what is the idea behind aggressively showing me captcas while I'm logged in with two different google controlled accounts, one gmail and one gsuite, both paid?
- capableweb 7y ago> Yes, on average it works Maybe we frequent vastly different websites, but this has absolutely not been true for me, even for companies who are supposed to be experts at using their data. I don't think I've ever seen an ad that has actually been relevant, and I'm not even trying to hide my habits or behaviors. For example, take Amazon. Their ads all over the web frequently recommends me stuff I've already bought just a month ago, the very same product. Or the products they recommend are way out of my zone, like woman clothing while I never purchased woman clothing or anything close to it. So, I'm not sure how the ad market even goes around and my friends are describing the same behavior from the ads, even from companies that have my entire shopping history already (like Amazon)
- eitland 7y ago> > Yes, on average it works > Maybe we frequent vastly different websites... I think we agree. What I mean is on average it works for Google, not that it works for us. They still makes boatloads of cash. For what I know the targeting is equally bad for you and me and everyone and they are just convincing advertisers that is worth paying for despite this.
- gsich 7y agoI see mainly two problems: - Affiliate spam from douchebags that provide "reviews" of products just to link back to Amazon. Makes it nearly impossible to find actual reviews of products. - People who type whole sentences in natural language into Google. I tried since I used the internet to serach for keywords, omit as much words as possible that aren't necessary. Most people (after I guess ~2010?) don't. This worsens the results.
- ivanche 7y agoWow! Now people who know how to type using proper grammar and vocabulary are a problem???
- purerandomness 7y agoNot OP, but let's say you want to find out the protein content of brussels sprouts. I would type `protein content brussels sprouts` (without quotes) because I fully understand that the information I'm seeking might be in some tabular form, or phrased in a way I don't anticipate. Most non-technical people however would type in `What is the protein content of brussels sprouts?` literally. This leads content creators who see these queries in "keyword analysis tools" to dump SEO-optimized crap into millions of blog posts, with completely irrelevant word soups with countless varations of the question, and the actual information buried deep within that gibberish essay, unreadable by humans, only optimized to drive ad traffic. Google's optimization for the non-technical use case has lowered the overall search result quality immensely. There was a time when Google didn't simply ignore some of your search words, or when control characters like +, -, and "" were actually respected (~pre 2010), and the introduction of verbatim mode didn't change much IMHO.
- ivanche 7y agoInteresting. Why do you think that content creators wouldn't see `protein content brussels sprouts` in "keyword analysis tools"? Why do you think they wouldn't create millions of blog posts containing words `protein content brussels sprouts` or countless variations thereof?
- CameronBanga 7y agoThis is correct. DuckDuckGo is finally better.
- msl 7y agoMy experience is the opposite: while there certainly was a time when I felt DDG actually respected my queries [1] that time is now gone. The results I get often have very little to do with what I typed in the search box. I find myself resorting to !g more often than ever before. [1] I seem to have thought so in last December: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18665232 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18665232
- eitland 7y ago> while there certainly was a time when I felt DDG actually respected my queries [1] that time is now gone. I sometimes wonder if they've hired some ex-googlers lately because yes, this is my experience as well ;-)
- Jaruzel 7y agoAfter the last bout of anti-google posts on HN about a month ago, I took the comment advice and switched fully to DDG. My experience was horrible. I don't tend to search 'popular' subjects, only technical ones, and hobbyist stuff. DDG was just plain useless for this, I had to switch back to google after about a week as I was using the !g prefix almost all the time.
- chongli 7y agoThis was my experience as of a year ago. Nowadays when I do a search on DDG (my default choice) the results are terrible. Then I add !g and the results are even worse. I’ve had so many recent searches for information on technical subjects result in abject failure, leaving me to throw my hands in the air in frustration. It’s gotten so bad that I’ve installed BasiliskII and SheepShaver [1] just so I can relive the nostalgia of the days when I had my first Macintosh, before I’d even had access to the Internet for the first time. The help system and the documentation for software back then was so much more exhaustive than it is today! [1] https://www.emaculation.com/doku.php/mac_emulation https://www.emaculation.com/doku.php/mac_emulation
- greggman3 7y agoThere are definitely sites who's results I wish I could ban from my results. I won't visit them so they are just a waste of space. My short list, thillist, collider, vulture. Also related to SEO I think is every cooking recipe seems to be 6 to 8 large images and a bunch of unneeded text followed by the recipe 8 to 12 screens down. AFAICT it's entirely not related to me getting to the recipe and instead either a pattern for SEO or ads.
- thomas 7y agoA Pinterest ban would greatly improve google results.
- newsbinator 7y agoI'm surprised Google's own Search team doesn't get frustrated enough by Pinterest results contaminating their own day-to-day searches that they'd consider ranking Pinterest results lower.
- KMag 7y agoThey aren't going to de-optimize their careers in order to optimize search just for themselves. Google used to be somewhat optimized for power users, but I suspect that learn-to-rank is over-optimizing search ranking for the median user. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22747889 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22747889
- Lammy 7y agoThat used to be available as a Google Labs feature.
- greggman3 7y agoGiven the uniformity of recipe site design I'm starting to wonder if there isn't more going on. Like maybe they are all run by the same company or maybe there is a template that every person that wants to run a recipe site is somehow pushed to use. I mean literally, search for any recipe, click the first 10 links. Screens and screens if large pictures and superfluous text with actual recipe way way down the page.
- comzilla 7y agoHow are you meant to find the most obscure content? If it's obscure, it probably means it is not relevant to your search. How would a search engine like that even work? Tweaking importance of some sites seems like a nice idea though, but it could also be a bad thing.
- nieve 7y agoI'm very confused by your definition of obscure. If I search for something rare and not covered very well using as set of precise search terms Altavista and company used to give me almost exclusively relevant results. Modern Google will give me windows helpdesk questions for a query about a linux driver using lots of of quoted terms, at most one of which will appear in the results. Rare results are _exactly_ the time that precise queries give higher quality hits. Substituting a different word will swamp them. Specifying sites to avoid or prefer is an extra signal to help with that
- Kye 7y agoRecent example: I wanted to find out why the directions on those Banquet pot pies say to let it stand for five minutes. The words on the box say it finishes cooking in those five minutes. I want to find out more about that: why didn't it finish in the oven? Is it cover for liability, so people don't get burned? All Google returns is page after page of recipes and posts about Banquet pot pies that have no connection to my input. Google used to be so good at this kind of thing. I know the answer exists somewhere because I found it once a long time ago searching for answers to the same question. Google found it then.
- ckolkey 7y agoThis could perhaps be illustrated well with a hard boiled egg. If you remove an egg at the 7 minute mark, the internal temperature is still around 100c, and it will continue to cook. To stop it cooking, dunk it in cold water. Similarly with the pot pie, the filling retains a ton of heat, so it still is cooking for those few minutes, as the heat dissipates. If you left it in the oven five minutes longer (to 'finish') then put it in cold water (like the egg), you would have a pie in a similar, though wetter, condition.
- Kye 7y agoI thought it might be something like that. You're way better than Google. Thanks.
- basch 7y agoI wish I would have seen this coming years ago. I would have built a Google Custom Search Engine, and every time I ran into a good website, added it to the whitelist. By now, it would probably be alright.
- unsupervisedluv 7y agoInsert allegory about the best time to plant a tree being 20 years ago... Or today.
- basch 7y agoIt is something ive started now.
- josephjrobison 7y agoGoogle is of course going to return the most popular results to please the largest amount of people. If you're looking for more technical results, it'll take a more technical approach. You should learn search operators - https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/2466433?hl=en https://support.google.com/websearch/answer/2466433?hl=en - that allow you to control the results for specific sites or very detailed requests. Even better, set up a custom search engine - https://support.google.com/customsearch/answer/4513882?hl=en https://support.google.com/customsearch/answer/4513882?hl=en - with 100 of your trusted sites and now you have Google search precisely tuned to your needs.
- cookiengineer 7y agoWe should manifest a website that we can both find right now, agree on the search terms and operators used... ... and then meet again, in say, 3 years, where this content is either only findable on tiktokterest or not at all anymore. Google has not a search problem. It has a chronological and social one.
- type0 7y agoEven better, don't use google
- DeathArrow 7y agoThe smarter Google has become, the less relevant it is. It was a lot easier finding things in 2004 than today. That's because it tries to be clever and use synonims and search for terms it deems as related instead of actual search terms.