5 ms·
I wouldn't call it "hidden", it's public knowledge. It needs to be filled however because oil is so cheap. And for the keyboard nay-sayers that are typing on a
by exabrial 7y ago
I wouldn't call it "hidden", it's public knowledge. It needs to be filled however because oil is so cheap.
And for the keyboard nay-sayers that are typing on a keyboard made of ABS, walking their down on a nylon leash, holding their iPhone in a TPU case, drinking from a polycarbonate reusable water bottle, wondering how we're going to refine steel for wind turbines, oil is an incredible useful substance.
Let's learn from the N95 mask shortage. It's incredibly important to have national stockpiles to decouple ourselves from the events in the world (like the one happening now).
- Grazester 7y agoIndeed it is useful. It's usefulness was never in debate(it is it's ability to pollute that's the problem) but most of the things you named has a substitute made from other materials exist.
- Glide 7y agoCan entire supply chains switch over that quickly? I would imagine that if something catastrophic were to occur and supply chains had to switch, we would need some buffer.
- animalnewbie 7y agoAnd yet neither you nor the companies selling to you have despite everone worried about the climate emergency
- geofft 7y agohttps://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/ https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/ I don't think any of the "keyboard nay-sayers" are saying that petroleum isn't useful, and it's worth engaging with their actual arguments.
- fastball 7y agoThat comic is a terrible Reductio ad absurdum. The first one is a fair point – Apple products are not a necessity. Therefore if you think the company behind them is behaving unethically, don't buy their products in order to not support their activities. The other two examples – not so much.
- geofft 7y agoSure, but 1. The validity of the argument isn't affected by whether one is a hypocrite. If Apple is indeed behaving unethically, it's still behaving unethically even if I own an iPhone. If Apple isn't behaving unethically, then you should be able to argue that on grounds other than "you bought an iPhone." The poster in this case made specific, refutable claims - that Apple dodges taxes and can't pay decent wages to their Chinese factory workers. A legitimate counterargument is that they don't in fact dodge taxes or do in fact pay decent wages (or perhaps that their current behavior is okay), not an attack on the person making the argument. 2. Apple products are not a necessity, but in the current era, a smartphone is very close to a necessity (yes, there are people who steadfastly avoid them, and there are also people who live in the forest, that's not what "necessity" means). And there are relatively few options for good smartphones, none of which come from morally blameless companies. (Personally, I find security valuable, and Apple has the best track record of producing phones with long-term security support, which means you can buy fewer Apple products than anything else.) It might be hypocritical to buy a product from company X while steadfastly believing that company X is behaving unethically, but it's hardly a sign that you don't in fact believe that company X behaves unethically. You might simply have weight the alternatives and decided that buying from company X is the best of several bad options.
- bluntfang 7y ago>The validity of the argument isn't affected by whether one is a hypocrite. I personally think it matters how much of an effort the person espousing beliefs is putting in to deviate from the norm their are complaining about. For example, I'm not going to listen to your arguments about climate change if you aren't actively curbing your red meat consumption. Although, if you're making an effort to reduce your red meat consumption, I'll take you more seriously about climate change. It may be virtue signaling, or whatever phrase of the week, but I need people to believe in what they're fighting for. edit: for those downvoting, please leave a remark. It's hard to understand this website since so many people downvote without any response.
- geofft 7y ago
- cscurmudgeon 7y agoUnless the keyboard nay-sayers help with a solution, the constant nay-saying of the obvious is just virtue signaling peacocking.
- ceejayoz 7y agoAccusing people of “virtue signaling” tends to be just another form of signaling. “There’s a problem, it matters, but I don’t personally have the fix handy” is not an unreasonable position. It’s like a non-chef saying “this food is bad”; that they can’t cook isn’t relevant to that fact.
- cscurmudgeon 7y agoStraw man. > “There’s a problem, it matters, but I don’t personally have the fix handy That is not what is happening is it? I am okay with that. > “There’s a problem with X, it matters, but I don’t personally have the fix handy AND YOU ARE EVIL FOR USING X That is what I call virtue signaling.
- ryguytilidie 7y agoYeah, the post you're responding to feels like a huge internet trend where people are absolutely desperate to grasp at straws to make complete strangers look like stupid hypocrites and rely on projections to do so. I'm not sure if people are more filled with angst because they're cooped up at home, but it seems to border on a mental disorder if you're sitting behind your keyboard all day screaming at people who are "hypocrites" because they both don't like oil being drilled, and also live in a society where they use some oil. I saw a video a few months ago mocking "anti police protesters asking for the police to help them when they were being attacked". And the premise seemed to be "haha, if you hate police so much (they don't), isnt it ironic that you need their help?" No, not really. They pay the police's salary though taxes. Its not like them protesting takes that funding away. Apparently its hypocritical to not mindlessly agree with everything police do if you will ever need the police to help you. Same shit here, just endless angst and hate for stranger based on made up projections. Why? What is the use for this?
- didibus 7y agoNot sure, I wondered if the comic actually was also trying to show the growth of "necessities" over time. Like a car at first was a luxury and not a necessity. A phone today might be a necessity. And the last strip doesn't even bring up necessities, it makes a case of the difficulty of fighting the system you complain about when being in it, which to me is also a point about necessities. Like one could argue society makes it harder and harder for you to be ethical as time goes on. Making the path of resistance ever so harder and requiring more risk from you. And this can be used as a tool later to justify societies unethical choices. Like, hey, if you can't even be ethical yourself, why do you expect society to be and say we should? And maybe this is the point of the comic?
- btian 7y agoOil is very useful, and that is precisely why we shouldn't waste it on things that don't need oil, e.g., power generation, vehicle fuel etc.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI think the stockpile argument made sense when the US was a net importer of oil. As an oil exporter nation, it's harder to defend. That said, a price war is of course the right time to bunker up, economically.
- krtong 7y agoI think the lesson from N95 is DONT OFFSHORE SHIT FOR NATIONAL DEFENSE.
- reshie 7y agowhen people speak ill of oil are they not actually talking about emissions?
- clSTophEjUdRanu 7y agoOil is useful. I get it. How much oil is burned in comparison to oil used in manufacturing? When we typically talk about eliminating oil we are talking about not burning it anymore.
- perl4ever 7y agoIt's already 80% full, isn't it?
- valuearb 7y agoThe US has nearly a trillion barrels worth of oil in the ground, but we should bail out oil producers by trying to fill a different hole with less than a billion barrels of oil at government expense?
- dewey 7y agoI haven't seen many people that say oil isn't useful. It's the burning of this valuable substance that is the problem when it could be used for all these things you list.
- Robotbeat 7y agoI'm 100% for filling up and even drastically expanding the Strategic Petroleum Reserve. I'm also for ending fossil fuels (we can synthesize plastics without fossil fuels) and keeping as much fossil fuel as possible underground. The Strategic Reserve's whole purpose is to sit underground for the most part, so it's compatible with an anti-fossil-fuel perspective. One way a massive Reserve could help fight fossil fuel production is because it devalues arguments that we need to expand drilling permits. With a big enough reserve, we can reduce permits on federal lands to just about nothing with plenty of time to drill them in case of an emergency like a war or something.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post flamebait to HN. Your comment turned the thread into a generic (I really want to say stupid) flamewar, which got more tedious and nastier as it went along, as such things predictably do. Worse, it sat at the top of the entire page, sucking oxygen away from everything else, because indignation routinely attracts upvotes. HN readers belong to the same species as Jerry Springer attendees. I've flagged it and marked it off topic now. "Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html