4 ms·
Maybe there is a way to use this concept of reducing stress with a gesture without invoking supernatural gibberish. I mean to me it seems totally plausible tha
by ilaksh 7y ago
Maybe there is a way to use this concept of reducing stress with a gesture without invoking supernatural gibberish.
I mean to me it seems totally plausible that having a person there that is trying to help you in and of itself can reduce stress. Also if they touch you, that seems like it could definitely reduce stress also.
Or just the psychological effect of knowing that there are people who care, that seems like it could have at least a minor lasting effect on stress.
The question is can that basic concept work without the mumbojumbo. Or could you sell it without talking about magical powers.
- gnramires 7y ago> The question is can that basic concept work without the mumbojumbo I used to think like that too, but I'm more open that sometimes a story, any story, allegory can be helpful in many contexts, by creating an identity, an aesthetic quality of the thing; help us conceptualize it. Since this in particular is about psychological phenomenon, I think it perhaps shouldn't be discarded. The question would be (if the story is an important part of a working practice) how to keep the story from being confused with fact. I think that's achievable (treat it as a mythology, or something). I don't think anyone would defend the banning of telling stories to children or fiction movies.
- waterhouse 7y agoSurely there's a way to believe something important and true with the right emotional valence. Consider the story I laid out in a nearby comment: "A competent, trusted person loves you and is laying hands on you in a kindly way to heal you. When this happened to our ancestors, they were in a safe position and their bodies needed healing; under these circumstances, there was no risk of further injury and no need to worry about other needs (because they will be attended to), which means the body should turn down its immune response and focus on healing. Evolution carried this lesson down into your body. I will be the competent, trusted person who loves you, and I will lay kindly hands on you, and your body will respond instinctively and heal." It doesn't need to be any more (or less) magical than what happens in theatre. The actors do their best to live their roles, to do the things and feel the emotions their characters would feel, and they let the audience see it—perhaps playing it up a little, because the audience is tens of feet away. I believe there are at least some in the service industry that have a related "I'm playing a role, of one who is delighted to help my great customer, to the best of my ability" ethos.
- gnramires 7y agoI guess it could be analogous to watching say a circus (say Cirque du Soleil) presentation with a story and a presentation without a story -- one with just actors doing impressive stunts, the other with a narrative, clothings, a coherent aesthetic, but still centered on doing impressive stunts, movements, etc. The story-free might be interesting, some would feel there is something missing (I would), the stunts themselves not as remarkable as they could be. There is always a story and an aesthetic -- if you chose to tell no story, you'll simply be clinging to the aesthetic of modern hospitals (with innocuous minimalist environments), hospital or casual clothing, etc. It just may not be sufficiently captivating, at least not for everyone. At least it's worth research and experimentation instead of dismissal as "unscientific" or "woo woo". To give other examples, imagine hospital clowns (hired for kids) without clown clothes or being identified as 'clowns', but rather 'entertainment therapists'. Possibly lame, just not the same.
- Illniyar 7y agoWell, placebo doesn't work if you know it isn't real.
- adrianN 7y agoActually it does: https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/placebo-can-work-even-know-placebo-201607079926 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/placebo-can-work-even-kn...
- tempestn 7y agoI have to imagine that it works even _better_ if you believe it's more than just a placebo though, but it'd be interesting to see evidence! That study compared open placebo to nothing. I'd be interested in a study where one group believed they were getting a trial drug and the other group believed they were getting placebo, but really both were getting the same placebo.
- henrikschroder 7y ago> Maybe there is a way to use this concept of reducing stress with a gesture without invoking supernatural gibberish. We know that fake acupuncture works just as well as real acupuncture, and we know that regular massage works pretty well to de-stress people, so it should absolutely be possible to remove the woo and still get the benefits.
- hcarvalhoalves 7y agoModern medicine is also mumbo jumbo for the average patient, and still it's crucial that the patient have faith in it and cooperates - without it, they won't be disciplined to take their prescribed drugs, monitor exams, follow up consultations, and in the end the treatment won't be effective. So I wouldn't downplay the importance of perception, and that depends on culture, traditions, individual values, etc.
- jtolmar 7y agoEvery supernatural gibberish healing practice I've seen gets one thing right - their lobbies are consistently cozy, inviting places full of soft chairs and natural materials. A doctor's office is often a place with horrible lighting, no decoration, and plastic chairs. There's a lot of stress and general unease that could be alleviated by getting someone to take time out of their day to go somewhere comfortable and explain their problems to a kind person. Unfortunately there's probably more stigma for that by itself - therapy - than there is for that plus a fanciful story.
- waterhouse 7y ago> just the psychological effect of knowing that there are people who care “You don’t have to be thinking anything,” one master said. “You are just there to love them.” Wow, no kidding. If the practitioners, through practice (and perhaps self-selection), manage to produce that feeling at will, and if the patient picks up on this... Imagine that a competent, trusted person loves you and is laying hands on you in a kindly way to heal you. That has to speak deeply to evolved instinct; if there are ways that the patient's emotion produces hormones or whatever to affect the body, this seems like a powerful way to affect the emotions.
- Traubenfuchs 7y agoYour first sentence is a very clear description of my feelings towards this whole thing. This article and commentators here attributing the effects to inexplicable phenomenons is infuriating. If it really does something, it can be explained.