7 ms·
> In the large public university that I attended, easily 80% of my courses were taught by graduate students not much older than I was. How typical is this? It
by Scoundreller 7y ago
> In the large public university that I attended, easily 80% of my courses were taught by graduate students not much older than I was.
How typical is this? It doesn't match my Canadian large public university experience, but maybe that's because I took clinical/tech programs? Or that our class sizes can be bigger? What would one prefer, classes of 300 with a full professor, or 30 with a grad student?
- joey_bob 7y agoNot typical in the US afaik. In my undergraduate, I had one course taught by a graduate student, and he was somewhere around twice my age. Recitation is typically taught by a graduate student, but taught is a loose word. Seems like recitation is really group office hours with one of the professors graduate students.
- bobthepanda 7y agoSome institutions definitely have this problem much worse than others in the US, and in certain subjects; while my CS courses were generally taught by professors, the CS labs were definitely run by grad students, grad students did all the grading, etc. For niche elective courses that I took to complete my humanities requirements, those were definitely more likely to be taught by a grad student. But YMMV; talking to peers from secondary school, it seemed like certain institutions (Harvard, Berkeley) were more likely to have this problem. Can't really verify that hearsay though. On the topic of large class sizes, there is definitely room for improvement in the US system; being at a poorly-funded mid-tier public university, we had several courses that were so large that there were overflow rooms with a camera pointing to the main lecturer in the main room, and these were lecture halls that could easily hold 400.
- asdff 7y agoVery typical in the U.S. for the professor to do the 300 person lecture twice a week, and have a TA go over homework, proctor quizzes, or run labs in smaller sections of ~30 people. At my undergrad, smaller classes that are lower division would be taught by a grad student to like 30 people, upper division seminars are usually faculty though.
- evgen 7y agoI guess it depends. If you were at a large state-funded research university it would not surprise me for low-level and intro classes. When I attended a mid-sized elite university I only had this sort of experience with a few math and sciences courses that everyone in several different degree tracks had to take. My upper-level humanities courses, OTOH, were usually 8-20 students and always taught by a prof (and by the later years it was more likely for grad students to be taking the course than to be teaching it.) I guess that given the breadth of possible options when it comes to American universities this is one area where YMMV.
- plandis 7y agoMy university was a mixture. For example, the introductory engineering classes you typically take in your first year are large 300+ classes taught by professors with lectures 2-3 times a week. Additionally, TAs (typically grad students) would hold smaller sessions for those classes with maybe 30 students each. Once you move into more specialized classes the size goes down significantly and are all taught by professors.