8 ms·
What I always wonder why Americans don't build solid houses? In Russia and in Kazakhstan everyone builds house with thick (70-150 cm) walls with bricks and with
by vbezhenar 7y ago
What I always wonder why Americans don't build solid houses? In Russia and in Kazakhstan everyone builds house with thick (70-150 cm) walls with bricks and with good foundation. Even poor people don't build houses from plywood. But in America it seems that everyone, poor and rich builds extremely fragile houses. Like I can punch a wall with my knuckle. It seems so absurd. Especially with those prices that I'm hearing about, like house costs hundreds of thousands of dollars, up to a millions of dollars. I can build awesome house here for like $200k with very quality materials. Can American build a good house from bricks with very thick walls for a reasonable amount of money?
- kylehotchkiss 7y agoI am temporarily living outside USA in a concrete walled apartment. The concrete cracks constantly, tiles fall off the walls, and the door fitting seems to be totally variable based on temp and humidity. I miss living in houses made of wood. And how easily central air systems are installed in wooden homes.
- vbezhenar 7y agoThis is just bad house. I'm sure that one could find comparably bad wood house. Usually nothing like that is happening.
- cambalache 7y agoIt seems you live in a shitty apartment then. Plenty of concrete apartments all over the world are well built.
- cpursley 7y agoAs an American now living in Russia (in a region with 30% Armenians), I can confirm this. Our construction quality of our house in the US is trash. It's made out of cheap pine and plywood and has terrible thermal properties. We recently had to replace all the siding because it just rotted off. Meanwhile the places in Russia are smaller, but generally higher quality (which I prefer). Also, many Russians don't take on mortgages and pay for property with cash - which is amazing considering how low salaries are vs the West (they're huge savers - at least the older generations).
- djohnston 7y agothe thermal properties of a wood house with insulation is far better than that of a concrete one
- the_gipsy 7y agowhat about a stone/brick/concrete house with insulation?
- mturmon 7y agoIn general, any thermally-conducting path from outside to inside will reduce the insulating value of the wall by a lot. The standard framing method used in American houses is described in basic terms here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Framing_(construction)#Balloon_framing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Framing_(construction)#Balloon... (Platform framing is different from balloon framing in some details, but that's not important for our purposes.) The gaps between the vertical "studs" allow insulation to be put in, covering ~90% of the surface area. I forget the details, but there are code and construction-method developments that are working to raise this figure closer to 100%. The final wall would then be a roughly 7" sandwich. Details vary, but perhaps 1" exterior cladding - stucco, siding, etc., 5.5" of insulation where the frame is, 0.75" of interior wallboard ("drywall"). In older homes, alas, the insulation is thinner than 5.5". The brick, concrete, concrete-block, and stone construction methods I know about do not allow such a thick layer of insulation. I know there are products available to get higher insulating value in less thickness, thus allowing for 3" of brick + 3" of rigid foam, but of course these are applicable to both methods. And, as I've tried to clarify, the concrete-block methods I know about have areas where there is a non-insulating path through the concrete. Perhaps there are other concrete or brick methods that provide significant insulating value, that I'm not aware of, that are realistic for single-family homes?
- the_gipsy 7y agoReinforced concrete is used mostly in Spain, where I live. Then walls are either traditional bricks, or some plasterboards stuffed with insulation, or an outer layer of thin bricks, insulation, and an inner layer of plaster. I think we're moving away from bricks because everybody has A/C now. But houses are still "solid", with a concrete skeleton and walls that you can't "punch through", at least the outer walls.
- hirundo 7y agoFor one thing most of America is at a much lower latitude than most of Russia and Kazakhstan. Houses don't need as much insulation to be habitable in the winter.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoYes and this influences even the places at higher latitudes. I live in WA state and it's very clear that during the 50s-90s a lot of the residential construction here was influenced by what was going on in California. I know a lot of trades people that moves up from CA in that time. So the houses are not built to adequately handle rain and are drafty due to colder temps here. WA state finally started instituting more specific build codes that match the region in the late 90s and 2000s
- Koshkin 7y agoClimate in much of the US is far from being mild. Winters are pretty cold at lower latitudes, and summers can be very hot.
- amiga_500 7y agoFinancialisation of land due to banking. The more land costs the less you have for materials.
- missosoup 7y agoAmericans and Australians still haven't learned about double glazing. Definitely one of the more 'wtf' moments when I moved.
- projektfu 7y agoMost new houses have double glazed windows. The cost to renovate all the windows in an old house usually doesn’t pay off in increased efficiency. The biggest bang for the buck is usually increasing insulation of walls and attics.
- missosoup 7y ago> The biggest bang for the buck is usually increasing insulation of walls and attics Take out a FLIR imager and observe that every window is a black hole compared to even poorly insulated walls.
- iends 7y agoI was told it would cost $80,000 to redo all the windows in my house.
- missosoup 7y agoThis feeds back into OP's point - the costs are loony. There's maybe 8k worth of materials and labour to double glaze a house (and that's still on the really high end), not 80. If the average Armenian can afford it, there's no natural reason why the average American shouldn't be able to.
- nikanj 7y agoArmenia did not spend the last few decades convincing it’s children that only losers go into trades, so the wages an armenian window installer are quite a bit lower
- 7y ago
- stevenwoo 7y agoTwo reasons - at least on the West coast, building codes incorporate earthquake survivability of the occupants, inexpensive solid walls collapse easily in earthquakes, 2. speed and cost of construction and availability of labor for woodframe housing and even multistory apartment buildings across the USA. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-13/why-america-s-new-apartment-buildings-all-look-the-same https://www.bloomberg.com/news/features/2019-02-13/why-ameri...
- arwhatever 7y agoWe build our houses so that if they collapse on you, you can just dust yourself off and walk away. :-)
- carreau 7y agoNot saying it is a good reason, but wood is more flexible so resist better to earthquake. Brick and concrete will crack more easily even if you have many small imperceptible tremors. So in some area it may make sense. I agree though it's weird.
- evv555 7y agoStacked cinderblocks are dangerous in areas with powerful earthquakes and tornadoes.
- nickbauman 7y agoAmericans tear down houses a lot more often than Russians and former Soviet client nations do. The housing sector in the US represents an oversized % of its GDP. In fact there are a number of sectors (health care/insurance, housing, military, VA) that are super gigantic compared to even a well off OECD country that, if sized down to a more "normal" level, would turn America into just another average OECD country. Something that might be really great for a number of reasons.
- karatestomp 7y ago> Can American build a good house from bricks with very thick walls for a reasonable amount of money? Not really, no. You can build a much bigger house and/or save money for upgrades to things that are expected to increase the later sale value of the house (chiefly, the kitchen, but also things like nice outdoor spaces) instead of building with brick. In some areas brick houses are more common but they are mostly older ones. It’s difficult to recover the extra cost of building with brick when selling a house, so it’s rarely done. Since most houses are build by housing developers contracted to one or more newly-building neighborhoods, they’re very sensitive to anything that would reduce their margins or see finished houses sit on their books, and all-brick construction would usually do that. Brick is sometimes used in pasted-on façades, usually as a kind of “skirt” on the lower part of the front of the house. These may not even be full bricks, but ones cut lengthwise to maximize use of material and reduce weight (see: “pasted-on”) [EDIT] I should add that the overriding concern of almost all home construction and renovation in the US is reducing the amount of labor required. That’s where most of the cost is, so it’s ruthlessly optimized.
- yayana 7y agoBuilding with insulated concrete forms costs about 5% more.. So it is really not unaffordable to build a durable house in the US. Everything is done to minimum standards in the US because of paradoxical markets like banks competing to give mortgages. The bank that wants only houses that will survive the mortgage let alone second buyers mortgage (for the threat to resale value) loses.
- orthoxerox 7y ago> That’s where most of the cost is, so it’s ruthlessly optimized. What about all these illegal immigrants I keep hearing about in the news? Shouldn't they depress the cost of manual labor?
- PaulDavisThe1st 7y agoThat is already factored into the comment you're replying to.
- dan_hawkins 7y agoBrick houses don't fare well in seismic areas (think California) and they're more costly/time consuming to fix in areas frequently visited by tornadoes.
- desert_boi 7y agoThe entirety of the American West is subject to seismic areas. We're still having aftershocks from a magnitude 6.5 earlier this week in Central Idaho. https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/map/#%7B%22autoUpdate%22%3A%5B%22autoUpdate%22%5D%2C%22basemap%22%3A%22grayscale%22%2C%22feed%22%3A%221day_m25%22%2C%22listFormat%22%3A%22default%22%2C%22mapposition%22%3A%5B%5B41.89409955811395%2C-117.3065185546875%5D%2C%5B45.034714778688624%2C-111.1541748046875%5D%5D%2C%22overlays%22%3A%5B%22plates%22%5D%2C%22restrictListToMap%22%3A%5B%22restrictListToMap%22%5D%2C%22search%22%3Anull%2C%22sort%22%3A%22newest%22%2C%22timezone%22%3A%22utc%22%2C%22viewModes%22%3A%5B%22list%22%2C%22map%22%5D%2C%22event%22%3Anull%7D https://earthquake.usgs.gov/earthquakes/map/#%7B%22autoUpdat...
- Torwald 7y ago> But in America it seems that everyone, poor and rich builds extremely fragile houses. Not everyone. In "flyover country" there are a lot of solid craftsmen doing solid work.
- projektfu 7y agoWhen you step out of the wood frame and asphalt roof mold, construction is considered specialized and costs go way up. You could use, for example, concrete masonry units or aerated concrete panels, and a metal roof. Your costs probably just doubled per square foot.
- StavrosK 7y agoSure, but it's specialized because not enough people do it, so not enough people know how to do it, so that's no explanation. You're basically saying "Americans don't build with brick because they don't build with brick".
- HarryHirsch 7y agoIt's the same phenomenon as in the Eastern Bloc countries, where the state subsidized prefab concrete construction and left the building trade to starve. The result was cheap housing for millions (sorely needed after the destructions of the War) and complete destruction of the construction trades.
- projektfu 7y agoThat’s exactly what I’m saying. There’s a chicken and egg problem. Perhaps an entrepreneur could change things but I think you’d have to be ready to lose a lot of money before getting traction.
- frank2 7y agoIn South Florida wood-framed buildings are rare and most small buildings, e.g., houses, are made from concrete masonry units -- or at least that was the case when I left in 1984. "CBS" it used to be called: "concrete block structure".
- projektfu 7y agoSouth Florida is a different business environment and metal roofs are also not overly expensive there.
- throw1234651234 7y agoI have never found an answer to this question, especially given the thermal efficiency costs. Homes in Crimea have meter-thick walls and hold insulation really well, that's actually a huge point considering how high my monthly electric bill is. Anyway, ONE reason is that the drywall home is more pliable - you can adjust the layout and change out the wiring / piping with relative ease. Of course, at that point you don't have much house left, other than a few supporting structures. The American home is really the cement basement/foundation (outside of Florida), a carrier beam or two across the basement (metal) and a few wood carrier beams on the upper floor / floors. Insulation is typically fiberglass. After that, there is not much substance to it. The brick on the outside does not bear weight. They do last a decent amount of time when maintained though. Then again, maintenance is high.
- quaquaqua1 7y agoAlmost every town has some code that says you can't do that. Or the house is already built, and tearing it down to make a brick one is $$$ plus permit maybe will be denied. And most homebuilding companies only use wood.
- tyingq 7y agoI imagine part of it is that we want big houses in the US, so cheaper materials allow a bigger house without a linear increase in costs. Also, I believe lumber is cheaper here. Wood houses are also popular in Norway, where wood is cheap.
- microcolonel 7y agoI think the concept that timber houses are inherently fragile is not really true. > Even poor people don't build houses from plywood. But in America it seems that everyone, poor and rich builds extremely fragile houses. It isn't generally just plywood, that would be a very unusual house. As for your question of cost, with brick exterior walls, the marginal cost of interior volume decreases with size, so the question of an "awesome house" kinda changes. What people expect to be paid for labour is also higher. Brick is not a panacea, when it comes to building houses. It is an efficient thermal conductor, so insulation is more difficult, the way you have to fasten the interior of the house to it causes thermal bridging. Common ways of constructing brick buildings can cause condensation on the inside in cold winters, which can cause damage and harm air quality. There are two and three hundred year old timber homes. It is quite doable if you have large enough overhangs, and a durable roof. Also keep in mind Russia and Kazakhstan have a completely different climate to most of North America. Then on top of all of this, a lot of North Americans think of houses very differently. There are people who are building for a lifetime and a legacy, but most are content to have a comfortable sizeable dwelling which isn't going to collapse. It's fine to build a mediocre timber home, if it means that people get more or less what they wanted. As somebody who appreciates fine quality housing, I'd like it another way, but it seems that my fellow North Americans have something else in mind, and that's their business.
- HarryHirsch 7y agoIt's fine to build a mediocre timber home How do you have sex in that? How do your teenagers have sex in that? Is that what you wanted or merely what you put up with because you don't know that it could be done any better? Also: open plan kitchen. You can't cook in there; if you do everything smells of cooking and it covered with oil mist in short order. You can't remodel, because you house is your biggest tax-free leveraged savings vehicle and Americans are surprisingly conformist; your remodel just won't sell.
- microcolonel 7y agoAre you alright? I have no idea what you're trying to say here. I don't generally put up with it, but who am I to dictate everyone else's standards for their own living? > Also: open plan kitchen. You can't cook in there; if you do everything smells of cooking and it covered with oil mist in short order Open plan kitchens are fine if you have a proper range hood, but yeah, some people undersize their range hoods... but also lots of people don't cook much.
- throwaway894345 7y agoI think the you're largely observing the difference in purchasing power of a dollar between the US and eastern Europe. If you spent $200K to build a stone house, it would be much smaller (for example, in Western Europe where the purchasing power is more similar to the United States and stone construction is more common, houses tend to be much smaller than the US). This isn't to say that large houses are ideal, but Americans in general certainly tend to value living space more than Europeans. Further, the American model might be more susceptible to damage, but the damage is more cheaply repaired. It also lends itself to remodel as trends change (e.g., central heating and airconditioning, innovations in indoor plumbing [like removing lead-based plumbing], computer networking, as well as changes in interior layout trends), which allows a property to hold more value for longer.
- avmich 7y agoMany Europeans are lazy. They don't want to have to repair damages. They prefer to build so that damage doesn't accumulate for decades. Don't see the point in easy repairing.
- Iv 7y agoThe difference in purchasing power comes from the difference in labor cost mainly. I think that in a construction project, labor costs are going to outweigh material costs by a lot. In such a case, it makes little sense to prefer cheap materials. Maybe it has to do with competitions. Many old European houses are made of stone. New houses have to compare to that.
- GordonS 7y agoI considered getting a house designed and built here in the UK some years ago, and quickly found that the biggest cost wasn't labour, it was land. Land anywhere you'd want to live, that has planning permission for buildings, is very expensive. There is a lot less land in the UK than there is the US, and planning regulations can make things difficult.
- kazen44 7y agoAlso, many european cities are build quite dense because of their age. Especially medieval town centers are build dense because building large buildings was very hard to do. This results in many requirements for living being close together(shops, markets etc). Also, the automobile made it possible to create large suburbs in america. In many european cities the focus on the car didn't happen because spending money on a car was not a reality for many people. (americans own considerable more cars then most europeans, and have so for decades, even compared to western european countries).
- prostoalex 7y ago1) As others pointed out, need to account for seismic activity. 2) The invention of air conditioning (and low prices for heating) allow inefficient architectures while maintaining reasonable comfort. 3) Corporatization of construction led to structures that are efficient and quick to erect. 4) Insurability of a tract house with standard architecture is much better, due to predictable materials + labor costs.
- tomatotomato37 7y agoWe do... on the East coast where the risk of a category 4 throwing a palm tree through your kitchen is higher than an earthquake causing all the bricks in your house to disassociate with one another. The Midwest is screwed either way with what tornados are capable of so they just build whatever is cheapest to rebuild
- NortySpock 7y agoI'll point out, as a midwesterner, that while we have tornadoes, they have a VERY narrow footprint vs a flood or earthquake or hurricane. There's plenty of houses around that are 50 to 100 years old. But yes, the preferred strategy for dealing with a tornado is a basement, below-ground shelter (aka root cellar) or concrete-and-steel "panic room", all of which are designed to protect the occupants, not the entire house.
- crazygringo 7y agoAll over the world houses are built according to available local materials and the degree of weather insulation required, mainly. In America, houses in Maine can be built completely differently from houses in Florida. The reason we don't build out of stone/brick, besides cost of construction, is that they're terrible insulators. So your heating or AC bill is going to go absolutely through the roof. A wood frame stuffed with insulation means your home can be energy-efficient. This is a good thing. We don't fetishize a house being "solid" and we don't generally punch our walls on a regular basis. :) "Solid" sounds like a big waste of money to me.
- enriquto 7y agoThe thing is, the USA is the country with most tornadoes in the world. A solid house with thick walls is tornado-resistant. Yet, you lose thousands of plywood homes per year due to tornadoes, while the rest of the world builds real houses with stone walls just because they are more beautiful. What it seems to me is that you have a weird, unhealthy fetish for paper-thin houses.
- pimlottc 7y agoThere are vast areas of the US that are not generally affected by tornados. It’s a big country.
- vageli 7y ago> The thing is, the USA is the country with most tornadoes in the world. A solid house with thick walls is tornado-resistant. Yet, you lose thousands of plywood homes per year due to tornadoes, while the rest of the world builds real houses with stone walls just because they are more beautiful. What it seems to me is that you have a weird, unhealthy fetish for paper-thin houses. It seems this fetish is spreading. My family is from a fairly small island in the Mediterranean where all the houses are constructed of solid reinforced concrete and foreigners who are buying property for vacation homes have been putting up little timber boxes which are the subject of local gossip.
- djohnston 7y ago
- ranDOMscripts 7y agoAnybody semi-capable can easily modify a stick built house. And Americans _love_ to modify their houses. DIY stores are big business here. I, myself, am adding some recessed LED lights into a couple bedroom ceilings this weekend. When I'm done, apart from the light fixtures themselves, you will never know the work was done 50 years after the house was built because there are no cable raceways and no external plugs.
- Torwald 7y ago> In Russia and in Kazakhstan everyone builds house with thick (70-150 cm) walls with bricks and with good foundation. Even poor people don't build houses from plywood. But in America it seems that everyone, poor and rich builds extremely fragile houses. Not everyone. In the more rural areas there are a lot of farm houses build very solidly. These are usually build according to traditional techniques stemming from the European guilds of carpenters and masons.
- joncp 7y agoOne thing is that we Americans loooove remodeling our houses. We have whole TV channels dedicated to the topic. So, besides the benefits that other people have mentioned here, wood-frame structures are easy to change to suit our needs.
- kazen44 7y agowhat constitutes remodeling? Changing the entire layout of the house? because from my experience, nearly all houses in my country have the same kind of layout. Having lived in both pre and post ww2 housing. The major differences seem to be: - new, post ww2 houses have larger kitchens - old, pre ww2 houses seem to have a smaller living room and a "front room" (with load bearing walls in between). Modern houses have these rooms combined into a larger, single living room. - the bathroom in post world war 2 houses are considerably larger. Also, what is the deal with many american houses having multiple bathrooms with showers/baths in them?
- jhbadger 7y agoHaving multiple bathrooms (with showers) is nice because in the mornings people can get ready in parallel rather than in serial and so people are less likely to be late. It's a good thing to have, but yes, it isn't really a necessity. It's a relatively new thing even in America -- the 1960s era house I grew up in America in the 1970s-1980s had just one bathroom for the whole family.
- fulafel 7y agoThe energy costs are probably a major part of the equation. Heating/AC costs are lower so it doesn't make sense to invest in energy efficiency. Same as low gas prices with very lightly taxed fuel compared to other western countries. This all has to change with the global warming threat (the much worse alternative of giving up on it, of course exists too)
- galkk 7y agoCome on, brick wall of 150cm? It's insane, no one builds that for individual house.
- plandis 7y agoIf you built with brick that would be against code and you’d be incredibly likely to die if there is an earthquake. Additionally, Americans are fairly fond of tearing down existing structures to rebuild which is harder to do with brick. Thirdly, wood is an abundant resource in the US.