4 ms·
As others have pointed out, this only gets thing to a steady state while everyone is still locked down. All the countries that have loosened their lockdown rest
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
As others have pointed out, this only gets thing to a steady state while everyone is still locked down. All the countries that have loosened their lockdown restrictions had to tighten them back up after they had new "flare-ups".
We're in this for many, many months. Somehow a lot of people have forgotten that "flattening the curve" greatly lengthens the time period of the curve.
Also, the thesis behind flattening the curve is still that the same number of people eventually get it, and it's only once you get broad population immunity that the spread stops.
We will be fighting this with social distancing until there is a vaccine.
- maxerickson 7y agoThe area under the flat curve is dramatically smaller. The theory is not that the same number of people get it.
- foobarbecue 7y agoThat's not how I understand it. "Flattening the curve" refers to reducing the peak. In the models I've seen, at the end of the epidemic, the %of population who have been infected is roughly the same with and without intervention. The point is that there were fewer infected at the same time.
- maxerickson 7y agoReducing the load on the medical system is the immediate goal, but the total number of people infected will also be smaller. Take the extreme example of Taiwan. If reports are accurate and they maintain their current situation, the literally flat curve there will lead to a few thousand people getting infected out of 23 million. Or compare this outbreak to the first SARS, where asymptomatic spreading was much less of an issue. Very few people globally got SARS, exactly because interventions to stop the spread were effective.
- hn_throwaway_99 7y ago> Very few people globally got SARS, exactly because interventions to stop the spread were effective. But SARS was also much less contagious than this virus, especially during the asymptomatic phase. SARS also was much more lethal, meaning people that got it had less of a chance of transmitting it, because they were dead. This virus is kind of the worst of all world's, in that it's very dangerous but only for a relatively small portion of the population, and that it can be spread by asymptomatic people much more easily. This means that it's very easy for any "embers" burning anywhere to eventually flare up into huge blazes wherever there are large number of people that still don't have immunity.
- foobarbecue 7y agoThat's called "containment," not "flattening the curve." It's great that some countries have been able to contain the virus, and I hope it lasts. I wish I could believe we had sufficient leadership and discipline to achieve that in the USA.
- standardUser 7y ago"We will be fighting this with social distancing until there is a vaccine." Well, not really. We can also fight it by producing more needed medical supplies, developing better treatments and expanding hospital capacity. We aren't just trying to influence the curve, but also the line we are trying to keep the curve under. And some nations have had luck flattening the curve using testing and tracing (but the US does not seem to be interested in this approach for some reason). It's also worth considering that the level of social distancing is not fixed. There is a wide range of options between universal quarantine and business as usual.
- jellicle 7y agoOkay, so if I promise you you'd have a hospital bed and a ventilator for your last week on Earth, you'd go let some infected people cough in your face? If your answer is no, you're still worried about the consequences of infection including death and permanent disability, then the public is still going to want to avoid infections even if ICU beds were completely unlimited.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI don't think anyone's proposing a policy where the public will be forbidden from social distancing if they want to.
- ADefenestrator 7y agoThe US was too little and too late with testing for contact tracing to work. It might become possible again if the number of cases gets low enough, though.