3 ms·
I feel like this whole thing is a sideshow. We should "bailout" based on just 2 criteria: * would the business be viable if it weren't for corona and will it
by LatteLazy 7y ago
I feel like this whole thing is a sideshow.
We should "bailout" based on just 2 criteria:
* would the business be viable if it weren't for corona and will it be viable after coronavirus?
* what's in it for us? We want equity, or juicy interest on the loan or you're industry needs to be a big net contributor of tax revenue.
We made a profit on the TARP activities. Let's do that again, then we can cut taxes and expand services. Who doesn't like that idea!
- themagician 7y agoIt is precisely because of the predictable government response to corona that many of these firms are viable at all. That is, many know that they can enter into what is essentially a "bad faith" debt obligation because they know a bailout will likley be available. There hasn't been any real incentive to save or be fiscally responsible since the 90's. Spend as much as possible. Take on as much debt as you can. If things get bad you can either abandon ship and do it all over again or wait for a bailout which is almost ingrained in the system at this point. In fact the more debt you have the less you have to worry.
- dillonmckay 7y agoQuite the moral hazard.
- LatteLazy 7y agoOnly if the industry being bailed out can somehow profit from causing the next plague...
- LatteLazy 7y agoCan you give me an example of companies entering into bad faith obligations over coronavirus? I can see how (especially now) banks take excess risks because they're too big to fail. But I don't think (say) airlines have taken any excess risks or could have reasonable forseen a "once in a century" pandemic... Also, it seems a bit arbitrary that some under capitalised businesses will be left to fail, while others will make a fortune (hospitals say or toilet paper manufacturing). I wouldn't want to pick winners in normal times. But these are not normal times...
- RHSeeger 7y agoI would add * Is the business important to society as a whole In my opinion, bailouts aren't about if a company "deserves" to survive, they are about if it's "important to us, as a society" that it survives. If so, we group together and save it (with out taxes).
- nopzor 7y agowho is the judge of what businesses are important to society?
- LatteLazy 7y agoI disagree, but I wrote my comment without explaining why the above should (I think) be the only criteria. Industries will survive and return to normal if they're economically viable, whether they are socially important or not. Cruise ships are (imho) floating cess pits that contribute nothing but pollution to our world. So we can just let them go bankrupt right? And they will. Then some billionaires will buy up the ships at auction for cheap, and reopen the same businesses under new names. They will make a killing for nothing more than being in the right place with a billion dollars. The number of ships and shittiness of the industry will not change. Maybe some mom-and-pop shareholders will get wiped out. And we will have missed the opportunity to make a fat profit for tax payers. That's what's happening here: the bailout will happen either way. But if the state leads it, the state gets the guaranteed profit. Now is a time to look at the benefit to our countries, not to moralise and let others privatise those benefits just because they're already rich.