3 ms·
> 2. Motivated reasoning is rampant. This is an important point. Scientific scrutiny is extremely important, but there is still a difference between a judge th
by xg15 7y ago
> 2. Motivated reasoning is rampant.
This is an important point. Scientific scrutiny is extremely important, but there is still a difference between a judge that is stern but fair - and one that actively wants you to fail.
Motivated reasoners have no problems holding opposing parties to impossibly high standards while accepting claims without any evidence as valid arguments for their side.
Today, climate scientists have learned the lessons and improved communication and modeling considerably, even to the point where we now how "attribution science" we we can discuss climate change in the context of particular weather events. We also start seeing changes in weather patterns that are hard to ignore even for laymen.
Nevertheless we are still having the same discussions as before.
- lopmotr 7y ago> We also start seeing changes in weather patterns that are hard to ignore even for laymen. Hard to ignore by motivated reasoners! Changes in weather patterns observed by individuals using their own experience are not evidence of global climate change. If there's science showing that, then yes, but personal experience doesn't add any value to the conclusion, it just reinforces whatever the person already wants to believe.