6 ms·
Wise words a former cell biology aware PhD said to me once: a cell is at a scale where van der Waals forces means 'water' isn't behaving like you think and the
by ggm 7y ago
Wise words a former cell biology aware PhD said to me once: a cell is at a scale where van der Waals forces means 'water' isn't behaving like you think and the 'liquid' of a cell is possibly more like a matrix than a fluid. Those high school cell models are very misleading. He basically said macro scale intuition was useless for what it means to pierce the cell wall, as an example. What does "pierce" even mean?
- JshWright 7y agoI'd highly recommend the YouTube channel "Journey to the Microcosmos" for videos that do a great job of improving that intuition.
- nojvek 7y agohttps://m.youtube.com/channel/UCBbnbBWJtwsf0jLGUwX5Q3g https://m.youtube.com/channel/UCBbnbBWJtwsf0jLGUwX5Q3g ^ here is the link. Pretty great animation. Thanks for the recommendation.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- computerphage 7y agoTo be clear, it's not an animation, it's video captured from a microscope.
- chadcmulligan 7y agoI picked up a microscope last year - they were on sale, and one of those things I'd always wanted to have a play with. I remember having a look with them in school and never seeing much and it seemed very hard. All you have to do is go to a pond or creek scoop out some weeds, dirt and water and stick it in a jar and there is hours of exploration in front of you. Once you start looking its like seeing an evolutionary world in front of you, everythings eating each other and trying to not be eaten. If you're thinking of getting a telescope (I had one), think of a microscope they open up a new world, its incredibly easy to see things - I thought it would be a lot more work. Probably there's so many on line resources now to - this guy is a great start - microbe hunter https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDpKY8-oz5PWlBPNzNsbLug https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCDpKY8-oz5PWlBPNzNsbLug
- nikofeyn 7y agoone of my greatest confusions of "life" is why there is this need to consume or feed off of or battle against other life. what is the purpose of this drive? why is it like this? i suspect the answer lies in thermodybamics and/or information theory, but it would be amazing to understand the reason behind life's battles for survival.
- cowboysauce 7y agoActually game theory is probably the better place to look. Though the concept of natural selection already tends to cover the big picture. Organisms need resources to reproduce. Those that can obtain more resources (or use what they have more efficiently) reproduce more and eventually drown out those who cannot reproduce as much. Taking from another organism (whether by hunting, parasitism, etc) is just one way of obtaining more resources.
- martythemaniak 7y agoLook into "dissipative structures", which are indeed closely linked to thermodynamics. In short, energy gradients (ie, on hydrothermal vents) can cause matter to organize itself into structures that more efficiently dissipate this energy. You can see how the creation of this structure would in turn enable the creation of a new kind of structure that lives on top of that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissipative_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dissipative_system https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqPGOhXoprU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PqPGOhXoprU
- effie 7y agoThere are competing processes in nature even without life (in the usual sense of the word) - atomic nucleus fission/fusion, light absorption/emission, crystal nucleation vs. decay, molecule synthesis vs molecule decay - each process operating towards getting more ground. Life fighting (or helping) other life can be looked upon as a more complex variant of the same process dynamics: one set of atoms and processes interacting with other set of atoms and processes, sometimes this looks like cooperation, sometimes like a battle.
- chadcmulligan 7y ago
- titzer 7y agoAgree! I found (https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/watch-the-life-cycle-of-hiv-in-colorful-new-detail/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/watch-the-...) to be pretty mind-blowing.
- iosjunkie 7y agoThanks for sharing. The lifecycle was much more sophisticated than I assumed.
- airstrike 7y agoThanks for sharing this link. Saw this video once and was COMPLETELY blown away but didn't know where it was from.
- johnohara 7y agoPity I only get 1 upvote. I'd triple-click if I could. This animation enables one to visualize a single SARS-CoV-2 virion binding with the ACE2 enzyme, entering the host cell, and replicating 4-5 new virions. One SARS-CoV-2 virion is 125 nanometers wide. By the time it shows up on a CT scan we are talking many, many billions. It's seems impossible anyone could test positive and still be asymptomatic.
- waterhouse 7y agoI note that the virus depicted in the animation is HIV. How much of the lifecycle is different from HIV to SARS-CoV-2? One thing I noted is that it said the inserted viral DNA might remain dormant for years; surely that part is HIV-specific? (Or do we really bear viral infections for years after recovery, and—I presume—rely on the continued presence of antibodies to quash the remaining DNA?)
- mardifoufs 7y agoThat part is mostly specific to retroviruses and DNA viruses. Retroviruses are special because even though they are RNA based they can "translate" their RNA into dna once inside the cell and embed that DNA into the cell's genome. That translation in itself is remarkable since it's the opposite of the normal DNA to RNA "translation" we see in almost every organism, hence the "retro". DNA based viruses don't have that unique mechanism but the result is conceptually the same: you get a virus that is extremely hard to completely cure/remove due to it being present in some of your own DNA. Herpes is a DNA based virus and that's why you can't ever be fully cured from it. That's also why retroviruses like HIV can only be suppressed. It's also why antiretroviral drugs try to inhibit the replication phases of the virus, which makes managing the disease possible but can't remove the virus itself. Still, a cocktail of those inhibitors is an amazingly powerful treatment against AIDS and leads to HIV becoming basically dorment in the body. A ribovirus (which is what coronaviruses are) is RNA based but it doesn't embed itself into our genome. It never translates it's RNA and since RNA is fundamentally less stable of a molecule than DNA, you get really high mutation rates. That "instability" is caused by the lack of a built in error checking mechanism in RNA. Those random mutations are part of why Influenza is hard to build immunity against. But it's also why RNA based viruses are generally either too virulent and mortal to allow for effective spread, or rapidly evolve towards less lethal forms. Keep in mind that I've generalized a lot and that there are a lot of exceptions and outliers when it comes to viruses. For example, Hepatitis C is a ribovirus but it has a special protection mechanism that protects it's core genetic material from mutations even if it's RNA based.
- Terr_ 7y agoAlso, on that scale individual molecules are bouncing around inside the cell faster than you can run or bike. It is a metaphorical froth of seething sliding movement.
- codekilla 7y agoI think this was first written about at length in the book ‘Soft Machines’, which is a really good critique of some of the nanotechnology thinking at the time. I highly recommend the book.
- garmaine 7y agoActually it was a terrible critique of nanotechnology, which doesn’t try to make things the same way as biology. But a good overview of the funkiness which comes part and parcel with life’s microbiology.
- codekilla 7y agoNot sure which field of bionanotechnology (I assume you meant bionanotechnology ) you work in, but for the one I work in, the metaphor of biology and computer science is extremely intertwined—like very explicitly. Circuits, computation, the whole nine yards. If you’re talking about graphene or something that is an entirely different field. I can’t see how this book was a terrible critique of bionanotechnology—or at least an excellent discussion of the hardships faced.
- garmaine 7y agoI did not mean bionanotechnology, and neither did Smalley. He offered that as a critique against Drexlar’s diamondoid molecular manufacturing, in a successful political coup to claim the billions in research dollars that were promised as part of the National Nanotechnology Initiative. Because of Richard Smalley that money went towards material science and chemical research instead of the molecular manufacturing it was promised for. Even though, as you point out, in terms of fact the critique only applied to life-like bionanotechnology. The history of this is laid out pretty well—with a surprisingly minimal amount of sour grapes—in Drexler‘s book Radical Abundance.
- ramraj07 7y agoWant to point out that this still slightly depends on what cell you are talking about - a mammalian cell is a thousand times larger than a bacterial cell, which in turn is a hundred or thousand times larger than a virus. An apt comparison is if you were a cell in your body, a bacteria is at best the size of a pea and a virus the size of an ant. Viruses are so small that you can sometimes just crystallize them to study their structure with crystallography as if the entire thing is a single molecule.
- dekhn 7y agoThe classic intro to this is "Life at Low Reynolds Number", https://science.curie.fr/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Purcell_life_at_low_reynolds_number_1977.pdf https://science.curie.fr/wp-content/uploads/2016/04/Purcell_... Another interesting thing: cells are packed so tightly (not just a bag of water) that proteins grind against each other and against their ligands, increasing the "activity" (even the free energy of ATP hydrolysis isn't the standard 7.3kcal/mol. Yes, macro-scale intuition isn't great (although people pierce cell walls with tiny needles all the time), but if you spend enough time looking at cells under a microscope, you start to build an intuition about cell and molecule behavior.