3 ms·
I certainly wouldn't dispute that rich people have more power and influence than your average Joe, or that they lead very different lives than him. I just disag
by SpicyLemonZest 7y ago
I certainly wouldn't dispute that rich people have more power and influence than your average Joe, or that they lead very different lives than him. I just disagree that there's such a thing as a homogenous class of capital owners, who would have or could have "created" the state as a conspiracy to "continue to own and profit from their ownership of capital".
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoI never claimed any "conspiracy"; there's no meeting or discussion (well, I guess there is stuff like Davos or whatever, but let's put that aside, that's mostly theatre). The formal mechanisms of the modern nation state were the outcome of a 200 year process, a development over time. The nation state _emerged_ along with the capitalist market system. Before that we had feudal autocracies. What we call a government now is a product of push and pull, trial and error, experimentation. And the dominant force shaping it has been the need for those with wealth to preserve a market of private ownership that keeps them wealthy, and to keep the simultaneously emergent forces of popular democracy from threatening that. The Marx quote might make it sound conspirational, but in the context of all the text around it, that's certainly not what he meant. For what it's worth, you don't have to go looking in Marx for this kind of analysis. Classical liberalism would also admit this role for the state -- just with a positive spin.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoSure, and I'm with you as far as that goes. But if that's what you meant it's a very strange response to the original comment. It's true that government bailouts wouldn't happen if the government were still run by a landed aristocracy that distrusts merchants, but I don't know if that's tremendously relevant to an analysis of actions in 2020.
- rmrfstar 7y agoYour belief does not reflect reality. 10% of households own 84% of equities owned by households [1]. This is actually a rosy estimate, because the denominator is "equities owned by households". Extremely wealthy households shield their assets in trusts and pooled investment vehicles that are not reflected in this figure. As we know, the distribution wealth follows a power law despite the distribution of human endowments following a Gaussian. [1] https://www.ft.com/content/2501e154-4789-11ea-aeb3-955839e06441 https://www.ft.com/content/2501e154-4789-11ea-aeb3-955839e06...